In this commentary, I engage with the recent dialogue on Sidaway's article, ‘Beyond the Decolonial: Critical Muslim Geographies’. In particular, I highlight four points that he makes about how to advance critical Muslim geographies within critical geography – including drawing directly from Islamic thought, critiquing formative thinkers of critical geography, connecting with Black geographies, and interfacing with area studies. I then shift to discuss why this is a challenging project, but one that is full of potential.
Abu-LughodL (2013) Do Muslim Women Need Saving?Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
2.
AkhterM (2023) Muslim peripheries: A world regional perspective. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 367–371.
3.
AnsharyF (2023) Critical geography, Islam, and the possibility of engaging the more-than-critical. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 377–381.
4.
AsselinHBasileS (2018) Concrete ways to decolonize research. ACME17(3): 643–650.
5.
CulcasiK (2023) Decolonizing the ‘Middle East’. Arab World Geographer26(2): 108–118.
6.
CulcasiK (2024) Gendered orientalism and the agency of Syrian, Muslim women refugees. Fennia: International Journal of Geography 202: 13–25.
7.
EssonJNoxoloPBaxterR, et al. (2017) The 2017 RGS-IBG chair’s theme: Decolonising geographical knowledges, or reproducing coloniality?Area49: 384–388.
8.
FerrettiF (2020) History and philosophy of geography I: Decolonising the discipline, diversifying archives and historicising radicalism. Progress in Human Geography44(6): 1161–1171.
9.
HammondT (2023) Languages of din: Place, history, and paths. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 372–376.
10.
KinkaidEFritzscheL (2022) The stories we tell: Challenging exclusionary histories of geography in U.S. graduate curriculum. Annals of the American Association of Geographers112(8): 2469–2485.
11.
KynsilehtoA (2008) Islamic Feminism: Current Perspectives. Tampere: University of Tampere.
12.
NassarA (2023) Decentering whiteness in engaging Muslim geographies. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 359–362.
13.
NaylorLDaigleMZaragocinS, et al. (2018) Interventions: Bringing the decolonial to political geography. Political Geography66: 199–209.
14.
NoxoloPHamisS (2023) Beyond the decolonial? Decolonial and Muslim feminist perspectives. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 363–366.
15.
OlivellaPMostowlanskyT (2023) Islam's weight in global history: A response to Sidaway. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 382–386.
16.
RadcliffeS (2017) Decolonising geographical knowledges. Transactions of the British Institute of Geographers42(3): 329–333.
17.
SidawayJ (2023a) Beyond the decolonial: Critical Muslim geographies. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 337–358.
18.
SidawayJ (2023b) A manifesto for critical Muslim geographies. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 387–391.
19.
SundbergJ (2014) Decolonizing posthumanist geographies. Cultural Geographies21(1): 33–47.
20.
TuckEYangKW (2012) Decolonization is not a metaphor. Decolonization: Indigeneity, Education & Society and Space1(1): 1–40.