In this commentary, I engage with the epistemic direction that Sidaway suggests geographers should take to decolonize Muslim geographies. Instead, I argue that geography will benefit from closing the gap with the anthropology of Islam where similar questions have long been debated following the influential work of Talal Asad and his conceptualization of Islam as a ‘discursive tradition’.
AkhterM (2023) Muslim peripheries: A world regional perspective. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 367–371.
2.
Al-AttasSMN (2020) Islām: The Concept of Religion and the Foundation of Ethics and Morality. Kuala Lumpur: Ta’dib International.
3.
AnsharyF (2023) Critical geography, Islam, and the possibility of engaging the more-than-critical. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 377–381.
4.
AsadT (1993) Genealogies of Religion: Discipline and Reasons of Power in Christianity and Islam. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press.
5.
AsadT (2009 [1986]) The idea of an anthropology of Islam. Qui Parle17(2): 1–30.
6.
AsadTScottD (2006) The trouble of thinking: An interview with Talal Asad. In: ScottDHirschkindC (eds) Powers of the Secular Modern: Talal Asad and His Interlocutors. Stanford: Stanford University Press, pp. 1–11.
7.
BrackeS (2008) Conjugating the modern/religious, conceptualizing female religious agency: Contours of a ‘post-secular’ conjuncture. Theory, Culture & Societ25(6): 51–67.
8.
DeebL (2015) Thinking piety and the everyday together: A response to Fadil and Fernando. HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory5(2): 93–96.
9.
FadilN (2011) Not-/unveiling as an ethical practice. Feminist Review98(1): 83–109.
10.
HammondT (2023) Languages of din: Place, history, and paths. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 372–376.
11.
HirschkindC (2006) The Ethical Soundscape: Cassette Sermons and Islamic Counterpublics. New York: Columbia University Press.
12.
IqbalBKAsadT (2017) Thinking about method. Qui Parle26(1): 195–218.
13.
MahmoodS (2005) Politics of Piety: The Islamic Revival and the Feminist Subject. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
14.
MillsAGökarıkselB (2014) Provincializing geographies of religion: Muslim identities beyond the ‘west’. Geography Compass8(12): 902–914.
15.
MoumtazN (2015) Refiguring Islam. In: AltorkiS (ed) A Companion to the Anthropology of the Middle East. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 125–150.
16.
NoxoloPHamisS (2023) Beyond the decolonial? Decolonial and Muslim feminist perspectives. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 363–366.
17.
OlivellaPLIMostowlanskyT (2023) Islam’s weight in global history: A response to Sidaway. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 382–386.
18.
SchielkeS (2009) Being good in Ramadan: Ambivalence, fragmentation, and the moral self in the lives of young Egyptians. Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute15(s1): S24–S40.
19.
SehlikogluS (2018) Revisited: Muslim women’s agency and feminist anthropology of the Middle East. Contemporary Islam12(1): 73–92.
20.
SehlikogluS (2021) Working Out Desire: Women, Sport, and Self-Making in Istanbul. Syracuse, Syracuse University Press.
21.
SehlikogluSKurtM (2024) Islam, critique, and the canon: An introduction. Contemporary Islam18: 1–5.
22.
SidawayJD (2023) Beyond the decolonial: Critical Muslim geographies. Dialogues in Human Geography13(3): 337–358.