Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The aim of this paper is to evaluate critically the extent to which the conventional eradication approach towards undeclared work has been transcended and replaced by an approach which seeks to shift undeclared work into the declared economy. Reporting the results of a 2010 survey of 104 senior stakeholders from government departments, trade unions and employer organisations in 31 European countries, and 24 follow-up in-depth interviews, the finding is that although there is a move towards adopting policy measures that shift undeclared work into the declared economy, a deterrence approach that simply seeks to eliminate undeclared work remains the principal approach in most nations and the approach viewed as the most effective way of tackling undeclared work. Given this intransigence on the part of European national governments, the paper concludes by setting out a future research agenda to bridge this gap.

Keywords

European Union informal sector labour law public policy shadow economy

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adom

and Williams

C.C.

(2012) ‘Evaluating the explanations for the informal economy in third world cities: Some evidence from Koforidua in the eastern region of Ghana’, International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, 8(3): 309–24.

Aidis

Welter

Smallbone

and Isakova

(2006) ‘Female entrepreneurship in transition economies: The case of Lithuania and Ukraine’, Feminist Economics, 13 (2): 157–83.

Allingham

and Sandmo

(1972) ‘Income tax evasion: A theoretical analysis’. Journal of Public Economics, 1: 323–38.

Antonopoulos

G.A.

and Mitra

(2009) ‘The hidden enterprise of bootlegging cigarettes out of Greece: Two schemes of illegal entrepreneurship’, Journal of Small Business and Entrepreneurship, 22(1): 1–8.

Bergman

and Nevarez

(2006) ‘Do audits enhance compliance? An empirical assessment of VAT enforcement’, National Tax Journal, 59(4): 817–32.

Braithwaite

(2007) ‘Responsive regulation and taxation: Introduction’, Law and Policy, 29(1): 3–10.

Braithwaite

and Reinhart

(2000) The Taxpayers' Charter: Does the Australian Tax Office comply and who benefits, Centre for Tax System Integrity Working Paper No. 1, Australian National University, Canberra.

Bureau

and Fendt

(2011) ‘Entrepreneurship in the informal economy: Why it matters’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 12(2): 85–94.

Castells

and Portes

(1989) ‘World underneath: The origins, dynamics and effects of the informal economy’, in Portes

Castells

and Benton

L.A.

(eds.), The Informal Economy: Studies in advanced and less developing countries, John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.

10.

Copisarow

and Barbour

(2004) Self-employed people in the informal economy – cheats or contributors? Community Links, London.

11.

Dana

L.-P.

(2013) ‘Informal economy, entrepreneurship and policy implications’, in Thai

and Turkina

(eds.), Entrepreneurship in the Informal Economy: Models, approaches and prospects for economic development, Routledge, London, pp. 260–268.

12.

Davis

(2006), Planet of slums, Verso, London.

13.

De Juan

Lasheras

M.A.

and Mayo

(1994) ‘Voluntary tax compliant behavior of Spanish income taxpayers’, Public Finance, 49: 90–105.

14.

Dekker

Oranje

Renooy

Rosing

and Williams

C.C.

(2010) Joining up the fight against undeclared work in the European Union, DG Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities, Brussels [Available at http://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?catId=471&langId=en].

15.

Dellot

(2012) Untapped enterprise: Learning to live with the informal economy, Royal Society of the Arts, London.

16.

Dibben

and Williams

C.C.

(2012) ‘Varieties of capitalism and employment relations: Informally dominated market economies’, Industrial Relations: A Review of Economy & Society, 51(S1): 563–82.

17.

European Commission (1998) Communication of the Commission on undeclared work, http://europa.eu.int/comm/employment_social/empl_esf/docs/com98-219_en.pdf.

18.

Commission

European

(2003a) European Commission proposes 10 priorities for employment reform. Press release 0311, Brussels, European Commission.

19.

Commission

European

(2003b) ‘Council decision on guidelines for the employment policies of the Member States’, Official Journal of the European Union, 22 July 2003, L.197/13.

20.

Commission

European

(2003c) ‘Council resolution on transforming undeclared work into regular employment’, Official Journal of the European Union, 29 October, C260, http://europa.eu.int/eur-lex/en/archive/index.html.

21.

Commission

European

(2007a), Stepping up the fight against undeclared work COM(2007) 628 final, European Commission, Brussels.

22.

Commission

European

(2007b), Special Eurobarometer 284: Undeclared work in the European Union (Brussels: European Commission).

23.

European Commission (2011) Economic and Social Developments in Europe 2011. Brussels: European Commission.

24.

European Commission (2013) Economic and Social Developments in Europe 2013. Brussels: European Commission.

25.

European Employment Observatory (2004) European Employment Observatory Review: Autumn 2004, Brussels, European Commission.

26.

European Industrial Relations Observatory (2005). Thematic issue: Industrial relations and undeclared work. Retrieved April 2013 from http://eurofound.europa.eu/eiro/thematicfeature11.html.

27.

Evans

Syrett

and Williams

C.C.

(2006) Informal Economic Activities and Deprived Neighbourhoods, Department of Communities and Local Government, London.

28.

Gerard

Neyens

and Valsamis

(2012) Evaluatie van het stelsel van de dienstencheques voor buurtdiensten en -banen 2011 (evaluation of the voucher scheme 2011) Brussels: IDEA Consult.

29.

GHK and Fondazione Brodolini (2009) Study on indirect measurement methods for undeclared work in the EU. Brussels: European Commission.

30.

Grabiner

Lord

(2000) The Informal Economy. London: HM Treasury.

31.

Gurtoo

and Williams

C.C.

(2009) ‘Entrepreneurship and the informal sector: Some lessons from India’, International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 10(1): 55–62.

32.

Hart

(1973) ‘Informal income opportunities and urban employment in Ghana’, Journal of Modern African Studies, 11(1): 61–89.

33.

Hasseldine

and Li

(1999) ‘More tax evasion research required in new millennium’, Crime, Law and Social Change, 31(1): 91–104.

34.

Hudson

Williams

C.C.

Orviska

and Nadin

(2012) ‘Evaluating the impact of the informal economy on businesses in South East Europe: Some lessons from the 2009 World Bank Enterprise Survey’, The South-East European Journal of Economics and Business, 7(1): 99–110.

35.

ILO (2002), Women and men in the informal economy: A statistical picture, International Labour Office, Geneva.

36.

ILO (2011), Statistical update on employment in the informal economy, ILO Department of Statistics, Geneva.

37.

Job

Stout

and Smith

(2007) ‘Culture change in three taxation administrations: From command-and-control to responsive regulation’, Law and Policy, 29: 84–101.

38.

Jütting

J.P.

and Laiglesia

J.R.

(2009) ‘Employment, poverty reduction and development: What's new?’, in Jütting

J.P.

and Laiglesia

J.R.

(eds.) Is Informal Normal? Towards more and better jobs in developing countries, OECD, Paris.

39.

Katungi

Neale

and Barbour

(2006) People in low-paid informal work, Joseph Rowntree Foundation, York.

40.

Klepper

and Nagin

(1989) ‘Tax compliance and perceptions of the risks of detection and criminal prosecution’, Law and Society Review, 23: 209–40.

41.

Krstić

and Sanfey

(2011), ‘Earnings inequality and the informal economy’, Economics of Transition, 19(1): 179–99.

42.

Kus

(2010) ‘Regulatory governance and the informal economy: Cross-national comparisons’, Socio-Economic Review, 8(3): 487–510.

43.

Leonard

(1994) Informal Economic Activity in Belfast. Aldershot: Avebury.

44.

MacDonald

(1994) ‘Fiddly jobs, undeclared working and the something for nothing society’. Work, Employment and Society, 8(4): 507–30.

45.

Meriküll

and Staehr

(2010) ‘Unreported employment and envelope wages in mid-transition: Comparing developments and causes in the Baltic countries’, Comparative Economic Studies, 52: 637–70.

46.

Morris

(2011) ‘Socially embedded workers at the nexus of diverse work in Russia: An ethnography of blue-collar informalization’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 31(11/12): 619–31.

47.

Murphy

(2005) ‘Regulating more effectively: The relationship between procedural justice, legitimacy and tax non-compliance’, Journal of Law and Society, 32: 562–89.

48.

Neef

(2002) ‘Observations on the concept and forms of the informal economy in Eastern Europe’, in Neef

and Stanuclescu

(eds.) The Social Impact of Informal Economies in Eastern Europe, Aldershot: Ashgate.

49.

OECD (2002) Measuring the Non-Observed Economy, OECD, Paris.

50.

OECD (2012) Reducing opportunities for tax non-compliance in the underground economy, OECD, Paris.

51.

Onoshchenko

and Williams

C.C.

(2013) ‘Paying for favours: Evaluating the role of blat in post-Soviet Ukraine’, Debatte: Journal of Contemporary Central and Eastern Europe, 21(2–3): 259–77.

52.

Pahl

R.E.

(1984) Divisions of Labour. Oxford: Blackwell.

53.

Peeters

van Pelt

and Valsamis

(2008) Evaluatie van het stelsel van de dienstencheques voor buurtdiensten en -banen 2007 (evaluation of the voucher scheme 2007), Brussels: IDEA Consult

54.

Persson

and Malmer

(2006) Purchasing and performing undeclared work in Sweden: Part 1: Results from various studies, Skatteverket, Stockholm.

55.

Ram

and Williams

C.C.

(2008) ‘Making visible the hidden: Researching off-the-books work’. In: Buchanan

and Bryson

(eds) Handbook of Organizational Research Methods. London: Sage.

56.

Ram

Edwards

and Jones

(2007) ‘Staying underground: Informal work, small firms and employment regulation in the United Kingdom’, Work and Occupations, 34(3): 318–44.

57.

Richardson

and Sawyer

(2001) ‘A taxonomy of the tax compliance literature: Further findings, problems and prospects’, Australian Tax Forum, 16(2): 137–320.

58.

Rodgers

and Williams

C.C.

(2009) ‘The informal economy in the former Soviet Union and in Central and Eastern Europe’, International Journal of Sociology, 39(1): 3–11.

59.

Round

Williams

C.C.

and Rodgers

(2008) ‘Corruption in the post-Soviet workplace: The experiences of recent graduates in contemporary Ukraine’, Work, Employment & Society, 22(1): 149–66.

60.

Sassen

(1997), Informalisation in advanced market economies, Issues in Development Discussion Paper 20, Geneva: International Labour Office.

61.

Schneider

(2005) ‘Shadow economy around the world: What do we really know?’, European Journal of Political Economy, 21(2): 598–642.

62.

Schneider

(2008) (ed.) The Hidden Economy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

63.

Schneider

(2011) (ed.) Handbook on the Shadow Economy. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

64.

Schneider

(2012) Size and development of the shadow economy of 31 European and 5 other OECD Countries from 2003 to 2012: Some new facts. www.economics.uni-linz.ac.at/members/Schneider/files/publications/2012/ShadEcEurope31.pdf (last accessed 6 May 2013).

65.

Schneider

(2013) Size and development of the shadow economy of 31 European and 5 other OECD countries from 2003 to 2013: A further decline. www.econ.jku.at/members/Schneider/files/publications/2013/ShadEcEurope31_Jan2013.pdf (last accessed 6 May 2013).

66.

Schneider

and Enste

D.H.

(2002) The Shadow Economy: An international survey. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

67.

Schneider

and Williams

C.C.

(2013) The Shadow Economy, Institute of Economic Affairs, London.

68.

Slemrod

(1992) ‘Why people pay taxes: Introduction’. In: Slemerod

(ed) Why People Pay Taxes. Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan Press.

69.

Small Business Council (2004), Small Business in the Informal Economy: Making the transition to the formal economy, Small Business Council, London.

70.

Thomas

J.J.

(1992) Informal economic activity, Hemel Hempstead, Harvester Wheatsheaf.

71.

Infratest

TNS

Foundation

Rockwool

and Regioplan (2006), Feasibility study on a direct survey about undeclared work VC/2005/0276 (Brussels: European Commission).

72.

Torgler

(2011) Tax morale and compliance: Review of evidence and case studies for Europe. Washington DC: World Bank Policy Research Working Paper 5922, World Bank.

73.

Varma

K.N.

and Doob

A.N.

(1998), ‘Deterring economic crimes: The case of tax evasion’, Canadian Journal of Criminology, 40: 165–84.

74.

Webb

J.W.

Tihanyi

Ireland

R.D.

and Sirmon

D.G.

(2009) ‘You say illegal, I say legitimate: Entrepreneurship in the informal economy’, Academy of Management Review, 34(3): 492–510.

75.

White

(2009) ‘Explaining why the non-commodified sphere of mutual aid is so pervasive in the advanced economies: Some case study evidence from an English city’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 29: 457–72.

76.

White

and Williams

C.C.

(2010) ‘Re-thinking monetary exchange: Some lessons from England’, Review of Social Economy, 68(3): 317–38.

77.

Williams

C.C.

(2001) ‘Tackling the participation of the unemployed in paid informal work: A critical evaluation of the deterrence approach’, Environment and Planning C, 19(5): 729–49.

78.

Williams

C.C.

(2007) ‘The nature of entrepreneurship in the informal sector: Evidence from England’, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship, 12(2): 239–54.

79.

Williams

C.C.

(2008a) ‘A critical evaluation of public policy towards undeclared work in the European Union’, Journal of European Integration, 30(2): 273–90.

80.

Williams

C.C.

(2008b) ‘Beyond ideal-type depictions of entrepreneurship: Some lessons from the service sector in England’, The Service Industries Journal, 28(7/8): 1041–53.

81.

Williams

C.C.

(2009a) ‘Evaluating the extent and nature of envelope wages in the European Union: A geographical analysis’, European Spatial Research and Policy, 16(1): 115–29.

82.

Williams

C.C.

(2009b) ‘Formal and informal employment in Europe: Beyond dualistic representations’, European Urban and Regional Studies, 16(2): 147–59.

83.

Williams

C.C.

(2013a) ‘Evaluating cross-national variations in the extent and nature of informal employment in the European Union’, Industrial Relations Journal, 44(5–6): 479–94.

84.

Williams

C.C.

(2013b) ‘Explaining employers' illicit envelope wage payments in the EU-27: A product of over- or under-regulation?’, Business Ethics: A European Review, 22(3): 325–340.

85.

Williams

C.C.

and Lansky

(2013) ‘Informal employment in developed and emerging economies: Perspectives and policy responses’, International Labour Review, 152(3–4): 355–380.

86.

Williams

C.C.

and Martinez

(2014) ‘Is the informal economy an incubator for new enterprise creation? a gender perspective’, International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research, 20(1): 4–19

87.

Williams

C.C.

and Nadin

(2013) ‘Harnessing the hidden enterprise culture: Supporting the formalization of off-the-books business start-ups’, Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 20(2): 434–47.

88.

Williams

C.C.

and Padmore

(2013a) ‘Envelope wages in the European Union’, International Labour Review, 152(3–4): 411–30.

89.

Williams

C.C.

and Padmore

(2013b) ‘Evaluating the prevalence and distribution of quasi-formal employment in Europe’, Relations Industrielles/Industrial Relations, 68(1): 71–95.

90.

Williams

C.C.

and Renooy

(2013) Tackling Undeclared Work in 27 European Union Member States and Norway: Approaches and measures since 2008, European Foundation for the Improvement of Living and Working Conditions, Dublin.

91.

Williams

C.C.

and Round

(2007a) ‘Entrepreneurship and the informal economy: A study of Ukraine's hidden enterprise culture’, Journal of Developmental Entrepreneurship, 12(1): 119–36.

92.

Williams

C.C.

and Round

(2007b) ‘Rethinking the nature of the informal economy: Some lessons from Ukraine’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 31(2): 425–41.

93.

Williams

C.C.

and Round

(2008) ‘Re-theorising the nature of informal employment: Some lessons from Ukraine’, International Sociology, 23(3): 367–88.

94.

Williams

C.C.

and Round

(2009) ‘Evaluating informal entrepreneurs' motives: Some lessons from Moscow’, International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research, 15(1): 94–107.

95.

Williams

C.C.

and Windebank

(1994) ‘Spatial variations in the informal sector: A review of evidence from the European Union’, Regional Studies, 28(8): 819–25.

96.

Williams

C.C.

Round

and Rodgers

(2013) The Role of Informal Economies in the Post-Soviet World: The end of transition?, Routledge, London.

97.

Wood

G.T.

and Bischoff

(2013) ‘Growth choices, formal and informal employment regulation: The case of small business in South Africa’, International Labour Review, 152: 3.

98.

Woolfson

(2007) ‘Pushing the envelope: The “informalization” of labour in post-communist new EU Member States’, Work, Employment and Society, 21: 551–64.

99.

Žabko

and Rajevska

(2007) ‘Undeclared work and tax evasion: Case of Latvia’, Paper presented at colloquium of the Belgian Federal Service for Social Security on Undeclared Work, Tax Evasion and Avoidance. Brussels, June.

Public Policy Approaches towards the Undeclared Economy in European Countries: A Critical Overview

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References