The aim of this study was to assess the effect of an external nasal dilator on several variables characterizing labor in both mother and fetus.
Methods
One hundred and fifty primigravida women in active labor were randomized to wear, throughout labor, either a dilator spring-loaded nasal strip or a placebo device. Data were obtained during labor and compared between the groups. After delivery, the satisfaction rate was assessed.
Results
No differences were found between the study and the control group regarding rate of induction or augmentation of labor as well as Montevideo units reached, frequency of rupture of membranes, duration of the active phase and second stage of labor, usage of epidural analgesia, normal fetal heart pattern, meconium-stained amniotic fluid, and neonatal well being. Length of maternal and neonatal hospitalization also did not differ between the groups. Satisfaction rate was significantly higher in parturient women wearing nasal strips with a dilator spring than in parturient women wearing a placebo spring (P < 0.0001).
Conclusion
Nasal strips do not change the course but ameliorate the quality of labor by improving the ease of breathing. Nasal dilators sustain the respiratory effort associated with the long process of labor and may control the switch from nasal to oronasal breathing during delivery.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
GoldmanN.D.Nasal airway devices from ancient history to the present.Facial Plast Surg7: 379–390, 1999.
2.
Di SommaE.M., WestS.N., WheatleyJ.R.Nasal dilator strips increase maximum inspiratory flow via nasal wall stabilization.Laryngoscope109: 780–784, 1999.
3.
PortugalL.G., MehtaR.H., SmithB.E.Objective assessment of the breath right device during exercise in adult males.Am J Rhinol11: 393–397, 1997.
4.
GriffinJ.W., HunterG., FergusonD.Physiologic effects of an external nasal dilator.Laryngoscope107: 1235–1238, 1997.
5.
RoithmannR., ChapnikJ., ColeP.Role of the external nasal dilator in the management of nasal obstruction.Laryngoscope108: 712–7155, 1998.
6.
KirknessJ.P., WheatleyJ.R., and AmisT.C.Nasal airflow dynamics: Mechanisms and responses associated with an external nasal dilator strip.Eur Respir J15: 929–936, 2000.
7.
PassaliD.Does the nasal dilator help in sports activity?Allergy52: 2, 1997.
PevernagieD., HamansE., Van-CauwenbergeP.External nasal dilation reduces snoring in chronic rhinitis patients: A randomized controlled trial.Eur Respir J15: 996–1000, 2000.
10.
ScharfM.B., BrannenD.E., and McDannoldM.A subjective evaluation of a nasal dilator on sleep and snoring.Ear Nose Throat J73: 395–401, 1994.
11.
UlfbergJ., and FentonG.Effect of Breathe Right nasal strip on snoring.Rhinology35: 50–52, 1997.
12.
TodorovaA., SchellenbergR., HofmannH.C.Effect of the external nasal dilator Breath Right on snoring.Eur J Med Res3: 367–379, 1998.
13.
ScharfM.B., McDannoldM.D., ZaretskyM.T.Cyclic alternating pattern sequences in non-apneic snorers with and without nasal dilation.Ear Nose Throat J75: 617–619, 1996.
14.
PujolT.J., LangenfeldM.E., HinojosaJ.R.Effects of an external nasal dilator strip on differentiated ratings of perceived exertion.Percept Mot Skills86: 1153–1154, 1998.
15.
O'KroyJ.A.Oxygen uptake and ventilatory effects of an external nasal dilator during ergometry.Med Sci Sports Exerc32: 1491–1495, 2000.
16.
Seto-PoonM., AmisT.C., KirknessJ.P.Nasal dilator strips delay the onset of oral route breathing during exercise.Can J Appl Physiol24: 538–547, 1999.
17.
ChinevereT.D., FariaE.W., and FariaI.E.Nasal splinting effects on breathing patterns and cardiorespiratory responses.J Sports Sci17: 443–447, 1999.
18.
O'KroyJ.A., JamesT., MillerJ.M.Effects of an external nasal dilator on the work of breathing during exercise.Med Sci Sports Exerc33: 454–458, 2001.
19.
TongT.K., FuF.H., and ChowB.C.Effect of nostril dilatation on prolonged all-out intermittent exercise performance.J Sports Med Phys Fitness41: 189–195, 2001.
20.
KnezevicD., and KniggeH.Das Nasenpflaster—Eine Untersuchung der Sporthochschule Kšln.Sport Praxis6: 42–43, 1996.
21.
PapanekP.E., BrownJ.A., and YoungC.C.The effects of an external nasal dilator on respiratory flow volume.Med Sci Sports Exerc29: S285, 1997.
22.
WestS.A., PerryA.C., SignorileJ.L.Effect of Breathe Right nasal strips (BRNS) on measures of performance in aerobically trained males.J Athlet Train33: S35, 1998.
23.
KirknessJ., AmisT.C., Seto-PoonM.External nasal dilator strips influence rowing performance in elite athletes.Proc. Thoracic Society of Australia and New Zealand Annual Scientific Meeting,1998: 98.
24.
CareyD., and FentonG.The physiological effects of Breathe Right nasal dilator during exercise and recovery in racing cyclists.Res Qtrly Exerc Sport Suppl67: A28, 1996.
25.
BourdinM., SalletP., DufourA.B.Influence of changes in nasal ventilation on estimated workload during submaximal field running.J Sports Med Phys Fitness42: 295–299, 2002.
26.
ChinevereT.D., FariaE.W., and FariaI.E.Comparative effects of an external nasal dilator on breathing pattern and cardiorespiratory responses.Med Sci Sports Exerc29: S283, 1997.
27.
ClappA.J., and BishopP.A.Effect of the breath right external nasal dilator during light to moderate exercise.Med Sci Sports Exerc28: 588, 1996.
28.
HuffmanM.S., HuffmanM.T., BrownD.D.Exercise responses using the breath right external nasal dilator.Med Sci Sports Exerc28: 570, 1996.
29.
TrocchioM., WimerJ.W., ParkmanA.W.Oxygenation and exercise performance-enhancing effects attributed to the breathe-right nasal dilator.J Athlet Train30: 211–214, 1995.
30.
SchonhoferB., FranklinK.A., BrunigH.Effect of nasal-valve dilation on obstructive sleep apnea.Chest118: 587–590, 2000.
31.
HornungD.E., ChinC., KurtzD.E.Effect of nasal dilators on perceived odor intensity.Chem Senses22: 177–180, 1997.
32.
MabryR.L.Rhinitis of pregnancy.South Med J79: 965–971, 1986.
33.
NiinimaaV., ColeP., MintzS.The switching point from oral to oronasal breathing.Respir Physiol42: 61–71, 1980.
34.
JamesD.S., LambertW.E., MermierC.M.Oronasal distribution of ventilation at different ages.Arch Environ Health52: 118–123, 1997.
35.
FergieN., and BinghamB.J.G.Do sports nasal strips improve nasal airflow? A preliminary report.J Otolaryngol27: 113–114, 1998.
36.
TongT.K., FuF.H., and ChowB.C.Nostril dilatation increases capacity to sustain moderate exercise under nasal breathing condition.J Sports Med Phys Fitness41: 470–478, 2001.
37.
HessonK., HillT., and BakalD.Variability in breathing patterns during latent labor.J Nurse Midwifery42: 99–103, 1997.
