Effectiveness of a Structured Trauma Template in Improving Clinical Examination Accuracy in Maxillofacial Trauma: A Prospective Study

Abstract

Study Design

Prospective pre-post study.

Objective

Maxillofacial trauma presenting to the emergency department (ED) are often accompanied with complex concomitant injuries, thereby making thorough diagnosis and treatment plan quite an exacting task owing to the demanding conditions of the ED. The use of a structured maxillofacial trauma template helps in documenting the injuries comprehensively, aids in treatment planning, avoids medical negligence thereby improving the quality of care given to the patient. The study introduced a structured maxillofacial trauma template to improve the quality of the ED documentation.

Methods

A total of 220 patients were evaluated for the quality of their ED documentation from September 2023 till February 2024. The group A included 110 patients where complete medical documentation was done routinely on a blank A4 sized paper, group B included 110 patients where the documentation was done using the structured oral and maxillofacial trauma template. The ED notes were thoroughly evaluated by the 2 independent authors for record completeness and documentation rate of history and examination findings.

Results

The introduction of trauma template demonstrated a significant improvement of 18.95 % in record completeness. Significant improvement was seen in documentation rate among the covariates like place of injury, time of evaluation, primary care given, wound classification, dento-alveolar injury, ophthalmic evaluation, nerve injury evaluation, comorbidities with P = .001, and referral with P = .03. The ophthalmic evaluation showed significant improvement among covariates (loss of visual acuity, reflexes, diplopia, enophthalmos, subconjunctival haemorrhage, chemosis, periorbital oedema, periorbital ecchymosis, ocular dystopia) with P = .001, and extraocular muscle restriction with P = .004.

Conclusions

The study demonstrated that the use of a structured oral and maxillofacial trauma template can significantly improve the quality of the ED documentation and contributes to better patient care in the ED.