As global environmental crises intensify, movements advocating for the Rights of Nature are gaining momentum, aiming to reshape legal frameworks that have historically reinforced human domination over the natural world. This movement seeks to end the commodification of nature as mere resources for exploitation and to restore a more balanced relationship between humans and ecosystems – viewed by its advocates as essential for a political and legal revolution. Progress has been notable in countries such as Ecuador, Bolivia, and New Zealand, where indigenous rights movements have successfully championed the intrinsic value of nature; however, in Ireland – both North and South – Rights of Nature campaigns have emerged outside traditional indigenous contexts. Irish activists, identifying as ‘environmental protectors’, have mobilised to promote these rights, but paradoxically, projects deemed ‘green extractivist’, such as gold mining in the Sperrins, continue to be implemented despite some local councils passing motions to recognise the Rights of Nature. This contradiction highlights that the Rights of Nature need to go beyond legal recognition and involve broader political implications for decision-making processes, which warrant thorough examination. This paper critically assesses the current state of the Rights of Nature in Northern Ireland, exploring their implications, analysing relevant planning cases, and examining political developments since the adoption of these motions. It contends that the Rights of Nature framework provides environmental defenders with a complementary yet essential tool to anchor their anti-mining resistance and to promote greater participation in environmental law and governance.
AkchurinM (2015) Constructing the Rights of Nature: Constitutional reform, mobilization, and environmental protection in Ecuador. Law & Social Inquiry40(4): 937–968.
2.
AmsterR (2015) Peace Ecology. London: Routledge.
3.
BaardP (2024) Rights of Nature through a legal expressivist lens: Legal revolution of non-anthropocentric values. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice28(4): 551–567.
4.
BarryJ (2009) ‘It ain’t easy being green’: Sustainable development between environment and economy in Northern Ireland. Irish Political Studies24(1): 45–66.
5.
BederS (2006) Environmental Principles and Policies: An Interdisciplinary Introduction. London: Routledge.
6.
BerrosMV (2021) Challenges for the implementation of the Rights of Nature: Ecuador and Bolivia as the first instances of an expanding movement. Latin American Perspectives48(3): 192–205.
7.
BerryT (2009) The Sacred Universe: Earth, Spirituality, and Religion in the Twenty-First Century. New York: Columbia University Press.
8.
BlackR (2025) Firm says ‘no cyanide will be used’ in Co Tyrone gold-mine operation. The Irish Independent, 14 January.
9.
BorràsS (2016) New transitions from human rights to the environment to the Rights of Nature. Transnational Environmental Law5(1): 113–143.
10.
BosselmannK (2021) The framework of ecological law. Environmental Policy and Law50(6): 479–486.
11.
BosselmannK (2025) Earth Trusteeship and the Sovereign State: Transforming International Environmental Law. London: Routledge.
12.
BoydD (2017) The Rights of Nature: A Legal Revolution that Could Save the World. Toronto: ECW Press.
13.
BrennanCDobbsMGraveyV (2019) Out of the frying pan, into the fire? Environmental governance vulnerabilities in post-Brexit Northern Ireland. Environmental Law Review21(2): 84–110.
14.
BrennanCDoranPHoughA, et al. (2022) Rights of Nature in Ireland: Towards a living island of rights-bearing communities. Report, Environmental Justice Network Ireland. September 2022.
15.
BrennanCPurdyRHjerpP (2017) Political, economic and environmental crisis in Northern Ireland: The true cost of environmental governance failures and opportunities for reform. Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly68(2): 123–157.
16.
BresnihanPBrodieP (2024) From toxic industries to green extractivism: Rural environmental struggles, multinational corporations and Ireland’s postcolonial ecological regime. Irish Studies Review32(1): 93–122.
17.
BresnihanPBrodieP (2025) From the Bog to the Cloud: Dependency and Eco-Modernity in Ireland. Bristol: Bristol University Press.
18.
BrunaN (2022) A climate-smart world and the rise of Green Extractivism. The Journal of Peasant Studies49(4): 839–864.
19.
Campion K (2023) Defining ecofascism: Historical foundations and contemporary interpretations in the extreme right. Terrorism and Political Violence35(4): 926–944.
20.
CarrollRCarrellS (2020) ‘How much is a life worth?’: Northern Irish community split over gold-mining plans. The Guardian, 28 July.
CireficeV (2025) Resistance to extractivism in the Sperrins, North of Ireland: Care, commoning and post-extractive futures. Capitalism Nature Socialism36(4): 73–95.
23.
CirefireV (2026) Resisting mining in Ireland: The social engineering and colonial logics of green extractivism. Human Geography, forthcoming.
24.
CireficeVMercierSO’DochartaighA (2022) Resistance to mining and pathways to a sustainable rural environment: Rewriting the maps. In: AttorpAHeronSMcAreaveyR (eds) Rural Governance in the UK: Towards a Sustainable and Equitable Society. London: Routledge, pp.99–119.
25.
CoakleyJ (2022) A farewell to Northern Ireland? Constitutional options for Irish unity. The Political Quarterly93(2): 307–315.
26.
Committee on the Administration of Justice (2024) Policing the protectors: A narrative report of PSNI policing of environmental protest in the Sperrins. Report, Committee on the Administration of Justice, Northern Ireland, September.
27.
Cortes-VazquezJAApostolopoulouE (2019) Against neoliberal natures: Environmental movements, radical practice and ‘the right to nature’. Geoforum; Journal of Physical, Human, and Regional Geosciences98: 202–205.
28.
CoulterC (2019) Northern Ireland’s elusive peace dividend: Neoliberalism, austerity and the politics of class. Capital & Class43(1): 123–138.
29.
CowieRHBouchetPFontaineB (2022) The sixth mass extinction: Fact, fiction or speculation?Biological Reviews97(2): 640–663.
30.
CrockfordS (2024) If the Earth is not your mother, are you from Mars? Ecospirituality, gender, and environmental activism. Correspondences12(1): 107–136.
31.
CullinanC (2011) Wild Law: A Manifesto for Earth Justice. Devon: Bloomsbury Publishing.
32.
DancerH (2021) Harmony with nature: Towards a new deep legal pluralism. The Journal of Legal Pluralism and Unofficial Law53(1): 21–41.
33.
DauvergneP (2018) Environmentalism of the Rich. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
34.
DeberdtRLe BillonP (2024) Green transition’s necropolitics: Inequalities, climate extractivism, and carbon classes. Antipode56(4): 1264–1288.
35.
DeckardS (2016) World-ecology and Ireland: The neoliberal ecological regime. Journal of World-Systems Research22(1): 145–176.
36.
DobbsMHoughAKelleherO, et al. (2024) Non-diminution, dynamic alignment and cooperation: Exploring the potential of the Windsor Framework to protect the environment. Northern Ireland Legal Quarterly75(3): 550–583.
37.
DooleyN (2025) The politics of structural reform in Ireland: Dominant growth coalitions, domestic business elites, and internal devaluation. Competition & Change29(3–4): 399–418.
38.
DoranP (2025) Are Lough Neagh and the Rights of Nature the unfinished business of ‘the peace process’?Administration72(4): 209–236.
39.
DryzekJS (2016) Institutions for the Anthropocene: Governance in a changing earth system. British Journal of Political Science46(4): 937–956.
40.
DunlapAVerweijenJTornelC (2024) The political ecologies of ‘green’ extractivism(s): An introduction. Journal of Political Ecology31(1): 436–463.
41.
EbbessonJ (2022) Getting it right: Advances of human rights and the environment from Stockholm 1972 to Stockholm 2022. Environmental Policy and Law52(2): 79–92.
42.
EspinosaC (2019) Intelligibility and the intricacies of knowledge and power in transnational activism for the Rights of Nature. Environmental Sociology5(3): 243–254.
43.
FaureMG (2024) The EU environmental crime directive 2024: A revolution in EU environmental criminal law?Journal of Environmental Law36(3): 323–342.
44.
FearonSBarryJ (2022) Beyond growth and partition: Post-growth and ecological perspectives on the political economy of Irish reunification. Irish Studies in International Affairs33(2): 373–405.
FowlerJ (2025) The controversial gold mine set to go before a planning inquiry. BBC, 10 January.
47.
GaardG (2011) Ecofeminism revisited: Rejecting essentialism and re-placing species in a material feminist environmentalism. Feminist Formations23(2): 26–53.
48.
GarryOO’LearyB (2025) Preparing to maximise losers’ consent in contested sovereignty referendums: The potential case of referendums in Irish unification. Political Studies73(2): 839–863.
49.
GouldKAPellowDNSchnaibergA (2008) Treadmill of Production: Injustice and Unsustainability in the Global Economy. London and New York: Routledge.
50.
GuzmánJJ (2019) Decolonizing law and expanding human rights: Indigenous conceptions and the Rights of Nature in Ecuador. Deusto Journal of Human Rights4: 59–86.
51.
HaywardT (2004) Constitutional Environmental Rights. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
HiskesRP (2009) The Human Right to a Green Future: Environmental Rights and Intergenerational Justice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
53.
HunnicuttG (2019) Gender Violence in Ecofeminist Perspective: Intersections of Animal Oppression, Patriarchy and Domination of the Earth. London: Routledge.
54.
HwangJ (2022) Building sustainable peace through environmental cooperation in the island of Ireland: Modelling transboundary conservation. Irish Political Studies37(4): 548–570.
55.
HwangJ (2023) Building sustainable peace through the ‘Rights of Nature’ in Western societies. Journal of Human Rights Studies6(1): 149–188.
56.
HwangJ (2025) The political economy of the Mobuoy Illegal Dump in Northern Ireland: A green criminology perspective. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy14(3): 13–24.
57.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (2022) Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. Geneva: Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.
58.
JosephE (2022) The wages and price of whiteness: The case of Ireland and White supremacy. Radical History Review2022: 79–88.
59.
KauffmanCMMartinPL (2018) Constructing Rights of Nature norms in the US, Ecuador, and New Zealand. Global Environmental Politics18(4): 43–62.
60.
KilleanRGilbertJDoranP (2024) Rights of Nature on the Island of Ireland: Origins, drivers, and implications for future Rights of Nature movements. Transnational Environmental Law13(1): 35–60.
61.
KolbertE (2014) The Sixth Extinction: An Unnatural History. New York: Henry Holt and Company.
62.
KotzéLJCalzadillaPV (2017) Somewhere between rhetoric and reality: Environmentalism and the Rights of Nature in Ecuador. Transnational Environmental Law6(3): 401–433.
63.
LalanderR (2014) Rights of Nature and the Indigenous peoples in Bolivia and Ecuador: A straitjacket for progressive development politics?Iberoamerican Journal of Development Studies3(2): 148–172.
64.
Lappe-OsthegeTDuffyR (2024) International relations and the non-human: Exploring animal culture for global environmental governance. Review of International Studies: 1–20. Epub ahead of print 27 May 2024. DOI: 10.1017/S0260210524000366.
65.
LeachM (2007) Earth mother myths and other ecofeminist fables: How a strategic notion rose and fell. Development and Change38(1): 67–85.
66.
LemesPGFigueiredoJBColenF, et al. (2025) Expansion of solar farms and deforestation in northern Minas Gerais, Brazil. Regional Environmental Change25(127). DOI: 10.1007/s10113-025-02464-z.
67.
LentonTMDutreuilSLatourB (2024) Gaia as seen from within. Theory, Culture & Society41(5): 69–90.
68.
LeonardL (2007) Environmentalism in Ireland: Ecological modernisation versus populist rural sentiment. Environmental Values16(4): 463–483.
69.
LesutisG (2022) The Politics of Precarity: Spaces of Extractivism, Violence and Suffering. London and New York: Routledge.
70.
LindgrenT (2025) In the name of nature: Making the League of Nations, the International Rights of Nature Tribunal and international law. Leiden Journal of International Law. DOI: 10.1017/S0922156525100344. Epub ahead of print 15 August 2025.
71.
LovelockJ (2000) Gaia: A New Look at Life on Earth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
72.
LustyPAJGunnAGMcDonnellPM, et al. (2009) Gold potential of the Dalradian rocks of north-west Northern Ireland: Prospectivity analysis using Tellus data. Applied Earth Science118: 162–177.
73.
LynchMJStreteskyPBLongMA (2020) The treadmill of production and the treadmill of law: Propositions for analyzing law, ecological disorganization and crime. Capitalism Nature Socialism31(1): 107–122.
74.
McBrideS (2019) Burned: The Inside Story of the ‘Cash-for-Ash’ Scandal and Northern Ireland’s Secretive New Elite. New Bridge: Merrion Press.
75.
McDonaldM (2021) Ecological Security. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
76.
MullenML (2016) How the Irish became settlers: Metaphors of indigeneity and the erasure of Indigenous peoples. New Hibernia Review20(3): 81–96.
77.
NashRF (1989) The Rights of Nature: A History of Environmental Ethics. Madison: The University of Wisconsin Press.
78.
O’KeyD (2023) Extinction in public: Thinking through the sixth mass extinction, environmental humanities, and extinction studies. Environmental Humanities15(1): 168–186.
79.
PaliewiczNS (2022) Arguments of green colonialism: A post-dialectical reading of extractivism in the Americas. Argumentation and Advocacy58(3–4): 232–248.
80.
PetelM (2024) The illusion of harmony: Power, politics, and distributive implications of Rights of Nature. Transnational Environmental Law13(1): 12–34.
81.
SandersK (2018) ‘Beyond human ownership’? Property, power and legal personality for nature in Aotearoa New Zealand. Journal of Environmental Law30(2): 207–234.
82.
SimpsonSCheeverK (2025) It was always blood and soil: Ecofascism and the racial Capitalocene. Antipode57(3): 1126–1147.
83.
StoneCD (1972) Should trees have standing? – Toward legal rights for natural objects. Southern California Law Review45: 450–501.
84.
StreckerACireficeVHoughA, et al. (2025) Transboundary environmental justice: Gold mining in the Sperrins Mountains. Report, Environmental Justice Network Ireland.
85.
SuarezJ (2024) Rights of Nature as an alternative or a complement to existing environmental protection. Opolskie Studia Administracyjno-Prawne22(1): 87–117.
86.
TanasescuM (2022) Understanding the Rights of Nature: A Critical Introduction. Bielefeld: Transcript.
87.
TanasescuM (2025) The Rights of Nature go from theory to reality. Current History124(858): 21–26.
88.
WashingtonHGomez-BaggethunEPiccoloJJ, et al. (2022) Harmony in conservation. Conservation2(4): 682–693.
89.
WeeratungeN (2000) Nature, harmony, and the Kaliyugaya: Global/local discourses on the human-environment relationship. Current Anthropology41(2): 249–268.
90.
World Health Organization (2024) COP29 Special Report on Climate Change and Health: Health is the Argument for Climate Action. Geneva: World Health Organization.
