Fictions of the market: The shelter component of the consumer price index in theory and practice

Abstract

Spanish

The consumer price index (CPI), calculated in the United States by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, is a gauge of commodity prices’ fluctuations month-over-month as they are experienced by consumer households. The CPI has wide-ranging influence on economic expectations, especially in inflationary periods. The influence of the so-called “shelter component” of the CPI, which purports to measure fluctuations in housing prices nationally, is considerable. Despite its primacy, the shelter component is deeply flawed and has only limited use when it comes to providing an actual picture of fluctuations in housing and rental prices. In the CPI, housing is not treated as a produced commodity but as a tap from which something called ‘housing services’ flows, to be consumed by households. The failures of the shelter component, I find, are the failures of orthodox economics, also springing from a steadfast refusal to center production. I argue that the reigning economic treatments of housing are based on untenable theoretical assumptions that severely constrain their usefulness; as such, the shelter component of the CPI should be rejected entirely. But first, it is necessary to understand it fully.

Keywords

Housing economics ‌Urban economics Consumer price index Inflation Real estate Tenants Homeowners ‌Landlords

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abraham

Greenlees

Moulton

(1998) Working to improve the consumer price Index. Journal of Economic Perspectives 12(1): 27–36.

Adams

Verbrugge

(2021) Location, location, structure type: Rent divergence within neighborhoods. SSRN Electronic Journal. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3782829.

Airgood-Obrycki

Hermann

Wedeen

(2022) “The rent eats first”: Rental housing unaffordability in the United States. Housing Policy Debate 33(6): 1–21.

Article 7 § 227 (2023) New York real property law. Available at: https://law.justia.com/codes/new-york/rpp/article-7/227/.

Barker

(2003) Length of residence discounts, turnover, and demand elasticity: Should long-term tenants pay less than new tenants? Journal of Housing Economics 12(1): 1–11.

Benítez-Silva

Eren

Heiland

, et al. (2015) How well do individuals predict the selling prices of their homes?. Journal of Housing Economics 29: 12–25. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhe.2015.04.001.

Bhandar

Toscano

(2015) Race, real estate and real abstraction. Radical Philosophy 194: 8–17.

BLS (2022) Handbook of methods: Consumer expenditures and income: Overview. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cex/home.htm (accessed 7 March 2023).

BLS (2023a) Calculation : Handbook of methods. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cex/calculation.htm#calculation-methodology (accessed 9 March 2023).

10.

BLS (2023b) Consumer price indexes overview: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/overview.htm (accessed 7 March 2023).

11.

BLS (2023c) Handbook of methods: Consumer price index: Design. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cpi/design.htm (accessed 8 March 2023).

12.

BLS (2023d) Measuring price change in the CPI: Rent and rental equivalence. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/owners-equivalent-rent-and-rent.htm (accessed 8 March 2023).

13.

BLS (2023e) Table 1. Consumer price index for all urban consumers (CPI-U): U. S. city average, by expenditure category - 2023 M01 results. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.t01.htm (accessed 8 March 2023).

14.

Böhm-Bawerk

(1923) The Positive Theory of Capital. New York: G.E. Stechert & Co.

15.

Clarke

(2016) Marx, Marginalism and Modern Sociology: From Adam Smith to Max Weber. New York: Springer.

16.

Conlisk

(1996) Why bounded rationality? Journal of Economic Literature 34(2): 669–700.

17.

Curtis

Wright

(2004) Price setting, price dispersion, and the value of money: Or, the law of two prices. Journal of Monetary Economics 51(8): 1599–1621.

18.

Díaz

Luengo-Prado

(2010) The wealth distribution with durable goods. International Economic Review 51(1): 143–170.

19.

Diewert

(2003) The treatment of owner occupied housing and other durables in a consumer price index. In: Vancouver, Canada, 26 November 2003. Available at: http://papers.economics.ubc.ca/legacypapers/dp0308.pdf (accessed 14 September 2022).

20.

Diewert

Nakamura

(2009) The housing bubble and a new approach to accounting for housing in a CPI. Journal of Housing Economics 18(3): 156–171. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhe.2009.07.008.

21.

Dunaway-Seale

(2024) 2024 Data: Half of Americans are surprised by how much it costs to move. Available at: https://homebay.com/moving-trends-2024/ (accessed 14 November 2024).

22.

Dunford

Perrons

(1983) The Arena of Capital. London: Macmillan Press.

23.

European Commission, International Monetary Fund, Organization for Economic Co-Operation and Development , et al. (2009) System of National Accounts. New York: United Nations.

24.

Fixler

(1999) The use of hedonic regressions to handle quality change: The experience in the U.S. CPI.

25.

Flueck

Waksberg

Kaitz

(1971) An overview of consumer expenditure survey methodology. Conference paper. Fort Collins, Colorado. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/cex/research_papers/pdf/flueck-an-overview-of-consumer-expenditure-survey-methodology.pdf.

26.

Fraser

Jaeggi

(2018) Capitalism: A Conversation in Critical Theory. 1st ed. Cambridge Medford (Mass): Polity.

27.

FRED Blog (2021) Rents still rising with regional riffs. Available at: https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2021/08/rents-still-rising-with-regional-riffs/ (accessed 5 November 2022).

28.

FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (2023) Consumer price index for all urban consumers: Rent of primary residence in U.S. City average [CUUR0000SEHA]. Available at: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=wHJG (accessed 8 March 2023).

29.

Frick

Grabka

Smeeding

, et al. (2010) Distributional effects of imputed rents in five European countries. Journal of Housing Economics 19(3): 167–179.

30.

Gallin

Verbrugge

(2019) A theory of sticky rents: Search and bargaining with incomplete information. Journal of Economic Theory 183: 478–519.

31.

Garcia

(2023) Renters: Results from the zillow consumer housing trends report 2023. Available at: https://www.zillow.com/research/renters-consumer-housing-trends-report-2023-33317/ (accessed 14 November 2024).

32.

Garner

Short

(2009) Accounting for owner-occupied dwelling services: Aggregates and distributions. Journal of Housing Economics 18(3). Special issue on owner occupied housing in national accounts and inflation measures: 233–248.

33.

Garner

Verbrugge

(2009) Reconciling user costs and rental equivalence: Evidence from the US consumer expenditure survey. Journal of Housing Economics 18(3): 172–192.

34.

Gillingham

(1983) Measuring the cost of shelter for homeowners: Theoretical and empirical considerations. The Review of Economics and Statistics 65(2): 254. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1924491.

35.

Girardi

(2017) Old and new formulations of the neoclassical theory of aggregate investment: A critical review. Working Paper 2017–03. University of Massachusetts Amherst.

36.

Greenlees

Williams

(2009) Reconsideration of weighting and updating procedures in the US CPI. In: Neuchâtel, Switzerland, 27 May 2009. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/osmr/research-papers/2009/pdf/ec090090.pdf.

37.

Gromis

Fellows

Hendrickson

, et al. (2022) Estimating eviction prevalence across the United States. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

38.

Guo

Hardin

(2014) Financial and housing wealth, expenditures and the dividend to ownership. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 54(1): 58–96. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11146-015-9540-1.

39.

Harrison

Immergluck

(2021) Housing vacancy and hypervacant neighborhoods: Uneven recovery after the U.S. foreclosure crisis. Journal of Urban Affairs 45(8): 1–17.

40.

Heeb

(2022) Mortgage rates record biggest calendar-year increase in 2022. Wall Street Journal, 29 December. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/mortgage-rates-record-biggest-annual-increase-in-four-decades-11672331790 (accessed 8 March 2023).

41.

Heston

Nakamura

(2009) Questions about the equivalence of market rents and user costs for owner occupied housing. Journal of Housing Economics 18(3): 273–279. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jhe.2009.07.007.

42.

Hill

(2013) Hedonic price indexes for residential housing: A survey, evaluation and taxonomy. Journal of Economic Surveys 27(5): 879–914. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/joes.2013.27.issue-5.

43.

Houck

(2022) Housing leases in the U.S. rental market: Spotlight on statistics. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/spotlight/2022/housing-leases-in-the-u-s-rental-market/home.htm (accessed 9 March 2023).

44.

Katz

(2017) Imputing rents to owner-occupied housing by directly modelling their distribution. BEA Working Papers 0144. Bureau of Economic Analysis.

45.

Kauder

(1965) A History of Marginal Utility Theory. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

46.

Kirk

(2022) Untangling eviction, disadvantage, race, and social processes: Neighborhood factors influencing crime. Crime & Delinquency 68(4). SAGE Publications Inc: 594–612.

47.

Kudlyak

(2012) Housing services price inflation. Economic Quarterly 98(3): 185–207.

48.

Liegey

(2002) Hedonic quality adjustments in the U.S. CPI: A statistical agency perspective. In: ZEW-Conference: Price Indices and the Measurement of Quality Changes, Mannheim, Germany, 26 April 2002. Available at: bls.gov/cpi/white-papers/hedonic-quality-adjustments-statistical-agency-perspective.pdf.

49.

Lovell

(1986) Tests of the rational expectations hypothesis. The American Economic Review 76(1). American Economic Association: 110–124.

50.

Lucas

(1980) Methods and problems in business cycle theory. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 12(4). [Wiley, Ohio State University Press]: 696–715.

51.

Menger

(1981) Principles of Economics. New York: New York University Press.

52.

Myers

Park

(2019) A constant quartile mismatch indicator of changing rental affordability in U.S. metropolitan areas, 2000 to 2016 | HUD USER. Cityscape (Washington, D C ) 21(1): 163–200.

53.

Naidin

M. Denisa

Waltl

Sofie R

Ziegelmeyer

Michael H.

(2025) Objective Housing Sales and Rent Prices in Representative Household Surveys: Implications for Wealth, Inequality, Housing Market, and Affordability Statistics. Review of Income and Wealth 71(1). DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/roiw.v71.1.

54.

Nilsen

Perrins

(2012) Math calculations to better utilize CPI data. Washington D.C.: Bureau of Labor Statistics. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/factsheets/cpi-math-calculations.pdf.

55.

Paben

Johnson

Schilp

(2016) The 2018 revision of the consumer price index geographic sample. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2016/article/the-2018-revision-of-the-cpi-geographic-sample.htm (accessed 12 March 2023).

56.

Poole

Ptacek

Verbrugge

(2005) Treatment of owner-occupied housing in the CPI.

57.

Prescott

(1997) On Defining Real Consumption. Review 79(3). DOI: https://doi.org/10.20955/r.

58.

Ptacek

Baskin

(1996) Revision of the CPI housing sample and estimators. Monthly Labor Review 119(12): 31–39.

59.

Rabin

(1983) Revolution in residential landlord-tenant law: Causes and consequences symposium. Cornell Law Review 69(3): 517–584.

60.

Roback

(1982) Wages, rents, and the quality of life. Journal of Political Economy 90(6). The University of Chicago Press: 1257–1278.

61.

Rosen

(1974) Hedonic prices and implicit markets: Product differentiation in pure competition. Journal of Political Economy 82(1). The University of Chicago Press: 34–55.

62.

Seron

Frankel

Van Ryzin

, et al. (2001) The impact of legal counsel on outcomes for poor tenants in New York city’s housing court: Results of a randomized experiment. Law & Society Review 35(2): 419–434.

63.

Shaikh

(2016) Capitalism: Competition, Conflict, Crises. New York: Oxford University Press.

64.

Shaikh

Tonak

(1996) Measuring the Wealth of Nations. New York: Cambridge University Press.

65.

Sheidu

(2013) Description of the Revised Commodities and Services Optimal Sample Design. Washington, DC: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.

66.

Sirmans

Macpherson

Zietz

(2005) The composition of hedonic pricing models. Journal of Real Estate Literature 13(1). American Real Estate Society: 3–43.

67.

Sommer

Sullivan

Verbrugge

(2013) The equilibrium effect of fundamentals on house prices and rents. Journal of Monetary Economics 60(7): 854–870.

68.

Statistical Office of the European Union (2023) Owner-occupied housing and the harmonised index of consumer prices. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union.

69.

Steindel

(2006) Owners’ equivalent rent and the cost of living. Business Economics 41(1). Palgrave Macmillan Ltd.: 66–68.

70.

Summers

(2020) The limits of good law: A study of housing court outcomes. The University of Chicago Law Review 87(1): 145–222.

71.

Timiraos

(2023) Jerome Powell to testify to congress on outlook for interest rates, inflation. Wall Street Journal, 7 March. Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/jerome-powell-to-testify-to-congress-on-outlook-for-rates-inflation-e4e7f1e3 (accessed 7 March 2023).

72.

U. S. Government Accountability Office (2020) How COVID-19 could aggravate the homelessness crisis? Available at: https://www.gao.gov/blog/how-covid-19-could-aggravate-homelessness-crisis (accessed 8 March 2023).

73.

Verbrugge

(2008) The puzzling divergence of rents and user costs, 1980–2004. Review of Income and Wealth 54(4): 671–699.

74.

Verbrugge

(2012) Do the consumer price index’s utilities adjustments for owners’ equivalent rent distort inflation measurement? Journal of Business & Economic Statistics 30(1). American Statistical Association: 143–148.

75.

Verbrugge

Gallin

(2017) A Theory of Sticky Rents: Search and Bargaining with Incomplete Information. 2973964, SSRN Scholarly Paper. Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2973964 (accessed 19 November 2024).

76.

Verbrugge

Poole

(2010) Explaining the rent-OER inflation divergence, 1999-2006. Real Estate Economics 38(4): 633–657.

77.

Waltl

Lepinteur

(2023) Tracking home-owners’ sentiments: Subjective indices and convergent validity. The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 35: 135. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11146-023-09949-w.