The Housing Question,ground rent theory,and differentiation vs. homogenization

Abstract

Spanish

This essay takes Engels’ The Housing Question as a provocation to (1) apply ground rent theory to housing (something which Engels neglected to do) and (2) investigate Engels’ conflation of housing struggles with the concerns of a “backwards” peasantry. I show that applying Marx’s ground rent theory to housing illuminates aspects of the housing question heretofore unexamined—in particular, the significance of the relationship between landowner and capitalist in housing. I then show that Engels’ dismissal of housing struggles and land-based struggles more broadly is rooted in the specious belief that proletarianization homogenizes people. Engels’ spurious logic nonetheless sets in relief an important connection: I suggest that only through grasping what Cedric Robinson has called racialization or differentiation and what Sylvia Wynter has named nonhomogeneity can we recognize the theoretical and practical centrality of housing and other land-based struggles to revolution and abolition.

Keywords

ground rent housing land rent political economy racial capitalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aalbers

MB.

Christophers

(2014a) Centering housing in political economy. Housing, Theory and Society 31(February 2015): 1–22.

Aalbers

MB.

Christophers

(2014b) The housing question under capitalist political economies. Housing, Theory and Society 31(4): 422–428.

Anderson

(2010) Marx at the Margins: On Nationalism, Ethnicity, and Non-Western Societies. Chicago: Chicago University Press.

Andreucci

García-Lamarca

Wedekind

et al. (2017) “Value grabbing”: a political ecology of rent. Capitalism Nature Socialism 28(3): 28–47.

Anti-Eviction Mapping Project (2019) (Dis) Location Black Exodus. Available at: http://archive.org/details/dislocationblackexodus (accessed 1 February 2020).

Association for Neighborhood and Housing Development (2009) Predatory Equity: Evolution of a Crisis. Available at: https://anhd.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/Predatory_Equity-Evolution_of_a_Crisis_Report.pdf (accessed 24 April 2019).

August

Walks

(2018) Gentrification, suburban decline, and the financialization of multi-family rental housing: the case of Toronto. Geoforum 89(2): 124–136.

Auspurg

Schneck

Hinz

(2019) Closed doors everywhere? A meta-analysis of field experiments on ethnic discrimination in rental housing markets. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 45(1): 95–114.

Ball

(1985) The urban rent question. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 17(4): 503–525.

10.

Banaji

(1990) Illusions about the peasantry: Karl Kautsky and the agrarian question. Journal of Peasant Studies 17(2): 288–307.

11.

Baranski

(2007) Something to help themselves: tenant organizing in San Francisco’s public housing, 1965–1975. Journal of Urban History 33(3): 418–442.

12.

Barton

(1977) The urban housing problem: Marxist theory and community organizing. The Review of radical political economics 9(4): 16–30.

13.

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (2019) Mortgage debt outstanding. Fred, federal reserve bank of St. Louis. Available at: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MDOAH (accessed 8 October 2020).

14.

Brenner

(1985) The agrarian roots of European capitalism. In: and Philpin

CHE.

Aston

TH.

(eds) The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe. Past and Present Publications. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press , pp. 213–328.

15.

Brooks

Tomengo

(2020) Webinar on afrofuturism and pop culture with Dr. Kinitra Brooks. 2020-2021 Afrofuturism Syllabus - Week 7. Available at: https://stars.library.ucf.edu/afrofuturism_syllabus_7/1

16.

Bullock

HE.

Reppond

HA.

Truong

et al. (2020) An intersectional analysis of the feminization of homelessness and mothers’ housing precarity. Journal of Social Issues 76(4): 835–858.

17.

Bureau of Economic Analysis (2019) Overview of Source Data and Estimating Methods. Bureau of Economic Analysis.

18.

Byres

(1991) The agrarian question and differing forms of capitalist agrarian transition: an essay with reference to Asia. In: Rural Transformation in Asia. Oxford: Oxford University Press , pp. 3–76.

19.

Caraway

(2007) Assembling Women: The Feminization of Global Manufacturing. Ithaca, NY: ILR Press.

20.

Carucci Goss

Campbell

(2008) The evolution of residential property management: from Caretaker to income Maximization managers. Housing and Society 35(1): 5–20.

21.

Chatterjee

(2014) Displacement, Revolution, and the New Urban Condition: Theories and Case Studies. 1st edn. Los Angeles: SAGE Publications Pvt. Ltd.

22.

Christophers

(2018) The New Enclosure: The Appropriation of Public Land in Neoliberal Britain. London; Brooklyn, NY: Verso.

23.

Clarke

Ginsburg

(1974) The Political Economy of Housing. Political Economy of Housing Group: 19.

24.

Corr

(1999) No Trespassing!: Squatting, Rent Strikes, and Land Struggles Worldwide. Cambridge, MA: South End Press.

25.

Crenshaw Subway Coalition (n.d.) Gentrification 101. Available at: https://www.crenshawsubway.org/gentrification101 (accessed 21 March 2021).

26.

Davies

(1958) Real Estate in American History. Washington: Public Affairs Press.

27.

Davis

MA.

Heathcote

(2007) The price and quantity of residential land in the United States. Journal of Monetary Economics 54(8): 2595–2620.

28.

Doucet

Weaver

(1991) Housing the North American City. Montreal; Buffalo: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

29.

Dougé-Prosper

(2019) Solidarity economy praxis in limonade: reintellecting woman as subject. WSQ: Women’s Studies Quarterly 47(3-4): 190–211.

30.

Du Bois

WEB

(1979) Black Reconstruction in America 1860-1880. New York: Atheneum.

31.

Dymski

(2009) Racial exclusion and the political economy of the Subprime crisis. Historical Materialism 17(2): 149–179.

32.

Economakis

(2003) On absolute rent: theoretical remarks on Marx’s analysis. Science & Society 67(3): 339–348.

33.

Edel

(1975) Marx’s theory of rent: urban applications. Kapitalistate 4/5.

34.

Engels

(1887) Preface to the second German edition of the housing question. Available at: https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1872/housing-question/ (accessed 16 May 2019).

35.

Engels

(2010) The housing question. In: Marx Engels Collected Works. 23. Lawrence & Wishart , pp. 1871–1874.

36.

Federici

(2004) Caliban and the Witch: Women, The Body, and Primitive Accumulation. Autonomedia. Available at: http://www.amazon.com/dp/1570270597

37.

Fernandez

Aalbers

(2017) Housing and capital in the 21st century: realigning housing studies and political economy. Housing, Theory and Society 34(2): 151–158.

38.

Fernandez

Aalbers

(2020) Housing financialization in the global South: in search of a comparative framework. Housing Policy Debate 30(4): 680–701.

39.

Fields

(2018) Constructing a new asset class: property-led financial accumulation after the crisis. Economic Geography 94(2): 118–140.

40.

Fields

Uffer

(2016) The financialisation of rental housing: a comparative analysis of New York City and Berlin. Urban Studies 53(7): 1486–1502.

41.

Fine

(1979) On Marx’s theory of agricultural rent. Economy and Society 8: 241–278.

42.

Fullilove

(2001) Root shock: the consequences of African American dispossession. Journal of Urban Health: Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine 78(1): 72–80.11368205

43.

Fullilove

(2016) Root Shock: How Tearing Up City Neighborhoods Hurts America, and What We Can Do About It. NYU Press.

44.

Fullilove

(2020) Revisiting “The Frayed Knot”: What happens to place attachment in the context of serial forced displacement? In: Place Attachment: Advances in Theory, Methods and Applications. London: Routledge.

45.

Gauldie

(1974) Cruel Habitations: A History of Working-Class Housing 1780-1918. London: Allen & Unwin.

46.

Gilmore

(2007) Golden Gulag. University of California Press. http://books.google.com/books?id=S8RU3YVNbkoC.

47.

Glick

JL.

Lopez

Pollock

et al. (2019) “Housing insecurity seems to almost go hand in hand with being trans”: Housing stress among transgender and gender non-conforming individuals in New Orleans. Journal of Urban Health 96(5): 751–759.31529193

48.

Goffe

(Forthcoming) Reproducing the plot. Antipode.

49.

Greystar (2020) Real estate investment management. Available at: https://www.greystar.com/investor-services/investment-management (accessed 4 January 2021).

50.

Haila

(1990) The theory of land rent at the crossroads. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space 8(3): 275–296.

51.

Haila

(2015) Urban Land Rent: Singapore as a Property State. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons.

52.

Hanchett

(2000) The other ‘subsidized housing’: federal aid to suburbanization, 1940s-1960s. In: From Tenements to the Taylor Homes: In Search of an Urban Housing Policy in Twentieth Century America. Pennsylvania: The Pennsylvania State University Press , pp. 163–179.

53.

Hartman

(2018) The anarchy of colored girls assembled in a Riotous manner. South Atlantic Quarterly 117(3): 465–490.

54.

Harvey

(1974) Class-monopoly rent, finance capital and the urban revolution. Regional Studies 8(3–4): 239–255.

55.

Harvey

(2007) The Limits to Capital. New York: Verso.

56.

Harvey

(2009) Social Justice and the City. Edición: Revised. Athens: University of Georgia Press.

57.

Harvey

(2013) A Companion to Marx’s Capital Volume 2. New York: Verso.

58.

Harvey

(2014) Seventeen Contradictions and the End of Capitalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

59.

Hauser

(1993) Violence, agrarian radicalism and electoral politics: Reflections on the Indian people’s front. Journal of Peasant Studies 21(1): 85–126.

60.

Herring

Rosenman

(2016) Engels in the crescent City: revisiting the housing question in post-Katrina new Orleans. ACME 15(3): 616–638.

61.

Hodkinson

(2012) The return of the housing question. Ephemera: Theory and Politics in Organization 12(4): 22.

62.

Horne

(2018) The Apocalypse of Settler Colonialism: The Roots of Slavery, White Supremacy, and Capitalism in 17th Century North America and the Caribbean. 1st edn. New York: Monthly Review Press , pp. 1–69.

63.

Hsing

(2010) The Great Urban Transformation: Politics of Land and Property in China. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

64.

Jacobe

(2007) Americans are hooked on home equity Loans/Lines. Available at: https://news.gallup.com/poll/26488/Americans-Hooked-Home-Equity-LoansLines.aspx (accessed 30 March 2021).

65.

Jäger

(2003) Urban land rent theory: a regulationist perspective. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 27(2): 233–249.

66.

James

(2020) Airbrushing revolution for the sake of abolition. In: AAIHS . Available at: https://www.aaihs.org/airbrushing-revolution-for-the-sake-of-abolition/ (accessed 2 April 2021).

67.

Kalman-Lamb

(2017) The financialization of housing in Canada: intensifying contradictions of neoliberal accumulation. Studies in Political Economy 98(3): 298–323.

68.

Kautsky

(1988) The Agrarian Question. Library 1.

69.

Knoll

Schularick

Steger

(2017) No price like home: global house prices, 1870–2012. American Economic Review 107(2): 331–353.

70.

Krijnen

(2018) Gentrification and the creation and formation of rent gaps: opening up gentrification theory to global forces of urban change. City 22(3): 437–446.

71.

Land Report (2019) Land report 100. Available at: https://landreport.com/americas-100-largest-landowners/ (accessed 7 August 2020).

72.

Larsen

HG.

Hansen

AL.

MacLeod

(2016) Introduction: the housing question revisited. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 15(3): 580–589.

73.

Lauster

NT.

Easterbrook

(2011) No Room for New Families?: A Field Experiment Measuring Rental Discrimination against Same-Sex Couples and Single Parents. Vancouver: University of British Columbia.

74.

Lea

(2010) International Comparison of Mortgage Product Offerings. Research Institute for Housing America , p. 118.

75.

Linebaugh

(2006) The London Hanged: Crime and Civil Society in The Eighteenth Century. 2nd edn. London; New York: Verso.

76.

Lopez-Morales

(2011) Gentrification by ground rent dispossession: the shadows cast by large-scale urban renewal in Santiago de Chile. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 35(2): 330–357.

77.

Manning

FTC

(Forthcoming) A defense of the concept of the Landowning class as 3rd class. Historical Materialism.

78.

Marx

(1881) Marx-Zasulich correspondence February/March 1881. Available at: https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1881/zasulich/reply.htm (accessed 30 September 2017).

79.

Marx

(1967) Capital Volume 3: The Process of Capitalist Production as a Whole. International Publishers.

80.

Marx

(1968) Theories of Surplus Value Part II. Moscow: Progress Publishers.

81.

Marx

(1993) Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy. (tran. M Nicolaus). Reprint ed. London; New York: Penguin Classics. http://www.amazon.com/Grundrisse-Foundations-Critique-Political-Classics/dp/0140445757/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1452810758&sr=1-1&keywords=grundrisse.

82.

Marx

(2015) Marx’s Economic Manuscript of 1864-1865 . (ed. F Moseley; tran. PB Fowkes). Lam edition. Leiden; Boston: Brill Academic Publications.

83.

McKittrick

Wynter

(2015) Unparalleled catastrophe for our species? Or, to give Humanness a different future: conversations. In: Sylvia Wynter: On Being Human as Praxis. Durham: Duke University Press Books.

84.

Neal

(2019) Mortgage debt has peaked: why has the share of Homeowners with a Mortgage fallen to a 13-year low? Available at: https://www.urban.org/urban-wire/mortgage-debt-has-peaked-why-has-share-homeowners-mortgage-fallen-13-year-low (accessed 8 October 2020).

85.

Omvedt

(1991) Theorists of the peasantry should at least have their feet on the ground: a response to Banaji. Journal of Peasant Studies 19(1): 138–141.

86.

Park

(2014) Land rent theory revisited. Science & Society 78(1): 88–109.

87.

Pereira

ALDS

(2017) Financialization of housing in Brazil: new frontiers. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 41(4): 604–622.

88.

Perry

K-KY

(2013) Black Women against the Land Grab: The Fight for Racial Justice in Brazil. 1st edn. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

89.

Purcell

TF.

Loftus

March

(2020) Value–rent–finance. Progress in Human Geography 44(3): 437–456.

90.

Quinn

(2010) Government Policy, Housing, and the Origins of Securitization, 1780-1968 . Berkeley, California: UC Berkeley.

91.

RENTCafé (2018) Renting landscape in the most populous & highly developed countries. Available at: https://www.rentcafe.com/blog/rental-market/renting-landscape-30-countries-around-world/ (accessed 7 March 2021).

92.

Robbins

(2018) Engels and the perennial housing crisis. Critical and Radical Social Work 6(2): 231–239.

93.

Robertson

(2017) The great British housing crisis. Capital & Class 41(2): 195–215.

94.

Robinson

(2000) Black Marxism: The Making of the Black Radical Tradition. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.

95.

Romainville

(2017) The Financialization of housing production in Brussels: the financialization of housing production in Brussels. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 41(4): 623–641.

96.

Rowe

Engelsman

Southern

(2016) Community land trusts - a radical or reformist response to the housing question today? ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 15(3): 590–615.

97.

Roy

(2014) Reserve labor, unreserved politics: dignified encroachments under India’s national rural employment guarantee act. The Journal of Peasant Studies 41(4): 517–545.

98.

Roy

(2015) Utopia in crisis? Subaltern Imaginations in contemporary Bihar. Journal of Contemporary Asia 45(4): 640–659.

99.

Rugh

JS.

Massey

(2010) Racial segregation and the American Foreclosure crisis. American Sociological Review 75(5): 629–651 . American Sociological Association, Sage Publications, Inc..25308973

100.

Saegert

(1989) Unlikely leaders, extreme circumstances: older black women building community households. American Journal of Community Psychology 17(3): 295–316.

101.

Saegert

(2016) Rereading “The Housing Question” in light of the foreclosure crisis. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 15(3): 659–678.

102.

Sahlins

(2017) Stone Age Economics. London: Routledge. 978-1-138-70261-5.

103.

Samwick

(1995) Tax Shelters and Passive Losses After the Tax Reform Act of 1986. Working Paper Series 5171, July. National Bureau of Economic Research.

104.

Schuetz

(2019) Renting the American dream: why homeownership shouldn’t be a prerequisite for middle-class financial security. In: Brookings . Available at: https://www.brookings.edu/blog/up-front/2019/02/13/renting-the-american-dream-why-homeownership-shouldnt-be-a-pre-requisite-for-middle-class-financial-security/ (accessed 8 October 2020).

105.

Schwegman

(2019) Rental market discrimination against same-sex couples: evidence from a Pairwise-Matched Email correspondence test. Housing Policy Debate 29(2): 250–272.

106.

Scott

(2018) The Common Wind: Afro-American Currents in the Age of the Haitian Revolution. London; New York: Verso.

107.

Shange

(2019) Progressive Dystopia: Abolition, Antiblackness, and Schooling in San Francisco. Illustrated Edition. Durham: Duke University Press Books.

108.

Smith

(1979) Toward a theory of gentrification a back to the city movement by capital, not people. Journal of the American Planning Association 45(4): 538–548.

109.

Smith

(1987) Gentrification and the rent gap. Annals of the Association of American Geographers 77(3): 462–465.

110.

Smith

(1996) The New Urban Frontier: Gentrification and the Revanchist City. UK: Routledge.

111.

Smith

(2016) The housing question revisited. ACME: An International Journal for Critical Geographies 15(3) 3: 679–683.

112.

Taylor

K-Y

(2019) Race for Profit: How Banks and the Real Estate Industry Undermined Black Homeownership. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.

113.

The Urban Displacement Project (2021) Gentrification explained. Available at: https://www.urbandisplacement.org/gentrification-explained (accessed 21 March 2021).

114.

Theurillat

Lenzer

JH.

Zhan

(2016) The increasing financialization of China’s urbanization. Issues & Studies 52(04): 1640002.

115.

Topal

Yalman

GL.

Çelik

Özlem

(2019) Changing modalities of urban redevelopment and housing finance in turkey: three mass housing projects in Ankara. Journal of Urban Affairs 41(5): 630–653.

116.

Turner

(2005) Discrimination Against Persons with Disabilities: Barriers at Every Step. Office of Policy Development and Research, U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.

117.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (n.d.) Consumer price index for all urban consumers: rent of primary residence in U.S. City average. Fred, federal reserve bank of St. Louis. Available at: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CUUR0000SEHA (accessed 7 March 2021).

118.

U.S. Census Bureau (2020) 2019 American community survey 1-year estimate detailed tables. Available at: https://data.census.gov/cedsci/table?q=renter%20households&tid=ACSDT1Y2019.B25003&hidePreview=false (accessed 7 March 2021).

119.

United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (2018) Rental housing finance survey (RHFS), 2012. Inter-university Consortium for political and social research (ICPSR).

120.

Van der Bracht

Coenen

Van de Putte

(2015) The Not-in-My-Property syndrome: the occurrence of ethnic discrimination in the Rental housing market in Belgium. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 41(1): 158–175.

121.

Varghese

(2021) Combating capitalism: a case study of left Polity in Kerala. International Critical Thought 40(6): 1–18.

122.

Vergerio

(n.d.) Evictions in NYC. Available at: https://www.manonvergerio.com/evictions-in-nyc-2 (accessed 6 April 2021).

123.

Wachsmuth

Weisler

(2018) Airbnb and the rent gap: Gentrification through the sharing economy. Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space 50(6): 1147–1170.

124.

Walker

(1974) Urban ground rent: building a new conceptual framework. Antipode 6(1): 51–58.

125.

Ward

Aalbers

(2016) Virtual special issue editorial essay: ‘The shitty rent business’: what’s the point of land rent theory? Urban Studies 53(9): 1760–1783.

126.

White

(2019) Freedom Farmers: Agricultural Resistance and the Black Freedom Movement. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press.

127.

Williams

(1994) Capitalism and Slavery. 1st edn. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.

128.

Williams

(2004) The Politics of Public Housing: Black Women’s Struggles against Urban Inequality. 1st edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

129.

Woods

(1998) Development Arrested. Verso.

130.

Chen

Pan

et al. (2020) Assetization: the Chinese path to housing Financialization. Annals of the American Association of Geographers 110(5): 1483–1499 . Taylor & Francis.

131.

Wynter

(1995) 1492: A new world view. Race, Discourse, and the Origin of the Americas: a New World View: 5–57.

132.

Yeşilbağ

(2020) The state-orchestrated financialization of housing in turkey. Housing policy debate 30(4): 533–558.