The centering of development in post-9/11 US national security strategies, combined with the restructuring of the US state's foreign development apparatus, promise deep changes in understandings and practices of food security and its relationship to development and processes of neoliberalization, securitization, and militarization. Long a stated objective within US foreign aid programs, especially those based around food aid, recent strategic shifts have rescripted food security as a basic need that should be met through the market, and as a proxy measurement for good governance. By the same token, food insecurity becomes a measure of poor governance and a contributor to political instability and persistent underdevelopment, laying the groundwork for international terrorism and criminal activity. This paper examines the altered contexts and practicalities of US food aid in Indonesia, as the relationship between such assistance and broader projects of sub-imperialism and neoliberalization, in Indonesia and in Southeast Asia more generally, must be interrogated. US development and geopolitical strategies identify Indonesia as both a strategically important ally in the global war on terror and a vulnerable state, prone to deteriorating security and governance. Under post-9/11 security and development strategies, development and humanitarian assistance centered on food aid and improved food security have become primary components of US policy in and toward Indonesia. I ground my discussion in two case studies: security-oriented food-for -work programs in Jakarta and the militarization of food aid in post-tsunami Aceh province.
Bappenas, Departmen Pertanian, US Agency for International Development, and DAI Food Policy Advisory Team. (2004) The Food Policy Support Activity Final Report.Washington, DC: Development Alternatives International, Inc.
2.
BarrettChristopher B., and DanielG. Maxwell (2005) Food Aid After Fifty Years: Recasting its role.London: Routledge.
3.
BerriganFrida (2005) “After the Tsunami: Military Aid For Indonesia?” CommonDreams.org News Center, 18 Feburary 2005, available online at http://www.commondreams.org/views05/0218-32.htm (last accessed 13 March 2008).
4.
CarrEdward R. (2005) “Development and the household: Missing the point?”GeoJournal, 62(1): 71–83.
5.
CarrEdward R. (2006) “Postmodern conceptualizations, modernist applications: Rethinking the role of society in food security.”Food Policy, 31(1): 14–29.
6.
EdkinsJenny (2000) Whose Hunger? Concepts of Famine, Practices of Aid.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
7.
EssexJamey (2008a) “Deservedness, development, and the state: Geographic Categorization in the US Agency for International Development's Foreign Assistance Framework.”Geoforum, 39 (4): 1625–1636.
8.
EssexJamey (2008b) “The Neoliberalization of Development: Trade Capacity Building and Security at the US Agency for International Development.”Antipode, 40 (2): 229–251.
9.
FriedmanThomas L. (1999) “A Manifesto for the Fast World.”The New York Times, 28 March 1999.
10.
GarstRachel, and BarryTom (1990) Feeding the Crisis: U.S. Food Aid and Farm Policy in Central America.Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press.
11.
GlassmanJim (2005a) “The new imperialism? On continuity and change in US foreign policy.”Environment and Planning A, 37(9): 1527–1544.
12.
GlassmanJim (2005b) “The ‘War on Terrorism’ comes to Southeast Asia.”Journal of Contemporary Asia, 35(1): 3–28.
13.
General Accounting Office. (1995a) Food Aid: Competing Goals and Requirements Hinder Title I ProgramResults [GAO/GGD-96-68].Washington, DC: GAO.
14.
General Accounting Office. (1995b) Foreign Aid: Actions Taken to Improve Food Aid Management [GAO/NSIAD-95-74].Washington, DC: GAO.
15.
General Accounting Office. (2002) Food Aid: Experience of US Programs Suggests Opportunities for Improvement, Statement of Loren Yager, Director, International Affairs and Trade [GAO-02-801T].Washington, DC: GAO.
16.
Government Accountability Office. (2007a) Foreign Assistance: US Agencies Face Challenges to Improvingthe Efficiency and Effectiveness of Food Aid, Statement of Thomas Melito, Director InternationalAffairs and Trade [GAO-07-616T].Washington, DC: GAO.
17.
Government Accountability Office. (2007b) Foreign Assistance: Various Challenges Impede the Efficiencyand Effectiveness of US Food Aid [GAO-07-560].Washington, DC: GAO.
18.
Government Accountability Office. (2007c) Foreign Assistance: Various Challenges Limit the Efficiency andEffectiveness of US Food Aid, Statement of Thomas Melito, Director, International Affairs and Trade[GAO-07-905T].Washington, DC: GAO.
19.
GebremedhimBerhanu, and ScottM. Swinton (2001) “Reconciling food-for-work project feasibility with food aid targeting in Tigray, Ethiopia.”Food Policy, 26(1): 85–95.
20.
HartGillian (2004) “Geography and development: critical ethnographies.”Progress in Human Geography, 28(1): 91–100.
21.
HarveyDavid (1998) “The body as an accumulation strategy.”Environment and Planning D: Society andSpace, 16(4): 401–421.
22.
HarveyDavid (2003) The New Imperialism.New York: Oxford University Press.
23.
HeynenNik (2006) “Justice of Eating In the City: The Political Ecology of Urban Hunger.” In HeynenNik, KaikaMaria, and SwyngedouwErik (eds.), In the Nature of Cities: Urban Political Ecology and the Politics of Urban Metabolism.London: Routledge, 129–142.
KleinNaomi (2007) The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism.Toronto: Alfred A. Knopf Canada.
27.
KleinfeldMargo (2007) “Misreading the Post-tsunami Landscape in Sri Lanka: The Myth of Humanitarian Space.”Space and Polity, 11(2): 169–184.
28.
KodrasJanet (1993) “Shifting global strategies of US foreign food aid, 1955–1990.”Political Geography, 12(3): 232–246.
29.
LobeJim (2005) “Bush Uses Tsunami Aid to Regain Foothold in Indonesia.” AntiWar.com and Inter Press Service, 18 January 2005, available online at http://www.antiwar.com/lobe/?articleid=4457 (accessed last March 13 2008)
MaxwellSimon (1996) “Food security: a post-modern perspective.”Food Policy, 21(2): 155–170.
32.
McMichaelPhilip (2003) “Food Security and Social Reproduction: Issues and Contradictions.” In BakkerIsabella, and GillStephen (eds.), Power, Production and Social Reproduction.New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 169–189.
33.
MurphySophia, and McAfeeKathy (2005) US Food Aid: Time to Get It Right.Minneapolis: The Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy.
34.
OrzeckReecia (2007) “What does not kill you: historical materialism and the body.”Environment andPlanning D: Society and Space, 25(3): 496–514.
35.
PapanekGustav F. (2004) The Poor of Indonesia: The Impact of Economic Decline, Rapid Growth, andCrisis, 1952–2003.Washington, DC: USAID.
36.
PurnomohadiNing (1999) Jakarta: Urban Agriculture as an Alternative Strategy to Face the EconomicCrisis.Resource Centres on Urban Agriculture and Food Security, available online at http://www.ruaf.org/node/88 (Last accessed 8 March 2008).
37.
RennerMichael (2006) “Aceh: Peacemaking after the Tsunami.”Worldwatch Institute, 17 May 2006, available online at http://www.worldwatch.org/node/3930 (Last accessed 13 March 2008)
38.
RobertsSusan, SecorAnna, and SparkeMatthew (2003) “Neoliberal Geopolitics.”Antipode, 35(5): 886–897.
39.
RoosaJohn (2005) “The Tsunami and Military Rule: Aceh's Dual Disasters.”CounterPunch, 12 January 2005, available online at http://www.counterpunch.org/roosa01122005.html (Last accessed 13 March 2008).
40.
SenAmartya (1981) Poverty and Famines.Oxford: Clarendon Press.
41.
SenAmartya (1999) Development as Freedom.New York: Alfred A. Knopf.
42.
ShepherdJack (1985) “Ethiopia: The Use of Food as an Instrument of US Foreign Policy.”Issue: AJournal of Opinion, 14: 4–9.
43.
SmithLisa C., AmaniE. El Obeid, and HelenH. Jensen (2000) “The geography and causes of food insecurity in developing countries.”Agricultural Economics, 22(2): 199–215.
44.
SparkeMatthew (2004) “Political geography: political geographies of globalization (1) – dominance.”Progress in Human Geography, 28(6): 777–794.
45.
SparkeMatthew (2005) In the Space of Theory: Postfoundational Geographies of the Nation-State.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
46.
SparkeMatthew, SidawayJames D., BunnellTim, and Grundy-WarrCarl (2004) “Triangulating the borderless world: geographies of power in the Indonesia-Malaysia-Singapore Growth Triangle.”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, NS 29: 485–498.
47.
TynerJames A. (2007) America's Strategy in Southeast Asia: From the Cold War to the Terror War.Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
48.
US Agency for International Development. (2004) USAID Strategic Plan for Indonesia, 2004–2008: Strengthening a Moderate, Stable and Productive Indonesia.Jakarta: USAID Indonesia.
49.
US Agency for International Development. (2005a) Fragile States Strategy.Washington, DC, USAID.
50.
US Agency for International Development. (2005b) Measuring Fragility: Indicators and Methods for RatingState Performance.Washington, DC, USAID.
51.
US Agency for International Development. (2006a) Budget Justification to the Congress (Fiscal Year 2007).Washington, DC, USAID.
52.
US Agency for International Development. (2006b) USAID/Indonesia Operational Plan FY 2006.Jakarta: USAID Indonesia.
53.
US Congress. (2000) An Overview of USAID Programs and Priorities on East Asia, Hearing before the Subcommittee on East Asian and Pacific Affairs of the Committee on Foreign Relations, US Senate, 106th Congress, 2nd Session, April 25, 2000 (S. Hr. 106–645).Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.
54.
US Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service. (2007) Food Security Assessment, 2006 [GFA-18].Washington, DC: USDA ERS.
55.
VickersAdrian (2005) A History of Modern Indonesia.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
56.
WattsMichael (1983) Silent Violence: Food, Famine, and Peasantry in Northern Nigeria.Berkeley: University of California Press.
57.
WattsMichael J. (2000) “The Great Tablecloth: Bread and Butter Politics, and the Political Economy of Food and Poverty.” In ClarkGordon L., FeldmanMaryann P., and GertlerMeric S. (eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 195–212.
58.
WinahyuRetno, and AcayeRichard (2005) Food Aid and the Market in Aceh: Observation of the impact offood aid to the local market, and how food aid could be redirected to help revive the local economy.Aceh: Oxfam UK.
59.
WrigleyNeil (2002) “‘Food Deserts’ in British Cities: Policy Context and Research Priorities.”UrbanStudies, 39(11): 2029–2040.
60.
YonekuraHitoshi (2005) “Institutional Reform in Indonesia's Food Security Sector: The Transformation of BULOG into a Public Corporation.”The Developing Economies, 43(1): 121–148.
