Research into reporting methods of journalists in the United States often focuses on efforts to be more transparent. However, little research examines the role source attribution plays in the audience’s perception of message credibility and information adequacy. Over two experiments, this research tests the role official government and elite sources play in message credibility judgments when compared to other, nongovernment and nonelite sources. Results suggest that messages attributed to elite and government sources are perceived as more credible and higher in information adequacy than other commonly cited sources used in news. Additionally, this research finds that information attributed to social media is perceived as less credible and lower in value. The results have implications for sourcing practices of journalists, suggesting that use of nonelite sources in news might lower people’s perceptions of the information.
AppelmanA.SundarS. S.2016. “Measuring Message Credibility: Construction and Validation of an Exclusive Scale.” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly93, no. 1: 59–79.
2.
ArielyG.2015. “Trusting the Press and Political Trust: A Conditional Relationship.” Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties25, no. 3: 351–67.
3.
ArmstrongC. L.NelsonM. R.2005. “How Newspaper Sources Trigger Gender Stereotypes.” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly82, no. 4: 820–37.
4.
BakkerT.TrillingD.de VreeseC.HelferL.SchönbachK.2013. “The Context of Content: The Impact of Source and Setting on the Credibility of News.” Recherches En Communication40, 151–68.
5.
BeckersK.HarderR. A.2016. “'Twitter Just Exploded': Social Media as Alternative Vox Pop.” Digital Journalism4, no. 7: 910–20.
6.
BeckersK.Van AelstP.2019. “Look Who’s Talking: An Analysis Of Actors In Television News (2003–2016).” Journalism Studies20, no. 6: 872–90.
BroersmaM.GrahamT.2012. “Social Media as Beat.” Journalism Practice6, no. 3: 403–19.
15.
CappellaJ. N.JamiesonK. H.1997. Spiral of Cynicism: The Press and the Public Good. Oxford University Press.
16.
CarlsonM.2009. “Dueling, Dancing, or Dominating? Journalists and Their Sources.” Sociology Compass3, no. 4: 526–42.
17.
ChaikenS.MaheswaranD.1994. “Heuristic Processing Can Bias Systematic Processing: Effects Of Source Credibility, Argument Ambiguity, And Task Importance On Attitude Judgment.” Journal of Personality and Social Psychology66, no. 3: 460.
18.
ClatterbuckG. W.1979. “Attributional Confidence and Uncertainty in Initial Interaction.” Human Communication Research5, no. 2: 147–57.
19.
CookF. L.JacobsL. R.KimD.2010. “Trusting What You Know: Information, Knowledge, and Confidence in Social Security.” The Journal of Politics72, no. 2: 397–412.
20.
CurryA. L.StroudN. J.2021. “The Effects of Journalistic Transparency On Credibility Assessments And Engagement Intentions.” Journalism22, no. 4: 901–18.
21.
DaschmannG.2000. “Vox Pop & Polls: The Impact Of Poll Results And Voter Statements In The Media On The Perception Of A Climate Of Opinion.” International Journal of Public Opinion Research12, no. 2: 160–81.
22.
FletcherR.ParkS.2017. “The Impact of Trust in the News Media on Online News Consumption and Participation.” Digital Journalism, 5, no. 10: 1281–99.
23.
García de TorresE.HermidaA.2017. “The Social Reporter in Action.” Journalism Practice11, no. 2/3: 177–94.
24.
GarrettR. K.Long.J. A.JeongM. S.2019. “From Partisan Media to Misperception: Affective Polarization as Mediator.” Journal of Communication69, no. 5: 490–512.
25.
GazianoC.McGrathK.1986. “Measuring the Concept of Credibility.” Journalism Quarterly633: 451–62.
26.
Gil de ZúñigaH.WeeksB.Ardèvol-AbreuA.2017. “Effects of the News-Finds-Me Perception in Communication: Social Media Use Implications for News Seeking and Learning About Politics. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication22, no. 3: 105–23.
27.
GrimmelikhuijsenS.JohnP.MeijerA.WorthyB.2018. “Do Freedom of Information Laws Increase Transparency Of Government? A Replication Of A Field Experiment.” Journal of Behavioral Public Administration, 1, no. 2: 1–10.
28.
HanitzschT.Van DalenA.SteindlN.2018. “Caught in the Nexus: A Comparative and Longitudinal Analysis of Public Trust in the Press.” The International Journal of Press/Politics23, no. 1: 3–23.
29.
HermidaA.2010. “Twittering the News.” Journalism Practice4, no. 3: 297–308.
30.
HöhneJ. K.SchlosserS.2018. “Investigating the Adequacy of Response Time Outlier Definitions in Computer-Based Web Surveys Using Paradata SurveyFocus.” Social Science Computer Review36, no. 3: 369–78.
31.
HoodC.HealdD.2006. Transparency: The Key to Better Governance?Oxford University Press.
32.
HopmannD. N.ShehataA.2011. “The Contingencies of Ordinary Citizen Appearances in Political Television News.” Journalism Practice5, no. 6: 657–71.
33.
HovlandC. I.JanisI. L.KelleyH. H.1953. Communication and persuasion: Psychological Studies of Opinion Change. Yale University Press.
34.
HurleyR. J.KosenkoK. A.BrashersD.2011. “Uncertain Terms: Message Features of Online Cancer News.” Communication Monographs78, no. 3: 370–90.
35.
HutchensM. J.HmielowskiJ. D.BeamM. A.RomanovaE.2021. “Trust Over Use: Examining the Roles of Media Use and Media Trust on Misperceptions in the 2016 US Presidential Election.” Mass Communication and Society24, no. 5: 701–24.
36.
JohnsonT. J.KayeB. K.2015. “Reasons to Believe: Influence of Credibility On Motivations For Using Social Networks.” Computers in Human Behavior50: 544–55.
37.
KarlssonM.2020. “Dispersing the Opacity of Transparency in Journalism on the Appeal of Different Forms of Transparency to the General Public.” Journalism Studies21, no. 13: 1795–814.
38.
KarlssonM.ClerwallC.2018. “Transparency to the Rescue?”Journalism Studies, 19, no. 13: 1923–33.
KiousisS.2001. “Public Trust or Mistrust? Perceptions of Media Credibility in the Information Age.” Mass Communication & Society4, no. 4: 381–403.
41.
KleemansM.SchaapG.HermansL.2017. “Citizen Sources in The News: Above and Beyond The Vox Pop?” Journalism18, no. 4: 464–81.
42.
KohringM.MatthesJ.2007. “Trust in News Media: Development and Validation of a Multidimensional Scale.” Communication Research34, no. 2: 231–52.
43.
LuoM.HancockJ. T.MarkowitzD. M.2022. “Credibility Perceptions and Detection Accuracy of Fake News Headlines on Social Media: Effects of Truth-Bias and Endorsement Cues.” Communication Research49, no. 2: 171–95.
44.
ManciniP.2013. “Rational Legal Authority, Formal and Informal Rules in the News Media.” In Routledge Handbook of Media Law, edited by PriceM.VerhulstS.MorganL. (1st ed, pp. 35–44). Routledge.
45.
ManningP.2000. News and News Sources: A Critical Introduction. Sage Publications.
46.
MasulloG. M.CurryA. L.WhippleK. N.MurrayC.2022. “The Story Behind the Story: Examining Transparency About the Journalistic Process and News Outlet Credibility.” Journalism Practice16, no. 7: 1287–305.
47.
MillerA.KurpiusD.2010. “A Citizen-Eye View of Television News Source Credibility.” American Behavioral Scientist54, no. 2: 137–56.
48.
MoyP.PfauM.2000. With Malice Toward All?: The Media and Public Confidence in Democratic Institutions. Greenwood Publishing Group.
49.
NewtonK.2001. “Trust, Social Capital, Civil Society, and Democracy.” International Political Science Review22, no. 2: 201–14.
50.
ParkS.LeeJ. Y.2023. “Incidental News Exposure on Facebook and Its Relation to Trust in News.” Social Media + Society9, no. 1: 20563051231158823.
51.
PaulussenS.HarderR. A.2014. “Social Media References in Newspapers: Facebook, Twitter and YouTube as sources in newspaper journalism.” Journalism Practice8, no. 5: 542–51.
52.
PehlivanogluD.LinT.DeceusF.HeemskerkA.EbnerN. C.CahillB. S.2021. “The Role of Analytical Reasoning and Source Credibility On The Evaluation Of Real And Fake Full-Length News Articles.” Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications6, no. 1: 24.
53.
PennycookG.RandD. G.2019. “Lazy, Not Biased: Susceptibility To Partisan Fake News Is Better Explained By Lack Of Reasoning Than By Motivated Reasoning.” Cognition188: 39–50.
54.
PicardR. G.2014. “Twilight or New Dawn of Journalism?: Evidence from the Changing News Ecosystem.” Journalism Practice, 8, no. 5: 488–98.
55.
PornpitakpanC.2004. “The Persuasiveness of Source Credibility: A Critical Review of Five Decades’ Evidence.” Journal of Applied Social Psychology34, no. 2: 243–81.
56.
PriorM.2013. “Media and Political Polarization.” Annual Review of Political Science16, no. 1: 101–27.
57.
ProchazkaF.SchweigerW.2019. “How to Measure Generalized Trust in News Media? An Adaptation and Test of Scales.” Communication Methods and Measures13, no. 1: 26–42.
58.
RamirezA.Jr.WaltherJ. B.BurgoonJ. K.SunnafrankM.2002. “Information-Seeking Strategies, Uncertainty, and Computer-Mediated Communication: Toward a Conceptual Model.” Human Communication Research28, no. 2: 213–28.
RobinsonS.2014. “The Active Citizen’s Information Media Repertoire: An Exploration of Community News Habits During the Digital Age.” Mass Communication and Society17, no. 4: 509–30.
61.
ScaccoJ. M.MuddimanA.2020. “The Curiosity Effect: Information Seeking In The Contemporary News Environment.” New Media & Society22, no. 3: 429–48.
62.
SchudsonM.2011. The Sociology of News. 2nd ed. W.W. Norton & Company.
63.
SteppatD.Castro HerreroL.EsserF.2020. “News Media Performance Evaluated by National Audiences: How Media Environments and User Preferences Matter.” Media and Communication8, no. 3: 321–34.
64.
StrömbäckJ.BoomgaardenH.BrodaE., et al2022. “From Low-Choice to High-Choice Media Environments: Implications for Knowledge Resistance.” In Knowledge Resistance in High-Choice Information Environments, edited by StrömbäckJ.WikforssÅ.GlüerK.LindholmT.OscarssonH. (1st ed., pp. 49–68). Routledge.
65.
StrömbäckJ.TsfatiY.BoomgaardenH., et al2020. “News Media Trust and its Impact On Media Use: Toward a Framework For Future Research.” Annals of the International Communication Association44, no. 2: 139–56.
66.
StroudN. J.2011. Niche News: The Politics of News Choice. Oxford University Press.
67.
TiffenR.JonesP. K.RoweD., et al2014. “Sources in the News: A Comparative Study.” Journalism Studies15, no. 4: 374–91.
68.
VargoC. J.GuoL.AmazeenM. A.2018. “The Agenda-Setting Power of Fake News: A Big Data Analysis of The Online Media Landscape From 2014 to 2016.” New Media & Society20, no. 5: 2028–49.
69.
WangQGuanZ.2023. “Can Sunlight Disperse Mistrust? A Meta-Analysis of the Effect of Transparency on Citizens’ Trust in Government.” Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory33, no. 3: 453–67.
70.
WeeksB. E.Menchen-TrevinoE.CalabreseC.CasasA.WojcieszakM.2021. “Partisan Media, Untrustworthy News Sites, and Political Misperceptions.” New Media & Society25, no. 1: 2644–62.
71.
WenzelA.2020. Community-Centered Journalism: Engaging People, Exploring Solutions, and Building Trust. University of Illinois Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
