This article assesses the link between the state and the media in their coverage of foreign policy decisions. It holds up to empirical scrutiny the claim that genuine press criticism can only occur within the bounds of political-elite debate. Taking the Australian government’s 2014 decision to fight the Islamic State as its case study, it explores areas of consensus and dissensus between political discourse and the media. Conducting a qualitative analysis of three media frames used by major newspapers, it tests the “indexing hypothesis” and concludes that some press coverage went beyond the parameters of political-elite debate. This finding of independent criticism has implications beyond the present case study, as it helps us better understand the role of the media in democracies—specifically, holding governments to account when sending their nations to war.
AllenWilliam L.BlinderScott. 2018. “Media Independence through Routine Press-State Relations: Immigration and Government Statistics in the British Press.” The International Journal of Press/Politics23 (2): 202–26.
2.
AlthausScott L.EdyJill A.EntmanRobert M.PhalenPatricia. 1996. “Revising the Indexing Hypothesis: Officials, Media, and the Libya Crisis.” Political Communication13 (4): 407–21.
3.
AuerMeaganSutcliffeJohnLee.Martha2018. “Framing the ‘White Widow’: Using Intersectionality to Uncover Complex Representations of Female Terrorism in News Media.” Media, War & Conflict. Published electronically April 23. doi:10.1177/1750635218769931.
4.
BaumMatthew A.PotterPhillip B. K. 2015. War and Democratic Constraint: How the Public Influences Foreign Policy. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
5.
BennettW. Lance. 1990. “Toward a Theory of Press-State Relations in the United States.” Journal of Communication40 (2): 103–25.
6.
BennettW. Lance. 2016. News: The Politics of Illusion. 10th ed.Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
7.
BennettW. LanceManheimJarol B. 1993. “Taking the Public by Storm: Information, Cuing, and the Democratic Process in the Gulf Conflict.” Political Communication10 (4): 331–51.
8.
ChristiansClifford G.GlasserTheodore L.McQuailDenisNodenstrengKaarleWhiteRobert A. 2009. Normative Theories of the Media: Journalism in Democratic Societies. Chicago: University of Illinois Press.
9.
CoronelSheila S.2010. “Corruption and the Watchdog Role of the News Media.” In Public Sentinel: News Media & Governance Reform, ed. NorrisPippa, 111–36. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.
10.
CurranJames. 2011. Media and Democracy. London: Routledge.
11.
DahlgrenPeter. 2009. Media and Political Engagement: Citizens, Communication, and Democracy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
12.
DekkerRianneScholtenPeter. 2017. “Framing the Immigration Policy Agenda: A Qualitative Comparative Analysis of Media Effect on Dutch Immigration Policies.” The International Journal of Press/Politics22 (2): 202–22.
13.
DimitrovaDaniela V.2006. “The War in Iraq: A View from Australia.” In Leading to the 2003 Iraq War: The Global Media Debate, ed. NikolaevAlexander G.HakanenErnest, 115–24. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
14.
DimitrovaDaniela V.KaidLynda LeeWilliamsAndrew PaulTrammellKaye D. 2005. “War on the Web: The Immediate News Framing of Gulf War II.” The International Journal of Press/Politics10 (1): 22–44.
15.
DonnarGlen. 2009. “A Support Withdrawn: ‘Spain’s 9/11’ and Australian Newspaper Framing.” Media International Australia130 (1): 39–49.
16.
FalkheimerJesperOlssonEva-Karin. 2015. “Depoliticizing Terror: The News Framing of the Terrorist Attacks in Norway, 22 July 2011.” Media, War & Conflict8 (1): 70–85.
17.
FoleyRebecca I. M.2018. “(Mis)Representing Terrorist Threats: Media Framing of Bill C-51.” Media, War & Conflict11 (2): 204–22.
18.
GitlinTodd. 1980. The Whole World Is Watching: Mass Media in the Making and Unmaking of the New Left. Berkeley: University of California Press.
19.
GlazierRebecca A.BoydstunAmber E. 2012. “The President, the Press, and the War: A Tale of Two Framing Agendas.” Political Communication29 (4): 428–46.
20.
GoffmanErving. 1974. Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. New York: Harper & Row.
21.
GroshekJacob. 2008. “Coverage of the Pre-Iraq War Debate as a Case Study of Frame Indexing.” Media, War & Conflict1 (3): 315–38.
22.
GyngellAllanWesleyMichael. 2007. Making Australian Foreign Policy. 2nd ed.Port Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
23.
HallinDaniel C.1986. The “Uncensored War”: The Media and Vietnam. Berkeley: University of California Press.
24.
HawkinsVirgil. 2009. “National Interest or Business Interest: Coverage of Conflict in the Democratic Republic of Congo in The Australian Newspaper.” Media, War & Conflict2 (1): 67–84.
25.
HayesAndrew F.KrippendorffKlaus. 2007. “Answering the Call for a Standard Reliability Measure for Coding Data.” Communication Methods and Measures1 (1): 77–89.
26.
HayesDannyGuardinoMatt. 2010. “Whose Views Made the News? Media Coverage and the March to War in Iraq.” Political Communication27 (1): 59–87.
27.
HermanEdward S.ChomskyNoam. 1988. Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media. New York: Pantheon Books.
28.
HjarvardStigKristensenNete Nørgaard. 2014. “When Media of a Small Nation Argue for War.” Media, War & Conflict7 (1): 51–69.
29.
IsakhanBenjamin. 2014. “The Politics of Australia’s Withdrawal from Iraq.” Australian Journal of Political Science49 (4): 647–61.
30.
KingErika G.2014. Obama, the Media, and Framing the U.S. Exit from Iraq and Afghanistan. New York: Routledge.
31.
KleinAdam G.ByerlyCarolyn M.McEachernTony M. 2009. “Counterframing Public Dissent: An Analysis of Antiwar Coverage in the U.S. Media.” Critical Studies in Media Communication26 (4): 331–50.
32.
KuypersJim A.2010. “Framing Analysis from a Rhetorical Perspective.” In Doing News Framing Analysis: Empirical and Theoretical Perspectives, ed. AngeloPaul D.KuypersJim A., 286–311. New York: Routledge.
33.
LentiniPete. 2014. “Demonizing ISIL and Defending Muslims: Australian Muslim Citizenship and Tony Abbott’s ‘Death Cult’ Rhetoric.” Islam and Christian-Muslim Relations26 (2): 237–52.
34.
MayringPhilipp. 2015. “Qualitative Content Analysis: Theoretical Background and Procedures.” In Approaches to Qualitative Research in Mathematics Education, ed. Bikner-AhsbahsAngelikaKnippingChristinePresmegNorma C., 365–80. Dordrecht: Springer.
35.
McCombsMaxwell E.2004. Setting the Agenda: The Mass Media and Public Opinion. Malden: Blackwell.
36.
McCombsMaxwell E.ShawDonald L. 1972. “The Agenda-Setting Function of Mass Media.” The Public Opinion Quarterly36 (2): 176–87.
37.
MacQueenKathleen M.McLellanEleanorKayKellyMilsteinBobby. 1998. “Codebook Development for Team-Based Qualitative Analysis.” Field Methods10 (2): 31–36.
38.
MelkiJad. 2014. “The Interplay of Politics, Economics and Culture in News Framing of Middle East Wars.” Media, War & Conflict7 (2): 165–86.
39.
MerminJoshua. 1999. Debating War and Peace: Media Coverage of U.S. Intervention in the Post-Vietnam Era. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
40.
MillerMarkRiechertBonnie Parnell. 2001. “Frame Mapping: A Quantitative Method for Investigation Issues in the Public Sphere.” In Theory, Method, and Practice in Computer Content Analysis, ed. WestMark D., 61-76. Westport: Ablex.
41.
Moore-GilbertKylie.2017. “A Visual Uprising: Framing the Online Activism of Bahrain’s Shi’i Opposition.” Media, War & Conflict. Published electronically December 1. doi:10.1177/1750635217741913.
42.
MulherinPeter E.IsakhanBenjamin. 2019. “The Abbott Government and the Islamic State: A Securitised and Elitist Foreign Policy Discourse.” Australian Journal of Political Science54 (1): 82–98.
43.
NorrisPippaOdugbemiSina. 2010. “Evaluating Media Performance.” In Public Sentinel: News Media & Governance Reform, ed. NorrisPippa, 3–30. Washington, D.C.: The World Bank.
44.
NowellLorelli S.NorrisJill M.WhiteDeborah E.Moules.Nancy J.2017. “Thematic Analysis: Striving to Meet the Trustworthiness Criteria.” International Journal of Qualitative Methods16(1): 1-13.
45.
OlmastroniFrancesco. 2014. Framing War: Public Opinion and Decision-Making in Comparative Perspective. New York: Routledge.
46.
OtopalikCameronSchaeferTodd. 2008. “Are the Lapdogs Starting to Bark? Japanese Newspaper Coverage of the SDF Mission to Iraq.” Media, War & Conflict1 (3): 271–91.
47.
PanZhongdangKosickiGerald M. 1993. “Framing Analysis: An Approach to News Discourse.” Political Communication10:55–75.
48.
PapacharissiZiziOliveiraMaria de Fatima. 2008. “News Frames Terrorism: A Comparative Analysis of Frames Employed in Terrorism Coverage in U.S. And U.K. Newspapers.” The International Journal of Press/Politics13 (1): 52–74.
49.
PowellKimberly A.2011. “Framing Islam: An Analysis of U.S. Media Coverage of Terrorism since 9/11.” Communication Studies62 (1): 90–112.
50.
ReeseStephen D.LewisSeth C. 2009. “Framing the War on Terror.” Journalism10 (6): 777–97.
51.
RiceStephen K. J.BartlettJennifer L. 2006. “Legitimating Organisational Decisions: A Study of Media Framing of the Australian Government’s Legitimacy Strategy and Public Opinion on the War in Iraq.” Journal of Communication Management10 (3): 274–86.
52.
RobinsonPiersGoddardPeterParryKaty. 2012. “Measuring Media Criticism of War and Political Elites: A Response to Florian Zollmann.” Global Media and Communication8 (2): 177–85.
53.
RobinsonPiersGoddardPeterParryKatyMurrayCraig. 2009. “Testing Models of Media Performance in Wartime: U.K. TV News and the 2003 Invasion of Iraq.” Journal of Communication59 (3): 534–63.
54.
RobinsonPiersGoddardPeterParryKatyMurrayCraig. 2010. Pockets of Resistance: British News Media, War and Theory in the 2003 Invasion of Iraq. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
55.
SchultzJulianne. 1998. Reviving the Fourth Estate. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
56.
ShawDonald L.MartinShannon E. 1992. “The Function of Mass Media Agenda Setting.” Journalism Quarterly69 (4): 902–20.
57.
SpeerIsaac. 2017. “Reframing the Iraq War: Official Sources, Dramatic Events, and Changes in Media Framing.” Journal of Communication67 (2): 281–302.
58.
TuchmanGaye. 1978. Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: Free Press.
59.
UbayasiriKasun. 2015. “The Anzac Myth and the Shaping of Contemporary Australian War Reportage.” Media, War & Conflict8 (2): 213–28.
60.
WrightKatharine A. M.HollandJack. 2014. “Leadership and the Media: Gendered Framings of Julia Gillard’s ‘Sexism and Misogyny Speech.’” Australian Journal of Political Science49 (3): 455–68.
61.
ZollmannFlorian. 2011. “Managing the Elite Consensus: A Critical Analysis of Press Discourses over Warfare in Iraq.” Global Media and Communication7 (3): 263–68.
62.
ZollmannFlorian. 2015. “Bad News from Fallujah.” Media, War & Conflict8 (3): 345–67.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
