Evidence suggests that anti-smoking programs that target school-aged children can be effective and that they can assist in reducing tobacco use among peers. This article presents an evaluation of a peer and school based mentoring program offered by Big Brothers/Big Sisters of Southwest Louisiana in conjunction with local elementary schools. The program matches high school mentors with elementary school children believed to be at a high risk for smoking, as well as for alcohol and drug abuse. The results of the evaluation were mixed. Teachers and mentors praised the program. Participation in the program was also associated with a reduction in peer use of alcohol and tobacco. However, there was no significant difference between experimental and control groups with respect to how the grade school subjects recognized the harm that alcohol can produce for children. Further, there was no significant difference in how experimental and control groups viewed the damage to children that could be done by a combination of alcohol, tobacco, and street drugs. The mixed results demonstrate the program's promise and its potential usefulness as a strategy to prevent teen smoking. At the same time, the results underscore the complex interplay of factors that may contribute to the success or failure of such innovative programs.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Adamzyck-RobinetteStaceyFletcherAnneWrightKristie. 2002. “Understanding the authoritative parenting-early adolescent tobacco link: The mediating role of peer tobacco use.”Journal of Youth and Adolescence31, 4: 311–18.
2.
American Heart Association. 2003. Tobacco industry's targeting of youth, minorities, and women (fact sheet).Dallas, TX: AHA.
3.
ArnettJeffrey. 2001. “Adolescents' responses to cigarette advertisements for five youth brands and one adult brand.”Journal of Research on Adolescence11, 4: 425–43.
4.
BryantAlisonSchulenbergJohnO'MalleyPatrickBachmanJeraldJohnstonLloyd. 2003. “How academic achievement, attitudes and behaviors relate to the substance use during adolescence: A 6-year, multi-wave national longitudinal study.”Journal of Research on Adolescence13, 3: 361–97.
5.
BuriJ.R.1989. “Self esteem and appraisals of parental behavior.”Journal of Adolescent Behavior4: 33–49.
6.
CampbellC.S.RobinsonJ.W.. 2001. The effects of teens offering positive support on preadolescent client's attitude toward the use of street drugs, alcohol, and tobacco, and their choice of peers.Lake Charles, LA: McNeese State University.
7.
CampbellC.S.WeeberS.C.. 2002. Annual review of the TOPS program.Lake Charles, LA: McNeese State University.
8.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.2002. Guide to prevent tobacco use and addiction (fact sheet).Atlanta, GA: National Center for Chronic Disease and Health Promotion.
9.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.2001. Women and smoking. National Center for Chronic Disease and Health Promotion. Atlanta, GA: CDCP.
10.
CrispArthurSedgwickPhillipHalekChristineJoughinNeilHumphreyHeather. 1999. “Why may many teenage girls persist in smoking?”Journal of Adolescence22, 5: 657–72.
11.
FischerJoelCorcoranKevin. 1994. Measure of clinical practice: A sourcebook. Volume 1: Couples, Families, and Children.New York: Free Press.
12.
FlisherAlanParryCharlesEvansJanetMullerMartieLombardCarl. 2003. “Substance use by adolescents in Cape Town: Prevalence and correlates.”Journal of Adolescent Health32, 1: 58–65.
13.
Fulkerson, Jayne and Simone French.2003. “Cigarette smoking for weight loss or control among adolescents: Gender and racial/ethnic differences.”Journal of Adolescent Health32, 4: 306–13.
14.
GardnerStephen E.GreenPatricia F.MarcusCarol, Eds. 1994. Signs of effectiveness II: Preventing alcohol, tobacco, and other drug use: A risk factor resiliency-based approach.Washington, D.C.: Center For Substance Abuse Prevention.
15.
GoodmanElizabethCapitmanJohn. 2000. “Depressive symptoms and cigarette smoking among teens.”Pediatrics106, 4: 748–55.
16.
HatcherJuliet L.ScarpaJuliet. 2002. “Reducing tobacco use in adolescents: What works, what doesn't.”NAADAC News12, 4: 16.
17.
HirschfieldP.P.1965. “Response set in impulsive children.”Journal of Genetic Psychology107: 117–26.
18.
KirbyJames. 2002. “The influence of parental separation on smoking initiation in adolescents.”Journal of Health and Social Behavior43, 1: 56–71.
19.
KobusK.2003. “Peers and adolescent smoking.”Addiction98: 37–55.
20.
LatimerWilliamFloydLeahVasquezMarcoO'BrienMeganArzolaAbigailRiveraNancy. 2004. “Substance use among school-based youths in Puerto Rico: Differences between gender and grade levels.”Addictive Behaviors29, 8: 1659–64.
21.
LipsittL.P.1958. “A self-concept scale for children and its relationship to the children's form of the manifest anxiety scale.”Child Development29: 463–72.
22.
MacFaydenLynnAmosAmandaHastingsGerardParkesEdward. 2003. “They look like my kind of people—perceptions of smoking images in youth magazines.”Social Science and Medicine56, 3: 491–99.
23.
McCoolJudithCameronLindaPetrieKeith. 2001. “Adolescent perceptions of smoking imagery in film.”Social Science and Medicine52, 10: 1577–87.
24.
MillerPatrick. 1997. “Family structure, personality, drinking, smoking and illicit drug use: A study of UK teenagers.”Drug and Alcohol Dependence45, 1–2: 121–29.
25.
NajemReza G.BatumanFatimaSmithAnnFeuermanMartin. 1997. “Patterns of smoking among inner-city teenagers: Smoking has a pediatric age of onset.”Journal of Adolescent Health20, 3: 226–31.
26.
National Institute on Drug Abuse.2002. Research report series — Nicotine addiction.Bethesda, MD: NIDA.
27.
PedersonL.L.BaskervilleJ.C.LefcoeN.M.. 1983. “Prevalence of and factors related to cigarette smoking among students in grade 6.”Journal of Drug Education13, 4: 305–12.
28.
PomerleauCynthia. 1997. “Co-factors for smoking and evolutionary psychobiology.”Addiction92, 4: 397–408.
29.
RitcheyPhillipReidGeraldHasseLora. 2001. “The relative influence of smoking on drinking and drinking on smoking among high school students in a rural tobacco growing county.”Journal of Adolescent Health29, 6: 386–94.
30.
RosenbergM.1979. Conceiving the self.New York: Basic Books.
31.
Simons-MortonBruce. 2002. “Prospective analysis of peer and parent influences on smoking initiation among early adolescents.”Prevention Science3, 4: 275.
32.
StraubDianeHillsNancyThompsonPamelaMoscickiAnna-Barbara. 2003. “Effects of pro-and anti-tobacco advertising on nonsmoking adolescents' intentions to smoke.”Journal of Adolescent Health32, 1: 36–43.
33.
SutherlandI.ShepherdJ.P.. 2002. “Adolescents' beliefs about future substance use: A comparison of current users and non-users of cigarettes, alcohol and illicit drugs.”Journal of Adolescence25, 2: 169–81.
34.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.1999. National household survey on drug abuse: Main finding, 1977.Rockville, MD: HHS.
35.
U.S. Public Health Service.1994. Preventing tobacco use among young people: A report of the surgeon general: At-a-glance.Rockville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Center for Mental Health Services.
36.
Von BothmerMargaretaMattssonB.FridlundB.. 2002. “Influences on adolescent smoking behaviour: Siblings' smoking and norms in the social environment do matter.”Health and Social Care in the Community10, 4: 213–20.
