Abstract
Background:
Smaller gauge, shorter needles have been shown to be as safe and effective for insulin delivery as longer needles in many patients. However, in obese patients with diabetes, results have been inconsistent with regard to the impact of needle length on leakage of injectate.
Methods:
A single-blind, randomized, two-period, crossover study compared injections with 5 mm needles to 8 mm needles regarding leakage, pain, bleeding, and bruising at abdominal injection sites in obese patients with diabetes using 20- and 60-unit (U) volume equivalent injections of sterile insulin diluent.
Results:
Fifty-six patients (54% male; mean age 56 years; mean body mass index of 36 kg/m2) with type 1 (n = 13) or type 2 (n = 43) diabetes participated. Median leakage (U) was similar for both needles [0.04 (5 mm/20 U) vs 0.02 (8 mm/20 U), P = .32; and 0.04 (5 mm/60 U) vs 0.02 (8 mm/60 U), P = 48]. Pain scores (mean) were similar [1.27 (5 mm/20 U) vs 1.14 (8 mm/20 U), P = .75, and 1.68 (5 mm/60 U) vs 0.95 (8 mm/60 U, P = .21)]. The proportion of injections with bleeding [10.8% (5 mm/20 U) vs 5.83% (8 mm/20 U), P = .23, and 4.92% (5 mm/60 U) vs 6.56% (8 mm/60 U), P = .73] and the proportion of patients with bruising [8.11% (5 mm/20 U) vs 10.81% (8 mm/20 U), p = .56, and 21.05% (5 mm/60 U) vs 26.32% (8 mm/60 U), p = .65] at injection sites were similar. Mean bruise size (mm) [0.73 (5 mm/20 U] vs 2.68 (8 mm/20 U), P = .23; and 1.11 (5 mm/60 U) vs 4.21 (8 mm/60 U), P = .08] at injection sites was similar.
Conclusions:
This study supports the suitability of the 5 mm needle for the injection of insulin in obese patients with diabetes.