Abstract
Medical record administrators in the United States have documented a range of ethical problems which they have experienced as a result of the advent of DRGs. This paper considers the similarities and differences between the Australian and United States experience of DRGs, and the implications of these for Australian medical record administrators. Some ethical problems are described, and it is argued that these problems relate particularly to power imbalances between medical record administrators and other health professions.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
(1986 ). HDV The New Direction . Melbourne, Victoria ; Health Department .
2.
Agich
G.J.
(1987 ). Incentives and obligations under prospective payment , Journal of Medicine and Philosophy , 12 (2 ), 123 –144 .
3.
Battin
T.
(1991 ). What is this thing called economic rationalism? Australian Journal of Social Issues , 26 (4 ), 294 –307 .
4.
Begley
E.
(1987 ). Prospective payment and medical ethics , Journal of Medicine and Philosophy , 12 (2 ), 107 –122 .
5.
Cole
C.
(1992 ). Letter , Journal of AHIMA , 63 (5 ), 97 .
6.
Davis
A.
George
J.
(1988 ). States of Health. Health and Illness in Australia , Harper & Row, Artarmon .
7.
Dougherty
C.J.
(1989 ). Ethical perspectives on prospective payment , Hastings Center Report , 19 (1 ), 5 –18 .
8.
Draper
M.
(1992 ). Casemix in search of a policy - part one , Health Issues , 31 , 21 –24 .
9.
Erlen
J.A.
Frost
B.
(1991 ). Nurses' perceptions of powerlessness in influencing ethical decisions , Western Journal of Nursing Research , 13 (3 ), 397 –407 .
10.
Fox
L.A.
(1992 ). An ethical dilemma: Coding medical records for reimbursement , Journal of AHIMA , 63 (2 ), 34 –37 .
11.
Haddad
A.M.
(1991 ). The nurse/physician relationship and ethical decision making , AORN Journal , 53 (1 ), 151 –155 .
12.
Hicks
N.
(1992 ). Economic Rationalism and Health Care , Adelaide ; Department of Community Medicine, Mimeo .
13.
Hindle
D.
Hanson
R.
Holt
J.
(1992 ). Casemix classification and Australian doctors , Medical Journal of Australia , 156 , 866 –869 .
14.
Mitchell
J.
(1991 ). President's report - Revised code of ethics for the MRAA , Australian Medical Record Journal , 21 (3 ), 83 .
15.
Palmer
G.R.
Short
S.D.
(1989 ). Health Care & Public Policy. An Australian Analysis , Macmillan, Melbourne .
16.
Spicker
S.F.
(1987 ). Introduction: Prospective payment: DRGs and ethics , Journal of Medicine and Philosophy , 12 (2 ), 101 –106 .
17.
Stein
L.I.
(1967 ). The doctor-nurse game , Archives of General Psychiatry , 16 , 699 –703 .
18.
Stein
L.I.
Watts
D.T.
Howell
T.
(1991 ). The doctor-nurse game revisited , New England Journal of Medicine , 322 (8 ), 546 –549 .
19.
Veatch
R.M.
(1986 ). DRGs and the ethical reallocation of resources , Hastings Center Report , 16 , 32 –40 .
20.
Vladeck
B.C.
Kramer
P.S.
(1988 ). Casemix measures: DRGs and Alternatives , Annual Review of Public Health , 9 , 333 –359 .