Rethinking Health Planning: A Framework for Organising Information to Underpin Collaborative Health Planning

Abstract

The field of collaborative health planning faces significant challenges created by the narrow focus of the available information, the absence of a framework to organise that information and the lack of systems to make information accessible and guide decision-making. These challenges have been magnified by the rise of the ‘healthy communities movement’, resulting in more frequent calls for localised, collaborative and evidence-driven health related decision-making. This paper discusses the role of decision support systems as a mechanism to facilitate collaborative health decision-making. The paper presents a potential information management framework to underpin a health decision support system and describes the participatory process that is currently being used to create an online tool for health planners using geographic information systems. The need for a comprehensive information management framework to guide the process of planning for healthy communities has been emphasised. The paper also underlines the critical importance of the proposed framework not only in forcing planners to engage with the entire range of health determinants, but also in providing sufficient flexibility to allow exploration of the local setting-based determinants of health.

Keywords

Clinical Decision Support Systems Health Planning Community Health Planning Primary Healthcare Healthy People Programs Collaboration Information Management Evidence-Based Healthcare

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ashton

J.R.

(2009). From healthy towns 1843 to healthy cities 2008. Public Health 123(1): 11–13.

Auditor-General of Queensland (2009). Report to Parliament no. 2 for 2009: Health service planning for the future - a performance management systems audit. Brisbane, Queensland: Queensland Audit. Available at: http://www.qao.qld.gov.au/downloadables/publications/auditor_general_reports/2009_Report_No.2.pdf (Accessed 1 August 2008).

Barnard

D.K.

(2005). The population health approach: Health GIS as a bridge from theory to practice. International Journal of Health Geographies 4(23) doi:10.1186/1476–072X-4-23. Available online from: http://www.ij-healthgeographics.com/content/4/1/23.

Baum

Kendall

Muenchberger

Gudes

(2010). Geographical information systems and on-line decision support platforms: Useful tools for community health coalitions in Australia. Unpublished paper.

Blum

H.L.

(1974). Planning for health: Development and application of social change theory. New York: Human Sciences Press.

Bishop

Davis

(2001). Developing consent: Consultation, participation and governance. In Are You Being Served? Eds. Davis

Weller

, Sydney, Allen & Unwin: 175–195.

Buchy

M.N.

Race

(2001). The twists and turns of community participation in natural resource management in Australia: What is missing? Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 44(3): 293–308.

Campbell

Fainstein

S.S.

(1996). Introduction: The structure and debates of planning theory. In Readings in urban theory, Eds. Campbell

Fainstein

S.S.

, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing: 1–16.

Central Northern Adelaide Health Service (2008). Central Northern Adelaide Health Service Social Health Atlas 2008. Available at: http://www.publichealth.gov.au/interactive_mapping/sa_sha_cnahs_2005/atlas.html.html (accessed November 24, 2008).

10.

Conway

M.D.

Rizzuto

C.D.

Weiss

L.M.

(2008). A better way to speed the adoption of vaccines. McKinsey Quarterly. Available at: http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/home.aspx (accessed 20 November 2008).

11.

Cromley

E.K.

McLafferty

S.L.

(2002). GIS and public health. Health & Place. 9(3): 279.

12.

Croner

C.M.

(2003). Public health, GIS and the internet. Annual Review of Public Health 24: 57–82.

13.

Dooris

(1999). Healthy cities and local agenda 21: The UK experience – challenges for the new millennium. Health Promotion International 14(4): 365–375.

14.

Duckett

S.J.

(2007). The Australian health care system (Third edition) . South Melbourne, Oxford University Press.

15.

Duhl

Sanchez

(1999). Healthy cities and the city planning process - a background document on links between health and urban planning. WHO Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen.

16.

Dur

Yigitcanlar

Bunker

(2009). A decision support system for sustainable urban development: The integrated land use and transportation indexing model. Proceedings of the Postgraduate Infrastructure Conference. Brisbane, Australia, 26 March. Queensland University of Technology.

17.

Eagar

Garrett

Lin

(2001). Health planning: Australian perspectives. Sydney, Allen & Unwin.

18.

Flynn

B.C.

(1996). Healthy cities: Toward worldwide health promotion. Annual Review of Public Health 17: 299–309.

19.

Forester

(1989). Planning in the face of power. Berkeley, University of California Press.

20.

Gorry

G.A.

Morton

M.S.S.

(1971). A framework for management information systems. Sloan Management Review 13(1): 55–70.

21.

Gudes

Yigitcanlar

Pathak

(2009). A community health support system for the planning of healthy cities. Proceedings of the Postgraduate Infrastructure Conference. Brisbane, Australia, 26 March. Queensland University of Technology.

22.

Gudes

Yigitcanlar

Tal

Bar-Lavi

(2009). Innovative geography standards for web-GIS portals: Case study of the Survey of Israel's Web-GIS Portal. 2009 FIG Working Week: Surveyors Key Role in Accelerated Development, 3–8 May 2009, Eilat, Israel.

23.

Hancock

(1993). Health, human development and the community ecosystem: Three ecological models. Health Promotion International 8(1): 41–47.

24.

Healey

(1993). Planning through debate: The communicative turn in planning theory. In The argumentative turn in policy analysis and planning. Eds. Fischer

Forester

, Durham and London, Duke University Press: 233–249.

25.

Healey

(1997). Collaborative planning: Shaping places in fragmented societies. Vancouver, University of British Columbia Press.

26.

Higgs

Gould

(2001). Is there a role GIS in the ‘new NHS’? Health & Place 7(3): 247–259.

27.

Innes

Booher

(1999). Consensus building and complex adaptive systems. Journal of the American Planning Association 65(4): 412–423.

28.

Kazada

M.J.

Beel

E.R.

Villegas

Matinez

J.G.

Patel

Migala

(2009). Methodological complexities and the use of GIS in conducting a community needs assessment of a large US municipality. Journal of Community Health 34(3): 210–215.

29.

Keenan

P.B.

(2006). Spatial decision support systems: A coming of age. Control and Cybernetics 35(1): 9–27.

30.

Kraemer

K.L.

King

J.L.

Maggi

(1983). Effectively utilising computer-aided design technology: The role of individual difference variables. Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Information Systems. Tucson, Arizona, United States, 28–30 November. Association for Computing Machinery.

31.

Leggat

S.G.

(2009). Hospital planning: The risks of basing the future on past data. Health Information Management Journal 37(3): 6–14.

32.

Logan City Council (2003). Logan Public Health Plan 2003–2008. Logan, Logan City Council.

33.

Margerum

(1999). Integrated environmental management: The foundations for successful practice. Environmental Management 24(2): 151–166.

34.

Melbourne City Council (2008). Melbourne 2030 planning for sustainable growth. Melbourne: Melbourne City Council. Available at: www.melbourne2030.vic.gov.au (accessed 15 November 2008).

35.

Minkler

, (2000). Using participatory action research to build healthy communities. Public Health Reports 115(2–3): 191–197.

36.

Mitchell

(1997). Resource and environmental management. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

37.

Mitchell

Hollick

(1993). Integrated catchment management in Western Australia: Transition from concept to implementation. Environmental Management 17(6): 735–743.

38.

Mooney

Fohtung

N.G.

(2008). Issues in the measurement of social determinants of health. Health Information Management Journal 37(3): 26–30.

39.

Murray

D.J.

(2006). A critical analysis of communicative planning theory as a theoretical underpinning for integrated resource and environmental management. Unpublished PhD thesis, Griffith University, Queensland.

40.

National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission (2009). A healthier future for all Australians. Final report. June. Canberra, ACT, National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission.

41.

Northridge

M.E.

Sclar

E.D.

Biswas

(2003). Sorting out the connections between the built environment and health: A conceptual framework for navigating pathways and planning healthy cities. Journal of Urban Health 80(4): 556–568.

42.

Plescia

Joyner

D.R.

Scheid

T.L.

(2004). A regional health care system partnership with local communities to impact chronic disease. Preventing Chronic Disease 1(4): 1–8.

43.

Queensland Health (2005). Report on GIS and public health spatial applications. Brisbane, Public Health Services.

44.

Reeves

P.N.

Coile

R.C.

(1989). Introduction to health planning. Arlington, VA: Information Resources Press.

45.

Reinke

W.A.

(1972). Health planning: Qualitative aspects and quantitative techniques. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University School of Hygiene and Public Health, Department of Internet Health.

46.

Sager

(1994). Communicative planning theory. Brookfield, Avebury Press.

47.

Satterthwaite

(1999). The Earthscan reader in sustainable cities. London, Earthscan.

48.

Schulz

Northridge

M.E.

(2004). Social determinants of health: Implications for environmental health promotion. Health Education & Behaviour 31(4): 455–471.

49.

Shim

J.P.

Warkentin

Courtney

J.F.

Power

D.J.

Sharda

Carlsson

(2002). Past, present, and future of decision support technology. Decision Support Systems 33(2): 111–126.

50.

Simon

(1960). New science of management decision. New York, Harper and Row.

51.

Todd

R.J.

Southon

(2001). Educating for a knowledge management future: Perceptions of library and information professionals. The Australian Library Journal 50(4): 313–326.

52.

Turban

(1993). Decision support and expert systems: Management support systems. Upper Saddle River, NJ, Prentice Hall.

53.

World Health Organization (1997). Twenty steps for developing a healthy cities project. WHO Regional Office of Europe.

54.

World Health Organization (1999). Health: Creating healthy cities in the 21st century. In The Earthscan reader in sustainable cities. Ed. Satterthwaite

. London, Earthscan: 137–172.

55.

Yigitcanlar

(2008). Public oriented interactive environmental decision support system. In GIS and evidence-based policy making. Eds. Wise

Craglia

Anttiroiko

, London, Taylor and Francis: 347–366.

56.

Yigitcanlar

Gudes

(2008). Web-based public participatory GIS. In Encyclopedia of decision making and decision support technologies. Adam

, (Ed.). Hersey PA, Information Science Reference, Volume II: 969–976.

57.

Yigitcanlar

(2006). Australian local governments practice and prospects with online planning. URISA Journal 18(2): 7–17.