Does regulation induce cost efficiency in electricity distribution utilities? Use of stochastic cost frontier analysis for the Indian states

Abstract

To overcome the macroeconomic crisis of the early 1990s, the Government of India persuaded the state governments to adopt market-oriented reforms for loss-making state public sector undertakings in general and power sector utilities in particular with an aim to limit the overall size of the public sector. This led the state governments to undertake unbundling of their vertically integrated State Electricity Boards (SEBs), establish independent regulatory bodies in the form of State Electricity Regulatory Commissions (SERCs) to regulate the power sector, and allow for an active participation of private sector. Given this backdrop, the present study attempts to examine the effect of establishment of SERCs on the cost-efficiency of electricity distribution in the Indian states. Thereby, it evaluates whether the establishment of SERCs has induced efficiency gains in the electricity distribution. Estimating a Cobb-Douglas stochastic cost frontier function, it finds that the establishment of independent regulators in various states has resulted in significant improvements in the cost-efficiency in the electricity distribution.

Keywords

Regulation privatization electricity distribution cost efficiency stochastic frontier analysis India

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Acemoglu

Johnson

Robinson

J. A.

(2001). The colonial origins of comparative development: An empirical investigation. American Economic Review, 91(5), 1369–1401.

Acemoglu

Johnson

Robinson

J. A.

(2005). Institutions as a fundamental cause of long-run growth. Handbook of Economic Growth, 1, 385–472.

Ahluwalia

M. S.

(2002).Economic reforms in India since 1991: Has gradualism worked? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 16(3), 67–88.

Aigner

Lovell

C. K.

Schmidt

(1977). Formulation and estimation of stochastic frontier production models. Journal of Econometrics, 6(1), 21–37.

Aubert

Reynaud

(2005). The impact of regulation on cost efficiency: An empirical analysis of Wisconsin water utilities. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 23(3), 383–409.

Baijal

(1999). Restructuring power sector in India: A base paper. Economic and Political Weekly, 34(39), 2795–2803.

Barro

R. J.

(1990). Government spending in a simple model of endogenous growth. Journal of Political Economy, 98(5, Part 2), S103–S125.

Belotti

Daidone

Ilardi

Atella

.(2013). Stochastic frontier analysis using Stata. Stata Journal, 13(4), 719–758.

Bera

A. K.

Sharma

S. C.

(1999). Estimating production uncertainty in stochastic frontier production function models. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 12(3), 187–210.

10.

Berg

Lin

Tsaplin

(2005). Regulation of state-owned and privatized utilities: Ukraine electricity distribution company performance. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 28(3), 259–287.

11.

Besley

Ghatak

(2010). Property rights and economic development. In Rodrick

Rosenzweig

(Eds), Handbook of development economics (Vol. 5, pp. 4525–4595). North-Holland.

12.

Burns

Weyman Jones

T. G.

(1996). Cost functions and cost efficiency in electricity distribution: A stochastic frontier approach. Bulletin of Economic Research, 48(1), 41–64.

13.

Carpenter

D. P.

(2004). Protection without capture: Product approval by a politically responsive, learning regulator. American Political Science Review, 98(4), 613–631.

14.

Caudill

S. B.

Ford

J. M.

Gropper

D. M.

(1995). Frontier estimation and firm-specific inefficiency measures in the presence of heteroscedasticity. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 13(1), 105–111.

15.

Central Electricity Authority (CEA 2001–2017). All India electricity statistics reports from 2001 to 2017.

16.

Central Electricity Regulatory Commission. (2003). The Electricity Act, 2003. http://www.cercind.gov.in/Act-with-amendment.pdf

17.

Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC). (2015). Report on short-term power market in India: 2015–16.

18.

Chan

H. S. R.

Cropper

M. L.

Malik

(2014). Why are power plants in India less efficient than power plants in the United States? American Economic Review, 104(5), 586–590.

19.

Cicala

(2015). When does regulation distort costs? Lessons from fuel procurement in US electricity generation. American Economic Review, 105(1), 411–44.

20.

Cicala

. (2017). Imperfect markets versus imperfect regulation in US electricity generation [Working paper No. 23053]. National Bureau of Economic Research.

21.

Cubbin

Stern

(2006). The impact of regulatory governance and privatization on electricity industry generation capacity in developing economies. The World Bank Economic Review, 20(1), 115–141.

22.

Dal Bó

Rossi

M. A.

(2007). Corruption and inefficiency: Theory and evidence from electric utilities. Journal of Public Economics, 91(5–6), 939–962.

23.

Davis

L. W.

Wolfram

(2012). Deregulation, consolidation, and efficiency: Evidence from US nuclear power. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics, 4(4), 194–225.

24.

Dubash

N. K.

Morgan

(2012). Understanding the rise of the regulatory state of the South. Regulation & Governance, 6(3), 261–281.

25.

Dubash

N. K.

Rajan

S. C.

(2001). Power politics: Process of power sector reform in India. Economic and Political Weekly, 36(35), 3367–3390.

26.

Dubash

N. K.

Rao

D. N.

(2008). Regulatory practice and politics: Lessons from independent regulation in Indian electricity. Utilities Policy, 16(4), 321–331.

27.

Easterly

Levine

(2003). Tropics, germs, and crops: How endowments influence economic development. Journal of Monetary Economics, 50(1), 3–39.

28.

Edwards

Waverman

(2006). The effects of public ownership and regulatory independence on regulatory outcomes. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 29(1), 23–67.

29.

Emmons

W. M.

III (1997). Implications of ownership, regulation, and market structure for performance: Evidence from the US electric utility industry before and after the New Deal. Review of Economics and Statistics, 79(2), 279–289.

30.

Fabrizio

K. R.

Rose

N. L.

Wolfram

C. D.

(2007). Do markets reduce costs? Assessing the impact of regulatory restructuring on US electric generation efficiency. American Economic Review, 97(4), 1250–1277.

31.

Farrell

M. J.

(1957). The measurement of productive efficiency. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series A (General), 120(3), 253–281.

32.

Farsi

Filippini

(2004). Regulation and measuring cost-efficiency with panel data models: Application to electricity distribution utilities. Review of Industrial Organization, 25(1), 1–19.

33.

Farsi

Filippini

(2009). An analysis of cost efficiency in Swiss multi-utilities. Energy Economics, 31(2), 306–315.

34.

Farsi

Filippini

Greene

(2006). Application of panel data models in benchmarking analysis of the electricity distribution sector. Annals of Public and Cooperative Economics, 77(3), 271–290.

35.

Faust

A. K.

Baranzini

(2014). The economic performance of Swiss drinking water utilities. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 41(3), 383–397.

36.

Filippini

Wetzel

(2014). The impact of ownership unbundling on cost efficiency: Empirical evidence from the New Zealand electricity distribution sector. Energy Economics, 45, 412–418.

37.

Foster

Rana

(2019). Rethinking power sector reform in the developing world. World Bank Sustainable Infrastructure Series.

38.

Fried

H. O.

Lovell

C. K.

Schmidt

S. S.

Schmidt

S. S.

(Eds.). (2008). The measurement of productive efficiency and productivity growth. Oxford University Press.

39.

Ghosh

Kathuria

(2016). The effect of regulatory governance on efficiency of thermal power generation in India: A stochastic frontier analysis. Energy policy, 89, 11–24.

40.

Greene

(2005a). Fixed and random effects in stochastic frontier models. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 23(1), 7–32.

41.

Greene

(2005b). Reconsidering heterogeneity in panel data estimators of the stochastic frontier model. Journal of Econometrics, 126(2), 269–303.

42.

GOI (2010). Finance Bill 2010, The Union Budget 2020-11. Minsitry of Finance, India.

43.

Huang

C. J.

Liu

J. T.

(1994). Estimation of a non-neutral stochastic frontier production function. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 5(2), 171–180.

44.

Jain

Nandan

(2019). Effect of Electricity Act on tariff gap within the subsidizing sector: The case of India. Energy Policy, 132(2019), 901–914.

45.

Jain

Nandan

(2020). Electricity prices and firms’ decisions and outcomes: The case of India after a decade of the Electricity Act. Energy Economics, 91, 104915.

46.

Jamasb

Llorca

Khetrapal

Thakur

(2018). Institutions and performance of regulated firms: Evidence from electric utilities in the Indian states. Cambridge Working Paper Economics, 1823. https://doi.org/10.17863/CAM.21799

47.

Jamasb

Nepal

Timilsina

G. R.

(2015). A quarter century effort yet to come of age: A survey of power sector reforms in developing countries [The World Bank Working Paper No. 7330].

48.

Jamasb

Pollitt

. (2000). Benchmarking and regulation: International electricity experience. Utilities Policy, 9(3), 107–130.

49.

Jondrow

Lovell

C. K.

Materov

I. S.

Schmidt

(1982). On the estimation of technical inefficiency in the stochastic frontier production function model. Journal of Econometrics, 19(2–3), 233–238.

50.

Jorgenson

D. W.

(1986). Econometric methods for modeling producer behavior. Handbook of Econometrics, 3, 1841–1915.

51.

Joskow

P. L.

(1997). Restructuring, competition and regulatory reform in the US electricity sector. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 11(3), 119–138.

52.

Joskow

P. L.

(2005). Regulation and deregulation after 25 years: Lessons learned for research in industrial organization. Review of Industrial Organization, 26(2), 169–193.

53.

Knittel

C. R.

(2002). Alternative regulatory methods and firm efficiency: Stochastic frontier evidence from the US electricity industry. Review of Economics and Statistics, 84(3), 530–540.

54.

Kochhar

Kumar

Rajan

Subramanian

Tokatlidis

(2006). India’s pattern of development: What happened, what follows? Journal of Monetary Economics, 53(5), 981–1019.

55.

Kumbhakar

S. C.

Ghosh

McGuckin

J. T.

(1991). A generalized production frontier approach for estimating determinants of inefficiency in US dairy farms. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 9(3), 279–286.

56.

Kumbhakar

S. C.

Lien

Hardaker

J. B.

(2014). Technical efficiency in competing panel data models: A study of Norwegian grain farming. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 41(2), 321–337.

57.

Kumbhakar

S. C.

Lovell

C. K

. (2003). Stochastic frontier analysis. Cambridge University Press.

58.

Künneke

Fens

(2007). Ownership unbundling in electricity distribution: The case of The Netherlands. Energy Policy, 35(3), 1920–1930.

59.

Kwoka

Pollitt

Sergici

. (2010). Divestiture policy and operating efficiency in US electric power distribution. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 38(1), 86–109.

60.

Laffont

J. J.

(1994). The new economics of regulation ten years after. Econometrica, 62(3), 507–537.

61.

Laffont

J. J.

Tirole

(1993). A theory of incentives in procurement and regulation. MIT Press.

62.

Lee

A. D.

Usman

(2018). Taking stock of the political economy of power sector reforms in developing countries [World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No . 8518].

63.

Levi-Faur

(2005). The global diffusion of regulatory capitalism. The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 598(1), 12–32.

64.

Levy

Spiller

P. T.

(1994). Regulation, institutions, and commitment in telecommunications: A comparative analysis of five country studies. The World Bank Economic Review, 7(Suppl_1), 215–252.

65.

H. Z.

Kopsakangas-Savolainen

Xiao

X. Z.

Lau

S. Y.

(2017). Have regulatory reforms improved the efficiency levels of the Japanese electricity distribution sector? A cost metafrontier-based analysis. Energy Policy, 108, 606–616.

66.

Lin

K. C.

Purra

M. M.

(2019). Transforming China’s electricity sector: Politics of institutional change and regulation. Energy Policy, 124, 401–410.

67.

Malik

Cropper

Limonov

Singh

. (2011). Estimating the impact of restructuring on electricity generation efficiency: The case of the Indian thermal power sector [Working Paper No. w17383]. National Bureau of Economic Research.

68.

Meeusen

van Den Broech

(1977). Efficeincy estimation from Cobb Douglas production with composed error. International Economic Review, 435–444.

69.

Mukherjee

(2014). Private participation in the Indian power sector: Lessons from two decades of experience [The World Bank Directions in Energy and Mining Series No. 91159].

70.

Nagayama

. (2007). “Effects of regulatory reforms in the electricity supply industry on electricity prices in developing countries.” Energy Policy, 35(6), 3440–3462.

71.

Nandan

Mallick

(2020). Does gender equality matter for regional growth and income inequality? An empirical analysis for the Indian states. Journal of International Development, 32(4), 439–469.

72.

Newbery

D. M.

(1995). A template for power reform [The World Bank Note No . 54].

73.

Ngan

H. W.

(2010). Electricity regulation and electricity market reforms in China. Energy Policy, 38(5), 2142–2148.

74.

Nillesen

P. H.

Pollitt

M. G.

(2011). Ownership unbundling in electricity distribution: Empirical evidence from New Zealand. Review of Industrial Organization, 38(1), 61–93.

75.

North

D. C.

(1986). The new institutional economics. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics (JITE)/Zeitschrift für die gesamte Staatswissenschaft, 142(1), 230–237.

76.

North

D. C.

(1991). Institutions. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5(1), 97–112.

77.

North

D. C

. (1993). Institutions and credible commitment. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics (JITE)/Zeitschrift für die gesamte Staatswissenschaft, 149(1), 11–23.

78.

Pargal

Ghosh Banerjee

. (2014). More power to India: The challenge of electricity distribution [The World Bank Report No. 88906 (Vol. 1)].

79.

Peltzman

Levine

M. E.

Noll

R. G.

(1989). The economic theory of regulation after a decade of deregulation. In Brookings papers on economic activity. Microeconomics (Vol. 1989, pp. 1–59). Brookings Institution Press.

80.

Pigou

(1932). The economics of welfare (4th ed.). Macmillan and Company.

81.

Pollitt

(2008). The arguments for and against ownership unbundling of energy transmission networks. Energy Policy, 36(2), 704–713.

82.

Pollitt

M. G.

(2012). The role of policy in energy transitions: Lessons from the energy liberalisation era. Energy Policy, 50, 128–137.

83.

Power Finance Corporation Limited. (2001–2015). Reports on performance of the state-power utilities from 2001 to 2015.

84.

Rao

C. R.

Konishi

Mukerjee

. (2001). On model selection. In Lahiri

(Ed.), Lecture notes-monograph series (Vol. 38, pp. 1–64). Institute of Mathematical Statistics.

85.

Ritter

Simar

(1997). Pitfalls of normal-gamma stochastic frontier models. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 8(2), 167–182.

86.

Romer

P. M.

(1986). Increasing returns and long-run growth. Journal of Political Economy, 94(5), 1002–1037.

87.

Ross

S. A.

(1973). The economic theory of agency: The principal’s problem. The American Economic Review, 63(2), 134–139.

88.

Sabel

Herrigel

Kristensen

P. H.

(2018). Regulation under uncertainty: The coevolution of industry and regulation. Regulation & Governance, 12(3), 371–394.

89.

Sarkar

Mukhi

Padmanaban

P. S.

Kumar

Bansal

Das

Ganta

Verma

. (2016). India’s state-level energy efficiency implementation readiness. The World Bank.

90.

Sen

Jamasb

(2012). Diversity in unity: An empirical analysis of electricity deregulation in Indian states. The Energy Journal, 33(1), 83–131.

91.

Sing

(1987). Are combination gas and electric utilities multiproduct natural monopolies? The Review of Economics and Statistics, 69(3), 392–398.

92.

Smith

T. B.

(2004). Electricity theft: A comparative analysis. Energy Policy, 32(18), 2067–2076.

93.

Stigler

G. J.

(1971). The theory of economic regulation. The Bell Journal of Economics and Management Science, 2, 3–21.

94.

Stigler

G. J.

Friedland

(1962). What can regulators regulate? The case of electricity. The Journal of Law and Economics, 5, 1–16.

95.

Stiglitz

(2010). Regulation and failure. Revista de Economía Institucional, 12(23), 13–28.

96.

Summanen

Arminen

(2018). Ownership unbundling in electricity distribution: The Russian experience. Energy, 161(October 2018), 1199–1210.

97.

Thakur

Deshmukh

S. G.

Kaushik

S. C.

(2006). Efficiency evaluation of the state-owned electric utilities in India. Energy Policy, 34(17), 2788–2804.

98.

The Orissa Electricity Reforms Act (1995). https://indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/5901/1/Odisha%20Electricity%20Reforms%20Act.pdf

99.

Wang

H. J.

(2002). Heteroscedasticity and non-monotonic efficiency effects of a stochastic frontier model. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 18(3), 241–253.

100.

Wang

H. J.

Schmidt

(2002). One-step and two-step estimation of the effects of exogenous variables on technical efficiency levels. Journal of Productivity Analysis, 18(2), 129–144.

101.

Williamson

O. E.

(1983). Credible commitments: Using hostages to support exchange. American Economic Review, 73(4), 519–540.

102.

Williamson

O. E.

(2000). The new institutional economics: Taking stock, looking ahead. Journal of Economic Literature, 38(3), 595–613.

103.

World Bank. (1993, October 29–31). Conference on power sector reform in India. Jaipur, India.

104.

World Bank (1995). Power sector reform in developing countries and role of the World Bank [Industry and Energy Department Occasional Paper No. 9].

105.

World Bank. (2014). India power sector faces $ 27 billion in annual losses. Appeared in Reuters on June 24, 2014. https://www.reuters.com/article/india-power/indian-power-sector-faces-27-bln-in-annual-losses-world-bank-idINKBN0EZ1U420140624?edition-redirect=in

106.

Zhang

Y. F.

Parker

Kirkpatrick

(2008). Electricity sector reform in developing countries: An econometric assessment of the effects of privatization, competition and regulation. Journal of Regulatory Economics, 33(2), 159–178.