Optimizing recovery after a distal radius fracture is a major concern. There continues to be discrepancies in findings on whether therapeutic exercise improves activity and participation by reducing limitations such as pain and range of motion after fracture. The main objective of this overview was to critically appraise the evidence to establish the effectiveness of therapeutic exercise to improve impairment for adults after a distal radius fracture.
Methods
An overview of systematic reviews was used, which summarizes a number of systematic reviews. PubMed, CINAHL, PEDro, Scopus, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library were searched. Systematic reviews were included in this overview if the study population was adults after a distal radius fracture, and the intervention group was therapeutic exercise. A systematic review was excluded from this overview if it did not include randomized controlled trials, the full text was not published, or if they were scoping or narrative reviews. The outcomes evaluated were pain, function/disability, range of motion, and strength.
Results
Five systematic reviews were included in this overview, with between 7 and 26 randomized controlled trials included in the SRs. The overall quality of the reviews was low with two systematic reviews rated as low quality and three rated as critically low quality on the AMSTAR 2 assessment tool.
Conclusion
The quality of reviews was low, with high risk of bias. All reviews were inconclusive due to limitations in the number and quality of randomized controlled trials. Due to the low quality of evidence, it remains unclear what the effectiveness of exercise is to improve impairments after a distal radius fracture.
LarsenCFLauritsenJ.Epidemiology of acute wrist trauma. Int J Epidemiol1993;
22: 911–916.
2.
BonafedeMEspindleDBowerAG.The direct and indirect costs of long bone fractures in a working age US population. J Med Econ2013;
16: 169–178.
3.
KilgoreMLMorriseyMABeckerDJ, et al.
Health care expenditures associated with skeletal fractures among Medicare beneficiaries, 1999–2005. J Bone Mineral Res2009;
24: 2050–2055.
4.
MacDermidJCRothJHMcMurtryR.Predictors of time lost from work following a distal radius fracture. J Occup Rehabil2007;
17: 47–62.
5.
BrennemanSKBarrett-ConnorE, et al.
Impact of recent fracture on health-related quality of life in postmenopausal women. J Bone Miner Res2006;
21: 809–816.
6.
HallbergIRosenqvistAKartousL, et al.
Health-related quality of life after osteoporotic fractures. Osteoporosis Int2004;
15: 834–841.
7.
MacDermidJCRothJHRichardsRS.Pain and disability reported in the year following a distal radius fracture: a cohort study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord2003;
4: 24.
8.
MooreCMLeonardi-BeeJ.The prevalence of pain and disability one year post fracture of the distal radius in a UK population: a cross sectional survey. BMC Musculoskelet Disord2008;
9: 129.
9.
BruderAMTaylorNFDoddKJ, et al.
Physiotherapy intervention practice patterns used in rehabilitation after distal radial fracture. Physiotherapy2013;
99: 233–240.
10.
Gutiérrez-EspinozaHRubio-OyarzúnDOlguín-HuertaC, et al.
Supervised physical therapy vs home exercise program for patients with distal radius fracture: a single-blind randomized clinical study. J Hand Ther2017;
30: 242–252.
11.
KrischakGDKrastevaASchneiderF, et al.
Physiotherapy after volar plating of wrist fractures is effective using a home exercise program. Arch Phys Med Rehabil2009;
90: 537–544.
12.
BrogrenEHoferMPetranekM, et al.
Fractures of the distal radius in women aged 50 to 75 years: natural course of patient-reported outcome, wrist motion and grip strength between 1 year and 2–4 years after fracture. J Hand Surg Eur Vol2011;
36: 568–576.
13.
EnglundUNordströmPNilssonJ, et al.
Active commuting reduces the risk of wrist fractures in middle-aged women – the UFO study. Osteoporos Int2013;
24: 533–540.
14.
FilipovaVLonzarićDPapežBJ.Efficacy of combined physical and occupational therapy in patients with conservatively treated distal radius fracture: randomized controlled trial. Wien Klin Wochenschr2015;
127: 282–287.
15.
GianoudisJBaileyCAEbelingPR, et al.
Effects of a targeted multimodal exercise program incorporating high-speed power training on falls and fracture risk factors in older adults: a community-based randomized controlled trial. J Bone Miner Res2014;
29: 182–191.
16.
MacDermidJCRichardsRSRothJH.Distal radius fracture: a prospective outcome study of 275 patients. J Hand Ther2001;
14: 154–169.
17.
MacDermidJCDonnerARichardsRS, et al.
Patient versus injury factors as predictors of pain and disability six months after a distal radius fracture. J Clin Epidemiol2002;
55: 849–854.
18.
MehtaSPMacDermidJCRichardsonJ, et al.
Baseline pain intensity is a predictor of chronic pain in individuals with distal radius fracture. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther2015;
45: 119–127.
19.
Handoll HelenHGMadhokR. Conservative interventions for treating distal radial fractures in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2003; 2: 1-75.
20.
Handoll HelenHGElliottJ. Rehabilitation for distal radial fractures in adults. Cochrane DatabaseSyst Rev2015; 9: 1-154 .
21.
HandollHMadhokRHoweT.Rehabilitation for distal radial fractures in adults. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2006;
3: 1–63.
22.
ValdesKNaughtonNBurkeCJ.Therapist-supervised hand therapy versus home therapy with therapist instruction following distal radius fracture. J Hand Surg Am2015;
40: 1110.e1–1116.e1.
23.
BougioukasKILiakosATsapasA, et al.
Preferred reporting items for overviews of systematic reviews including harms checklist: a pilot tool to be used for balanced reporting of benefits and harms. J Clin Epidemiol2018;
93: 9–24.
24.
SheaBJReevesBCWellsG, et al.AMSTAR 2: a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions, or both. BMJ2017;
358: j4008.
25.
BruderAMShieldsNDoddKJ, et al.
Prescribed exercise programs may not be effective in reducing impairments and improving activity during upper limb fracture rehabilitation: a systematic review. J Physiother2017;
63: 205–220.
26.
ValdesKNaughtonNMichlovitzS.Therapist supervised clinic-based therapy versus instruction in a home program following distal radius fracture: a systematic review. J Hand Ther2014;
27: 165–174.
27.
KaySMcMahonMStillerK.An advice and exercise program has some benefits over natural recovery after distal radius fracture: a randomised trial. Aust J Physiother2008;
54: 253–259.
28.
Lefevre-ColauMBabinetAFayadF, et al.
Immediate mobilization compared with conventional immobilization for the impacted nonoperatively treated proximal humeral fracture: a randomized controlled trial. JBJS2007;
89: 2582–2590.
29.
ChristensenOKunovAHansenF, et al.
Occupational therapy and Colles’ fractures. Int Orthop2001;
25: 43–45.
30.
SladeSCDionneCEUnderwoodM, et al.
Consensus on exercise reporting template (CERT): explanation and elaboration statement. Br J Sports Med2016;
50: 1428–1437.
31.
BruderATaylorNFDoddKJ, et al.
Exercise reduces impairment and improves activity in people after some upper limb fractures: a systematic review. J Physiother2011;
57: 71–82.
32.
HodgsonSMawsonSStanleyD.Rehabilitation after two-part fractures of the neck of the humerus. J Bone Joint Surg Br Vol2003;
85: 419–422.
33.
WakefieldAMcQueenM.The role of physiotherapy and clinical predictors of outcome after fracture of the distal radius. J Bone Joint Surg Br Vol2000;
82: 972–976.
34.
MooreRAMooreOADerryS, et al.
Responder analysis for pain relief and numbers needed to treat in a meta-analysis of etoricoxib osteoarthritis trials: bridging a gap between clinical trials and clinical practice. Ann Rheum Dis2010;
69: 374–379.
35.
NueschETrelleSReichenbachS, et al.
Small study effects in meta-analyses of osteoarthritis trials: meta-epidemiological study. BMJ2010;
341: c3515.
36.
WeareKNindM.Mental health promotion and problem prevention in schools: what does the evidence say?Health Promot Int2011;
26: i29–i69.
37.
Layne JE and Nelson ME. The effects of progressive resistance training on bone density: a review. Med Sci Sport Exer 1999; 31: 25--30.
38.
Liu CJ and Latham NK. Progressive resistance strength training for improving physical function in older adults. Cochrane DatabaseSyst Rev 2009; 3: 1--227.
39.
Lock CA, Lecouturier J, Mason JM, et al. Lifestyle interventions to prevent osteoporotic fractures: a systematic review. Osteoporosis Int 2006; 17: 20--28.
40.
Tsuda T. Epidemiology of fragility fractures and fall prevention in the elderly: a systematic review of the literature. Curr Orthop Pract 2017; 28: 580--585.
41.
Agorastides I, Sinopidis C, El Meligy M, et al. Early versus late mobilization after hemiarthroplasty for proximal humeral fractures. J Shoulder Elbow Surg 2007; 16(3 Suppl): S33--S38.
42.
Bache SJ. The effective two different physiotherapy approaches to rehabilitation on outcome of patients with distal radial fractures. In: The National Research Register, Issue 1, 2001.
43.
Basso O and Pike JM. The effect of low frequency, long-wave ultrasound therapy on joint mobility and rehabilitation after wrist fracture. J Hand Surg (British Volume) 1998; 23: 136--139.
44.
Bertoft ES, Lundh I and Ringqvist I. Physiotherapy after fracture of the proximal end of the humerus. Comparison between two methods. Scand J Rehabil Med 1984; 16: 11--16.
45.
Bighea AC, Patru S, Marcu IR, et al. Supervised and unsupervised rehabilitation after osteoporotic wrist fracture (abstract). Osteoporosis Int 2013; 24(Suppl 1): S152.
46.
Brehmer JL and Husband JB. Accelerated rehabilitation compared with a standard protocol after distal radial fractures treated with volar open reduction and internal fixation: A prospective, randomized, controlled study. J Bone Joint Surg (American Volume) 2014; 96: 1621--1630.
47.
Bruder AM, Shields N, Dodd KJ, et al. A progressive exercise and structured advice program does not improve activity more than structured advice alone following a distal radial fracture: A multi-centre phase I/II randomized controlled trial. J Physiother 2016; 62: 145--152.
48.
Challis MJ, Jull GJ, Stanton WR, et al. Cyclic pneumatic soft-tissue compression enhances recovery following fracture of the distal radius: a randomised controlled trial. Aust J Physiother 2007; 53: 247--252.
49.
Cheing GL, Wan JW and Kai Lo S. Ice and pulsed electromagnetic field to reduce pain and swelling after distal radius fractures. J Rehab Med 2005; 37: 372--377.
50.
Cooper A. Early therapeutic intervention following fractured distal radius [abstract]. Proceedings of The Chartered Society of Physiotherapy Annual Congress and Exhibition, Birmingham, UK, 8--10 October 2004.
51.
Gronlund B, Harreby MS, Kofoed R, et al. The importance of early exercise therapy in the treatment of Colles' fracture. A clinically controlled study [Betydningen af tidlig ergoterapi ved behandling af Colles--fraktur. En klinisk kontrolleret undersogelse]. Ugeskrift for Laeger 1990; 152: 2491--2493.
52.
Hodgson SA, Mawson SJ, Saxton JM, et al. Rehabilitation of two-part fractures of the neck of the humerus (two-year follow-up). J Shoulder Elbow Surg 2007; 16: 143--145.
53.
Jongs RA, Harvey LA and Lucas BR. Dynamic splints do not reduce contracture following distal radial fracture: a randomised controlled trial. J Physiother 2012; 58: 173--180.
54.
Kay S, Haensel N and Stiller K. The effect of passive mobilisation following fractures involving the distal radius: a randomised study. Aust J Physiother 2000; 46: 93--101.
55.
Knygsand-Roenhoej K and Maribo T. A randomized clinical controlled study comparing the effect of modified manual edema mobilization treatment with traditional edema technique in patients with a fracture of the distal radius. J Hand Ther 2011; 24: 184--193.
56.
Kuo LC, Yang TH, Hsu YY, et al. Is progressive early digit mobilization intervention beneficial for patients with external fixation of distal radius fracture? A pilot randomized controlled trial. Clin Rehab 2013; 27: 983--993.
57.
Lazovic M, Kocic M, Dimitrijevic L, et al. Pulsed electromagnetic field during cast immobilization in postmenopausal women with Colles' fracture. Srpski Arhiv Za Celokupno Lekarstvo 2012; 140: 619--624.
58.
Lundberg BJ, Svenungson-Hartwig E and Wikmark R. Independent exercises versus physiotherapy in non displaced proximal humeral fractures. Scand J Rehabil Med 1979; 11: 133--136.
59.
Maciel JS, Taylor NF and McIlveen C. A randomised clinical trial of activity-focussed physiotherapy on patients with distal radius fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2005; 125: 515--520.
60.
Magnus CR, Arnold CM, Johnston G, et al. Crosseducation for improving strength and mobility after distal radius fractures: a randomized controlled trial. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2013; 94: 1247--1255.
61.
Mitsukane M, Sekiya N, Himei S, et al. Immediate effects of repetitive wrist extension on grip strength in patients with distal radial fracture. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2015; 96: 862--868.
62.
Paschos NK, Mitsionis GI, Vasiliadis HS, et al. Comparison of early mobilization protocols in radial head fractures. J Orthop Trauma 2013; 27: 134--139.
63.
Pasila M, Karaharju EO and Lepisto PV. Role of physical therapy in recovery of function after Colles' fracture. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1974; 55: 130--134.
64.
Revay S, Dahlstrom M and Dalen N. Water exercise versus instruction for self-training following a shoulder fracture. Int J Rehabil Res 1992; 15: 327--333.
65.
Rozencwaig R, Kaye JJ, Gravois D, et al. Efficacy of continuous passive motion after external fixation of unstable distal radius fractures in reducing amount of therapeutic intervention required to return to daily activities and employment [abstract]. Orthopaedic Transactions 1996; 20: 879.
66.
Souer JS, Buijze G and Ring D. A prospective randomized controlled trial comparing occupational therapy with independent exercises after volar plate fixation of a fracture of the distal part of the radius. J Bone Joint Surg (American Volume) 2011; 93: 1761--1766.
67.
Svensson BH, Frellsen MB, Basse PN, et al. Effect of pneumatic compression in connection with ergotherapeutic treatment of Colles' fracture. A clinical controlled trial [Effekten af trykbandagebehandling i forbindelse med ergoterapeutisk behandling af Colles--fraktur. En klinisk kontrolleret undersogelse]. Ugeskrift for Laeger 1993; 155: 463--466.
68.
Taylor NF and Bennell KL. The effectiveness of passive joint mobilisation on the return of active wrist extension following Colles' fracture: a clinical trial. New ZealandJ Physiother 1994; 22: 24--28.
69.
Toomey R, Grief Schwartz R, PiperMC. Clinical evaluation of the effects of whirlpool on patients with Colles' fractures. Physiotherapy Canada 1986; 38: 280--284.
70.
Watt CF, Taylor NF and Baskus K. Do Colles' fracture patients benefit from routine referral to physiotherapy following cast removal? Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2000; 120: 413--415.
