De Quervain’s syndrome: It may not be an isolated pathology

Abstract

Introduction

This paper details a retrospective review of patients’ records diagnosed with de Quervain’s syndrome following a traumatic event but no history of repetitive strain.

Methods

Data analysis of 41 patients was performed. The inclusion criteria were pain over first dorsal compartment, pain on resisted extensor pollicis brevis and/or abductor pollicis longus, and a positive Finkelstein’s test. The assessment included a subjective history to establish a repetitive activity or a traumatic incident and diagnostic tests to establish possible instability or osteoarthritis.

Results

There were 13 men and 28 women with an age range from 20 to 72 years. Statistical analysis was undertaken using Fisher’s Exact tests. 46.3% (n = 19) of 41 patients had a ligament injury diagnosed after the de Quervain’s. 94.7% (n = 18) of 19 patients with ligament instability had a history of trauma, and this was statistically significant. Clinically significant was that 82.9% (n = 34) of 41 patients demonstrated extensor carpi ulnaris (ECU) muscle weakness, but there was no statistical significant correlation between ECU weakness and ligament instability. Patients could have ECU weakness without ligament instability; however, patients with ligament instability appeared more likely to have ECU weakness.

Conclusions

The results would suggest that de Quervain’s syndrome, in a proportion of patients, could be secondary to underlying wrist pathology due to previous trauma. If the patient does not report a true repetitive strain history, a more thorough assessment may need to be undertaken to establish if there is any underlying pathology.