In 1911, Oppenheim coined the term ‘dystonia’ to describe disordered motor control, characterised by an association of hypotonia and tonic muscle spasm. Focal hand dystonia is one form of this disorder, in which symptoms are often task-specific and occur during skilled movements such as writing (writer's cramp) or playing a musical instrument (musician's cramp). Much research has been conducted on the pathophysiology of dystonia, but the underlying mechanisms still remain unclear. Hypotheseses about functional central nervous system alterations continue to gain more support. Scientific treatment-based publications on focal dystonia are sparse, and progress in evidence-based treatment options are necessary in order to assist this patient group. This paper will review the literature, documenting dystonia classification criteria, manifestations, pathophysiology and medical treatment techniques for musicians affected by focal hand dystonia.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AbbruzzeseG, MarcheseR, BuccolieriA, GasparettoB, and TrompettoC (2001). ‘Abnormalities of sensorimotor integration in focal dystonia - a transcranial magnetic stimulation study’Brain124: 537–545
2.
AltenmüllerE (2001). ‘Causes et traitements de la dystonie de fonction chez les musiciens. Une etude sur 5 ans’Medecine des Arts36: 19–27
3.
AltenmüllerE (1998). ‘Causes and cures of focal limb dystonia in musicians’International Society for Study of Tension In Performance9: 13–17
4.
AmadioPC, and RussottiGM (1990). ‘Evaluation and treatment of hand and wrist disorders in musicians’Hand Clinics6 (3): 405–416
5.
BerardelliA, RothwellJC, HallettM, ThompsonPD, ManfrediM, and MarsdenCD (1998). ‘The Pathophysiology of primary dystonia’Brain121: 1195–1212
6.
BergD, WeishauptA, FrancisMJ, MiuraN, YangXL, GoodyerID, NaumannM, KoltzenburgM, ReinersK, and BeckerG (2000). ‘Changes of copper-transporting proteins and ceruloplasmin in the lentiform nuclei in primary adult-onset dystonia’Annals of Neurology47: 827–830
7.
BihariK, HillJL, and MurphyDL (1992a). ‘Obsessive-compulsive characteristics in patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis’Psychiatry Research42: 267–272
8.
BihariK, PigottTA, HillJL, and MurphyDL (1992b). ‘Blepharospasm and obsessive-compulsive disorder’Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease180: 130–132
9.
BrandfonbrenerAG (1995). ‘Musicians with focal dystonia: A report of 58 cases seen during a ten-year period at a performing arts medicine clinic’Medical Problems of Performing Artists10 (4): 121–127
10.
BressmanSB (1998). ‘Dystonia’Current Opinion in Neurology11: 363–372
11.
BressmanSB, de LeonD, RaymondD, OzeliusLJ, BreakefieldXO, NagaardTG, AlmasyL, RischNJ, and KramerPL (1998). ‘Clinical-genetic spectrum of primary dystonia’Advances in Neurology78: 79–91
12.
BylN, MerzenichMM, and JenkinsWM (1996a). ‘A primate genesis model of focal dystonia and repetitive strain injury: Learning-induced dedifferentiation of the representation of the hand in the primary somatosensory cortex in adult monkeys’Neurology47 (2): 508–520
13.
BylN, and ToppKS (1998). ‘Focal hand dystonia’Physical Therapy Case Reports1 (1): 39–52
14.
BylN, WilsonF, MerzenichM, MelnickM, ScottP, OakesA, and McKenzieA (1996b). ‘Sensory dysfunction associated with repetitive strain injuries of tendonitis and focal hand dystonia: A comparative study’Journal of Orthopaedic and Sports Physical Therapy23 (4): 234–244
15.
Ceballos-BaumannAO, and BrooksDJ (1997). ‘Basal ganglia function and dysfunction revealed by PET activation studies’Advances in Neurology74: 127–139
16.
Ceballos-BaumannAO, and BrooksDJ (1998). ‘Activation position emission tomography scanning in dystonia’Advances in Neurology78: 135–152
17.
CharnessME, RossMH, and ShefnerJM (1996). ‘Ulnar neuropathy and dystonic flexion of the fourth and fifth digits: Clinical correlation in musicians’Muscle and Nerve19: 431–437
18.
CoffieldJA, ConsidineRV, and SimpsonLL (1994). ‘The site and mechanism of action of botulinum neurotoxin’ In JankoviJ, and HallettM (Eds.), Therapy with botulinum toxin.New York: Marcel Dekker.
19.
ColeRA, HallettM, and CohenLG (1995). ‘Double-blind trial of botulinum toxin for treatment of focal hand dystonia’Movement Disorders10: 466–471
20.
ColeRA, CohenLG, and HallettM (1991). ‘Treatment of musician's cramp with botulinum toxin’Medical Problems of Performing Artists6 (4): 137–143.
21.
DeuschlG, and HallettM (1998). ‘Focal dystonias: from occupational cramp to sensorimotor disease that can be treated’Aktuelle Neurologie25: 320–328
22.
ElbertT, CandiaV, AltenmüllerE, RauH, SterrA, RockstrohB, PantevC, and TaubE (1998). ‘Alteration of digital representations in somatosensory cortex in focal hand dystonia’Clinical Neuroscience9 (16): 3571–3575.
23.
ElbertT, PantevC, WienbruchC, RockstrohB, and TaubE (1995). ‘Increased cortical representation of the fingers of the left hand in string players’Science270: 305–307
24.
FahnS (1998). ‘Concept and classification of dystonia’Clinical Neuropharmacology’9(2): S37–S48
25.
FahnS, BressmanSB, and MarsdenCD (1998). ‘Classification of dystonia’Advances in Neurology78: 1–10
26.
FahnS, MarsdenCD, and CalneDB (1987). ‘Classification and investigation of dystonia’ In MarsdenCD, and FahnS (Eds.) Movement Disorders 2, London: Butterworths.
27.
FeveA, BathienN, and RondotP (1994). ‘Abnormal movement related potentials in patients with lesions of basal ganglia and anterior thalamus’Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry57: 100–104
28.
GasserT, BoveCM, OzeliusLJ, HalletM, CharnessME, HochbergFH, and BreakfieldXO (1996). ‘Haplotype analysis at the DYT1 locus in Ashkenazi Jewish patients with occupational hand dystonia’Movement Disorders11 (2): 163–6
29.
GowersWR (1893). ‘A Manual of diseases of the nervous system’ 2nd ed, Vol II, Reprinted by Hafner Publishing Company, Darien, Connecticut
30.
HochbergFH, HarrisSU, and BlattertTR (1990). ‘Occupational hand cramps: Professional disorders of motor control’Hand Clinics6: 417–428
31.
HochbergFH, LeffertRD, HellerMD, and MerrimanL (1983). ‘Hand difficulties among musicians’Journal of the American Medical Association249 (14): 1869–1872.
32.
IkomaK, SamiiA, MercuriB, WassermannEM, and HalletM (1996). ‘Abnormal cortical motor excitability in dystonia’Neurology46: 1371–1376
33.
JabuschHC (2006). ‘Epidemiology, phenomenology and therapy of musician's cramp’ In: AltenmüllerE, ed. Music, Motor Control and the Brain.Oxford University Press: Oxford
34.
JankovicJ, and ShaleH (1989). ‘Dystonia in musicians’Seminars in Neurology9: 131–135
35.
KedlayaD, ReynoldsLW, StrumSR, and WaldmanSD (1999). ‘Effective treatment of cervical dystonia with botulinum toxin: Review’Journal of Back and Musculoskeletal Rehabilitation13: 3–10
36.
KemberJM (1997). ‘Focal dystonia in a musician’Manual Therapy2 (4): 221–225
37.
LedermanRJ (1991). ‘Focal Dystonia in instrumentalists: Clinical features’Medical Problems of Performing Artists6: 132–136
38.
LeijnseJN (1997a). ‘Anatomical factors predisposing to focal dystonia in the musician's hand - principles, theoretical examples, clinical significance’Journal of Biomechanics30: 659–669
39.
LeijnseJN (1997b). ‘Measuring force transfers in the deep flexors of the musician's hand: Theoretical analysis clinical examples’Journal of Biomechanics30: 873–882
40.
LeijnseJN, SnijdersCJ, BonteJE, LandsmeerJM, KalkerJJ, Van der MeulenJC, SonneveldGJ, and HoviusSE (1993). ‘The hand of the musician: The kinematics of the bidigital finger system with anatomical restrictions’Journal of Biomechanics26: 1169–1179
41.
LeijnseJN, BonteJE, LandsmeerJM, KalkerJJ, Van der MeulenJC, and SnijdersCJ (1992). ‘Biomechanics of the finger with anatomical restrictions - the significance for the exercising hand of the musician’Journal of Biomechanics25: 1253–1264
42.
LenzFA, and BylNN (1999) ‘Reorganization in the cutaneous core of the human thalamic principal somatic sensory nucleus (ventral caudal) in patients with dystonia’Journal of Neurophysiology82: 3204–3212
43.
LimVK, AltenmüllerE, and BradshawJL (2001). ‘Focal dystonia: Current theories’Human Movement Science20: 875–914
44.
LozanoA, and LinazasoroG (2000). ‘Tratamiento quirurgigo de la distonia’Revista de Neurologia, 30 (11): 1073–1076.
45.
MarionMH (1999). ‘Traitement des dystonies’Presse Medicale28 (6): 312–315
46.
MavroudakisN, CaroyerJM, BrunkoE, Zegers de BeylD (1995). ‘Abnormal motor evoked responses to transcranial magnetic stimulation in focal dystonia’Neurology45: 1671–7
47.
MullerF, DichgansJ, and JankovicJ (1996). ‘Dyskinesias’ In BrandtT, CaplanLK, DichgansJ, DienerHC, and KennardC (Eds.). Neurological disorders: Course and treatment.Academy Press: San Diego.
48.
NaumannM, WarmuthmetzM, HillererC, SolymosiL, and ReinersK (1998). ‘H-1 magnetic resonance spectroscopy of the lentiform nucleus in primary focal dystonia’Movement Disorders13: 929–933
49.
NaumannM, BeckerG, ToykaKV, SupprianT, and ReinersK (1996). ‘Lenticular nucleus lesions in idiopathic dystonia detected by transcranial sonography’Neurology47: 1284–1290
50.
NuttJG, MuenterMD, and MeltonIJ (1988). ‘Epidemiology of dystonia in Rochester, Minnesota’Advances in Neurology50: 361–365
51.
OppenheimH (1911). ‘Über eine eingenartige Krampfkrankheit des Kindlichen und jugenlichen Alters (Dystonia musculorum deformans)’Neurologisches Zentralblatt30: 1090–1107
52.
Pascual-LeoneA (2001). ‘The brain that plays music and is changed by it’Annals of New York Academy of Science930: 315–29
53.
PrioriA, PesentiA, CappellariA, ScarlatoG, and BarbieriS (2001). ‘Limb immobilization for the treatment of focal occupational dystonia’Neurology57 (3): 405–409
54.
RiddingMC, SheeanG, RothwellJC, InzelbergR, and KujiraiT (1995). ‘Changes in the balance between motor cortical excitation and inhibition in focal, task specific dystonia’Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry59: 493–8.
55.
RosenkranzK, AltenmüllerE, SiggelkowS, and DenglerR (2000). ‘Alteration of sensorimotor integration in musician's cramp: impaired focusing of proprioception’Clinical Neurophysiology111: 2040–2045
56.
RossMH, CharnessME, SudarskyL, and LogigianEL (1997). ‘Treatment of occupational cramp with botulinum toxin: Diffusion of toxin to adjacent non-injected muscles’Muscle and Nerve20: 593–598
57.
RossMH, CharnessME, LeeD, and LogigianEL (1995). ‘Does ulnar neuropathy predispose to focal dystonia?’Muscle and Nerve18: 606–611
58.
SangerTD, and MerzenichMM (2000). ‘Computational model of the role of sensory disorganisation in focal task-specific dystonia’Journal of Neurophysiology84: 2458–2464.
59.
SheehyMP, and MarsdenCD (1982). ‘Writer's cramp - a focal dystonia’Brain105: 461–480
60.
SiebnerH, AuerC, and ConradB (1999). ‘Abnormal increase in the corticomotor output to the affected hand during repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the primary motor cortex in patients with writer's cramp’Neuroscience Letters262: 133–136
61.
SingerC, and WeinerWJ (1995). ‘Primary dystonias current therapeutic recommendations’CNS Drugs3 (3): 186–193
62.
SojerM, WisselJ, MullerJ, and PoeweW (2001). ‘Treatment of focal dystonia with botulinum toxin A’Wiener Klinische Wochenschrift Supplement113 (4): 6–10
63.
ThompsonML, ThickbroomGW, SaccoP, WilsonSA, StellR, and MastagliaFL (1996). ‘Changes in the organisation of the corticomotor projection to the hand in writer's cramp (abstract)’Movement Disorders 11 Supplement1: 219
64.
Van der KampW, RothwellJC, ThompsonPD, DayBL, and MarsdenCD (1995). ‘The movement-related cortical potential is abnormal in patients with idiopathic torsion dystonia’Movement Disorders10: 630–633
65.
WangX, MerzenichMM, SameshimaK, and JenkinsWM (1995). ‘Remodeling of hand representation in adult cortex determined by timing of tactile stimulation’Nature378: 71–75
66.
WilsonFR, WagnerC, and HombergV (1993). ‘Biomechanical abnormalities in musicians with occupational cramp/focal dystonia’Journal of Hand Therapy6: 298–307
67.
WinspurI (1998). ‘Surgical indications, planning and technique’ In: WinspurI, and Wynn ParryCB (eds). The Musician's Hand: A Clinical Guide.Martin Dunitz: London
68.
Wynn ParryCB (1998). ‘Dystonia’ In: WinspurI, and Wynn ParryCB (Eds.) The Musician's Hand: A Clinical Guide.Martin Dunitz: London
69.
YazawaS, IkedaA, KajiR, TeradaK, NagamineT, TomaK, KuboriT, KimuraJ, and ShibasakiH (1999). ‘Abnormal cortical processing of voluntary muscle relaxation in patients with focal hand dystonia studied by movement-related potentials’Brain122: 1357–1366
