A systematic review and meta-synthesis of policy intervention characteristics that influence the implementation of government-directed policy in the hospital setting: implications for infection prevention and control
Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online May, 2020
A systematic review and meta-synthesis of policy intervention characteristics that influence the implementation of government-directed policy in the hospital setting: implications for infection prevention and control
Government-directed policy plays an important role in the regulation and supervision of healthcare quality. Effective implementation of these policies has the potential to significantly improve clinical practice and patient outcomes, including the prevention of healthcare-associated infections. A systematic review of research describing the implementation of government-directed policy in the hospital setting was performed with the aim to identify policy intervention characteristics that influence implementation.
Methods:
A systematic search of four electronic databases was undertaken to identify eligible articles published between 2007 and 2017. Studies were included if published in the English language and described the implementation of government-directed policy in a high-income country hospital setting. Data on policy and implementation were extracted for each article and interpretive syntheses performed.
Results:
A total of 925 articles were retrieved and titles and abstracts reviewed, with 69 articles included after review of abstract and full text. Qualitative synthesis of implementation data showed three overarching themes related to intervention characteristics associated with implementation: clarity; infrastructure; and alignment.
Conclusion:
Better understanding and consideration of policy intervention characteristics during development and planning will facilitate more effective implementation although research describing implementation of government-directed policy in the hospital setting is limited and of variable quality. The findings of this study provide guidance to staff tasked with the development or implementation of government-directed policy in the hospital setting, infection prevention and control professionals seeking to maximise the impact of policy on practice and improve patient outcomes.
AltmanSH. (2012) The lessons of Medicare’s prospective payment system show that the bundled payment program faces challenges...[corrected] [published erratum appears in HEALTH AFF 2012; 31(12): 2831]. Health Affairs31: 1923–1930.
2.
AminANHofmannHOwenMMTranHTuckerSKaplanSH. (2014) Reduce readmissions with service-based care management. Professional Case Management19: 255–262.
3.
AmlandRCDeanBBYuHTRyanHOrsundTHackmanJLRobertsSR. (2015) Computerized clinical decision support to prevent venous thromboembolism among hospitalized patients: Proximal outcomes from a multiyear quality improvement project. Journal for Healthcare Quality37: 221–231.
4.
BackJRossAJDuncanMDJayePHendersonKAndersonJE. (2017) Emergency Department escalation in theory and practice: a mixed-methods study using a model of organizational resilience. Annals of Emergency Medicine70: 659–671.
5.
BarbashIJRakKJKuzaCCKahnJM. (2017) Hospital perceptions of Medicare’s sepsis quality reporting initiative. Journal of Hospital Medicine12: 963–968.
6.
BatesOLO’ConnorNDunnDHasenauSM. (2014) Applying STAAR interventions in incremental bundles: Improving post-CABG surgical patient care. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing11: 89–97.
7.
BellEJTakharSSBeloffJRSchuurDLandmanAB. (2013) Information technology improves emergency department patient discharge instructions completeness and performance on a national quality measure: A quasi-experimental study. Applied Clinical Informatics4: 499–514.
8.
BraithwaiteJMannionRMatsuyamaYShekellePWhittakerSAl-AdawiSLudlowKJamesWTingHPHerkesJEllisLAChurrucaKNicklinWHughesC. (2017) Accomplishing reform: successful case studies drawn from the health systems of 60 countries. International Journal for Quality in Health Care29: 880–886.
9.
BraunBIHarrisADRichardsCLBeltonBMDembryLMMortonDJXiaoY. (2013) Does health care role and experience influence perception of safety culture related to preventing infections?American Journal of Infection Control41: 638–641.
10.
ByronSCGardnerWKleinmanLCMangione-SmithRMoonJSachdevaRSchusterMAFreedGLSmithGScholleSH. (2014) Developing measures for pediatric quality: methods and experiences of the CHIPRA pediatric quality measures program grantees. Academic Pediatrics14: S27–S32.
11.
CalikogluSMurrayRFeeneyD. (2012) Hospital pay-for-performance programs in Maryland produced strong results, including reduced hospital-acquired conditions. Health Affairs31: 2649–2658.
12.
CanawayRBismarkMDuntDKelaherM. (2017) Perceived barriers to effective implementation of public reporting of hospital performance data in Australia: a qualitative study. BMC Health Services Research17: 391.
CherlinEJBrewsterALCurryLACanavanMEHurzelerRBradleyEH. (2017) Interventions for reducing hospital readmission rates: the role of hospice and palliative care. American Journal of Hospice & Palliative Care34: 748–753.
15.
ChildsLAlexanderEDuongMT. (2012) Risk evaluation and mitigation strategies: Assessment of a medical center’s policies and procedures. American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy69: 885–889.
16.
ChukmaitovAHarlessDWBazzoliGJCarrettaHJSiangphoeU. (2015) Delivery system characteristics and their association with quality and costs of care: implications for accountable care organizations. Health Care Management Review40: 92–103.
17.
ColemanEAParryCChalmersSAChughAMahoneyE. (2007) The central role of performance measurement in improving the quality of transitional care. Home Health Care Services Quarterly26: 93–104.
18.
DeasyCCroninMCahillFGearyUHoulihanPWoodfordMLeckyFMealyKCrowleyP, Major Trauma Audit Governance Committee, National Office of Clinical Audit, Ireland. (2016) Implementing major trauma audit in Ireland. Injury47: 166–172.
19.
DenisJ-LHébertYLangleyALozeauDTrottierLH. (2002) Explaining diffusion patterns for complex health care innovations. Health Care Management Review27: 60–73.
20.
DharampalNCameronCDixonEGhaliWQuanML. (2016) Attitudes and beliefs about the surgical safety checklist: Just another tick box?Canadian Journal of Surgery59: 268–275.
21.
Dixon-WoodsMCaversDAgarwalSAnnandaleEArthurAHarveyJHsuRKatbamnaSOlsenRSmithLRileyRSuttonAJ. (2006) Conducting a critical interpretive synthesis of the literature on access to healthcare by vulnerable groups. BMC Medical Research Methodology6: 35.
22.
DuckersMMakaiPVosLGroenewegenPWagnerC. (2009a) Longitudinal analysis on the development of hospital quality management systems in the Netherlands. International Journal of Quality in Health Care21: 330–340.
23.
DuckersMLStegemanISpreeuwenbergPWagnerCSandersKGroenewegenP. (2009b) Consensus on the leadership of hospital CEOs and its impact on the participation of physicians in improvement projects. Health Policy91: 306–313.
24.
DumartinCRoguesAMAmadeoBPefauMVenierAGParneixPMaurainC. (2011) Antibiotic stewardship programmes: Legal framework and structure and process indicator in Southwestern French hospitals, 2005–2008. Journal of Hospital Infection77: 123–128.
25.
DyersRWardGdu PlooySFourieSEvansJMahomedH. (2017) Training and support to improve ICD coding quality: A controlled before-and-after impact evaluation. South African Medical Journal107: 501–506.
26.
FanelliSFerrettiMZangrandiA. (2017) The impact of regional policies on emergency department management and performance: the case of the regional government of Sicily. The International Journal of Health Planning and Management32: e83–e98.
27.
FasslBANkoyFLStoneBLSrivastavaRSimonTDUchidaDAKoopmeinersKGreeneTCookLJMaloneyCG. (2012) The Joint Commission children’s asthma care quality measures and asthma readmissions. Pediatrics130: 482–491.
28.
GaspariniRChampagneMStephanyAHudsonJFuchsMA. (2015) Policy to practice: increased family presence and the impact on patient- and family-centered care adoption. The Journal of Nursing Administration45: 28–34.
29.
GreenhalghTRobertGMacfarlaneFBatePKyriakidouO. (2004) Diffusion of innovations in service organizations: systematic review and recommendations. Milbank Quarterly82: 581–629.
30.
HafnerJMWilliamsSCKossRGTschurtzBASchmaltzSPLoebJM. (2011) The perceived impact of public reporting hospital performance data: interviews with hospital staff. International Journal of Quality in Health Care23: 697–704.
31.
HalpinHAMilsteinAShortellSMVannemanMRosenbergJ. (2011) Mandatory public reporting of hospital-acquired infection rates: a report from California. Health Affairs30: 723–729.
32.
HassanainM. (2017) An overview of the performance improvement initiatives by the ministry of health in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Inquiry54: 46958017707872.
33.
HauschildtKPaulTKDe VriesRSmithLBVerclerCJShumanAG. (2017) The use of an online comment system in clinical ethics consultation. AJOB Empirical Bioethics8: 153–160.
34.
HaversSMRussoPLPageKWilsonAHallL. (2019) Clinician perspectives of policy implementation: A qualitative study of the implementation of a national infection prevention policy in Australian hospitals. American Journal of Infection Control47: 366–370.
35.
HeitmannRNillesEKJeansAMorelandJClarkeCMcDonaldMFWarrenMD. (2017) Improving safe sleep modeling in the hospital through policy implementation. Maternal and Child Health Journal21: 1995–2000.
36.
HosfordSB. (2008) Hospital progress in reducing error: the impact of external interventions. Hospital Topics86: 9–19.
37.
HupePLHillMJ. (2016) ‘And the rest is implementation.’ Comparing approaches to what happens in policy processes beyond Great Expectations. Public Policy and Administration31: 103–121.
38.
IorioR. (2015) Strategies and tactics for successful implementation of bundled payments: bundled payment for care improvement at a large, urban, academic medical center. Journal of Arthroplasty30: 349–350.
39.
IorioRClairAJInnehIASloverJDBoscoJAZuckermanJD. (2016) Early results of Medicare’s bundled payment initiative for a 90-day total joint arthroplasty episode of care. Journal of Arthroplasty31: 343–350.
40.
JhaAPrasopa-PlaizierNLarizgoitiaIBatesDW; Research Priority Setting Workshop Group of the WHO World Alliance for Patience Safety. (2010) Patient safety research: an overview of the global evidence. Quality and Safety in Health Care19: 42–47.
41.
JorgensenSThorlbyRWeinickRMAyanianJZ. (2010) Responses of Massachusetts hospitals to a state mandate to collect race, ethnicity and language data from patients: a qualitative study. BMC Health Services Research10: 352.
42.
JuMHKoCYHallBLBoskCLBilimoriaKYWickEC. (2015) A comparison of 2 surgical site infection monitoring systems. JAMA Surgery150: 51–57.
43.
JurkowskiJMSvistovaJNguyenTDennisonBA. (2016) Public reporting of hospital-specific breastfeeding measures: a qualitative study of hospital staff and administrators. Journal of Human Lactation32: 666–674.
44.
KachaliaAMelloMMNallamothuBKStuddertDM. (2016) Legal and policy interventions to improve patient safety. Circulation133: 661–671.
45.
KahinSAMcGurkMHansen-SmithHWestMLiRMelcherCL. (2017) Key program findings and insights from the Baby-Friendly Hawaii Project. Journal of Human Lactation33: 409-414.
46.
KetkoAKMartinCMNemshakMANiednerMVartanianRJ. (2015) Balancing the tension between hyperoxia prevention and alarm fatigue in the NICU. Pediatrics136: e496–e504.
47.
KodalTKjærNKQveselD. (2012) Improved education after implementation of the Danish postgraduate medical training reform. Danish Medical Journal59: A4392.
48.
KohnLTCorriganJMDonaldsonMS (eds) (2000) To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
49.
KozhimannilKBSommernessSARaukPGamsRHirtCDavisSMillerKKLandersDV. (2013) A perinatal care quality and safety initiative: are there financial rewards for improved quality?Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety39: 339–348.
50.
KreinSLDamschroderLJKowalskiCPFormanJHoferTPSaintS. (2010) The influence of organizational context on quality improvement and patient safety efforts in infection prevention: a multi-center qualitative study. Social Science & Medicine71: 1692–1701.
51.
KurtzmanETO’LearyDSheingoldBHDeversKJDawsonEMJohnsonJE. (2011) Performance-based payment incentives increase burden and blame for hospital nurses. Health Affairs30: 211–218.
52.
LambertMLBruyndonckxRGoossensHHensNAertsMCatryBNeelyFVogelaersDHammamiN. (2015) The Belgian policy of funding antimicrobial stewardship in hospitals and trends of selected quality indicators for antimicrobial use, 1999–2010: A longitudinal study. BMJ Open5: e006916.
53.
LaneseB. (2016) Implementation of the affordable care act: a case study of a service line co-management company. Journal of Health, Organisation and Management30: 818–835.
54.
LombartsMJMHRuppIVallejoPSunolRKlazingaNS. (2009) Application of quality improvement strategies in 389 European hospitals: results of the MARQuIS project. Quality & Safety in Health Care 18 (Suppl. 1): i28–i37.
55.
MarstellerJAHsuY-JWeeksK. (2014) Evaluating the impact of mandatory public reporting on participation and performance in a program to reduce central line-associated bloodstream infections: evidence from a national patient safety collaborative. American Journal of Infection Control42: S209–S215.
56.
MartínezCFuMMartínez-SánchezJMBallbeMPuigMGarciaMCarabasaESaltoEFernandezE. (2009) Tobacco control policies in hospitals before and after the implementation of a national smoking ban in Catalonia, Spain. BMC Public Health9: 160.
57.
MayCRJohnsonMFinchT. (2016) Implementation, context and complexity. Implementation Science11: 141.
McHughMVan DykeKOsei-AntoAHaqueA. (2011) Medicare’s payment policy for hospital-acquired conditions: perspectives of administrators from safety net hospitals. Medical Care Research and Review68: 667–682.
60.
MendelsonAKondoKDambergCLowAMotuapuakaMFreemanMO’NeilMRelevoRKansagaraD. (2017) The effects of pay-for-performance programs on health, health care use, and processes of care: a systematic review. Annals of Internal Medicine166: 341–353.
61.
MittlerJNO'HoraJLHarveyJBPressMJVolppKGScanlonDP. (2013) Turning readmission reduction policies into results: Some lessons from a multistate initiative to reduce readmissions. Population Health Management16: 255–260.
62.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJAltmanDGPRISMA Group. (2009) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. PLoS Medicine6: e1000097.
63.
MolinaGJiangWEdmondsonLGibbonsLHuangLCKiangMVHaynesABGawandeAABerryWRSingerSJ. (2016) Implementation of the surgical safety checklist in South Carolina hospitals is associated with improvement in perceived perioperative safety. Journal of the American College of Surgeons222: 725–736.e725.
64.
MorrowERobertGMabenJGriffithsP. (2012) Implementing large-scale quality improvement: lessons from The Productive Ward: Releasing Time to Care™. International Journal of Health Care Quality Assurance25: 237–253.
65.
NislySShiltzEVanarsdaleVLaughlinJ. (2013) Implementation of an order set to Adhere to National patient safety goals for warfarin therapy. Hospital Pharmacy48: 828–833.
66.
PadulaWVMishraMKMakicMBFWaldHLCampbellJDNairKVValuckRJ. (2015) Increased adoption of quality improvement interventions to implement evidence-based practices for pressure ulcer prevention in U.S. academic medical centers. Worldviews on Evidence-Based Nursing12: 328–336.
67.
Pogorzelska-MaziarzMde CordovaPBHerzigCTDickAReaganJStonePW. (2019) Perceived impact of state-mandated reporting on infection prevention and control departments. American Journal of Infection Control47: 118–122.
68.
PurvisTMossKFrancisLBorschmannKKilkennyMFDenisenkoSBladinCFCadilhacDA. (2017) Benefits of clinical facilitators on improving stroke care in acute hospitals: a new programme for Australia. Internal Medicine Journal47: 775–784.
69.
RejtarMRanstromLAllcoxC. (2017) Development of the 24/7 nurse practitioner model on the inpatient pediatric general surgery service at a large tertiary care children’s hospital and associated outcomes. Journal of Pediatric Health Care31: 131–140.
70.
ResarRNolanKKaczynskiDJensenK. (2011) Using real-time demand capacity management to improve hospitalwide patient flow. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety37: 217–227.
71.
RichardsF3rdPitlukHCollierPPowellSDionCStruchen-ShellhornWPlunkettM. (2008) Reducing unnecessary Medicare hospital admissions for chest pain in Arizona and Florida. Professional Case Management13: 74–84; quiz 85–76.
72.
RussSJSevdalisNMoorthyKMayerEKRoutSCarisJMansellJDaviesRVincentCDarziA. (2015) A qualitative evaluation of the barriers and facilitators toward implementation of the who surgical safety checklist across hospitals in England. Annals of Surgery261: 81–91.
73.
SautterKMBokhourBGWhiteBYoungGJBurgessJFJrBerlotwitzDWheelerJR. (2007) The early experience of a hospital-based pay-for-performance program. Journal of Healthcare Management / American College of Healthcare Executives52: 95–107.
74.
SekimotoMImanakaYKobayashiHOkuboTKizuJKobuseHMiharaHTsujiNYamaguchiA; Japan Council for Quality Health Care, Expert Group on Healthcare-Associated Infection Control and Prevention. (2008) Impact of hospital accreditation on infection control programs in teaching hospitals in Japan. American Journal of Infection Control36: 212–219.
75.
ShiloachMFrencherSKJrSteegerJERowellKSBartzokisKTomehMGRichardsKEKoCYHallBL. (2010) Toward robust information: data quality and inter-rater reliability in the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program. Journal of the American College of Surgeons210: 6–16.
76.
SmithDMurphyPPhillipsMPaulsenMVisloskyFMWildeMSantosP. (2009) The implementation of an innovative statewide quality improvement initiative. Journal of Neuroscience Nursing41: 106–114.
77.
SmithJGMetzgerNL. (2011) Evaluation of pneumococcal vaccination rates after vaccine protocol changes and nurse education in a tertiary care teaching hospital. Journal of Managed Care Pharmacy17: 701–708.
78.
SomCV. (2007) Exploring the human resource implications of clinical governance. Health Policy80: 281–296.
79.
StonePWPogorzelska-MaziarzMReaganJMerrillJASperberBCairnsCPennMRamanathanTMothershedESkillenE. (2015) Impact of laws aimed at healthcare-associated infection reduction: a qualitative study. BMJ Quality & Safety24: 637–644.
TungYCChangGM. (2016) The relationships among regionalization, processes, and outcomes for stroke care: a nationwide population-based study. Medicine95: e3327.
82.
TungYCYangMC. (2009) How to effectively implement an indicator system to improve performance from a management perspective: the case of Taiwan Healthcare Indicator Series (THIS) system. Journal of Medical Systems33: 215–221.
83.
UrbachDRGovindarajanASaskinRWiltonASBaxterNN. (2014) Introduction of surgical safety checklists in Ontario, Canada. New England Journal of Medicine370: 1029–1038.
84.
WaldHRichardADicksonVVCapezutiE. (2012) Chief nursing officers' perspectives on Medicare’s hospital-acquired conditions non-payment policy: implications for policy design and implementation. Implement Science7: 78.
85.
WeeksKRHsuY-JYangTSawyerMMarstellerJA. (2014) Influence of a multifaceted intervention on central line days in intensive care units: results of a national multisite study. American Journal of Infection Control42: S197–S202.
86.
WiigSStormMAaseKGjestsenMTSolheimMHarthugSRobertGFulopNQUASER team. (2013) Investigating the use of patient involvement and patient experience in quality improvement in Norway: Rhetoric or reality?BMC Health Services Research13: 206.
87.
WoodwardBUmbergerR. (2016) Review of best practices for CLABSI prevention and the impact of recent legislation on CLABSI reporting. SAGE Open6: 2158244016677747.
88.
YellandJBiroMADawsonWRiggsEVanpraagDWiggKAntonopoulosJMorgansJSzwarcJEastCBrownS. (2017) Bridging the language gap: A co-designed quality improvement project to engage professional interpreters for women during labour. Australian Health Review41: 499–504.
89.
YuYRAbbasPISmithCMCarberryKERenHPatelBNuchternJGLopezME. (2017) Time-driven activity-based costing: A dynamic value assessment model in pediatric appendicitis. Journal of Pediatric Surgery52: 1045–1049.
