Over 4 million patients acquire a healthcare-associated infection (HCAI) in Europe every year, indicating possible shortcomings in hospitals converting evidence-based infection prevention and control (IPC) strategies into universal adherence. We present a literature review exploring whether insufficient adherence could be culturally based.
Aim:
To find empirical evidence if and how specific traits of organisational culture improve adherence to IPC strategies utilising HCAI rates as the marker of system failures or successes.
Methods:
PubMed, CINAHL, PsycINFO and the British Nursing index database were searched from January 2007 to June 2018. Hand-searching, Google Scholar and the snowball effect completed the investigation. The quality of the studies was assessed with the guidance of CASP and Cochrane tools.
Results:
Twenty papers were eligible for data extraction and thematic analysis. Studies predominantly report positive findings for the association, but none were determined high quality due to multiple methodological concerns. Analysing both quantitative and qualitative research revealed eight major themes: hospital cultures with better HCAI rates foster safety culture; have a generative leadership style; embrace innovation; ensure interventions fit local context; accept long-term orientation; engage and empower health professionals; promote collaboration and communication; and see the benefits of a non-punitive climate.
Interpretation:
The literature linking organisational culture and HCAI rates is suggestive, but not conclusive, indicating caution about their inferences. Leaving cultural growth to chance or allowing for weak or toxic cultures impedes on our IPC strategies and equivalently our HCAI rates.
ACOG. (2017) Committee Opinion No. 683 Summary: Behavior That Undermines a Culture of Safety. Obstetrics and Gynecology129: e1–4.
2.
AveyardH. (2014) Doing a Literature Review in Health and Social care; a practical guide. 3rd edn.Maidenhead: McGraw-Hill Education, Open University Press.
3.
BernardLBironALavigneGFrechetteJBernardAMitchellJLavoie-TremblayM. (2018) An exploratory study of safety culture, biological risk management and hand hygiene of healthcare professionals. Journal of Advanced Learning74: 827–837.
4.
BirkS. (2015) Accelerating the adoption of a safety culture. Healthcare Executive30: 18–20, 22–4, 26.
5.
BorgMA. (2014a) Lowbury Lecture 2013. Cultural determinants of infection control behaviour: understanding drivers and implementing effective change. Journal of Hospital Infection86: 161–168.
6.
BorgMA. (2014b) Prolonged perioperative surgical prophylaxis within European hospitals: an exercise in uncertainty avoidance?Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy69: 1142–1144.
7.
BorgMACamilleriLWaisfiszB. (2012) Understanding the epidemiology of MRSA in Europe: do we need to think outside the box?Journal of Hospital Infection81: 251–256.
8.
BorgMAWaisfiszBFrankU. (2015) Quantitative assessment of organizational culture within hospitals and its relevance to infection prevention and control strategies. Journal of Hospital Infection90: 75–77.
9.
BraithwaiteJHerkesJLudlowKTestaLLamprellG. (2017). Association between organisational and workplace cultures, and patient outcomes: systematic review. BMJ Open7: e017708.
10.
BraithwaiteJHerkesJLudlowKLampressGTestaL. (2016) Association between organisational and workplace cultures, and patient outcomes: systematic review protocol. BMJ Open6: e013758.
11.
BraithwaiteJWearsRLHollnagelE. (2015) Resilient health care: turning patient safety on its head. International Journal of Quality in Health Care27: 418–420.
12.
BraunVClarkeV. (2006) Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology3: 77–101.
De BonoSHelingGBorgMA. (2014) Organizational culture and its implications for infection prevention and control in healthcare institutions. Journal of Hospital Infection86: 1–6.
18.
EscobarNMMarquezIAQuirogaJATrujilloTGGonzalezFAguilarMIEscobar-PerezJ. (2017) Using Positive Deviance in the prevention and control of MRSA infections in a Colombian hospital: a time-series analysis. Epidemiology and Infection145: 981–989.
19.
Ettorchi-TardyALevifMMichelP. (2012) Benchmarking: a method for continuous quality improvement in health. Healthcare Policy7: e101–119.
20.
FanCJPawlikTMDanielsTVernonNBanksKWestbyPWickECSextonJBMakaryMA. (2016) Association of safety culture with surgical site infection outcomes. Journal of the American College of Surgeons222: 122–128.
21.
FedorowskyRPeles-BortzAMasarwaSLibermanDRubinovitchBLipvkinV. (2015) Carbapenem-resistant Enterobacteriaceae carriers in acute care hospitals and postacute-care facilities: The effect of organizational culture on staff attitudes, knowledge, practices, and infection acquisition rates. American Journal of Infection Control43: 935–939.
22.
HofstedeG. (2001) Cultures consequences; Comparing Values, Behaviors, Institutions and Organizations Across Nations. 2nd edn.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
23.
HuangDTClermontGKongLWeissfeldLASextonJBRowanKMAngusDC. (2010) Intensive care unit safety culture and outcomes: a US multicenter study. International Journal for Quality in Health Care22: 151–161.
24.
JacksonCLowtonKGriffithsP. (2014) Infection prevention as “a show”: a qualitative study of nurses’ infection prevention behaviours. Int J Nurs Stud51: 400–408.
25.
JacobsRMannionRDaviesHTHarrisonSKontehFWalsheK. (2013) The relationship between organizational culture and performance in acute hospitals. Social Science & Medicine76: 115–125.
26.
JainRKralovicSMEvansMEAmbroseMSimbartlLAObroskyDSRenderMLFreybergRWJerniganJAMuderRRMillerLJRoselleGA. (2011) Veterans Affairs initiative to prevent methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infections. New England Journal of Medicine364: 1419–1430.
27.
JBI. (2014) Joanna Briggs Institute Reviewers Manual: 2014. Methodology for JBI Mixed Methods Systematic Reviews. Adelaide: The Joanna Briggs Institute. Available at: www.joannabriggs.org
28.
JohnsonLGrueberSSchlotzhauerCPhillipsEBullockPBasnettJHahn-CoverK. (2014) A multifactorial action plan improves hand hygiene adherence and significantly reduces central line-associated bloodstream infections. American Journal of Infection Control42: 1146–1151.
29.
JungTScottTDaviesHTOBowerPWhalleyDMcNallyRMannionR. (2009) Instruments for Exploring Organizational Culture: A Review of the Literature. Public Administration Review69: 1087–1096.
30.
KaplanGMasonVCarayonPPronovostPRouseWReidPSaundersR. (2013) Bringing a systems approach to health. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine and National Academy of Engineering.
31.
LarsonELQuirosDLinSX. (2007) Dissemination of the CDC’s Hand Hygiene Guideline and impact on infection rates. American Journal of Infection Control35: 666–675.
32.
LatifAKellyBEdreesHKentPSWeaverSJJovanovicBAttallahHde GrouchyKKAl-ObaidliAGoeschelCABerenholtzSM. (2015) Implementing a multifaceted intervention to decrease central line-associated bloodstream infections in SEHA (Abu Dhabi Health Services Company)intensive care units: the Abu Dhabi experience. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology36: 816–822.
33.
LinDCarsonKALubomskiLHWickECPhamJC. (2018) Statewide Collaborative to Reduce surgical site Infections: Results of the Hawaii Surgical Unit-Based safety Program. Journal of the American College of Surgeons227: 189–197.
34.
LingardLEspinSWhyteSRegehrGBakerGRReznickRBohnenJOrserBDoranDGroberE. (2004) Communication failures in the operating room: an observational classification of recurrent types and effects. Quality & Safety in Health Care13: 330–334.
35.
MeddingsJReichertHGreeneMTSafdarNKreinSLOlmsteadRNWatsonSREdsonBLesherMASaintS. (2017) Evaluation of the Association between Hospital Survey on Patient Safety Culture (HSOPS)Measures and Catheter-Associated Infections: Results of Two National Collaboratives. BMJ Quality & Safety26: 226–235.
36.
MoherDLiberatiATetzlaffJAltmanDG and The PRISMA Group. (2009) Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement. PLoS Med6: e1000097.
37.
MillerKBriodyCCaseyDKaneJKMitchellDPatelBRitterCSeckelMWakaiSDreesM. (2016) Using the Comprehensive Unit-based Safety Program model for sustained reduction in hospital infections. American Journal of Infection Control44: 969–976.
38.
PalomarMAlvarez-LermaFRieraADiazMTTorresFAgraYLarizgoitiaIGoeschelCAPronovostPJ and Bacteremia Zero Working Group. (2013) Impact of a national multimodal intervention to prevent catheter-related bloodstream infection in the ICU: the Spanish experience. Critical Care Medicine41: 2364–2372.
39.
PellegrinK. L.CurreyH. S. (2011) ‘Demystifying and improving organizational culture in health-care’, Adv Health Care Manag, 10, pp. 3–23.
40.
PHE. (2016) A point prevalence survey on levels of healthcare-associated infections (HAI) and levels of antimicrobial use in hospitals in England in 2016. London: Public Health England.
41.
PronovostP. (2008) Interventions to decrease catheter-related bloodstream infections in the ICU: the Keystone Intensive Care Unit Project. American Journal of Infection Control36: S171.e1–5.
42.
RaveisVHConwayLJUchidaMPogorzelska-MaziarzMLarsonELStonePW. (2014) Translating infection control guidelines into practice: implementation process within a health care institution. Quality Health Research24: 551–560.
43.
ReiterSStewardGBruceC. (2010) Integrating qualitative and quantitative approaches in cross-cultural research. Available at: http://eprints.qut.edu.au/41057/1/41057.pdf (accessed 26 February 2017).
44.
RobbinsJMcAlearneyAS. (2016) Encouraging employees to speak up to prevent infections: Opportunities to leverage quality improvement and care management processes. American Journal of Infection Control44: 1224–1230.
45.
RodziewiczTLHipskindJE. (2018) Medical Error Prevention. Treasure Island, FL: StatPearls Publishing.
46.
SacksGDShannonEMDawesAJRolloJCNguyenDKRussellMMKoCYMaggard-GibbonsMA. (2015) Teamwork, communication and safety climate: a systematic review of interventions to improve surgical culture. BMJ Quality & Safety24: 458–467.
47.
SalgeTVeraAAntonsDCimiottiJP. (2017) Fighting MRSA Infections in Hospital Care: How Organizational Factors Matter. Health Services Research52: 959–983.
48.
SeptimusEYokoeDSWeinsteinRAPerlTMMaragakisLLBerenholtzSM. (2014) Maintaining the momentum of change: the role of the 2014 updates to the compendium in preventing healthcare-associated infections. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology35: 460–463.
49.
Sinkowitz-CochranRLBurkittKHCuerdonTHarrisonCGaoSObroskyDSJainRFineMJJerniganJA. (2012) The associations between organizational culture and knowledge, attitudes, and practices in a multicenter Veterans Affairs quality improvement initiative to prevent methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus. American Journal of Infection Control40: 138–143.
50.
SohKLSohKGDavidsonP. (2013) The role of culture in quality improvement in the intensive care unit: a literature review. Journal of Hospital Administration2: 97–104.
51.
SoodGCaffreyJKroutKKhouri-StevensZGeroldKRiedelSMcIntyreJMaragakisLLBlandingRZenilmanJBennettRPronovostP. (2017). Use of implementation science for a sustained reduction of central-line-associated bloodstream infections in a high-volume, regional burn unit. Infection Control & Hospital Epidemiology38: 1306–1311.
52.
StonePWMooney-KaneCLarsonELHoranTGlanceLGZwanzigerJDickAW. (2007) Nurse working conditions and patient safety outcomes. Medical Care45: 571–578.
53.
SuG. (2016) A collaborative approach to reduce healthcare-associated infections. British Journal of Nursing25: 582–586.
54.
SullivanGM. (2011) Getting Off the “Gold Standard”: Randomized Controlled Trials and Education Research. Journal of Graduate Medical Education3: 285–289.
55.
ThomasLGallaC. (2013) Republished: Building a culture of safety through team training and engagement. Postgraduate Medical Journal89: 394–3401.
VigoritoMCMcNicollLAdamsLSextonB. (2011) Improving safety culture results in Rhode Island ICUs: lessons learned from the development of action-oriented plans. Joint Commission Journal on Quality and Patient Safety37: 509–514.
58.
WarrickDD. (2017) What leaders need to know about organization culture. Business Horizons60: 395–404.
59.
WeaverSJWeeksKPhamJCPronovostPJ. (2014) On the CUSP: Stop BSI: evaluating the relationship between central line-associated bloodstream infection rate and patient safety climate profile. American Journal of Infection Control42(Suppl. 10): S203–208.
60.
WeickKESutcliffeKM. (2003) Hospitals as cultures of entrapment: a re-analysis of the Bristol Royal Infirmary. California Management Review45: 73–84.
61.
WeinerB. (2009) A theory of organizational readiness for change. Implementation Science4: 67.
62.
ZinggWHolmesADettenkoferMGoettingTSecciFClackLAllegranziBMagiorakosAPPittetD and Systematic Review and Evidence-based Guidance on Organization of Hospital Infection Control Programmes (SIGHT) Study Group. (2015) Hospital organisation, management, and structure for prevention of health-care-associated infection: a systematic review and expert consensus. Lancet Infectious Diseases15: 212–224.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
