Impact parameters used to design the American football helmet and the parameters associated with mechanisms of concussive injury are not consistent. Head impacts resulting in concussive injury in football are characterized as events creating rotational motion of the head that generate brain tissue strain. The extent of tissue strain influences the resulting severity of injury. Helmet technology aimed to decrease brain tissue strain by reducing the extent of brain motion could help reduce injury risk. Current helmet performance and evaluation measures, such as peak resultant of linear and rotational acceleration, do not fully define directional brain motion and therefore cannot provide sufficient information for this type of improvement. This study was conducted to determine whether coordinate components (X, Y, and Z) of linear and rotational acceleration would correlate with maximum principal strain, a common measure of brain injury risk. Coordinate components define directional motion of the head and offer a specific design parameter more easily reduced using engineered structures than peak resultant acceleration. In addition to coordinate components, this study introduces the dominant component, defined as the coordinate component with the highest contribution to the resultant acceleration, for additional evaluation. The results show that the relationship between the X, Y, and Z coordinate components of acceleration and maximum principal strain is location- and direction-dependent. The study indicates a strong relationship between the peak resultant and dominant components of acceleration to maximum principal strain. Because the dominant component of acceleration accounts for direction and location, identifying the relationship between dominant acceleration and maximum principal strain demonstrates the potential use of this metric to improve future helmet innovation aimed at reducing tissue strain.
BailesJEHudsonV. Classification of sport-related head trauma: a spectrum of mild to severe injury. J Athl Training2001; 36(3): 236–243.
2.
McCreaMHammekeTOlsenG, et al. Unreported concussion in high school football players: implications for prevention. Clin J Sports Med2004; 14(1): 13–17.
3.
DumaSMManoogianSJBussoneWR. Analysis of real-time head accelerations in collegiate football players. Clin J Sports Med2005; 15(1): 3–8.
4.
CollinsCLComstockRDDickRW, et al. Concussions among United States high school and collegiate athletes. J Athl Training2007; 42(4): 495–503.
5.
HootmanJMDickRAgelJ. Epidemiology of collegiate injuries for 15 sports: summary and recommendations for injury prevention initiatives. J Athl Training2007; 42(2): 311–319.
6.
CriscoJJFioreRBeckwithJG, et al. Frequency and location of head impact exposures in individual collegiate football players. J Athl Training2010; 45(6): 549–559.
7.
CassonIRVianoDCPowellJW, et al. Twelve years of National Football League concussion data. Sports Health2010; 2(6): 471–483.
8.
BeckwithJGZhaoWJiS, et al. Estimated brain tissue response following impacts associated with and without diagnosed concussion. Ann Biomed Eng2018; 46(6): 819–830.
9.
JiSGhadyaniHBolanderRP, et al. Parametric comparisons of intracranial mechanical responses from three validated finite element models of the human head. Ann Biomed Eng2014; 42(1): 11–24.
10.
OmmayaAKGennarelliTA. Cerebral concussion and traumatic unconsciousness. Brain1974; 97: 633–654.
11.
PrangeMTMarguliesSS. Regional, directional, and age-dependent properties of the brain undergoing large deformation. J Biomed Eng2002; 124: 244–252.
12.
GilchristMD. Modeling and accident reconstruction of head impact injuries. Eng Mater2003; 245–245: 417–429.
13.
ZhangLYangKHKingAI. A proposed injury threshold for mild traumatic brain injury. J Biomed Eng2004; 126: 226–236.
14.
TakhountsEGRidellaSA. Investigation of traumatic brain injuries using the next generation of simulate injury monitor (SIMon) finite element head model. Stapp Car Crash J2008; 52: 1–31.
15.
MeaneyDFSmithDH. Biomechanics of concussion. Clin Sports Med2011; 30: 19–31.
16.
GennarelliTAThibaultLETomeiG. Directional dependence of axonal brain injury due to centroidal and non-centroidal acceleration. In: 31st Stapp car crash conference, New Orleans, LA, 9–11 November 1987, SAE paper no. 872197. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.
17.
KleivenS. Influence of impact direction on human head in prediction of subdural hematoma. J Neurotraum2003; 20(4): 365–379.
18.
PellmanEJVianoDVCassonIR, et al. Concussion in professional football: reconstruction of game impacts and injuries. Neurosurgery2003; 53: 799–814.
19.
HrapkoMvan DommelenJAPetersGW, et al. The influence of test conditions on characterization of the mechanical properties of brain tissue. J Biomech Eng2008; 130(3): 031003.
20.
GiordanoCClootsRJHvan DommelenJAW, et al. The influence of anisotropy on brain injury prediction. J Biomech2014; 47: 1052–1059.
21.
PostAOeurAHoshizakiB, et al. An examination of American football helmets using brain deformation metrics associated with concussion. Mater Design2013; 45: 653–662.
22.
GreenwaldRMGwinJTChuJJ, et al. Head Impact Severity Measures for Evaluating Mild Traumatic Brain Injury Risk Exposure. Neurosurgery2008; 62(4): 789–797.
23.
BroglioSPSosnoffJJShinSH, et al. Head impacts during high school football: a biomechanical assessment. J Athl Training2009; 44(4): 343–349.
24.
KerrZYCollinsCLMihalikJP, et al. Impact locations and concussion outcomes in high school football player-to-player collisions. Pediatrics2014; 134(3): 489–496.
25.
ClarkMDBretonMAMarshallSW, et al. Descriptive characteristics of concussion in National Football League games. Am J Sport Med2017; 45(4): 929–936.
26.
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment. Standard drop test method and equipment used in evaluating the performance characteristics of protective headgear: NOCSAE Standard 001-04m05, 2004, www.nocsae.org
27.
National Operating Committee on Standards for Athletic Equipment. Standard performance specification for newly manufactured football helmets: NOCSAE DOC (ND) 002-14, 2014, www.nocsae.org
28.
McIntoshASPattonDAFrechedeB, et al. The biomechanics of concussion in un-helmeted football players in Australia: a case-control study. Biomed J2014; 4: 1–9.
29.
McAllisterTWFordJCSongbaiJ, et al. Maximum principal strain and strain rate associated with concussion diagnosis correlates with changes in corpus callosum white matter indices. Ann Biomed Eng2012; 40(1): 127–140.
30.
ElkinBSGablerLFPanzarMB, et al. Brain tissue strains vary with head impact location: a possible explanation for increased concussion risk in struck versus striking football players. Clin Biomech2018; 64: 49–57.
31.
YoganandanNLiJZhangJ, et al. Influence of angular acceleration-deceleration pulse shapes on regional brain strains. J Biomech2008; 41: 2253–2262.
32.
VianoDCCassonIRPellmanEJ, et al. Concussion in professional football comparison with boxing head impacts. Neurosurgery2005; 57(6): 1154–1172.
33.
KleivenS. Predictors for traumatic brain injuries evaluated through accident reconstructions. Stapp Car Crash J2007; 51: 81–114.
34.
PostAHoshizakiTB. Rotational acceleration, brain tissue strain, and the relationship to concussion. J Biomech Eng2015; 137: 1–8.
35.
PostAOeurAHoshizakiTB, et al. The influence of centric and non-centric impacts to American football helmets on the correlation between commonly used metrics in brain injury research. In: International research council on biomechanics of injury conference (IRCOBI), Dublin, 12–14 September 2012. Zurich: IRCOBI.
36.
PostAOeurAHoshizakiTB. The influence of velocity on the performance range of American football helmets. In: Proceeding of the 1st international conference on helmet performance and design, London, 15 February 2013, HPD-2013-10. London: DEG Imperial College London.
37.
CournoyerJPost ARousseauP, et al. The ability of American football helmets to manage linear acceleration with repeated high-energy impacts. J Athl Training2016; 51(3): 258–263.
38.
NewmanJA. Biomechanics of human trauma: head protection. In: NahumAMMelvinJW (eds) Accidental injury biomechanics and prevention. New York: Springer-Verlag, 1993, pp.292–310.
39.
PellmanEJVianoDCWithnallC, et al. Concussion in professional football: helmet testing to assess impact performance—part 11. J Neurosurg2006; 58: 78–96.
40.
GharjariMPeldschusSGalvanettoU, et al. Evaluation of the effective mass of the body for helmets impacts. Int J Crashworthines2011; 16(6): 621–631.
41.
RousseauPHoshizakiTB. Defining the effective impact mass of elbow and shoulder strikes in ice hockey. Sport Biomech2015; 14: 57–67.
42.
BartschABenzelEMieleV, et al. Impact test comparisons of 20th and 21st century American football helmets. J Neurosurg2012; 116: 222–233.
43.
PostAWalshESHoshizakiTB, et al. Analysis of loading curve characteristics on the production of brain deformation metrics. Proc IMechE, Part P: J Sports Engineering and Technology2012; 226: 200–207.
44.
SchnebelBGwinJTAndersonS, et al. In vivo study of head impacts in football: a comparison of National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I versus High School impacts. Neurosurgery2007; 60: 490–496.
45.
VianoDCCassonIPellmanEJ. Concussion in professional football: biomechanics of the struck player—part 14. Neurosurgery2007; 16(2): 313–327.
46.
ASTM F1446-2013. Standard test methods for equipment and procedures used in evaluating the performance characteristics of protective headgear.
47.
WalshESKendallMPostA, et al. Comparative analysis of Hybrid III neckform and an unbiased neckform. Sport Eng2018; 21(4): 479–485.
48.
PadgaonkarAJKreigerKWKingAI. Measurements of angular accelerations of a rigid body using linear accelerometers. J Appl Mech1975; 42: 552–556.
49.
PellmanEJVianoDVTuckerAM, et al. Concussion in professional football: location and direction of helmet impacts—part 2. Neurosurgery2003; 53: 1328–1341.
50.
DoorlyMCGilchristMD. The use of accident reconstruction for the analysis of traumatic brain injury due to head impacts arising from falls. Comput Method Biomec2006; 9(6): 371–377.
51.
HorganTJGilchristMD. The creation of 3D finite element models for simulating head impact biomechanics. Int J Crashworthines2003; 8(4): 353–366.
52.
HorganTJ. A finite element model of the human head for use in the study of pedestrian accidents. PhD Thesis, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, University of College Dublin, Dublin, February2005.
53.
NahumAMSmithRWardCC. Intracranial pressure dynamics during head impact. In: 21st annual Stapp car crash conference, New Orleans, LA, 16–21 October 1977. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.
54.
TrosseilleXTarriéreCLavasteF, et al. Development of a FEM of the human head according to a specific test protocol. In: 36th Stapp car crash conference, Seattle WA, 2–4 November 1992, SAE paper 922527. Warrendale, PA: Society of Automotive Engineers.
55.
HardyWNFosterCDMasonMJ, et al. Investigation of head injury mechanisms using neutral density technology and high-speed biplanar X-ray. Stapp Car Crash J2001; 45: 337–368.
56.
WeaverAADanelsonKAStitzelJD. Modeling brain injury response for rotational velocities of varying directions and magnitudes. J Biomed Eng2012; 40(9): 2005–2018.
57.
WalshESRousseauPHoshizakiTB. The influence of impact location and angle on the dynamic impact response of a hybrid III headform. Sport Eng2011; 13: 135–143.
58.
LiaoSLynallRCMihalikJP. The effect of head impact location on day of diagnosed concussion in college football. Med Sci Sport Exer2016; 48(7): 1239–1243.
59.
KrzeminskiDEFernandoBMDCurtzwilerG, et al. Repetitive impact exposure and characterization of stress-whitening of an American football helmet outer shell material. Polym Test2016; 55: 190–203.
60.
PostAOeurAWalshE, et al. A centric/non-centric impact protocol and finite element model methodology for the evaluation of American football helmets to evaluate risk of concussion. Comput Method Biomec2014; 17: 1785–1800.
61.
OeurRAKartonCPostA, et al. A comparison of head dynamic response and brain tissue stress and strain using accident reconstruction for concussion, concussion with persistent postconcussive symptoms and subdural hematoma. J Neurosurg2015; 123: 415–422.
