Mnemonic wars and parallel polis: The anti-politics of memory in Central and Southeast Europe: Kosovar women and Black/Roma Lives Matter

Abstract

The essay argues that anti-politics, a category borrowed from the anti-communist movement in the Eastern Bloc, can inspire memory studies. We focus on one of the chosen categories – the parallel polis (with some forays into the matter of the nonviolence movement). We discuss this universal category through the particular lens of Central and Southeast Europe with two examples: (1) women’s memories of war and violence in Kosovo with a specific focus on the Heroinat monument in Pristina and (2) the Black Lives Matter movement in Czechia that can be used to highlight the racially and ethnically motivated activities of the police, as well as oblivion of the Holocaust of the Roma community in mainstream discourse. It all leads to the identification of parallel orders of memory produced by marginalized groups, as well as the development of anti-politics of memory in opposition to the official, state-driven politics of memory.

Keywords

anti-politics of memory Black Lives Matter Kosovar Women nonviolence movement parallel polis Roma Lives Matter

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Albert

(2019) Nucené sterilizace jako projev anticikanismu: Příklad Československa a České/Slovenské republiky [Forced sterilization as sntigypsyism: The Czechoslovak / Czech and Slovak examples]. Romano džaniben časopis romistických studií 26(2): 21–41.

Beliveau

(2020) The public secret and private pain of wartime sexual violence: comparing the Heroinat memorial and the 2020 newborn monument from the perspective of NGOs in Kosovo. Independent Study Project Collection 3270. Available at: https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection/3270 (accessed 18 August 2022)

Benda

(1990) Paralelní polis [Parallel polis]. In: Prečan

(ed.) Charta 77. 1977-1989. Od morální k demokratické revoluci [From Moral to Democratic Revolution]. Scheinfeld-Schwarzenberg: Československé středisko nezávislé literatury, pp. 43–51.

Billig

(1995) Banal Nationalism. London: Sage.

Birkner

Donk

(2020) Collective memory and social media: fostering a new historical consciousness in the digital age? Memory Studies 13(4): 367–383.

Česká tisková kancelář (2019) Czech Govt report on the state of the Romani minority estimates 830 ghettos with 127 000 inhabitants in the regions. Available at: http://www.romea.cz/en/news/czech/czech-govt-report-on-the-state-of-the-romani-minority-estimates-830-ghettos-with-127-000-inhabitants-in-the-regions (accessed 30 May 2022).

Česká televize Еdu (2022) Holocaust Romů: Téma, které stále rozděluje českou společnost [The Holocaust of the Roma: A topic that still divides Czech society]. Available at: https://edu.ceskatelevize.cz/kolekce/holocaust-romu (accessed 20 March 2022).

Česká tisková kancelář Ryšavý

(2022) President of Czech Senate says Lety commemorations are a call for people to treat minorities fairly. Available at: http://www.romea.cz/en/news/czech/president-of-czech-senate-says-lety-commemorations-are-a-call-for-people-to-treat-minorities-fairly#.YnjUYgGXFOE.twitter (accessed 30 May 2022).

Chao

(2020) Women’s activism in the civil resistance movement in Kosovo (1989–1997): characteristics, development, encounters. Nationalities Papers 48(5): 843–860.

10.

Chappell

(2021) ‘There has always been a Black women’s peace movement’: Women of colour and anti-war activism in the U.S., 1968-1972. In: Women’s History Network. Available at: https://womenshistorynetwork.org/there-has-always-been-a-black-womens-peace-movement-by-frankie-chappell (accessed 7 June 2022).

11.

Clark

(2013) Kosovo: civil resistance in defense of the nation, 1990s. In: Bartkowski

(ed.) Recovering Nonviolent History, Civil Resistance in Liberation Struggles. Boulder CO: Lynne Rienner Publishers, pp. 279–296.

12.

Council of Europe (2022) Czech Republic – recognition of the Roma genocide. Available at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/roma-genocide/virtual-library/-/asset_publisher/M35KN9VVoZTe/content/cyprus-recognition-of-the-genocide?inheritRedirect=false (accessed 20 March 2022).

13.

De Sousa Santos

(2007) Another Knowledge Is Possible. Beyond Northern Epistemologies. London: Verso.

14.

Di Lellio

Schwandner-Sievers

(2006) The legendary commander: the construction of an Albanian master-narrative in post-war Kosovo. Nations and Nationalism 12(3): 513–529.

15.

Donert

(2018) Anti-Roma stigma of Czech president Miloš Zeman threatens progress over Romani rights. The Conversation, 24 January. Available at: https://theconversation.com/anti-roma-stigma-of-czech-president-milos-zeman-threatens-progress-over-romani-rights-88437 (accessed 20 March 2022)

16.

Gashi

(2022) ‘The Other Serbia’ Srdja Popovic. Available at: https://sbunker.net/teh/91527/the-other-serbia-srdja-popovi/ (accessed 7 June 2022).

17.

Gordeeva

(2019) The religious roots of the pacifist movement in the Russian empire and the USSR in the 20th century. Religiski-filozofiski raksti 25(1): 242–263.

18.

Gruda

(2004) Some key principles for a lasting solution of the status of Kosova: uti possidetis, the ethnic principle, and self-determination. Chicago-Kent Law Review 80: 353–394.

19.

Grzechnik

(2019) The missing second world: on Poland and postcolonial studies. International Journal of Postcolonial Studies 27(7): 998–1014.

20.

Gutman

Wüstenberg

(2021) Challenging the meaning of the past from below: a typology for comparative research on memory activists. Memory Studies, 15, 1070–1086.

21.

Hasani

(2022) For peace today, let’s recall wartime Yugoslav feminist solidarity. Balkan Insight, 13 April. Available at: https://balkaninsight.com/2022/04/13/for-peace-today-lets-recall-wartime-yugoslav-feminist-solidarity/ (accessed 7 June 2022).

22.

Havelka

(1998) ‘Nepolitická politika’: kontexty a tradice [‘Non-political politics’: contexts and traditions]. Sociologický časopis/Czech Sociological Review 24(4): 455–466.

23.

Helms

(2013) Innocence and Victimhood: Gender, Nation, and Women's Activism in Postwar Bosnia-Herzegovina. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.

24.

Hrušková

Somr

(2012) Apolitical politics and political reality (Masaryk‘s humanity of historical moment). Studia Edukacyjne 21: 19–29.

25.

Ingimundarson

(2003) The politics of memory and the reconstruction of Albanian national identity in postwar Kosovo. History & Memory 19(1): 95–123.

26.

Kenety

(2005) The ‘devouring’: a look at the Romani holocaust. Available at: https://romove.radio.cz/en/clanek/20320 (accessed 20 March 2022).

27.

Kola

(2017) The politics of the archive in semi-peripheries. In: Heise

Andrew

Beecroft

, et al. (eds) Futures of Comparative Literature. ACLA State of the Discipline Report. London: Routledge, pp. 51–60.

28.

Kola

(2018) Socjalistyczny postkolonializm. Rekonsolidacja pamięci [ Socialist Postcolonialism. Memory Reconsolidation ]. Toruń: Nicolaus Copernicus University Press.

29.

Krasniqi

(2021) Same goal, different paths, different class: women’s feminist political engagements in Kosovo from the mid-1970s until the mid-1990s. Comparative Southeast European Studies 69(2–3): 313–334.

30.

Krasniqi

Sokolić

Kostovicova

(2020) Skirts as flags: transitional justice, gender and everyday nationalism in Kosovo. Nations and Nationalism 26: 461–476.

31.

Kubik

Bernhard

(2014) A theory of the politics of memory. In: Bernhard

Kubik

(eds) Twenty Years after Communism. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 7–34.

32.

Kundra

(2016) Babiš zpochybnil holocaust v Letech [Babiš questioned the Holocaust in Lety]. Respekt. Available at: https://www.respekt.cz/politika/babis-zpochybnil-holocaust-v-letech (accessed 20 March 2022).

33.

Kwadrans

(2014) Polityka wobec Romów na obszarze Czech i Słowacji po II wojnie światowej [Policies towards Roma in the Czech and Slovak lands after World War II] . Przegląd Narodowościowy/Review of Nationalities 3: 43–79.

34.

Liebermann

(2021) Born digital: the Black Lives Matter movement and memory after the digital turn. Memory Studies 14(4): 713–732.

35.

Luci

Gusia

(2019) Inside-out and outside-in on dealing with the past in Kosovo. In: Visoka

Musliu

(eds) Unravelling Liberal Interventionism. New York: Routledge, pp. 132–147.

36.

Málek

(2021) Romové uctili v Teplicích památku ‘českého Floyda’, část se pak vydala do města [Romani people honored the memory of 'Czech Floyd' in Teplice, some went to the town]. Available at: https://teplicky.denik.cz/zpravy_region/foto-romove-uctili-pamatku-muze-zemreleho-po-zakroku-policie-20210626.html (accessed 23 February 2022).

37.

Masaryk

(1895) Česká otázka. Snahy a tužby národního obrození [ Czech Question. Efforts and Aspirations of the National Revival ]. Praha: Čas.

38.

Minić

(2000) Ratovi na Kosova, 1998-1999, i v Čečeniji, 1994-1996 [ Wars in Kosovo, 1998-1999, and in Chechnya, 1994-1996 ]. Sarajevo: Rabic.

39.

Moyzes

(2021) RKP – Otče národa, zklamali jsme Stanislava Tomáše! [ RKP - Father of the Nation, we have failed Stanislav Tomáš! ] [Video]. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIAlStoBM1M&ab_channel=TamaraMoyzes (accessed 23 February 2022).

40.

Nelson

(1959) The tradition of non-violence and its underlying forces. Faculty Reprints 159: 121–136 [reprinted from the Journal of the Religious Thought, summer-autumn 1959]. Available at: https://dh.howard.edu/reprints/159/ (accessed 20 May 2022)

41.

O’Byrne

(2019) When war meets art: Doris Salcedo on representing violence without violence. Irish Examiner, 2 May. Available at: https://www.irishexaminer.com/lifestyle/arid-30921685.html (accessed 7 June 2022)

42.

Ost

(1990) Solidarity and the Politics of Anti-politics: Reform and Opposition in Poland since 1968. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.

43.

Pető

(2021a) The missing war memorials to the victims of rape during the World War II in Europe. In: Schafhausen

Zadoff

(eds) Tell Me about Yesterday Tomorrow. Munich: NS-Dokumentationszentrum, pp. 112–119.

44.

Pető

(2021b) The new monument of victims of military sexual violence in Budapest. Hungarian Studies Review 48(2): 209–216.

45.

Přibyl

Sedlářová

(2021) My jsme lidi! Stovky lidí v Teplicích vzpomínaly na zesnulého Roma [We are human! Hundreds of people in Teplice remembered the murdered Roma]. Available at: https://www.idnes.cz/usti/zpravy/pieta-protest-teplice-smrt.A210626_122136_usti-zpravy_bse (accessed 23 February 2022).

46.

Romane KALE Panthera/Roma Black Panthers (2021) Romane KALE Panthera/Roma Black Panthers [Facebook]. 25 July. Available at: https://www.facebook.com/Romane-KALE-Panthera-Roma-Black-Panthers-1583574075261127 (accessed 23 February 2022).

47.

Romea

(2021) Přímý přenos demosntrace: na romských životech záleží [ Live broadcast of the demonstration: Roma lives matter ]/ Roma lives matter [Video]. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJ_DM6xWLBc&t=1483s (accessed 23 February 2022)

48.

Ryšavý

(2021) Na demonstraci Roma Lives Matter bylo zveřejněno svědectví, podle kterého byl Stanislav Tomáš nakládán na nosítka zcela bezvládný [At a Roma Lives Matter demonstration, testimony was released that Stanislav Tomáš was loaded onto a stretcher completely unconscious] . Available at: http://www.romea.cz/cz/zpravodajstvi/domaci/zaznam-a-fotogalerie-na-demonstraci-roma-lives-matter-bylo-zverejneno-svedectvi-podle-ktereho-byl-stanislav-tomas-nakladan (accessed 23 February 2022).

49.

Ryšavý

Bikár

(2021) Na shromáždění proti rasismu v Ústí nad Labem přišlo asi 200 lidí. Představila se na něm nová romská politická strana Roma Luma [About 200 people came to the rally against racism in Ústí nad Labem. The new Roma political party Roma Luma presented itself there]. Available at: http://www.romea.cz/cz/zpravodajstvi/domaci/primy-prenos-shromazdeni-proti-rasismu-a-diskriminaci-v-usti-nad-labem (accessed 23 February 2022).

50.

Sbrissa

(2015) The Circle of Silence: Wartime Sexual Violence against Men. A Case Study of Bosnia and Herzegovina. Master’s Thesis, University of Sarajevo/University of Bologna. Available at: https://repository.gchumanrights.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11825/50/Sbrissa_Thesis.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y (accessed 20 November 2021).

51.

Schwandner-Sievers

(2013) The bequest of Ilegalja: contested memories and moralities in contemporary Kosovo. -Nationalities Papers 41(6): 953–970.

52.

Sindbæk

(2012) Usable History? Representations of Yugoslavia’s Difficult past from 1945 to 2002. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press.

53.

Sniegoň

(2015) Evropeizace holocaustu a česká národní identita [Europeanisation of the Holocaust and Czech national identity]. In: Šustrová

Hédlová

(eds) Česká paměť: národ, dějiny a místa paměti [ Czech Memory: Nation, History and Places of Memory ]. Praha: Academia, pp. 81–109.

54.

Święch

(2017) Václav Havel i koncepcja niepolitycznej polityki [Václav Havel and the concept of non-political politics]. Doctrina. Studia społeczno-polityczne 14: 271–301.

55.

Young

(1992) The counter-monument: Memory against itself in Germany Today. Critical Inquiry 18(2): 267–296.