Memory politics in the future tense: Exceptionalism,race,and insurrection in America

Abstract

The grounding myth of American collective memory is built on the idea of America as a promise, what it shall be. Crises place futures in doubt. Against these two considerations, this article examines how the future can be used to shape the past. In the American context, the future as a general promise is invoked in times of crisis to reassure a nation by way of laundering difficult pasts so as to fit a narrative of progress in spite of the continued presence and recursive nature of these pasts. In the immediate wake of the 2021 Capitol Insurrection, another crisis (itself a harbinger of crises to come), the 2000 Bush v Gore decision, was rewritten as an exemplar of American exceptionalism rather than a stain on it. Beyond displaying the intricate relationship between future and past in collective memory, the case highlights how this operation only works to further neglect the racism and unresolved pasts entrenched in the myth of exceptionalism that motivated the Capitol Riot.

Keywords

American exceptionalism 2021 Capitol Riot crisis futures

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

(2011) Du Boisian critique of American exceptionalism and its limitations: from The Souls of Black Folk (1903) to Dusk of Dawn (1940). English Literature and Language 57(3): 391–411.

Beck

(1992) Risk Society. London: SAGE.

Biskupic

(2020) Supreme Court is about to have 3 Bush v Gore alumni sitting on the bench. CNN, 17 October. Available at: https://www.cnn.com/2020/10/17/politics/bush-v-gore-barrett-kavanaugh-roberts-supreme-court/index.html (accessed 26 April 2021).

Bond

Craps

Vermeulen

(2016) Memory Unbound: Tracing the Dynamics of Memory Studies. New York: Berghahn Books.

Byers

(2001) A city upon a hill: American literature and the ideology of exceptionalism. In: Carter

(ed.) Marks of Distinction: American Exceptionalism Revisited. Aarhus: Aarhus University Press, pp. 45–68.

Calhoun

(2008) Chicagoans: reports misrepresent Obama’s Church. NPR, 19 March. Available at: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=88552254 (accessed 26 April 2021).

Calhoun

(2011) The Sand Creek massacre national historic site: challenge to and reification of American exceptionalism. In: Edwards

Weiss

(eds) The Rhetoric of American Exceptionalism. Jefferson, NC: McFarland & Company, pp. 153–170.

Cole

(2006) The liberal legacy of Bush v Gore. The Georgetown Law Journal 94: 1427–1474.

Congressional Record (2021a) Proceedings and debates of the 117th congress, first session 167(4), 6 January. Washington, DC: United States Government Publishing Office.

10.

Congressional Record (2021b) Proceedings and debates of the 117th congress, first session 167(50), 17 March. Washington, DC: United States Government Publishing Office.

11.

Craps

(2017) Climate change and the art of anticipatory memory. Parallax 23(4): 479–492.

12.

Dershowitz

(2001) Curious fallout from Bush v Gore. The New York Times, 4 July, A15.

13.

Dewan

Baker

(2021) In Georgia race, raising “uncomfortable” truths. The New York Times, 2 January, A1.

14.

Fong

(2015) American Exceptionalism and the Remains of Race: Multicultural Exorcisms. New York: Routledge.

15.

Forsythe

McMahon

(eds) (2017) American Exceptionalism Reconsidered: US Foreign Policy, Human Rights, and World Order. New York: Routledge.

16.

Gilmore

(2015) Translating American exceptionalism: comparing presidential discourse about the United States at home and abroad. International Journal of Communication 8: 2416–2437.

17.

Gilmore

Sheets

Rowling

(2016) Make no exception, save on: American exceptionalism and its culmination in the age of Obama. Communication Monographs 83(4): 505–520.

18.

Glaude

Jr (2016) Democracy in Black: How Race Still Enslaves the American Soul. New York: Crown Publishers.

19.

Gore

(1998) Speech delivered by Vice President Al Gore at Ebenezer Baptist Church, Atlanta, 19 January. Available at: https://clintonwhitehouse2.archives.gov/WH/EOP/OVP/speeches/mlktrans.html (accessed 26 April 2021).

20.

Gorman

(2021) The Hill We Climb. New York: Viking Books.

21.

Greenhouse

(2001) Bush v Gore: a special report. The New York Times, 20 February, A1.

22.

Greenhouse

(2020) Could it be Bush v Gore all over again? The New York Times, 30 August, SR9.

23.

Grusin

(2010) Premediation: Affect and Mediality after 9/11. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

24.

Gunter

Kizzire

Kent

(2016) Whose heritage? Public symbols of the confederacy. Report for the Southern Poverty Law Center. Available at: https://www.splcenter.org/20190201/whose-heritage-public-symbols-confederacy (accessed 24 October 2021).

25.

Gutman

Brown

Sodaro

(2010) Memory and the Future: Transnational Politics, Ethics and Society. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

26.

Hartog

(2015) Regimes of Historicity: Presentism and Experiences of Time. New York: Columbia University Press.

27.

Hasen

(2020) Twenty years after Bush v Gore, America has learned the key wrong lesson. Election Law Blog, 12 December. Available at: https://electionlawblog.org/?p=119586 (accessed 26 April 2021).

28.

Hixson

(2008) The Myth of American Diplomacy: National Identity and U.S. Foreign Policy. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

29.

Hodgson

(2009) The Myth of American Exceptionalism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

30.

Hoffmann

(2005) American exceptionalism: the new version. In: Ignatieff

(ed.) American Exceptionalism and Human Rights. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp. 225–240.

31.

Hong

Szpunar

(2019) The futures of anticipatory reason: contingency and speculation in the sting operation. Security Dialogue 50(4): 314–330.

32.

Howard

(2017) Unusually Cruel: Prisons, Punishment, and the Real American Exceptionalism. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

33.

Ivie

Giner

(2009) American exceptionalism in a democratic idiom: transacting the mythos of change in the 2008 presidential campaign. Communication Studies 60(4): 359–375.

34.

Jackson

(2021) Making #BlackLivesMatter in the shadow of Selma: collective memory and racial justice activism in US news. Communication, Culture & Critique 14: 385–404.

35.

Lewis

(2002) Two responses to American exceptionalism: W.E.B. Du Bois and martin Luther King, Jr. Black Renaissance 4(2): 9–28.

36.

Lipset

(1996) American Exceptionalism: A Double-Edged Sword. New York: W. W. Norton.

37.

McCrisken

(2003) American Exceptionalism and the Legacy of Vietnam: US Foreign Policy since 1974. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.

38.

MacDougall

(2020) Why Bush v Gore still matters. ProPublica, 1 November. Available at: https://www.propublica.org/article/why-bush-v-gore-still-matters (accessed 26 April 2021).

39.

Madsen

(1998) American Exceptionalism. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

40.

Margolick

(2004) The path to Florida. Vanity Fair, October. Available at: https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2004/10/florida-election-2000

41.

Massumi

(2015) Ontopower: War, Powers, and the State of Perception. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.

42.

Mulroy

(2020) Trump’s Pennsylvania lawsuits invoke Bush v Gore—but the Supreme Court probably won’t decide the 2020 election. The Conversation, 5 November. Available at: https://theconversation.com/trumps-pennsylvania-lawsuits-invoke-bush-v-gore-but-the-supreme-court-probably-wont-decide-the-2020-election-149538 (accessed 26 April 2021).

43.

Mutz

(2018) Status threat, not economic hardship, explains the 2016 presidential vote. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 115(19): E4330–E4339.

44.

Nora

(1989) Between memory and history: Les lieux de memoire. Representations 26: 7–25.

45.

Obama

(2008) A more perfect union. NPR, 18 March. Available at: https://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=88478467 (accessed 26 April 2021).

46.

Pease

(2009) The New American Exceptionalism. Minneapolis, MN: Minnesota University Press.

47.

Polletta

Marseca

(2021) Claiming Martin Luther King, Jr. for the right: the Martin Luther King Day holiday in the Reagan era. Memory Studies. Epub ahead of print 27 February. DOI: 10.1177/1750698021995932.

48.

Restad

(2015) American Exceptionalism: An Idea That Made a Nation and Remade the World. New York: Routledge.

49.

Restad

(2019) Whither the “city upon a hill”? Donald Trump, America First, and American exceptionalism. Texas National Security Review 3(1): 62–93.

50.

Rodgers

(2018) As a City on a Hill: The Story of America’s Most Famous Lay Sermon. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

51.

Rose

(2008) Antonin Scalia. Charlie Rose, 20 June. Available at: https://charlierose.com/videos/15555 (accessed 26 April 2021).

52.

Rosen

(2000) Disgrace: the Supreme Court commits suicide. The New Republic, 24 December. Available at: https://newrepublic.com/article/70674/disgrace (accessed 26 April 2021).

53.

Saito

(2010) Meeting the Enemy: American Exceptionalism and International Law. New York: New York University Press.

54.

Sellnow

Seeger

(2013) Theorizing Crisis Communication. Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

55.

Smith

(2010) From the shining city on a hill to a great metropolis on a plain? American stories of immigration and peoplehood. Social Research: An International Quarterly 77: 21–44.

56.

Squires

(2014) The Post-Racial Mystique: Media and Race in the Twenty-First Century. New York: New York University Press.

57.

Szpunar

(2016) Collective future thinking: concept, function, and implications for collective memory studies. Memory Studies 9(4): 376–389.

58.

The Chronicle of Higher Education (2001) What we’ll remember in 2050: 9 views on Bush v Gore. The Chronicle of Higher Education, 5 January. Available at: https://www.chronicle.com/article/what-well-remember-in-2050-9-views-on-bush-v-gore/ (accessed 26 April 2021).

59.

Van Engen

(2020) City on a Hill: A History of American Exceptionalism. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

60.

Van Prooijen

J-W

Douglas

(2017) Conspiracy theories as part of history: the role of societal crisis situations. Memory Studies 10(3): 323–333.

61.

Waldman

(2021) Georgia’s voter suppression law. Brennan Center for Justice, 31 March. Available at: https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/georgias-voter-suppression-law (accessed 26 April 2021).

62.

Walton

(2020) Raphael Warnock’s Georgia critics don’t understand Black churches. Washington Post, 30 December. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2020/12/30/warnock-georgia-senate-runoff-black-church/ (accessed 24 October 2021).

63.

Warnock

(2018) Transcript of remarks by Rev. Dr. Raphael D. Warnock at the Cathedral of Mary Our Queen. Catholic Review, 19 April. Available at: https://catholicreview.org/transcript-of-remarks-of-rev-dr-raphael-d-warnock-at-the-cathedral-of-mary-our-queen/ (accessed 26 April 2021).

64.

Warnock

(2021) Live: reverence Warnock addresses supporters on election night. YouTube, 6 January. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilef-Wa3NvM&t=2s (accessed 26 April 2021).

65.

Waymer

Heath

(2016) Black voter dilution, American exceptionalism, and racial gerrymandering: the paradox of the positive in political public relations. Journal of Black Studies 47(7): 635–658.

66.

Wertsch

(2009) Collective memory. In: Boyer

Wertsch

(eds) Memory in Mind and Culture. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 117–137.

67.

West

Sanders

Hochman

(2020) Bush v Gore and why it matters in 2020. NPR, 5 November. Available at: https://www.npr.org/2020/11/03/930833448/bush-v-gore-and-why-it-matters-in-2020 (accessed 26 April 2021).

68.

Williams

(2020) Blasting reproach and all-pervading light: Frederick Douglass’s aspirational American exceptionalism. American Political Thought 9: 369–395.

69.

Zelizer

(1995) Reading the past against the grain: the shape of memory studies. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 12: 214–239.