Contemporary issues in law and ethics: Exploring the family veto for organ donation

Abstract

This article explores current issues surrounding the impact of family veto for organ donation in the UK. A critical, reflective analysis of the theoretical, legal and ethical aspects aims to evaluate how the deceased’s explicit wish to donate may be revoked. Under current UK legislation and upon death, money and property are protected; however, the body is not. When investigating personal wishes, interests and decisions must be weighed against the moral legitimacy of the family veto.

Keywords

Law and ethics / Family veto / Organ donation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Academy of Royal Medical Colleges/UK Donation Ethics Committee 2016 Involving the family in deceased organ donation Available from: http://www.aomrc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Involving_family_deceased_organ_donation_0416-2.pdf (accessed 25 December 2016)

Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain & Ireland 2005 Management of Anaesthesia for Jehovah’s Witnesses 2nd ed London, AAGBI

Barber

Baker

(2018) Briefing Paper CBP 8236 21 February 2018 The Organ Donation (Deemed Consent) Bill 2017-19 Available from: https://researchbriefings.parliament.uk/ResearchBriefing/Summary/CBP-8236 (accessed 1 April 2018).

Beauchamp

Childress

2001 Principles of Biomedical Ethics 5th ed Oxford, Oxford University Press

Bell

2004

Is post mortem practice in terminal decline and should we care?

Practical Neurology 4 257–259

Bird

Harris

2010

Time to move to presumed consent for organ donation

BMJ: British Medical Journal 340 (7754) 1010–1012

Boillat

2016 Human rights and biomedicine: Ethical and legal aspects of organ donation International Conference Concluding remarks Available from: https://rm.coe.int/CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/DisplayDCTMContent?documentId=090000168064839b (accessed 20 November 2016)

Buchanan

2009 Justice & Healthcare, Selected Essays Oxford, Oxford University Press

Buggins E 2008 The potential impact of an opt out system for organ donation in the UK. An independent report from the Organ Donation Taskforce Available from: https://nhsbtdbe.blob.core.windows.net/umbraco-assets-corp/4250/thepotentialimpactofanoptoutsystemfororgandonationintheuk.pdf

10.

Champney

2016

The business of bodies: Ethical perspectives on for-profit body donation companies

Clinical Anatomy 29: 25–29

11.

Chester v Afshar 2004 3 WLR 927 Available from: http://www.e-lawresources.co.uk/Chester-v-Afshar.php

12.

Cronin

Douglas

2010

Directed and conditional deceased donor organ donations: Laws and misconceptions

Medical Law Review 2010 18 (3): 275–301

13.

Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Dignity of the Human Being with regard to the application of biology and medicine: Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine Available from: https://rm.coe.int/CoERMPublicCommonSearchServices/DisplayDCTMContent?documentId=090000168007cf98 (1997, accessed 11 December 2016)

14.

Cowling

2010 The Good Funeral Guide London, The Continuum Publishing Group

15.

Department for Constitutional Affairs (DCA) Mental Capacity Act Code of Practice 2007 Available from: www.dca.gov.uk/menincap/legis.htm#codeofpractice (accessed 1 January 2017)

16.

Department of Health 2009 Legal Issues Relevant to Non-heartbeating Donation London, DOH

17.

Department of Health and Social Care 2008 Fifty Per Cent increase in organ donation possible within five years Available from: https://www.wired-gov.net/wg/wg-news-1.nsf/print/Fifty+Per+Cent+increase+in+organ+donation+possible+within+five+years+16012008102600 (accessed 13 July 2018)

18.

Dewar

Boddington

2004

Returning to the Alder Hey report and its reporting: Addressing confusions and improving inquiries

Journal of Medical Ethics 30 463–469

19.

Douville

Godin

Vezina-Im

L A

2014

Organ and tissue donation in clinical settings: A systematic review of the impact of interventions aimed at health professionals

Transplant Research 2014 3 8

20.

Emson

2003

It is immoral to require consent for cadaver organ donation

Journal of Medical Ethics 2003 29 125–127

21.

English

Sommerville

2003

Presumed consent for transplantation: A dead issue after Alder Hey?

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 147–152

22.

Erin

Harris

2003

An ethical market in human organs

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 137–138

23.

European Convention on Human Rights ECHR 1950 Available from: http://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Convention_ENG.pdf (accessed 21 November 2016)

24.

Fabre

2014

A presumed consent for organ donation: A clinically unnecessary and corrupting influence in medicine and politics

Clinical Medicine 14(6) 567–571

25.

Farsides

2012

Respecting wishes and avoiding conflict: Understanding the ethical basis for organ donation and retrieval

British Journal of Anaesthesia 108 (suppl 1) i73–i79

26.

Foster

2014

Dignity and the use of body parts

Journal of Medical Ethics 40 44–47

27.

General Medical Council 2010 Treatment and Care Towards the End Of Life: Good Practice in Decision Making London, GMC

28.

Ghorbani

Khoddami-Vishteh

Ghobadi

Shafaghi

Louyeh

Najafizadeh

2011

Causes of family refusal for organ donation

Transplantation Proceedings 43 (2) 405–406

29.

Gillick v West Norfolk & Wisbech Area Health Authority 1986 AC 112 Available from: http://www.e-lawresources.co.uk/cases/Gillick-v-West-Norfolk.php

30.

Glannon

2003

Do the sick have a right to cadaveric organs?

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 153–156

31.

Hamer

Rivlin

2003

A stronger policy of organ retrieval from cadaveric donors: Some ethical considerations

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 196–200

32.

Harper

2013 Applying behavioural insights to organ donation Available from: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/267100/Applying_Behavioural_Insights_to_Organ_Donation.pdf (accessed 2 January 2016)

33.

Harpwood

2016

Law and ethics in medicine

Medicine 44 (10) 619–622

34.

Harris

2003

Organ procurement: Dead interests, living needs

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 130–134

35.

Harrop-Griffiths W 2015 Chapter 8: ‘Organ Donation and the Anaesthetist’. In: Harrop-Griffiths

Griffiths

Plaat

(Eds) AAGBI Core Topics in Anaesthesia West Sussex, John Wiley & Sons

36.

Hulme

Allen

Manara

Murphy

Gardiner

Poppitt

2016

Factors influencing the family consent rate for organ donation in the UK

Anaesthesia 71(9) 1053–1063

37.

Human Tissue Authority (HTA) 2004a Human Tissue Act 2004 Available from: www.hta.gov.uk/policies/human-tissue-act-2004 (accessed 11 December 2016)

38.

Human Tissue Authority 2004b Human Tissue (Scotland) Act Available from: www.hta.gov.uk/sites/default/files/Information_about_HT_(Scotland)_Act.pdf (accessed 11 December 2016)

39.

Human Tissue Authority 2010 Policy on consent for post-mortem examination and tissue retention under the Human Tissue Act 2004 Available from: www.hta.gov.uk/policies/policy-consent-post-mortem-examination-and-tissue-retention-under-human-tissue-act-2004 (accessed 28 October 2016)

40.

Human Tissue Authority 2016 Donating your body Available from: www.hta.gov.uk/donating-your-body (accessed 11 December 2016)

41.

Human Transplantation (Wales) Act 2013 anaw 5 Available from: www.legislation.gov.uk/anaw/2013/5/pdfs/anaw_20130005_en.pdf (accessed 4 November 2016)

42.

In JS and M and F 2016 EWHC 2859 Fam Available from: https://www.judiciary.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/js-judgment-20161118.pdf

43.

In re S (Adult Patient: Sterilisation) 2001 Fam 15 Available from: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1991/1.html

44.

Jackson

2013 Medical law, Text, Cases and Materials 3rd ed Oxford, Oxford University Press

45.

Jacoby

Jaccard

2010

Perceived support among families deciding about organ donation for their loved ones: Donor vs non-donor next of kin

American Journal of Critical Care 19 (5) e52–e61

46.

Kant

1785 Groundwork of the Metaphysic of Morals in Patton HJ 1948 The Moral Law Oxfordshire, Routledge

47.

Kennedy

2001 The Report of the Public Inquiry into children’s heart surgery at the Bristol Royal Infirmary 1984–1995 Learning from Bristol Available from: http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20090811143745/http:/www.bristol-inquiry.org.uk/final_report/the_report.pdf (accessed 12 November 2016)

48.

Kious

2015

Respect for autonomy: Deciding what is good for oneself

Journal of Medical Ethics 42 (12) 769–775

49.

McCorristine

2015

The dark value of criminal bodies: Context, consent, and the disturbing sale of John Parker’s Skull

Journal of Conservation and Museum Studies 13 (1) part 2 Available from: www.jcms-journal.com/articles/10.5334/jcms.1021220/(accessed 8 January 2017)

50.

McHanwell

Brenner

Chirculescu

ARM

Drukker

van Mameren

Mazzotti

Pais

, et al 2008

The legal and ethical framework governing body donation in Europe: A review of current practice and recommendations for good practice

European Journal of Anatomy 12 (1) 1–24

51.

Macklin

2003

Applying the four principles

Journal of Medical Ethics 29 275–280

52.

Maclean

(2009) Autonomy, Informed Consent and Medical Law Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

53.

McLean

SAM

(Ed) 2010 Autonomy, Consent and the Law London, Routledge

54.

Meany

2011

No, a nudge in the direction of organ donation is not enough

BMJ 343: d5726

55.

Modra

Hilton

2015

Ethical issues in organ transplantation

Anaesthesia and Intensive Care Medicine 16 7

56.

Montgomery (Appellant) v Lanarkshire Health Board (Respondent) (Scotland) 2015

57.

Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (Scotland) 2015 UKSC 11 Available from: https://www.supremecourt.uk/decided-cases/docs/UKSC_2013_0136_Judgment.pdf

58.

Ms B v An NHS Hospital Trust 2002 EWHC 429 Fam (22 March 2002) Available from: http://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Fam/2002/429.html

59.

National Health Blood and Transplant Service (NHSBT) 2013 Approaching the families of potential organ donors Available from: www.odt.nhs.uk/pdf/family_approach_best_practice_guide.pdf (accessed 17 November 2016)

60.

National Health Blood and Transplant Service 2016 Taking Organ Transplantation to 2020: A detailed strategy Available from: www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/to2020/resources/nhsbt_organ_donor_strategy_long.pdf (accessed 4 November 2016)

61.

NHS Blood and Transplant Service 2016 Legislative framework Available from: www.odt.nhs.uk/donation/deceased-donation/consent-authorisation/legislative-framework.asp (accessed 12 December 2016)

62.

NHS Blood and Transplant Service 2016 Highest number of organ transplants ever across UK, but many families still say no to donation Available from: www.organdonation.nhs.uk/news-and-campaigns/news/highest-number-of-organ-transplants-ever-across-uk-but-many-families-still-say-no-to-donation/ (accessed 22 November 2016)

63.

NHS Blood and Transplant Service 2017 Transplant activity report Available from: www.organdonation.nhs.uk/supporting-my-decision/statistics-about-organ-donation/transplant-activity-report/ (accessed 22 October 2017)

64.

NHS Blood and Transplant Service 2018 Role of HM Coroner & Procurator Fiscal Available from: www.odt.nhs.uk/odt-structures-and-standards/organ-donation-retrieval-and-transplantation-teams/role-of-hm-coroner-procurator-fiscal/ (accessed 12 November 2018)

65.

National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence 2016 Organ donation for transplantation: Improving donor identification and consent rates for deceased organ donation (CG135) 2016 Available from: www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg135 (accessed 12 December 2016)

66.

Nuffield Council on Bioethics 2010 Give and take? Human bodies in medicine and research Available from: http://nuffieldbioethics.org/wp-content/uploads/Human-bodies-in-medicine-and-research-consultation-paper.pdf (accessed 12 December 2016)

67.

Nuffield Council on Bioethics 2012 Human bodies: Donation for medicine and research Available from: http://nuffieldbioethics.org/wp-content/uploads/HumanBodies_report_developments_web.pdf (accessed 5 November 2016)

68.

Oliver

Woywodt

Ahmed

Saif

2010 Organ donation, transplantation and religion Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation 1 of 8 Available from: http://ndt.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2010/10/20/ndt.gfq628.full.pdf+html (accessed 23 December 2016)

69.

Omrod

Ryder

Chadwick

Bonner

2015

Experiences of families when a relative is diagnosed brain stem dead: Understanding of death, observation of brain stem death testing and attitudes to organ donation

Anaesthesia 60 1002–1008

70.

Organ Donation and Transplantation 2016 Legislative framework Available from: www.odt.nhs.uk/donation/deceased-donation/consent-authorisation/legislative-framework.asp (accessed 29 December 2016)

71.

Pearson

Zurynski

1995

A survey of personal and professional attitudes of intensivists to organ donation and transplantation

Anaesthesia and Intensive Care 23 (1) 68–74

72.

Pelligrino

2001

The internal morality of clinical medicine: A paradigm for the ethics of the helping and healing professions

Journal of Medical Philosophy 26 (6) 559–579

73.

Pocklington

2014 Law and Religion Opt-out organ donation: UK Available from: www.lawandreligionuk.com/2014/06/24/opt-out-organ-donation-uk/ (accessed 2 January 2016)

74.

Potts

Verheijde

Rady

Evans

2010

Normative consent and presumed consent for organ donation: A critique

Journal of Medical Ethics 36(8) 498–499

75.

Poyntz

Lusuardi

Price

2009 West Midlands Specialised Commissioning Team, Organs for transplant: An analysis of the current costs of the NHS transplant programme; the cost of alternative medical treatments and the impact of increasing organ donation October 2010 Available from: www.nhsbt.nhs.uk/to2020/the-strategy/supporting-documents/economic-case-for-organ-transplantation.pdf (accessed 8 January 2016)

76.

Price

DPT

2012

Legal framework governing deceased organ donation in the UK

BJA 108 (Supplement 1) i68–i72

77.

Public Health Control of Disease Act 1984 c.22 Part lll disposal of dead bodies Available from: www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1984/22/part/III/crossheading/disposal-of-dead-bodies (accessed 12 November 2018)

78.

Randall

Downie

2012

Misguided presumptions: British Medical Association BMA and National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence NICE guidance on organ retrieval and opt out or presumed consent

Clinical Medicine 12 (6) 513–516

79.

Redfern

2001 The Royal Liverpool Children’s Inquiry Report London, The Stationary Office

80.

Re S (Adult Patient: Sterilisation): CA 26 May 2001

81.

Simpkin

Robertson

Barber

Young

2009

Modifiable factors influencing relatives’ decision to offer organ donation: Systematic review

British Medical Journal 339 b991

82.

Smith

2005

Fallacies of the logical slippery slope in the debate on physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia

Medical Law Review 13 224–243

83.

Spencer

2012

The barriers to organ and tissue donation in palliative care

End of Life Journal 2: 1–11

84.

Spital

1996

Mandated choice for organ donation: Time to give it a try

Annals of Internal Medicine 125 66–69

85.

Stevens

2015 Call for debate on presumed consent organ donation in parliament Available from: www.jostevens.co.uk/call_for_debate_on_presumed_consent_organ_donation_in_parliament (accessed 12 November 2016)

86.

Sutchfield

Wigmore

2011

The ethics of transplantation and legal issues

Surgery 29 (7) 301–305

87.

The Declaration of Istanbul 2014 The council of Europe convention against trafficking in human organs Available from: www.declarationofistanbul.org/resources/recommended-reading/the-council-of-europe-convention-against-trafficking-in-human-organs (accessed 13 December /2016)

88.

Thiroux

Krasemann

2012 Ethics: Theory and Practice 11th ed New Jersey, Pearson/Prentice Hall

89.

Tomasini

2009

Is post-mortem harm possible? Understanding death, harm and grief

Bioethics 23 (8) 441–449

90.

Traino

Alolod

Shafer

Siminoff

2012

Interim results of a national test of the rapid assessment of hospital procurement barriers in donation (RAPiD)

American Journal of Transplantation 12 (11) 3094–3103

91.

Veatch

Ross

2015 Transplantation Ethics 2nd ed USA, Georgetown University Press

92.

Vincent

Logan

2012

Consent for organ donation

British Journal of Anaesthesia 108 (suppl 1) i80–i87

93.

Von Hargens

1995 Body worlds Available from: www.bodyworlds.com/en/exhibitions/questionsanswers.html#1 (accessed 11 November 2016)

94.

Walker

Broderick

Sque

2013

Factors influencing bereaved families decisions about organ donation: An integrative literature review

Western Journal of Nursing Research 35 (10) 1339–1359

95.

Williams v Williams 1882 LR 20 ChD 659 Available from: http://iclr.co.uk/document/1865228282/casereport_4597/html?query=&filter=courts%3A%22ChD%22+browse%3A%225%2F20%22&fullSearchFields=&hx0026;page=2&sort=relevance&pageSize=10

96.

Wilkinson

2005

Individual and family consent to organ and tissue donation: Is the current position coherent?

Journal of Medical Ethics 31 (10) 587–590

97.

Winklemann

2016

Consent and Consensus – Ethical perspectives on obtaining bodies for anatomical dissection

Clinical Anatomy 29(1) 70–77

98.

Yearworth v North Bristol NHS Trust 2009 EWCA Civ 37 Court of Appeal Available from: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2009/37.html