The legal and ethical issues surrounding the care of children and young people in the perioperative setting are often vague and an anaesthetic practitioner could find themselves inadequately prepared for any issues that may arise. This paper details the case of an adolescent who withdrew her consent to surgery whilst in the anaesthetic room. It raises questions about Gillick Competency and whether the use of restraint is ever justified.
BrennerM2007Child restraint in the acute setting of paediatric nursing: an extraordinarily stressful evenIssues in Comprehensive Pediatric Nursing30 (1-2) 29–37
CaveE2014Goodbye Gillick? Identifying and resolving problems with the concept of child competenceLegal Studies34 (1) 103–22
5.
CoyneIScottP2013Alternatives to restraining children for clinical proceduresNursing Children and Young People26 (2) 22–27
6.
Department of Health2005Mental Capacity ActLondon,
HMSO
7.
Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority1985 2 A11 ER 402
8.
GorgyM2012 Article 8 and minors’ right to refuse medical treatment Available from: https://blogs.kcl.ac.uk/kslr/?p=645 [Accessed September 2017]
9.
Health and Care Professions Council2016Standards of conduct, performance and ethics London, HCPC
10.
Her Majesty’s Stationery Office1969Family Law Reform Act London, HMSO
11.
JeffreyK2010Supportive holding or restraint: terminology and practicePaediatric Nursing22 (6) 24–28
12.
KupietzkyA2004Strap him down or knock him out: Is conscious sedation with restraint an alternative to general anaesthesia?British Dental Journal196 (3) 133–38
13.
McgrathPHuffN2003Including the father's perspective in holistic care. Part 1: Findings on the father's hospital experience including restraining the child patient for treatmentAustralian Journal of Holistic Nursing10 (2) 127–32
14.
MorrisCD2004A commentary on the legal issuesBritish Dental Journal196 (3) 139–40
SelekmanJSnyderB1996Uses of and alternatives to restraints in pediatric settingsAdvanced Practice in Acute Critical Care7 (4) 603–10
22.
TanLMeakinG2010Anaesthesia for the uncooperative childContinuing Education in Anaesthesia Critical Care and Pain10 (2) 48–52
23.
United Nations1989 Convention on the rights of the child adopted under general assembly resolution 44/25 1989
24.
WalkerH2009The child who refuses to undergo anaesthesia and surgery: A case scenario-based discussion of the ethical and legal issuesPaediatric Anaesthesia191017–21
