A retrospective observational study was performed in our trust in October 2010 that examined compliance, and the financial and clinical implications of performing inappropriate preoperative blood tests on adult patients prior to elective surgery, against the 2003 NICE guidelines. An unacceptable proportion of inappropriate tests (31.3%) were being performed. None were associated with adverse outcome or changes in management. Based on our results, we estimate that an extrapolated cost of £11.2 million is being spent on inappropriate blood tests in NHS England and Wales.
AllisonJG, BromleyHR1996Unnecessary preoperative investigations evaluation and cost analysisAmerican Journal of Surgery62686–9
2.
American Society of Anesthesiologists2002Practice advisory for preanesthesia evaluation: A report by the American Society of Anesthesiologists Task Force on Preanesthesia EvaluationAnesthesiology96(2) 485–9
BarazzoniF, GrilliR, AmicosanteAM2002Impact of end use involvement in implementing guidelines on routine preoperative testsInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care81–7
BrysonGL2005Has preoperative testing become a habit?Canadian Journal of Anesthesia52557–61
7.
BrysonGL, WyandS, BraggPR2006Preoperative testing is inconsistent with published guidelines and rarely changes managementCanadian Journal of Anesthesia53236–41
8.
ChungF, YuanH, YinL, VairavanathanS, WongDT2009Elimination of testing in ambulatory surgeryAnesthesia & Analgesia108467–75
9.
EiichoI2005Role of preoperative laboratory tests in preoperative assessmentThe Journal of Japan Society for Clinical Anesthesia25582–7
10.
FerrandoA, IvaldiC, ButtiglieriA2005Guidelines for preoperative assessment: Impact on clinical practices and costsInternational Journal for Quality in Health Care17323–9
JohnsonRK, MortimerAJ2002Routine preoperative blood testing: is it necessary?Anaesthesia57(9) 914–7
14.
KrishnamurthyA, DuttaD, PhillipsJ, MethalN2007Are we still performing too many blood tests?Quality & Safety in Health Care16(5) 400
15.
KumarA, SrivastavaU2011Role of routine laboratory investigations in preoperative evaluationJournal of Anaesthesiology & Clinical Pharmacology27174–9
16.
Lopez-ArgumedoM, AsuaJ1999Preoperative evaluation in elective surgery INAHTA Synthesis Report. Osteba, Vitoria-Gasteiz. Dept of Health, Basque GovernmentBasque Office for Health Technology Assessment
17.
MacphersonDS1993Preoperative laboratory testing: Should any test be routine before surgeryMedical Clinics of North America77289–308
18.
MacPhersonRD, ReeveSA, StewartTV2005Effective strategy to guide pathology test ordering in surgical patientAustralia & New Zealand Journal of Surgery75138–43
19.
MunroJ, BoothA, NichollJ1997Routine preoperative testing: a systematic review of the evidenceHealth Technology Assessment1(12) 1–62
20.
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence2003Preoperative tests: The use of routine preoperative tests for elective surgery. Appendix 1: Results of a systematic review of the literature for routine preoperative testing; Appendix 5: Economics of routine preoperative testing Available from: http://www.nice.org.uk/Guidance/CG3 [Accessed May 2012]
21.
National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence2005A survey measuring the impact of NICE guidelines. 3: Preoperative testsLondon, NICE
22.
PasternakLR2004Preoperative laboratory testing: General issues and considerationsAnesthesiology Clinics2213–25
23.
PowerLM, ThackrayNM1999Reduction of preoperative investigations with the introduction of an anaesthetist led preoperative assessment clinicAnaesthesia and Intensive Care27481–8
24.
PutnisS, NanuckJ, HeathD2008An audit of preoperative blood testsJournal of Perioperative Practice18(2) 56–9
25.
RanasingheP, PereraYS, AbayadeeraA2010Preoperative investigations in elective surgery: Practices and costs at the national hospital of Sri LankaSri Lankan Journal of Anaesthesiology1829–35
26.
RoizenMF, LichtorJL2003Preoperative assessment and premedication for adults In: HealyTEJ, KnightPR (eds) Wylie and Churchill Davidson's A practice of Anesthesia7th ed415–25
27.
SarayrahMA, HabaibenE2009Preoperative blood testing in pediatric age group: Is it necessary?Middle East Journal of Family Medicine537–9
28.
SmetanaGW, MacphersonDS2003The case against preoperative laboratory testingMedical Clinics of North America877–40
29.
Swedish Council on Technology Assessment in Health Care1991Preoperative routinesInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care7(1) 95–100
30.
TurnbullJM, BuckC1987The value of preoperative screening investigations in otherwise healthy individualsArchives of Internal Medicine147(6) 1101–5
31.
VelanovichV1996Collective review: Preoperative laboratory evaluationJournal of the American College of Surgeons18379–87
