This article is presented in two interconnected parts. It addresses issues that have arguably received insufficient attention in most sociologically oriented criminological research and commentary on youth justice and related policy and practice developments, both within the UK jurisdictions and in wider international contexts. First, it highlights the need to recognize the complexities of comparative policy analysis at international, national, regional and local levels. Second, in the light of such complexity, the article attempts to explore the challenges confronting social science in general and sociological criminology in particular, in efforts to critically inform policymaking processes. In conclusion, it is suggested that the possibilities for vibrant, critical and publicly engaged academic intervention in the youth justice policy sphere rest upon the mobilization of theoretically and empirically based analyses, together with research-informed proposals for policy formation and practice development.
Bala, N.,J. Hornick , H. Snyder and J. Paetsch (eds) (2002) Juvenile Justice Systems: An International Comparison of Problems and Solutions. Toronto: Thompson.
2.
Bottoms, A. and J. Dignan ( 2004) Youth Justice in Great Britain. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
3.
Bryman, A. ( 2004) Social Research Methods. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
4.
Burawoy, M. ( 2004) ‘For Public Sociology’, British Journal of Sociology56(2): 417-32.
5.
Carr, P. ( 2010) ‘The Problem of Experimental Criminology: A Response to Sherman’s "Evidence and Liberty" ’, Criminology and Criminal Justice10(1) [this issue].
6.
Casey, R. and J. Flint ( 2008) ‘Governing through Localism, Contract and Community: Evidence from Anti-Social Behaviour Strategies in Scotland’, in P. Squires (ed.) ASBO Nation , pp. 106-116. Bristol: Policy Press.
7.
Chancer, L. and E. McLaughlin ( 2007) ‘Public Criminologies’, Theoretical Criminology11(2): 155-73.
8.
Cipriani, D. ( 2009) Children’s Rights and the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility: A Global Perspective. Aldershot: Ashgate.
9.
Coleman, R., J. Sim, S. Tombs and D. Whyte (eds) (2009) State Power Crime. London: SAGE. Crawford, A. (2009a) ‘Criminalizing Sociability through Anti-Social Behaviour Legislation: Dispersal Powers, Young People and the Police’, Youth Justice9(1): 5-26.
10.
Crawford, A. (2009b) ‘Governing through Anti-Social Behaviour’, British Journal of Criminology49(9): 810-31.
11.
Criminal Justice Review Group (2000) Review of the Criminal Justice System in Northern Ireland: A Guide. Belfast: HMSO.
12.
Cross, N., J. Evans and J. Minkes ( 2002) ‘Still Children First? Developments in Youth Justice in Wales’, Youth Justice2(3): 151-62.
13.
Currie, E. ( 1985) Confronting Crime: An American Challenge. New York: Random House. Currie, E. (1992) Reckoning: Drugs, the Cities and the American Future. New York: Hill & Wang. Currie, E. (1996) Is America Really Winning the War on Crime and Should Britain Follow Its Example?NACRO 30th annual lecture. London: NACRO.
14.
Currie, E. ( 2007) ‘Against Marginality: Arguments for a Public Criminology’ , Theoretical Criminology11(2): 175-90.
15.
Defence for Children International (2007) From Legislation to Action? Trends in Juvenile Justice Systems across 15 Countries . Geneva: Defence for Children International .
16.
Edwards, A. and P. Gill ( 2002) ‘The Politics of "Transnational Organised Crime": Discourse, Reflexivity and the Narration of "Threat"’, British Journal of Politics and International Relations4(2): 245-63.
17.
Edwards, A. and G. Hughes ( 2005) ‘Comparing the Governance of Safety in Europe: A Geo-Historical Approach’, Theoretical Criminology9(3): 345-63.
18.
Edwards, A. and G. Hughes ( 2008) ‘Resilient Fabians? Anti-Social Behaviour and Community Safety Work in Wales’, in P. Squires (ed.) ASBO Nation, pp. 57-72. Bristol: Policy Press. Edwards, A. and G. Hughes (2009a) ‘The Preventive Turn and the Promotion of Safer Communities in England and Wales: Political Inventiveness and Governmental Instabilities’, in A. Crawford (ed.) Crime Prevention in Europe: Comparative Perspectives, pp. 62-85. Cullompton: Willan. Edwards, A. and G. Hughes (2009b) ‘Crime, Science and Politics’, paper presented at the European Society of Criminology, Ljubjiana, 10 September.
19.
Edwards, A. and J. Sheptycki ( 2009) ‘Third Wave Criminology: Guns, Crime and Social Order’, Criminology and Criminal Justice9(3): 379-97.
20.
Farrington, D. ( 2000) ‘Explaining and Preventing Crime: The Globalisation of Knowledge. The American Society of Criminology 1999 Presidential Address’ , Criminology38(1): 1-24. Fergusson, R. (2007) ‘Making Sense of the Melting Pot: Multiple Discourses in Youth Justice Policy’, Youth Justice7(3): 179-94.
21.
Garland, D. ( 2001) The Culture of Control. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
22.
Garland, D. and R. Sparks ( 2000) ‘Criminology, Social Theory and the Challenge of Our Times’, British Journal of Criminology40(2): 189-204.
23.
Goldson, B. ( 2001) ‘The Demonisation of Children: From the Symbolic to the Institutional’, in P. Foley , J. Roche and S. Tucker (eds) Children in Society: Contemporary Theory, Policy and Practice, pp. 34-41. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
24.
Goldson, B. ( 2009) ‘"Difficult to Understand or Defend": A Reasoned Case for Raising the Age of Criminal Responsibility’, Howard Journal of Criminal Justice48(5): 514-21.
25.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie ( 2006a) ‘Rethinking Youth Justice: Comparative Analysis, International Human Rights and Research Evidence’, Youth Justice6(2): 91-106.
26.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie ( 2006b) ‘Critical Anatomy: Towards a Principled Youth Justice’ , in B. Goldson and J. Muncie (eds) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical Issues , pp. 203-31. London: SAGE.
27.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie (eds) (2006c) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical Issues. London: SAGE.
28.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie ( 2007) ‘Youth Justice with Integrity: Beyond Allen’s "New Approach"’, in Z. Davies and W. McMahon (eds) Debating Youth Justice: From Punishment to Problem Solving?, pp. 57-64. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
29.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie ( 2009a) ‘Editors’ Introduction’, in B. Goldson and J. Muncie (eds) Youth Crime and Juvenile Justice, Volume 2: ‘Juvenile Corrections’, Sage Library of Criminology, pp. vii-xxi. London : SAGE.
30.
Goldson, B. and J. Muncie (eds) (2009b) Youth Crime and Juvenile Justice, Volume 3: ‘Children’s Rights and State Responsibilities’, Sage Library of Criminology. London: SAGE.
31.
Haines, K. ( 2009) ‘The Dragonisation of Youth Justice’, in W. Taylor, R. Earle and R. Hester (eds) Youth Justice Handbook: Theory, Policy and Practice. Cullompton : Willan.
32.
Hammarberg, T. ( 2009) Children and Juvenile Justice: Proposals for Improvements . Strasbourg: Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights.
33.
Haydon, D. ( 2009) Developing a Manifesto for Youth Justice in Northern Ireland: Background Paper. Belfast: Include Youth.
34.
Hazel, N. ( 2008) Cross-National Comparison of Youth Justice. London: Youth Justice Board.
35.
Henry, A. ( 2009) ‘The Development of Community Safety in Scotland: A Different Path?’, in A. Crawford (ed.) Crime Prevention in Europe: Comparative Perspectives, pp. 86-109. Cullompton : Willan.
36.
Hillyard, P., J. Sim, S. Tombs and D. Whyte ( 2004) ‘Leaving a "Stain upon the Silence": Contemporary Criminology and the Politics of Dissent’, British Journal of Criminology44(3): 369-90.
37.
Hope, T. ( 2008) ‘A Firing Squad to Shoot the Messenger: Home Office Peer Review of Research’, in T. Hope and R. WaltersCritical Thinking about the Uses of Research, pp. 27-44. London : Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
38.
Hope, T. ( 2009) ‘The Illusion of Control: A Response to Professor Sherman’, Criminology and Criminal Justice9(2): 125-34.
39.
Hough, M. ( 2010) ‘Gold Standard or Fool’s Gold?’, Criminology and Criminal Justice10(1) [this issue].
40.
Hughes, G. ( 1998) Understanding Crime Prevention. Buckingham : Open University Press.
41.
Hughes, G. ( 2007) The Politics of Crime and Community. Basingstoke: Palgrave.
42.
Hughes, G. (forthcoming) ‘The Politics of Criminological Research’, in P. Davies and P. Francis (eds) Doing Criminological Research. London: SAGE.
43.
Hughes, G. and M. Follett ( 2006) ‘Community Safety, Youth and the "Anti-Social"’ , in B. Goldson and J. Muncie (eds) Youth Crime and Justice: Critical Issues , pp. 157-171. London: SAGE.
44.
Hughes, G., S. Case, A. Edwards, K. Haines, M. Liddle, A. Smith and S. Wright ( 2009) Evaluation of the Effectiveness of the Safer Communities Fund 2006-2009: Final Research Report Submitted to the Welsh Assembly Government by Cardiff University, Swansea University and ARCS Ltd. Cardiff: Welsh Assembly Government.
45.
Jacobson, J. and P. Gibbs ( 2009) Out of Trouble: Making Amends-Restorative Youth Justice in Northern Ireland. London: Prison Reform Trust
46.
Junger-Tas, J. and S. Decker (eds) (2008) International Handbook of Juvenile Justice. New York: Springer.
47.
Junger-Tas, J., I. Haen Marshall , D. Enzmann, M. Killias, S. Majone and B. Gruszczynska (eds) (2010) Juvenile Delinquency in Europe and Beyond. New York: Springer.
48.
Kilkelly, U. ( 2008) ‘Youth Justice and Children’s Rights: Measuring Compliance with International Standards’, Youth Justice8(3): 187-92.
49.
Leigh, A. ( 2009) ‘Evidence-Based Criminal Justice Policy: Summon the Randomistas?’, paper presented at the 40th Anniversary Symposium of the New South Wales Bureau of Crime Statistics , Sydney, February.
50.
Lindsay, T. and T. Chapman ( 2001) ‘Youth Justice in Northern Ireland’, in J. Roche and S. Vernon (eds) Youth Justice: Topic 10 K201 Working with Young People. Milton Keynes: The Open University.
51.
Loader, I. and R. Sparks ( 2008) ‘What Are We Gonna Do Now? Revisiting the Public Roles of Criminology’, Criminal Justice Matters72(1): 18-19.
52.
Lösel, F. ( 2007) ‘Doing Evaluation Research in Criminology: Balancing Scientific and Practical Demands’, in M. King and E. Wincup (eds) Researching Crime and Justice, pp. 141-170. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
53.
McAlister, S., P. Scraton and D. Haydon ( 2009) Childhood in Transition: Experiencing Marginalisation and Conflict in Northern Ireland. Belfast: Queen’s University, Prince’s Trust Northern Ireland and Save the Children.
54.
McGillivray, A. (ed.) (1997) Governing Childhood. Aldershot: Dartmouth.
55.
McLaughlin, E., J. Muncie and G. Hughes ( 2001) ‘The Permanent Revolution: New Labour, New Public Management and the Modernisation of Criminal Justice’, Criminal Justice1(3): 301-18.
56.
Muncie, J. ( 2005) ‘The Globalization of Crime Control-the Case of Youth and Juvenile Justice: Neo-Liberalism, Policy Convergence and International Conventions’, Theoretical Criminology9(1): 35-64.
57.
Muncie, J. ( 2009) Youth and Crime, 3rd edn. London: SAGE.
58.
Muncie, J. and B. Goldson (eds) (2006) Comparative Youth Justice: Critical Issues. London: SAGE.
59.
Muncie, J. and G. Hughes ( 2002) ‘Modes of Youth Governance: Political Rationalities, Criminalisation and Resistance’, in J. Muncie, G. Hughes and E. McLaughlin (eds) Youth Justice: Critical Readings, pp. 1-18. London: SAGE.
60.
Newburn, T. ( 2002) ‘Young People, Crime, and Youth Justice’, in M. Maguire, R. Morgan and R. Reiner (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Criminology, pp. 531-578. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
61.
Pinheiro, P.S. ( 2006) World Report on Violence against Children. Geneva: United Nations.
62.
Pinkerton, J. ( 2003) ‘From Parity to Subsidiarity? Children’s Policy in Northern Ireland Under New Labour: The Case of Child Welfare’, Children and Society17(3): 254-60.
63.
Pitts, J. ( 2000) ‘The New Youth Justice and the Politics of Electoral Anxiety’, in B. Goldson (ed.) The New Youth Justice, pp. 1-13. Lyme Regis: Russell House Publishing.
64.
Pitts, J. and T. Kuula ( 2006) ‘Incarcerating Young People: An Anglo-Finnish Comparison’ , Youth Justice5(3): 147-64.
65.
Prior, D. ( 2007) Continuities and Discontinuities in Governing Anti-Social Behaviour. Birmingham: University of Birmingham.
66.
Rhodes, R. ( 1997) Understanding Governance. Buckingham : Open University Press.
67.
Rose, N. ( 1989) Governing the Soul: The Shaping of the Private Self. London: Routledge.
68.
Said, E. ( 1996) Representations of the Intellectual: The 1993 Reith Lectures . London: Random House.
69.
Scraton, P. (ed.) (1997) ‘Childhood’ in ‘Crisis’?London: UCL Press.
70.
Shepherd, J. ( 2007) ‘The Production and Management of Evidence for Public Service Reform’, Evidence and Policy3(2): 231-51.
71.
Sherman, L.(2009) ‘Evidence and Liberty: The Promise of Experimental Criminology’ , Criminology and Criminal Justice9(1): 5-28.
72.
Stenson, K. and A. Edwards ( 2004) ‘Policy Transfer in Local Crime Control: Beyond Naïve Emulation’, in T. Newburn and R. Sparks (eds) Criminal Justice and Political Cultures: National and International Dimensions of Crime Control. Cullompton: Willan .
73.
Tilley, N. ( 2009) ‘Sherman vs Sherman: Realism vs Rhetoric’ , Criminology and Criminal Justice9(2): 135-44.
74.
Tonry, M. and A. Doob (eds) (2004) Youth Crime and Youth Justice: Comparative and Cross-National Perspectives, ‘Crime and Justice’ Volume 31. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
75.
United Nations (2010) United Nations Treaty Collection. http://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY&mtdsg_no=IV-11&chapter=4&lang=en
76.
United Nations Committee on the Rights of the Child ( 2007) General Comment No. 10: Children’s Rights in Juvenile Justice. Geneva: United Nations .
77.
Walters, R. ( 2003) Deviant Knowledge: Criminology, Politics and Policy. Cullompton: Willan.
78.
Walters, R. ( 2008) ‘Government Manipulation of Criminological Knowledge and Policies of Deceit’, in T. Hope and R. WaltersCritical Thinking about the Uses of Research, pp. 7-26. London: Centre for Crime and Justice Studies.
79.
Winterdyk, J. (ed.) (2002) Juvenile Justice Systems: International Perspectives, 2nd edition. Toronto: Canadian Scholars Press.
80.
Wright Mills, C. ( 1959) The Sociological Imagination. New York : Oxford University Press.
