This article draws on an evaluation of a large-scale programme in London,
‘From Dependency to Work’ (D2W), to discuss the obstacles to
effective work with offenders with multiple needs. D2W, a five-year programme funded
through the Single Regeneration Budget, aimed to support offenders with a range of
multiple needs including drug dependence, mental health issues, employment problems
and illiteracy. It was an ambitious programme that sought to co-ordinate the work of
statutory and voluntary agencies in a similar way to the ‘mixed
economy’ model envisaged for the National Offender Management Service
(NOMS); that met with implementation problems, which limited its overall impact.
These related in part to problems in finding ways of effectively assessing those
with multiple needs, and planning a rational sequence of interventions; but the way
in which the programme was performance-managed also destabilized the partnership to
a considerable degree. The study carries important lessons for NOMS, both in
relation to approaches to offender management and to contract management.
Audit Commission
(2004) Drug Misuse 2004: Reducing the Local Impact.
London: Audit Commission
.
2.
Bridges, A.
(1998) Increasing the Employability of Offenders: An Inquiry
into Probation Service Effectiveness. Probation Studies Unit Report No. 5.
Oxford: Centre for Criminological Research,
University of Oxford
.
3.
Caddick, C.
and
A. Webster
(1998)
‘Offender Literacy and the Probation Service’
, The Howard Journal37(2):
137–147
.
4.
Carter, P.
(2003) ‘Managing Offenders, Reducing
Crime—a New Approach’, Correctional Services Review by
Patrick Carter.
London: Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit
.
5.
Davies, K.
,
J. Lewis
,
J. Byatt
,
E. Purvis
and
C. Cole
(2004) An Evaluation of the Literacy Demands of General
Offending Behaviour Programmes. Home Office Research Findings No. 233.
London: Home Office
.
6.
Effective Interventions Unit
(2003) Moving On Update: Education, Training and Employment
for Recovering Drug Users.
Edinburgh: Scottish Executive
.
7.
Farrall, S.
(2002) Rethinking What Works with Offenders.
Cullompton: Willan Publishing
.
8.
Farrall, S.
and
S. Maruna
(2004)
‘Desistance-Focused Criminal Justice Policy Research:
Introduction to a Special Issue on Desistance from Crime and Public Policy’
, The Howard Journal43(4):
358–367
.
9.
Farrington, D.P.
,
B. Gallagher
,
L. Morley
,
R.J. St Ledger
and
D.J. West
(1986)
‘Unemployment, School Leaving and Crime’
, British Journal of Criminology26(4):
335–356
.
10.
Fletcher, D.
,
D. Woodhill
and
A. Herrington
(1998) Building Bridges into Employment and Training for Ex-offenders.York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation
.
11.
Flynn, N.
(2004) Employers and Offenders: Reducing Crime through Work
and Rehabilitation.
London: The Chartered Institute of Personnel
and Development (CIPD)
.
12.
Graham, J.
and
J. Bowling
(1995) Young People and Crime. Home Office Research
Study No. 145.
London: Home Office
.
13.
Home Office
(2004) Reducing Crime: Changing Lives.
London: Home Office
.
14.
Hough, M.
and
D. Mitchell
(2003) ‘Drug-Dependent Offenders and Justice for
All’, in
M. Tonry
(ed.) Confronting Crime: Crime Control Policy under New Labour,
pp. 26–50.
Cullompton: Willan Publishing
.
15.
Institute for Criminal Policy Research (ICPR), School of Law,
King’s College, London and Centre for Research on Drugs and Health
Behaviour (CRDHB), Imperial College, London (2004) ‘Criminal Justice
Integrated Teams: Summary of the Scoping Exercise’, unpublished report
prepared for the Home Office.
16.
Keetley, K. and T. Weaver (2004) ‘Evaluation of the Drug
Interventions Programme: Literature Review of Case Management’,
unpublished paper. Centre for Research on Drugs and Health Behaviour. London:
Imperial College.
17.
Klee, H.
,
I. McLean
and
C. Yavorsky
(2002) Employing Drug Users: Individual and Systematic
Barriers to Rehabilitation.
York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation
.
18.
Laub, J.H.
and
R.J. Sampson
(2001)
‘Understanding Desistance from Crime’
, Crime and Justice: An Annual Review of Research28:
1–70
.
19.
Liebling, A.
(2004) Prisons and Their Moral Performance: A Study of
Values, Quality and Prison Life.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
20.
McKeganey, N.
,
C. Connelly
,
J. Knepil
,
J. Norrie
and
L. Reid
(2000) Interviewing and Drug Testing of Arrestees in
Scotland: A Pilot of the Arrestee Drug Abuse Monitoring (ADAM)
Methodology.
Edinburgh: Scottish Executive Central Research Unit
.
21.
McSweeney, T.
and
M. Hough
(2005) ‘Drugs and Alcohol’,
in
N. Tilley
(ed.) A Handbook of Crime Prevention and Community Safety, pp.
563–594.
Cullompton: Willan Publishing
.
22.
McSweeney, T.
,
V. Herrington
,
M. Hough
,
P.J. Turnbull
and
J. Parsons
(2004) From Dependency to Work: Addressing the Multiple Needs
of Offenders with Drug Problems. Researching Criminal Justice
Series.
Bristol: The Policy Press
.
23.
Mair, G.
and
C. May
(1997) Offenders on Probation. Home Office Research
Study No. 167.
London: Home Office
.
24.
Maruna, S.
,
R. Immarigeon
and
T.P. LeBel
(2004) ‘Ex Offender Reintegration: Theory and
Practice’, in
S. Maruna
and
R. Immarigeon
(eds) After Crime and Punishment: Pathways to Offender
Reintegration, pp. 3–26.
Cullompton: Willan Publishing
.
25.
May, C.
(1999) Explaining Reconviction Following a Community
Sentence: The Role of Social Factors. Home Office Research Study No. 192.
London: Home Office
.
26.
Metcalf, H.
,
T. Anderson
and
H. Rolfe
(2001) Barriers to Employment for Offenders and
Ex-offenders.Department of Work and Pensions Report No. 155.
Leeds: CDS
.
27.
Miller, W.R.
and
S. Rollnick
(1991) Motivational Interviewing: Preparing People to Change
Addictive Behaviour.
New York: Guilford Press
.
28.
Niven, S.
and
D. Stewart
(2005) Resettlement Outcomes on Release from Prison in
2003. Home Office Research Findings No. 248.
London: Home Office
.
29.
O’Shea, N.
,
I. Moran
and
S. Bergin
(2003) Snakes and Ladders: Mental Health and Criminal
Justice. Findings from the Evaluation of the Revolving Doors Agency Link Worker
Schemes.
London: Revolving Doors Agency
.
30.
Preble, E.
and
J.J. Casey
(1969)
‘Taking Care of Business’
, International Journal of the Addictions4(1):
1–24
.
31.
Prochaska, J.O.
,
C.C. DiClemente
and
J.C. Norcross
(1992)
‘In Search of How People Change: Applications to Addictive Behaviors’
, American Psychologist47(9):
1102–1114
.
32.
Sampson, R.J.
and
J. Laub
(1993) Crime in the Making: Pathways and Turnings Points
through Life.
Cambridge: Harvard University Press
.
33.
Sarno, C.
,
I. Hearnden
,
C. Hedderman
,
M. Hough
,
C. Nee
and
V. Herrington
(2000) Working Their Way Out of Offending: An Evaluation of
Two Probation Employment Schemes. Home Office Research Study No. 218.
London: Home Office
.
34.
Singleton, N.
,
H. Meltzer
,
R. Gatward
,
J. Coid
and
D. Deasy
(1998) Psychiatric Morbidity among Prisoners in England and
Wales.
London: Office of National Statistics
.
35.
Social Exclusion Unit
(2002) Reducing Re-offending by Ex-prisoners.London: Social Exclusion Unit
.
36.
Sondhi, A.
,
J. O’Shea
and
T. Williams
(2002) Arrest Referral Statistical Update: Statistics from
the Arrest Referral Monitoring Programme for October 2000 to March 2001.
London: Home Office
(http://www.drugs.gov.uk/ReportsandPublications/Communities/1034258640/ArrestReferral_stat_update.pdf).
37.
Tarling, R.
(1982) Unemployment and Crime. Home Office Research
Bulletin No. 14: 28–33.
London: Home Office Research and Planning Unit
.
38.
Uggen, C.
(2000)
‘Work as a Turning Point in the Life Course of Criminals: A
Duration Model of Age, Employment and Recidivism’
, American Sociological Review65(4):
529–546
.
39.
Uggen, C.
and
J. Staff
(2001)
‘Work as a Turning Point for Criminal Offenders’
, Corrections Management Quarterly5(4):
1–16
.
40.
Webster, R.
,
C. Hedderman
,
P.J. Turnbull
and
T. May
(2001) Building Bridges to Employment for Prisoners.
Home Office Research Study No. 226.
London: Home Office
.
