Practitioner perceptions: Critical junctures and the global emergence and challenges of fact-checking

Abstract

Since 2003 and the emergence of FactCheck.org in the United States, fact-checking has expanded both domestically and internationally. As of February 2018, the Duke Reporter's Lab identified nearly 150 active initiatives around the world. Seen as a professional reform movement in the journalistic community, this research explores fact-checker perceptions of why the practice is spreading globally at this point in time. Using a phenomenological approach, two focus groups were conducted among fact-checkers during the 2015 Global Fact-checking Summit in London, England. Participants shared rich experiences about conditions and contexts surrounding the emergence and challenges facing their organizations including perceived public disempowerment, declines in journalism, technological changes, and socio-political strife. Ultimately, as the purpose of this research is to help future fact-checkers around the world become aware of the circumstances under which fact-checking is most likely to emerge and thrive (or fail), recommendations from current global practitioners are offered.

Keywords

Consumer reform movement critical juncture theory fact-checking focus groups journalism studies persuasive intervention political communication qualitative research

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adatto K (1990) Sound bite democracy: Network evening news presidential campaign coverage, 1968 and 1988. Research Paper R2, Harvard University.

Amazeen MA (2013) Making a difference: A critical assessment of fact‐checking in 2012. New America Foundation Media Policy Initiative Research Paper. Available at: www.newamerica.org/new-america/making-a-difference/ (accessed 26 November 2018).

Amazeen MA (2015) Sometimes political fact‐checking works. Sometimes it doesn’t. Here’s what can make the difference. Washington Post, 3 June. Available at: www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/monkey-cage/wp/2015/06/03/sometimes-political-fact-checking-works-sometimes-it-doesnt-heres-what-can-make-the-difference/ (accessed 26 November 2018).

Amazeen

(2017) Journalistic interventions: The structural factors affecting the global emergence of fact-checking. Journalism 95(1): 28–48.

Amazeen

Thorson

Muddiman

, et al.(2018) Correcting political and consumer misperceptions: The effectiveness and effects of rating scale versus contextual corrections. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 95(1): 28–48.

Arceneaux

Johnson

(2013) Changing Minds or Changing Channels? Partisan News in an Age of Choice, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.

Arceneaux

Johnson

Lindstadt

, et al.(2015) The influence of news media on political elites: Investigating strategic responsiveness in Congress. American Journal of Political Science 60(1): 5–29.

Barthel M, Gottfried J and Lu K (2016) Trump, Clinton supporters differ on how media should cover controversial statements. Pew Research Center, 17 October. Available at: www.journalism.org/2016/10/17/trump-clinton-supporters-differ-on-how-media-should-cover-controversial-statements/#majorities-of-both-candidates-supporters-say-the-media-should-fact-check-though-a-larger-share-of-clinton-supporters-say-this (accessed 26 November 2018).

Bates S 1990. Political ads: journalists as jurors. American Enterprise 1: 15–19.

10.

Cassedy

(1964) Muckraking and medicine: Samuel Hopkins Adams. American Quarterly 16(1): 85–99.

11.

Cron

(1997) Consumer journalism. In: Brobeck

(ed) Encyclopedia of the Consumer Movement, Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, pp. 342–350.

12.

Dicke W (1995) Georges Seldes is dead at 104: An early, fervent press critic. New York Times, 3 July. Available at: www.nytimes.com/1995/07/03/obituaries/george-seldes-is-dead-at-104-an-early-fervent-press-critic.html.

13.

Frieda B (1963) The Feminine Mystique. New York: WW Norton & Co.

14.

Friedman TL (2016) The age of protest. New York Times, 13 January, A21.

15.

Gans

(2003) Democracy and the News, New York: Oxford University Press.

16.

Glaser

Strauss

(1967) The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research, Chicago: Aldine.

17.

Gramlich J (2016) America's political divisions in 5 charts. Pew Research Center, 7 November. Available at: www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/11/07/americas-political-divisions-in-5-charts/.

18.

Graves

(2016) Deciding what's true: The fact-checking movement in American journalism, New York: Columbia University Press.

19.

Graves

(2018) Boundaries not drawn: Mapping the institutional roots of the global fact-checking movement. Journalism Studies 19(5): 613–631.

20.

Herrmann

Mayer

(1997) US consumer movement: History and dynamics. In: Brobeck

(ed) Encyclopedia of the Consumer Movement, Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, pp. 584–601.

21.

Husserl

(1970) The Crisis of the European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology, Evanston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

22.

Jackson J and Jamieson KH (2007) UnSpun: Finding Facts in a World of Disinformation. New York: Random House.

23.

Jamieson

(1992) Dirty Politics: Deception, Distraction, and Democracy, New York: Oxford University Press.

24.

Jensen

Jankowski

(1991) A Handbook of Qualitative Methodologies for Mass Communication Research, London: Routledge.

25.

Kovach

Rosenstiel

(2001) The Elements of Journalism, New York: Crown Publishers.

26.

Lieberman

(1994) What ever happened to consumer reporting?. Columbia Journalism Review 33(3): 34–40.

27.

Lincoln

Guba

(1985) Naturalistic Inquiry, Newbury Park, CA: SAGE.

28.

Lowrey

(2017) The emergence and development of news fact-checking sites: Institutional logics and population ecology. Journalism Studies 18(3): 376–394.

29.

Lynch M (2016) Why Saudi Arabia escalated the Middle East's sectarian conflict. Washington Post, 4 January. Available at: www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2016/01/04/why-saudi-arabia-escalated-the-middle-easts-sectarian-conflict/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_cage (accessed 26 November 2018).

30.

McChesney

(2007) Communication Revolution: Critical Junctures and the Future of Media, New York: The New Press.

31.

McChesney

Pickard

(2011) Will the Last Reporter Please Turn Out the Lights?, New York: The New Press.

32.

Nyhan B and Reifler J (2012) Misinformation and fact-checking: Research findings from social science. New America Foundation. Available at: http://www-personal.umich.edu/∼bnyhan/Misinformation_and_Fact-checking.pdf (accessed 6 December 2018).

33.

Nyhan

Reifler

(2015a) The effect of fact-checking on elites: A field experiment on U.S. state legislators. American Journal of Political Science 59(3): 628–640.

34.

Nyhan B and Reifler J (2015b) Estimating fact-checking's effects: Evidence from a long-term experiment during campaign 2014. American Press Institute. Available at: www.americanpressinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/04/Estimating-Fact-Checkings-Effect.pdf.

35.

Packard V (1957) The Hidden Persuaders. Brooklyn, New York: Ig Publishing.

36.

Pickard

(2015) Media activism from above and below. Journal of Information Policy 5: 109–128.

37.

Pingree

Brossard

McLeod

(2014) Effects of journalistic adjudication on factual beliefs, news evaluations, information seeking, and epistemic political efficacy. Mass Communication and Society 17(5): 615–638.

38.

Prior

(2007) Post-broadcast Democracy: How Media Choice Increases Inequality in Political Involvement and Polarizes Elections, New York: Cambridge University Press.

39.

Santaella L (1997) The development of Peirce's three types of reasoning: Abduction, deduction, and induction. In: 6th Congress of the international association for semiotic studies. Available at: www.pucsp.br/~lbraga/epap_peir1.htm (accessed 26 November 2018).

40.

Stencel M and Griffin R (2018) Fact-checking triples over four years. Duke Reporters' Lab. Available at: https://reporterslab.org/fact-checking-triples-over-four-years/.

41.

Stole IL (2006) Advertising on Trial: Consumer Activism and Corporate Public Relations in the 1930s. Urbana, IL: The University of Illinois Press.

42.

Stole IL (2015) History of consumer movements. In: Ryan JM and Cook DT (eds) Wiley-Blackwell Encyclopedia of Consumption and Consumer Studies. West Sussex, UK: John Wiley & Sons, pp. 1–5.

43.

Sulzberger AG (2011) States look to ban efforts to reveal farm abuse. New York Times, 13 April. Available at: www.nytimes.com/2011/04/14/us/14video.html?_r=0.

44.

Thorson E (2013) The consequences of misinformation and fact‐checking for citizens, politicians and the media. In: Annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association, April, Chicago, Illinois.

45.

Vargo

Guo

Amazeen

(2018) The agenda-setting power of fake news: A big data analysis of the online media landscape from 2014 to 2016. New Media & Society 20(5): 2028–2049.

46.

Voeten E (2013) Maps of global polarization. Washington Post, 10 October. Available at: www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2013/10/10/maps-of-global-polarization/?utm_term=.245c995474f9 (accessed 26 November 2018).

47.

West DM (1993) Air Wars. Thousand Oaks: CQ Press.

48.

Wood

(1990) Television's first political spot ad campaign: Eisenhower answers America. Presidential Studies Quarterly 20(2): 265–283.