Mapping talent pathways: A comparative study of developmental activities and practice structure in Brazilian and Spanish U-18 elite youth male soccer players
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online October, 2024
Mapping talent pathways: A comparative study of developmental activities and practice structure in Brazilian and Spanish U-18 elite youth male soccer players
The purpose of this study was threefold: (1) to compare the engagement in various types and amounts of soccer activities during childhood and adolescence between Brazilian and Spanish elite youth soccer players; (2) to test what talent development pathway characterizes youth development in elite soccer in Brazil and Spain and (3) to compare the practice structure between elite youth soccer in Brazil and Spain. Participants were 131 U-18 elite male soccer players from Brazil (n = 68) and Spain (n = 63) competing in the national league. The Participant History Questionnaire was used to measure the soccer activities undertaken by players. Developmental activities were analyzed for two age periods: childhood (6–12 y/o) and early adolescence (13–15 y/o). In Spain, players started their involvement in practice and competition in soccer earlier compared to Brazilian players (p < .05). Brazilian players were more involved in structured activities, such as practice in soccer and futsal, and participated in a greater number of sports in childhood and early adolescence (p < .05). We found a very similar percentual practice structure (individual, pair, drills, group tactics and collective tactics activities) between Spain and Brazil, although Brazilian players accumulated a greater practice volume. It is concluded that Spanish and Brazilian U-18 elite youth male soccer players were differentiated by their milestones in soccer and their engagement in practice activities during childhood and early adolescence. Talent development pathway of male soccer players in Spain was characterized by the early engagement pathway, while the Brazilian system was characterized by the specialized sampling model.
WilliamsAMFordPRDrustB. Talent identification and development in soccer since the millennium. J Sports Sci2020; 38: 1199–1210.
2.
SarmentoHAngueraMPereiraA, et al.Talent identification and development in male football: a systematic review. Sport Med2018; 48: 907–931.
3.
SweeneyLHoranDMacNamaraÁ. Premature professionalisation or early engagement? Examining practise in football player pathways. Front Sport Act Living2021; 3: 1–9.
4.
TurnnidgeJCôtéJHancockD. Positive youth development from sport to life: explicit or implicit transfer?Quest2014; 66: 203–217.
5.
CôtéJ. The influence of the family in the development of talent in sport. Sport Psychol1999; 13: 395–417.
6.
CôtéJBakerJAbernethyB.Practice and play in the development of sport expertise. In: EklundRTenenbaumG (eds) Handbook of sport psychology. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, 2007, pp.184–202.
7.
FordPRHodgesNJBroadbentD, et al.The developmental and professional activities of female international soccer players from five high-performing nations. J Sports Sci2020; 38: 1432–1440.
8.
RocaAWilliamsAMFordPR. Developmental activities and the acquisition of superior anticipation and decision making in soccer players. J Sports Sci2012; 30: 1643–1652.
9.
EricssonAKKrampeRTTesch-RomerC. The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychol Rev1993; 100: 363–406.
10.
BergkampTLGFrenckenWGPNiessenASM, et al.How soccer scouts identify talented players. Eur J Sport Sci. Epub ahead of print2021; 22(7): 994–1004.
11.
ErikstadMKHøigaardRJohansenBT, et al.Childhood football play and practice in relation to self-regulation and national team selection; a study of Norwegian elite youth players. J Sports Sci2018; 36: 2304–2310.
12.
HendryDTHodgesNJ. Early majority engagement pathway best defines transitions from youth to adult elite men’s soccer in the UK: a three time-point retrospective and prospective study. Psychol Sport Exerc2018; 36: 81–89.
13.
HorningMAustFGüllichA. Practice and play in the development of German top-level professional football players. Eur J Sport Sci2016; 16: 16–105.
14.
FordPRWardPHodgesNJ, et al.The role of deliberate practice and play in career progression in sport: the early engagement hypothesis. High Abil Stud2009; 20: 65–75.
15.
SieghartsleitnerRZuberCZibungM, et al.The early specialised bird catches the worm!’ – A specialised sampling model in the development of football talents. Front Psychol2018; 9: 1–12.
16.
CôtéJEricksonK. Diversification and deliberate play during the sampling years. In: BakerJFarrowD (eds) Routledge handbook of sport expertise. Abingdon: Routledge, 2015, pp.305–316.
17.
IBGE. Atlas Geográfico das Zonas Costeiras e Oceânicas do Brasil [Geographical Atlas of the Coastaline and Oceanic Zones of Brazil]. Rio de Janeiro: Diretoria de Geociências, 2011.
18.
YiannakiCCarlingCCollinsD. Futsal as a potential talent development modality for soccer–a quantitative assessment of high-level soccer coach and player perceptions. Sci Med Footb2018; 2: 299–308.
19.
OppiciLPanchukDSerpielloFR, et al.Futsal task constraints promote transfer of passing skill to soccer task constraints. Eur J Sport Sci2018; 18: 947–954.
20.
TravassosBAraújoDDavidsK. Is futsal a donor sport for football?: exploiting complementarity for early diversification in talent development. Sci Med Footb2018; 2: 66–70.
21.
RocaAFordPR. Decision-making practice during coaching sessions in elite youth football across European countries. Sci Med Footb2020; 4: 263–268.
22.
FordPRYatesIWilliamsAM. An analysis of practice activities and instructional behaviours used by youth soccer coaches during practice: exploring the link between science and application. J Sports Sci2010; 28: 483–495.
23.
WardPHodgesNJStarkesJL, et al.The road to excellence: deliberate practice and the development of expertise. High Abil Stud2007; 18: 119–153.
24.
MachadoGGonzález-VílloraSSarmentoH, et al.Development of tactical decision-making skills in youth soccer players: macro- and microstructure of soccer developmental activities as a discriminant of different skill levels. Int J Perform Anal Sport2020; 20: 1072–1091.
25.
FordLowJMcRobertA, et al.Developmental activities that contribute to high or low performance by elite cricket batters when recognizing type of delivery from bowlers’ advanced postural cues. J Sport Exerc Psychol2010; 32: 638–654.
26.
FordPRWilliamsA. The developmental activities engaged in by elite youth soccer players who progressed to professional status compared to those who did not. Psychol Sport Exerc2012; 13: 349–352.
27.
MachadoGGonzález-VílloraSTeoldoI.Contribution of deliberate practice, play, and futsal to the acquisition of decision-making skills in Brazilian professional female soccer players. Int J Sport Exerc Psychol. Epub ahead of print2022.
28.
MachadoGGonzález-VílloraSTeoldoI. The relationship between deliberate practice, play, and futsal in childhood and adolescence and the development of different decision-making skills in professional female soccer players. Psychol Sport Exerc2023; 68: 102470.
29.
GüllichA. Many roads lead to Rome – developmental paths to Olympic gold in men’s field hockey. Eur J Sport Sci2014; 14: 763–771.
30.
MemmertDBakerJBertschC. Play and practice in the development of sport-specific creativity in team ball sports. High Abil Stud2010; 21: 3–18.
31.
HaugaasenMToeringTJordetG. From childhood to senior professional football: a multi-level approach to elite youth football players’ engagement in football-specific activities. Psychol Sport Exerc2014; 15: 336–344.
32.
FordPRCarlingCGarcesM, et al.The developmental activities of elite soccer players aged under-16 years from Brazil, England, France, Ghana, Mexico, Portugal and Sweden. J Sports Sci2012; 30: 1653–1663.
33.
MooreRRamchandaniDGBulloughS, et al.The world at their feet: a combined historical ranking of nations competing in football and futsal. Am J Sport Sci Med2018; 6: 49–59.
34.
FritzCMorrisPRichlerJ. Effect size estimates: current use, calculations, and interpretation. J Exp Psychol Gen2012; 141: 2–18.
35.
ForsmanHBlomqvistMDavidsK, et al.The role of sport-specific play and practice during childhood in the development of adolescent Finnish team sport athletes. Int J Sport Sci Coach2016; 11: 69–77.
36.
GüllichAKovarPZartS, et al.Sport activities differentiating match-play improvement in elite youth footballers – a 2-year longitudinal study. J Sports Sci2016; 35: 207–215.
37.
TeoldoISilvinoMP.Analysis of tactical behavior in full- and small-sided games : Comparing professional and youth academy athletes to enhance player development in soccer. Int J Sports Sci Coach. Epub ahead of print2022.
38.
CONMEBOL. Manual Orientador [Guidance Manual]. Luque: Nobel Indústria Gráfica, 2020.
39.
SarmentoHClementeFMHarperLD, et al.Small sided games in soccer–a systematic review. Int J Perform Anal Sport2018; 18: 693–749.
40.
O’ConnorDWardakDGoodyearP, et al.Conceptualising decision-making and its development: a phenomenographic analysis. Sci Med Footb2018; 2: 261–271.
41.
TeoldoIGuilhermeJGargantaJ. Football intelligence: Training and tactics for soccer success. Oxfordshire: Routledge, 2022.
42.
MooreRRadfordJ. Is futsal kicking off in England? A baseline participation study of futsal. Am J Sport Sci Med2014; 2: 117–122.
43.
MCDE. Anuário de Estadísticas Deportivas 2021 [Directory of Spain Sports Statistics 2021]. 2021.
44.
CBF. Cadastro Nacional de Estádios de Futebol [National Register of Football Stadiums]. Rio de Janeiro, 2016.
45.
IBGE. Censo Demográfico [Demographic Census]. 2010.
46.
CSD. Los hábitos deportivos de la población escolar en España [Sports habits of the school population in Spain]. 2011.
47.
Castellanos-GarcíaPLera-LópezFSánchez-SantosJM. Patterns of sports involvement in Spain. Eur J Sport Sci2021; 21: 895–906.
48.
StonebridgeICushionC. An exploration of the relationship between educational background and the coaching behaviours and practice activities of professional youth soccer coaches. Phys Educ Sport Pedagog2018; 23: 636–656.
49.
MarquesRFRSchubringABarker-RuchtiN, et al.From soccer to futsal: Brazilian elite level men players’ career pathways. Soccer Soc2021; 22: 486–501.
50.
YiannakiCBarronDJCollinsD, et al.Match performance in a reference futsal team during an international tournament – implications for talent development in soccer. Biol Sport2020; 37: 147–156.
51.
FordPRBordonauJLDBonannoD, et al.A survey of talent identification and development processes in the youth academies of professional soccer clubs from around the world. J Sports Sci2020; 38: 1269–1278.
