Evaluating the impact of a coach development intervention for improving coaching practices and player outcomes in netball: The MASTER coaching randomized control trial
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online June, 2021
Evaluating the impact of a coach development intervention for improving coaching practices and player outcomes in netball: The MASTER coaching randomized control trial
The aim of this randomized controlled trial was to evaluate the impact of a novel 8-week coach development intervention (MASTER) on game-based coaching practices of netball coaches from one netball club (n = 16; 8 intervention, 8 active-control; NSW Australia), and player outcomes for the junior athletes being coached. The multi-component MASTER intervention aimed to educate coaches on how to design and implement high quality game-based coaching sessions. The core pillar of MASTER is ‘positive coaching,’ delivered through games-based coaching practices. At baseline and 10-weeks, two coaching sessions per coach were filmed and assessed using the MASTER assessment tool. Players (8-16yrs; n = 85) were videoed during structured gameplay, with three aspects of game play assessed using Game Performance Assessment Instrument. Coaches and players (n = 75; 12-16yrs) completed a perceptions questionnaire. Using linear mixed model ITT analysis, significant interventions effects were observed for the primary outcome: percentage of time spent performing playing-form activities [25.7% (95% CI (7.79-43.65), P = 0.008, d = 1.52]. Significant interventions effects were also observed for coach perceptions, player game skills, and player self-perceptions (P < 0.05). No significant changes were observed for player enjoyment, motivation, or wellbeing. The MASTER program was effective in improving coach and player self-perceptions, and coaching practices of netball coaches during training sessions.
Australian Sports Commission.Ausplay focus: children’s participation in organised physical activity outside of school hours.
Australia:
Australian Government, 2018, p.23.
2.
RidleyKZabeenSLunnayBK.Children’s physical activity levels during organised sports practices. J Sci Med Sport2018;
21: 930–934.
3.
ScharfenH-EMemmertD.The relationship between cognitive functions and sport-specific motor skills in elite youth soccer players. Front Psychol2019;
10: 817–817.
4.
Sierra-DíazMJGonzález-VílloraSPastor-VicedoJC, et al.
Can we motivate students to practice physical activities and sports through models-based practice? A systematic review and meta-analysis of psychosocial factors related to physical education. Front Psychol2019;
10: 1–24.
5.
LiddleSKDeaneFPVellaSA.Addressing mental health through sport: a review of sporting organizations' websites. Early Interv Psychiatry2017;
11: 93–103.
6.
EimeRYoungJHarveyJ, et al.
A systematic review of the psychological and social benefits of participation in sport for children and adolescents: informing development of a conceptual model of health through sport. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act2013;
10: 98.
7.
VellaSOadesLCroweT.The role of the coach in facilitating positive youth development: moving from theory to practice. J Appl Sport Psychol2011;
23: 33–48.
8.
FordPRYatesIWilliamsAM.An analysis of practice activities and instructional behaviours used by youth soccer coaches during practice: exploring the link between science and application. J Sports Sci2010;
28: 483–495.
9.
MuirBMorganGAbrahamA, et al. Developmentally appropriate approaches to coaching children. In: Stafford I (ed.) Coaching children in sport. London, UK: Routledge, 2011, pp.17–56.
10.
CushionCJHarveySMuirB, et al.
Developing the coach analysis and intervention system (CAIS): establishing validity and reliability of a computerised systematic observation instrument. J Sports Sci2012;
30: 201–216.
11.
LyleJ.Reflecting on the development of a conceptual framework for sport coaching. Int Sport Coach J2018;
5: 90–98.
12.
HedlundDPFletcherCAPackSM, et al.
The education of sport coaches: what should they learn and when should they learn it?Int Sport Coach J2018;
5: 192–199.
13.
Australian Sports Commission. Teaching sport to children: discussion paper. Canberra: Australian Sports Commission, 2017.
14.
HarveySJarrettK.A review of the game-centred approaches to teaching and coaching literature since 2006. Phys Educ Sport Pedagogy2014;
19: 278–300.
15.
NobleJVermillionMFosterK.Coaching environments and student-athletes: perceptions of support, climate and autonomy. Sport J2016;
19: 17–01.
16.
MillerAHarveySMorleyD, et al.
Exposing athletes to playing form activity: outcomes of a randomised control trial among community netball teams using a game-centred approach. J Sports Sci2017;
35: 1846–1812.
17.
BalishSMMcLarenCRainhamD, et al.
Correlates of youth sport attrition: a review and future directions. Psychol Sport Exercise2014;
15: 429–439.
18.
PillS.Informing game sense pedagogy with constraints led theory for coaching in Australian football. Sports Coach Rev2014;
3: 46–62.
19.
MillerAChristensenEEatherN, et al.
Can physical education and physical activity outcomes be developed simultaneously using a game-centered approach?Eur Phys Educ Rev2016;
22: 113–133.
20.
LightRLHarveyS.Positive pedagogy for sport coaching. Sport Educ Soc2017;
22: 271–287.
21.
LightR.Game sense: pedagogy for performance, participation and enjoyment.
London and New York:
Routledge, 2013.
22.
LightRLFawnsR.Knowing the game: Integrating speech and action in games teaching through TGfU. Quest2003;
55: 161–176.
23.
HedstromRGouldD.Research in youth sports: critical issues status – white paper summaries of the existing literature.
East Lansing, MI:
Institute for the Study of Youth Sports, Michigan State University, 20014.
24.
TempleVACraneJR.A systematic review of drop-out from organized soccer among children and adolescents. Soccer Soc2016;
17: 856–881.
25.
HowieEKMcVeighJASmithAJ, et al.
Organized sport trajectories from childhood to adolescence and health associations. Med Sci Sports Exerc2016;
48: 1331–1339.
26.
WittPADangiTB.Why children/youth drop out of sports. Jpra2018;
36: 191–199
27.
BakerJCôtéJHawesR.The relationship between coaching behaviours and sport anxiety in athletes. J Sci Med Sport/Sports Medicine Australia2000;
3: 110–119.
28.
Pill S. Moving, learning and achieving in sport related games teaching by playing with purpose. In: 27th ACHPER international conference, Adelaide, South Australia, The Australian Council for Health, Physical Education and Recreation, 2011, pp.57-65.
29.
WilliamsAMHodgesNJ.Practice, instruction and skill acquisition in soccer: challenging tradition. J Sports Sci2005;
23: 637–650.
30.
NarwalR.Effect of coaching behavior in sports. Int J Enhanced Res Educ Dev2014;
2: 111–115.
31.
PartingtonMCushionCHarveyS.An investigation of the effect of athletes’ age on the coaching behaviours of professional top-level youth soccer coaches. J Sports Sci2014;
32: 403–414.
32.
O'ConnorDLarkinPWilliamsAM.Observations of youth football training: how do coaches structure training sessions for player development?J Sports Sci2018;
36: 39–47.
33.
PillS.Teaching game sense in soccer. J Phys Educ Recreat Dance2012;
83: 42–46.
34.
ElmoreRF.Professional networks and school improvement. School Admin2007;
64: 20–25.
35.
CropleyBHantonSMilesA, et al.
Exploring the relationship between effective and reflective practice in applied sport psychology. Sport Psychol2010;
24: 521–541.
36.
KinnerkPHarveySMacDonnchaC, et al.
A review of the game-based approaches to coaching literature in competitive team sport settings. Quest2018;
70: 401–418.
37.
MerkelDL.Youth sport: positive and negative impact on young athletes. Open Access J Sports Med2013;
4: 151–160.
38.
GilbertWGallimoreRTrudelP.A learning community approach to coach development in youth sport. J Coach Educ2009;
2: 3–23.
39.
MacleanJLorimerR.Are coach education programmes the most effective method for coach development?Int J Sports Sci Coach2016;
10: 72–90.
40.
SmollFLSmith Re CummingSP, et al. Coaching behaviors, motivational climate, and young athletes’ sport experiences. In: GoncavesCECummingsSECoelho e SilvaMJ (eds) Sport education: tribute to martin lee.
Coimbra, Portugal:
Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra, 1983, pp.165–178.
41.
EatherNJonesBMillerA, et al.
Evaluating the impact of a coach development intervention for improving coaching practices in junior football (soccer): the “MASTER” pilot study. J Sports Sci2020;
38: 1441–1413.
42.
Australian Sports Commission.Netball state of play report.
Bruce, ACT:
Australian Government, Australian Sports Commission, 2019.
43.
GuzmánJFKingstonKGrijalboC.Predicting coaches' adherence/dropout: a prospective study. Int J Sports Sci Coach2015;
10: 353–363.
44.
Rundle-ThieleSAuldC.Should I stay or should I go? Retention of junior sport coaches. Ann Leisure Res2009;
12: 1–21.
45.
WoodsMErwinH.Using good B.E.H.A.V.I.O.R. to improve the learning environment. J Phys Educ Recreat Dance2008;
79: 14–16.
46.
NSW DET. Quality teaching in Nsw public schools: a classroom practice guide. 2nd ed.
Ryde:
NSW Department of Education and Training Professional Support and Curriculum Directorate., 2006.
47.
Hill-HaasSVDawsonBImpellizzeriFM, et al.
Physiology of small-sided games training in football: a systematic review. Sports Med2011;
41: 199–220.
48.
LightRL.Coaches' experiences of game sense: opportunities and challenges. Phys Educ Sport Pedagogy2004;
9: 115–131.
49.
Forrest G. Questions and answers: understanding the connection between questioning and knowledge in game-centred approaches. In: Contemporary developments in games teaching (eds R Light, J Quay, S Harvey, and A Mooney), 2014, pp.67-177. London: Routledge.
50.
RyanRMDeciEL.Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. Am Psychol2000;
55: 68–78.
51.
DudaJL.The conceptual and empirical foundations of empowering coaching™: setting the stage for the PAPA project AU – Duda. Joan L. Int J Sport Exercise Psychology2013;
11: 311–318.
52.
JonesRL.The sports coach as educator. 1st ed.
UK:
Routledge, 2006.
53.
SmeetonNJWilliamsAMHodgesNJ, et al.
The relative effectiveness of various instructional approaches in developing anticipation skill. J Exp Psychol Appl2005;
11: 98–110.
54.
VickersJNLivingstonLFUmeris-BohnertS, et al.
Decision training: the effects of complex instruction, variable practice and reduced delayed feedback on the acquisition and transfer of a motor skill. J Sports Sci1999;
17: 357–367.
55.
DeweyJ, How we think: a restatement of the relation of reflective thinking to the educative process. In: Boydson J (ed.) John Dewey: the later works, 1925–1953. Carbondale: Southern Illinois University Press, 1936/1986, pp.105–352.
56.
CurryCLightR. Addressing the NSW quality teaching framework in physical education: is game sense the answer? In: Asia Pacific conference of teaching sport and physical education for understanding. Sydney: University of Sydney, 2007, pp.7–19.
CôtéJGilbertW.An integrative definition of coaching effectiveness and expertise. Int J Sports Sci Coach2009;
4: 307–323.
59.
NewtonMDudaJLYinZ.Examination of the psychometric properties of the perceived motivational climate in sport questionnaire-2 in a sample of female athletes. J Sports Sci2000;
18: 275–290.
60.
HerringtonJParkerJBoase-JelinekD.Connected authentic learning: reflection and intentional learning. Aust J Educ2014;
58: 23–35.
61.
ZeichnerKTabachnickBR.Reflections on reflective teaching. In: ZeichnerKTabachnickBR (eds) Issues and practices in inquiry-oriented teacher education.
London:
Falmer Press, 1991, pp.1–21.
62.
GilbertWDTrudelP.Learning to coach through experience: reflection in model youth sport coaches. J Teach Phys Educ2001;
21: 16–34.
63.
CushionCJArmourKMJonesRL.Coach education and continuing professional development: experience and learning to coach. Quest2003;
55: 215–230.
EatherNRileyNMillerD, et al.; University of Newcastle, Australia.
Evaluating the effectiveness of using peer-dialogue assessment (PDA) for improving pre-service teachers' perceived confidence and competence to teach physical education. AJTE2017;
42: 69–83.
66.
DuFourR.What is a professional learning community?Educ Leadership2004;
61: 6–11.
67.
EatherNRileyNMillerD, et al.
Evaluating the impact of two dialogical feedback methods for improving pre-service teacher's perceived confidence and competence to teach physical education within authentic learning environments. Jets2019;
7: 32.
68.
MillerAChristensenEMEatherN, et al.
The PLUNGE randomized controlled trial: Evaluation of a games-based physical activity professional learning program in primary school physical education. Prevent Med2015;
74: 1–8.
69.
MotlRWDishmanRKSaundersR, et al.
Measuring enjoyment of physical activity in children: validation of the physical activity enjoyment scale. J Appl Sport Psychol2009;
21: S116–S129.
70.
ClarkeAFriedeTPutzR, et al.
Warwick-Edinburgh mental well-being scale (WEMWBS): validated for teenage school students in England and Scotland. A mixed methods assessment. BMC Public Health2011;
11: 487.
71.
LonsdaleCHodgeKRoseEA.The behavioral regulation in sport questionnaire (BRSQ): instrument development and initial validity evidence. J Sport Exerc Psychol2008;
30: 323–355.
72.
ViladrichCAppletonPRQuestedE, et al.
Measurement invariance of the behavioural regulation in sport questionnaire when completed by young athletes across five European countries. Int J Sport Exercise Psychol2013;
11: 384–394.
73.
HarterS.Manual for the self-perception profile for children: revision of the perceived competence scale for children.
Denver, CO:
University of Denver Press, 1985.
74.
GraySSprouleJ.Developing pupils’ performance in team invasion games. Phys Educ Sport Pedagogy2011;
16: 15–32.
75.
HarveySCushionCJWegisHM, et al.
Teaching games for understanding in American high-school soccer: a quantitative data analysis using the game performance assessment instrument. Phys Educ Sport Pedagogy2010;
15: 29–54.
76.
WickelEEEisenmannJC.Contribution of youth sport to total daily physical activity among 6- to 12-yr-old boys. Med Sci Sports Exercise2007;
39: 1493–1500.
77.
GuaglianoJMRosenkranzRRKoltGS.Girls' physical activity levels during organized sports in Australia. Med Sci Sports Exerc2013;
45: 116–122.
78.
LubansDRLonsdaleCCohenK, et al.
Framework for the design and delivery of organized physical activity sessions for children and adolescents: rationale and description of the 'SAAFE' teaching principles. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act2017;
14: 24
79.
SovikML.Evaluating the implementation of the empowering coaching TM program in Norway.
Norway:
University ofBergen, 2017.
80.
ThorpeAS.R. A comparison of the effectiveness of two approaches to teaching games within physical education. A skills approach versus a games for understanding approach. Br J Phys Educ1997;
28: 9–13.
81.
ChatzopoulosDDrakouAKotzamanidouM, et al.
Girls' soccer performance and motivation: games vs technique approach. Percept Mot Skills2006;
103: 463–470.
82.
McCarthyPJonesM.A qualitative study of sport enjoyment in the sampling years. Sport Psychol2007;
21: 400–416.
83.
McCarthyPJonesMClark-CarterD.Understanding enjoyment in youth sport: a developmental perspective. Psychol Sport Exerc2008;
9: 142–156.
84.
CraneJTempleV.A systematic review of dropout from organized sport among children and youth. Eur Phys Educ Rev2015;
21: 114–131.
85.
BalaguerIAtienzaFLDudaJ.Self-perceptions, self-worth and sport participation in adolescents. Span J Psychol2012;
15: 624–630.
86.
GilsonNCookeC, an and MahoneyC.Adolescent physical self-perceptions, sport/exercise and lifestyle physical activity. Health Educ2005;
105: 437–450.
87.
WiersmaLD.Conceptualization and development of the sources of enjoyment in youth sport questionnaire. Measure Phys Educ Exerc Sci2001;
5: 153–177.
88.
CopeEBaileyRPearceG.Why do children take part in, and remain involved in sport?: implications for children’s sport coaches. Int J Coach Sci2013;
7: 55–74.
89.
HellstedtJC.Early adolescent perceptions of parental pressure in the sport environment. J Sport Behav1990;
13: 135.
90.
BeiswengerKLGrolnickWS.Interpersonal and intrapersonal factors associated with autonomous motivation in adolescents’ after-school activities. J Early Adolescence2010;
30: 369–394.
91.
NtoumanisNTaylorIMThøgersen-NtoumaniC.A longitudinal examination of coach and peer motivational climates in youth sport: implications for moral attitudes, well-being, and behavioral investment. Dev Psychol2012;
48: 213–223.
92.
NtoumanisNBiddleSJ.A review of motivational climate in physical activity. J Sports Sci1999;
17: 643–665.
93.
SmithALGustafssonHHassménP.Peer motivational climate and burnout perceptions of adolescent athletes. Psychol Sport Exerc2010;
11: 453–460.
94.
AdieJWDudaJLNtoumanisN.Perceived coach-autonomy support, basic need satisfaction and the well- and ill-being of elite youth soccer players: a longitudinal investigation. Psychol Sport Exerc2012;
13: 51–59.
95.
O’ConnorDLarkinPWilliamsAM.What learning environments help improve decision-making?Phys Educ nd Sport Pedagogy2017;
22: 647–660.
96.
SmithRESmollFLCummingSP.Effects of a motivational climate intervention for coaches on young athletes' sport performance anxiety. J Sport Exerc Psychol2007;
29: 39–59.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
