Discerning risk-takers from avoiders: Which teachers are more likely to support teaching about the violent past in Ambon,Indonesia?

Abstract

In 2005, Kitson and McCully introduced the ‘risk-taking’ continuum, representing the multiple ways in which teachers in post-conflict societies deal with the history of conflict in the classroom. ‘Avoiders’, at one extreme, refrain from teaching the violent past, while at the other extreme ‘risk-takers’ analyse multiple perspectives on what happened and why. Since their seminal study, scholars have increasingly studied the challenges and opportunities related to teaching the violent past. Yet, so far no study has empirically tested and applied the continuum. Drawing on a survey of 558 secondary school teachers in post-conflict Ambon, Indonesia, we analyse the proportion and characteristics of ‘risk-takers’ as compared to ‘avoiders’. Our results show that ‘risk-takers’ represent a slim majority. While ‘risk-taking’ is associated with political interest and higher levels of education, teachers who suffered much harm during the conflict, whose students belong to a religious group other than theirs and/or those who think conflict causes have been addressed are less supportive of conflict history teaching.

Keywords

Ambon Indonesia peace education reconciliation risk-taking continuum teachers and teaching

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbey

Wansink

BGJ

(2022) Brokers of multiperspectivity in history education in post-conflict societies. Journal of Peace Education 19: 67–90.

Adam

(2010) How ordinary folk became involved in the Ambonese conflict: Understanding private opportunities during communal violence. Bijdragen tot de taal-, land- en volkenkunde / Journal of the Humanities and Social Sciences of Southeast Asia 166(1): 25–48.

Alpha Amirrachman

(2014) Education in the conflict-affected Moluccas local tradition, identity politics and school principal leadership. South East Asia Research 22(4): 561–578.

Al Qurtuby

(2015) Christianity and militancy in Eastern Indonesia: Revisiting the maluku violence. South Asian Studies 4(2): 313–339.

Al Qurtuby

(2016) Religious Violence and Conciliation in Indonesia: Christians and Muslims in the Moluccas. New York: Routledge.

Ansori

Sukandar

Peranto

, et al. (2014) Post-Conflict Segregation, Violence, and Reconstruction Policy in Ambon. The Habibie Institute. Available at: https://www.neliti.com/publications/45147/post-conflict-segregation-violence-and-reconstruction-policy-in-ambon (accessed 12 August 2020).

Barron

(2019) When Violence Works: Postconflict Violence and Peace in Indonesia. Cornell University Press. Available at: https://muse.jhu.edu/book/64328 (accessed 6 August 2020).

Barron

Jaffrey

Varshney

(2016) When large conflicts subside: The ebbs and flows of violence in postsuharto Indonesia. Journal of East Asian Studies 16(2): 191–217.

Bar-Tal

Harel

(2002) Teachers as agents of political influence in the Israeli high schools. Teaching and Teacher Education 18(1): 121–134.

10.

Bar-Tal

Rosen

(2009) Peace education in societies involved in intractable conflicts: Direct and indirect models. Review of Educational Research 79(2): 557–575.

11.

Bar-Tal

Oren

Nets-Zehngut

(2014) Sociopsychological analysis of conflict-supporting narratives. Journal of Peace Research 51(5): 662–675.

12.

Barton

McCully

(2007) Teaching controversial issues. . . Where controversial issues really matter. Teaching History 127: 13–19.

13.

Barton

McCully

(2005) History, identity, and the school curriculum in Northern Ireland: An empirical study of secondary students’ ideas and perspectives. Journal of Curriculum Studies 37(1): 85–116.

14.

Bellino

Paulson

Anderson Worden

(2017) Working through difficult pasts: Toward thick democracy and transitional justice in education. Comparative Education 53(3): 313–332.

15.

Bentrovato

(2017) History textbook writing in post-conflict societies: From battlefield to site and means of conflict transformation. In: Psaltis

Carretero

Čehajić-Clancy

(eds) History Education and Conflict Transformation. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.37–76.

16.

Bentrovato

Wassermann

(2018) Mediating transitional justice: South Africa’s TRC in history textbooks and the implications for peace. Global Change Peace & Security 30(3): 335–351.

17.

Bertrand

(2004) Democratization and religious and nationalist conflict in post-Suharto Indonesia. In: Henders

(ed) Democratization and Identity: Regimes and Ethnicity in East and Southeast Asia. Plymouth: Lexington Books, pp.17–200.

18.

Bräuchler

(2019) From transitional to performative justice: Peace activism in the aftermath of communal violence. Global Change Peace & Security 31(2): 201–220.

19.

Carter

(2007) Teacher Preparation for peace-building in United States of America and Northern Ireland. In: Bekerman Z and McGlynn C (eds) Addressing Ethnic Conflict Through Peace Education. New York: Palgrave Macmillan US, pp.245–258.

20.

Chhabra

(2017) Text and Contexts: Pedagogical Practices for a History Textbook Lesson on the 1947 British India Partition. In: Elmersjö

HÅ

Clark

Vinterek

(eds) International Perspectives on Teaching Rival Histories. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK, pp.87–106.

21.

Clarke-Habibi

(2018) Teachers’ perspectives on educating for peace in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Journal of Peace Education 15(2): 144–168.

22.

Cole

(2007) Transitional Justice and the reform of history education. International Journal of Transitional Justice 1(1): 115–137.

23.

Cole

(2017) No Legacy for Transitional Justice Efforts Without Education. International Center for Transitional Justice: New York, NY, USA.

24.

Cole

Barsalou

(2006) Unite or Divide? The Challenges of Teaching History in Societies Emerging From Violent Conflict. Washington, DC: United States Institute of Peace. Available at: https://www.usip.org/publications/2006/06/unite-or-divide-challenges-teaching-history-societies-emerging-violent (accessed 26 August 2020).

25.

Davies

(2016) The politics of peace education in post-conflict countries. In: Langer A and Brown GK (eds) Building Sustainable Peace. New York City: Oxford University Press, pp.181–199, 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198757276.003.0011

26.

Davies

(2017) Justice-sensitive education: The implications of transitional justice mechanisms for teaching and learning. Comparative Education 53(3): 333–350.

27.

De Baets

(2015) Post-conflict history education moratoria: A balance. World Studies in Education 16(1): 5–30.

28.

DiStefano

Zhu

Mindrila

(2009) Understanding and using factor scores: Considerations for the applied researcher. Practical Assessment, Research, and Evaluation 14(1): 20.

29.

Ernas

(2012) Policy of social conflict resolution: Implementation of the Malino agreement in Maluku. Journal of Government and Politics 3(2): 297–324.

30.

Field

(2014) Discovering Statistics Using IBM SPSS Statistics, 5th edn. London: SAGE Publications, Inc.

31.

Gellman

(2015) Teaching silence in the schoolroom: Whither national history in Sierra Leone and El Salvador? Third World Quarterly 36(1): 147–161.

32.

Goldberg

(2017) The official, the empathetic and the critical: Three approaches to history teaching and reconciliation in Israel. In: Psaltis

Carretero

Čehajić-Clancy

(eds) History Education and Conflict Transformation. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.277–299.

33.

Goss

(2000) Understanding the “Maluku Wars”: Overview of sources of communal conflict and prospects for peace. Cakalele 11: 7–39.

34.

Hair

Black

Babin

, et al. (2006) Multivariate Data Analysis, 6th edn. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Inc.

35.

Harris

Clarke

(2011) Embracing diversity in the history curriculum: A study of the challenges facing trainee teachers. Cambridge Journal of Education 41(2): 159–175.

36.

Karim

(2018) Ambon: A regime of pluralism and compromise. In: Bayo

Santoso

Samadhi

(eds) Search of local regime in Indonesia: Enhancing democratisation in Indonesia. Jakarta: Yayasan Pustaka Obor Indonesia, pp.261–288. Available at: http://obor.or.id/index.php?route=product/product&product_id=794&search=in+search+of+local+regime+in+Indonesia (accessed 12 August 2020).

37.

Kello

Wagner

(2017) History teaching as ‘Propaganda’? Teachers’ communication styles in post-transition societies. In: Psaltis

Carretero

Čehajić-Clancy

(eds) History Education and Conflict Transformation. Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp.201–230.

38.

Khairunisa

Wahab

(2019) Synergy between character education and local wisdom. Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research 326(ICCIE 2018): 64–70.

39.

Kitson

McCully

(2005) You hear about it for real in school.’ Avoiding, containing and risk-taking in the history classroom. Teaching History 120(120): 32–37.

40.

Klein

(2017) Preparing to teach a slavery past: History teachers and educators as navigators of historical distance. Theory & Research in Social Education 45(1): 75–109.

41.

Komara

Hendriana

Suherman

(2021) The roles of Character Education in 21St Century Learning. Journal of Educational Experts 4(1): 10–17. Available at: http://journal.kopertis-4.org/index.php/jee/article/view/119

42.

Korostelina

(2015) Reproduction of conflict in history teaching in Ukraine: A social identity theory analysis. Identity 15(3): 221–240.

43.

Korthagen

FAJ

Kessels

Koster

, et al. (2001) Linking Theory and Practice: The Pedagogy of Realistic Teacher Education. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

44.

Kuppens

Langer

(2016) To address or not to address the violent past in the classroom? That is the question in Côte d’Ivoire. Journal of Peace Education 13(2): 153–171.

45.

Kuppens

Langer

(2020) Reconciling before educating? Narratives of conflict and peace among teachers in Côte d’Ivoire. International Journal of Intercultural Relations 76: 37–51.

46.

Lauritzen

Nodeland

(2017) What happened and why? Considering the role of truth and memory in peace education curricula. Journal of Curriculum Studies 49(4): 437–455.

47.

McCully

(2012) History teaching, conflict and the legacy of the past. Education Citizenship and Social Justice 7(2): 145–159.

48.

Panggabean

(2018) Konflik Dan Perdamaian Etnis Di Indonesia. Tangerang Selatan: PT Pustaka Alvabet.

49.

Paulson

(2015) “Whether and How?” History Education about Recent and Ongoing Conflict: A Review of Research. Available at: https://archive.nyu.edu/handle/2451/39649 (accessed 7 August 2020).

50.

Paulson

Bellino

(2017) Truth commissions, education, and positive peace: An analysis of truth commission final reports (1980–2015). Comparative Education 53(3): 351–378.

51.

Ramírez-Barat

Duthie

(2015) Education and Transitional Justice: Opportunities and Challenges for Peacebuilding. Available at: https://www.ictj.org/sites/default/files/ICTJ-UNICEF-Report-EducationTJ-2015.pdf (accessed 12 August 2020).

52.

Sakki

Pirttilä-Backman

A-M

(2019) Aims in teaching history and their epistemic correlates: A study of history teachers in ten countries. Pedagogy Culture and Society 27(1): 65–85.

53.

Salomon

Nevo

(2002) Peace Education: The Concept, Principles, and Practices around the World. New York, NY: Psychology Press.

54.

Sayed

Carrim

Badroodien

, et al. (2018) Learning to Teach in Post-Apartheid South Africa – ‘Student Teachers’ Encounters with Initial Teacher Education ( Y

Sayeded

). Stellenbosch: African Sun Media.

55.

Schulze

(2017) The “ethnic” in Indonesia’s communal conflicts: Violence in Ambon, Poso, and Sambas. Ethnic and Racial Studies 40(12): 2096–2114.

56.

Shepler

Williams

(2017) Understanding Sierra Leonean and Liberian teachers’ views on discussing past wars in their classrooms. Comparative Education 53(3): 418–441.

57.

Skårås

(2021) Teaching and learning the most recent history in divided societies emerging from conflict: A review of the literature through the lens of social justice. Journal of Peace Education 18(3): 282–308.

58.

Statistics of Ambon Municipality (2019) Kota Ambon Dalam Angka 2019. Available at: https://ambonkota.bps.go.id/publication/2019/08/16/d461752245c4953ec943cce5/kota-ambon-dalam-angka-2019.html (accessed 6 August 2020).

59.

Supriatna

(2011) Indonesia’s Issues and Challenges on Teacher Professional Development. CICE Series. Hiroshima. Available at: https://cice.hiroshima-u.ac.jp/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/4-2-41.pdf (accessed 19 March 2020).

60.

Tajima

(2014) The Institutional Origins of Communal Violence: Indonesia’s Transition from Authoritarian Rule. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOI: 10.1017/CBO9781139235716.

61.

Tawil

Harley

(2004) Education and Identity-based Conflict: Assessing curriculum policy for social and civic reconstruction. Education, Conflict and Social Cohesion. Geneva. Available at: http://www.ibe.unesco.org/fileadmin/user_upload/archive/conflict/educ_ind_01.pdf (accessed 19 August 2020).

62.

The World Bank ( 2014) The Indonesia Database for Policy and Economic Research (INDO-DAPOER). Available at: https://datacatalog.worldbank.org/search/dataset/0041056 (accessed 20 August 2020).

63.

Tibbitts

Weldon

(2017) History curriculum and teacher training: Shaping a democratic future in post-apartheid South Africa? Comparative Education 53(3): 442–461.

64.

Turner

(2006) Competing Myths of Nationalist Identity: Ideological Perceptions of Conflict in Ambon, Indonesia. Perth, Australia: Murdoch University. Available at: https://researchrepository.murdoch.edu.au/id/eprint/374/ (accessed 19 March 2020).

65.

van Klinken

(2001) The Maluku wars: Bringing Society back in. Indonesia 71(71): 1–26.

66.

van Klinken

(2007) Communal Violence and Democratization in Indonesia: Small Town Wars, 1st edn. New York: Routledge.

67.

van Klinken

(2014) Ale Rasa beta Rasa. In: Manuputty

Salampessy

Ali-Fauzi

(eds) CARITA ORANG Basudara; Kisah-Kisah Perdamaian Dari Maluku, 1st edn. Jakarta: Lembaga Antar Iman Maluku, pp.1–427.

68.

Weinstein

Freedman

Hughson

(2007) School voices: Challenges facing education systems after identity-based conflicts. Education, Citizenship and Social Justice 2(1): 41–71.

69.

Yogev

(2012) The image of the 1967 war in Israeli history textbooks as test case: Studying an active past in a protracted regional conflict. Oxford Review of Education 38(2): 171–188.

70.

Zembylas

Charalambous

(2016) Peace Education in a Conflict-Affected Society. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

71.

Zembylas

Kambani

(2012) The teaching of controversial issues during elementary-level history instruction: Greek-Cypriot teachers’ perceptions and emotions. Theory & Research in Social Education 40(2): 107–133.

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.03 MB

0.01 MB