Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2009-05
Clinical supervision for nurses working in mental health settings in Queensland,Australia: a randomised controlled trial in progress and emergent challenges
Several national and state-based inquiry documents have reported long-standing and major concerns about mental health service provision in Australia. In particular, accounts of the difficult circumstances that surround the recruitment and retention of high-quality mental health nurses have clearly emerged, independent of jurisdiction. However, the privately experienced cost of working and coping in contemporary mental health settings, especially when the resilience of nursing staff is tested remains poorly understood. Clinical supervision (CS), a structured staff support arrangement, has shown promise as a positive contribution to the clinical governance agenda and is now found reflected in central policy themes elsewhere in the world. However, the concept of CS remains underdeveloped in Australia. The background to a unique randomised controlled trial (RCT), currently in progress in Queensland, Australia, has been described in this study. The efficacy of the most widely adopted model of CS that may address the promotion of standards and clinical audit issues, the development of skills and knowledge and the personal well-being of the supervisee will be tested. This study, funded by the Queensland Treasury/Golden Casket Foundation, will focus not only on the outcomes for individual mental health nurses but also examine the quality of care they provide and the effects of both on patient outcomes. This study will seek to establish a sustainable, strategically significant contribution to the knowledge base both for the mental health nursing workforce in Queensland (and beyond) and the patients they seek to serve.
Aiken L Patrician P (2000) Measuring organizational traits of hospitals: the revised nursing work index . Nurs Res49: 146 – 153 .
2.
Allitt Inquiry (1991) Independent inquiry relating to the deaths and injuries on the children’s ward at Grantham and Kesteven General Hospital during the period February to April 1991.London , HMSO .
Australian Government (2007) Council of Australian Governments [COAG] National Action Plan on Mental Health2006-2011, Canberra .
5.
Australian Government (2008) National Mental Health Report 2007: Summary of Twelve Years of Reform in Australia’s Mental Health Services under the National Mental Health Strategy 1993-2005.Canberra : Commonwealth of Australia .
6.
Australian Health Ministers’ Advisory Council’s National Mental Health Working Group (1997) National Standards for Mental Health Services; endorsed by the AHMAC National Mental Health Working Group. National Mental Health Strategy.Canberra : Commonwealth of Australia .
7.
Australian Health Workforce Advisory Committee (2003) Australian Mental Health Nurse Supply, Recruitment and Retention. A joint project of the National Mental Health Working Group Australian Health Workforce Officials’ Committee and the Australian Health Workforce Advisory Committee. AHWAC Report 2003.2. December. Sydney.
8.
Bishop V (2008) Clinical governance and clinical supervision: protecting standards of care . J Res Nurs13: 3 – 5 (editorial).
9.
Brooker C White E (1997) The Fourth Quinquennial National Community Mental Health Nursing Census of England and Wales.Manchester: Universities of Manchester and Keele .
10.
C Bulman S Schutz (2004) Reflective Practice in Nursing.London : Blackwell Publishing .
11.
Butterworth T Bell L Jackson C Majda P (2008) Wicked spell or magic bullet? A review of the clinical supervision literature 2001–2007 . Nurse Educ Today28: 264 – 272 .
12.
Butterworth T Carson J Jeacock J White E Clements A (1999) Stress, coping, burnout and job satisfaction in British nurses: findings from the clinical supervision evaluation project . Stress Med15: 27 – 33 .
13.
Butterworth T Carson J White E Jeacock J Clements A Bishop V (1997) Clinical Supervision and Mentorship. It is good to talk: an evaluation study in England and Scotland.University of Manchester .
14.
Clinton M (1999) Scoping Study of the Australian Mental Health Nursing Workforce 1999. Report from the Australian and New Zealand College of Mental Health Nurses.Canberra : Mental Health and Special Programs Branch of the Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care .
15.
Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care (2001) Measuring remoteness: Accessibility/Remoteness Index of Australia (ARIA), Octoberrevised ed.Canberra : Department of Health and Aged Care .
16.
Cronenwett L; (1997) A Multidisciplinary Measure of Perceptions of Unit Quality. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of North Carolina
17.
Davey B Desousa C Robinson S Murrells T (2006) The policy-practice divide. Who has clinical supervision in nursing . J Res Nurs11: 237 – 248 .
18.
Department of Health (1994) Independent inquiry relating to deaths and injuries on the children's ward at Grantham and Kesteven General Hospital. Clothier Report.London : HMSO .
19.
Department of Health (1999) Making a Difference: Strengthening the Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting Contribution to Health and Health Care.London : Department of Health .
20.
Department of Health (2000) Making a Difference: Clinical Supervision in Primary Care.London : Department of Health .
21.
Department of Health and Ageing (2008) Presentation by Ms L Racic, Director, Clinical Services Reform, Mental Health Branch, Department of Health and Ageing, to the Primary Mental Health Care Division National Forum, 12 June. Canberra.
22.
Duncan-Grant A (2001) Clinical Supervision Activity Among Mental Health Nurses: a Critical Organizational Ethnography.Portsmouth : Nursing Praxis International .
23.
Edwards D Burnard P (2003) A systematic review of stress and stress management interventions for mental health nurses . J Adv Nurs42: 169 – 200 .
24.
Faugier J Butterworth T (1994) Clinical Supervision: A Position Paper.School of Nursing Studies. Manchester: The University of Manchester .
25.
Foddy W (1993) Constructing Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires: Theory and Practice in Social Research.Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
26.
Goldberg D Williams P (1988) A Users Guide to the General Health Questionnaire.Windsor : NFER-Nelson .
27.
Goldstein H Rasbash J Plewis I Draper D Browne W Yang M (1998) A user's guide to MLwiN.London : Institute of Education .
28.
Goodwin I Holmes G Cochrane R Mason O (2003) The ability of adult mental health services to meet clients’ attachment needs: the development and implementation of the Service Attachment Questionnaire . Psychol Psychother76: 145 – 161 .
29.
Greene J (1968) The psychiatric nurse in the community . Int J Nurs Stud5: 175 – 183 .
30.
Hallberg I Norberg A (1993) Strain among nurses and their emotional reactions during 1 year of systematic Clinical Supervision with the implementation of individualised care in dementia nursing . J Adv Nurs18: 1860 – 1875 .
31.
Holsti O (1969) Content analysis for the Social Sciences and Humanities.Massachusetts : Addison-Wesley .
32.
Hoot S (2002) Trials, tribulations and triumphs of Mental Health Nursing. Tenth Annual Oration. The 28th Australian & New Zealand College of Mental Health Nurses Annual Conference. Powerhouse Museum, Sydney. ANCMHN, Greenacres, South Australia.
33.
Lauder W Reynolds W Reilly V Angus N (2000) The development and testing of the mental health problems perception questionnaire . J Psychiatr Ment Health Nurs7: 221 – 226 .
34.
Maslach C Jackson S (1986) The Maslach Burnout Inventory. Palo Alto, California University: Consulting Psychologists Press.
35.
Mental Health Council of Australia (2005) Not for Service: Experiences of injustice and despair in mental health care in Australia.Canberra : Mental Health Council of Australia .
36.
Milne D (2007) An empirical definition of clinical supervision . Br J Clin Psychol46: 437 – 447 .
37.
Moore S; (1961) A psychiatric outpatient nursing service. Ment Health Bull, Summer.
38.
Moutoussis M Gilmour J Barker D Orrell M (2000) Quality of care in a psychiatric out-patient department . J Ment Health9: 409 – 420 .
39.
National Mental Health Education and Training Advisory Group (2002) National Practice Standards for the Mental Health Workforce. September.Canberra : Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing .
40.
Norusis M (1986) The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences, Version 16.SPSS , Chicago .
41.
NSWHealth (2007) NSW Drug and Alcohol Clinical Supervision Guidelines.Sydney : New South Wales Health Department .
42.
Open University (1998) K509: Clinical Supervision: a development pack for nurses. Milton Keynes: OU Press.
43.
Proctor B (1986) Supervision: a cooperative exercise in accountability. In: M Marken M Payne (eds) Enabling and Ensuring: Supervision in Practice.Leicester : National Youth Bureau and Council for Education and Training in Youth and Community Work .
44.
Queensland Government (2005) Queensland Government Action Plan.Brisbane : Queensland Government .
45.
Roxon N; (2008) The Grace Groom Memorial Lecture. Camberra: National Press Club.
46.
Russell L (2008) An Analysis of the 2008/9 Health Budget.Sydney : Menzies Centre for Health Policy .
47.
Senate Community Affairs References Committee (2002) The Patient Profession: Time for Action.Canberra : Commonwealth of Australia .
48.
UKCC (1996) Position statement on clinical supervision for Nursing and Health Visiting. London: United Kingdom Central Council for nursing, midwifery and health visiting.
49.
Ware J Kosinski M Dewey J Gandek B (2001) A Manual for Users of the SF-8 Health Survey. Boston, MA: Quality Metric, Inc., Lincoln , RI and Health Assessment Laboratory .
50.
Wetherington H Hahn R Fuggua-Whitely DS Sipe TA Crosby AE Johnson RL Task Force on Community Preventive Services. (2008) The effectiveness of interventions to reduce psychological harm from traumatic events among children and adolescents; a systematic review . Am J Prev Med35: 287 – 313 .
51.
White E (1986) Factors influencing General Practitioners to refer patients to community psychiatric nurses (Chapter 12). In: J Brooking (ed), Psychiatric Nursing Research.Chichester : Wiley .
52.
White E (1990) Community Psychiatric Nursing: The 1990 National Survey.Bradford : CPNA Publications .
53.
White E (1996) Clinical Supervision and Project 2000: the identification of some substantive issues . Nurs Times Res1: 102 – 111 .
54.
White E; (2003) Work and profession. Invited workshop. World Psychiatric Association [Section of Epidemiology and Public Health]. Paris, France. July.
55.
White E (2003a) Patient safety and staff support; the sine qua non of high quality mental health service provision. In: Treatment Protocol Project (2003) Acute Inpatient Psychiatric Care: A Source Book (Chapter 13). Sydney, Australia: World Health Organisation Collaborating Centre for Evidence in Mental Health Policy.
56.
White E (2003b) The struggle for methodological orthodoxy in nursing research; the case of mental health . Int J Ment Heal Nurs12: 88 – 95 .
57.
White E; (2008) Interview with Charmaine Kane, ABC Radio News. Broadcast at 06.30 on 19 August, 2008.
58.
White E Brooker E (1997) The Fourth Quinquennial National Community Mental Health Nursing Census of Northern Ireland. Final Report to the Department of Health and Social Services, Belfast , Northern Ireland. Universities of Manchester and Keele .
59.
White E Butterworth T Carson J Jeacock J Clements A (1998) Clinical Supervision: insider reports of a private world . J Adv Nurs28: 185 – 192 .
60.
White E Riley E Davies S Twinn S (1993) A detailed study of the relationship between teaching, support, supervision and role modelling in clinical areas, within the context of Project 2000 courses.Final Report. English National Board for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting [now the Nursing and Midwifery Council], London .
61.
White E Roche M (2006) A selective review of mental health nursing in New South Wales, Australia, in relation to Clinical Supervision . Int J Ment Heal Nurs15: 209 – 219 .
62.
White E Winstanley J (2004) Mental health nursing and clinical supervision . Health Law Can24: 43 – 47 .
63.
White E Winstanley J (2006) Cost and resource implications of Clinical Supervision: an Australian perspective . J Nurs Manage14: 1 – 9 .
64.
Williamson G Dodds S (1999) The effectiveness of a group approach to clinical supervision in reducing stress: a review of the literature . J Clin Nurs8: 338 – 344 .
65.
Winstanley J (2001) Developing methods for evaluation Clinical Supervision. In: J Cutcliffe T Butterworth B Proctor (eds), Fundamental themes in Clinical Supervision.London : Routledge .
66.
Winstanley J Barnes M (2007) An online survey of nurses and midwives in Queensland. In preparation.Queensland : University of the Sunshine Coast .
67.
Winstanley J White E (2002) Clinical Supervision: models, measures and best practice.Greenacres, South Australia : Australian and New Zealand College of Mental Health Nurses .
68.
Yegdich T (2001) An Australian perspective on clinical supervision. In: J Cutcliffe T Butterworth B Procter (eds), Fundamental Themes in Clinical Supervision.London : Routledge .
