Understanding management gurus and historical narratives: The benefits of a historic turn in management and organization studies

Abstract

A historic turn in organization studies requires a basic theoretical understanding of ‘doing history’ and an appreciation of the centrality of narrative in history. Following the cultural turn in history, narrativist historians and philosophers of history such as Hayden White, Frank Ankersmit and Paul Ricoeur have made the case that narrative is an essential and unavoidable component in history. We demonstrate the persuasive capacity of narrative through a narrativist critique of three best-selling ‘management gurus’. This analysis illustrates the following: (1) the narrative features of popular organizational theories; (2) the basis of the success of guru literature; and (3) why gurus and organizational scientists themselves do not understand the narratological mechanisms behind their success. Finally, we maintain that historical narrativism offers the possibility for positioning organizational history as a highly relevant field for management academics, gurus and even managers, providing support for a historic turn.

Keywords

historiography management gurus management fashions methodology historical narrativism new cultural history historical theory practical relevance

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abrahamson

1996. ‘Management Fashion.’ The Academy of Management Review 21(1): 254–85.

Abrahamson

Fairchild

1999. ‘Management Fashion: Lifecycles, Triggers, and Collective Learning Processes.’ Administrative Science Quarterly 44(4): 708–40.

Amatori

2009. ‘Business History: State of the Art and Controversies.’ Enterprises et histoire 55(2): 11–23.

Andersen

1985. ‘A Spunky Tycoon Turned Superstar.’ Time Magazine, 1 April, pp. 30–9. Available at: http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,141447,00.html (accessed February 2012).

Ankersmit

F. R.

1983. Narrative Logic: A Semantic Analysis of the Historian’s Language. The Hague: Nijhoff.

Ankersmit

F. R.

1984. Denken over geschiedenis: Een overzicht van moderne geschiedfilosofische opvattingen. Groningen: Wolters-Noordhoff.

Ankersmit

F. R.

2001. Historical Representation. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

Ankersmit

F. R.

2006. ‘Analytische Politieke Geschiedenis.’ In Kossmann Instituut. Benaderingen van de geschiedenis van politiek, edited by Voerman

Wolffram

D. J.

(pp. 55–61). Groningen: Kossmann Institute.

Ashplant

T. G.

2004. ‘Anecdote as Narrative Resource in Working-Class Life Stories.’ In Narrative and Genre: Contexts and Types of Communication, edited by Chamberlain

Thompson

(pp. 99–113). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

10.

Berghoff

2008. ‘Wozu Unternehmensgeschichte? Erkenntnisinteressen, Forschungsansätze und Perspektiven des Faches.’ Zeitschrift für Unternehmensgeschichte 49(2): 131–48.

11.

Bevir

2000. ‘Narrative as Form of Explanation.’ Disputatio 9(November): 10–18.

12.

Booth

Rowlinson

2006. ‘Management and Organizational History: Prospects.’ Management & Organizational History 1(1): 5–30.

13.

Brady

F. N.

1997. ‘Finding a History for Management.’ Journal of Management Inquiry 6(2): 144–59.

14.

Burke

2005. History and Social Theory. Cambridge: Polity.

15.

Burke

2008. What is Cultural History Now? Cambridge: Polity.

16.

Burrell

1997. Pandemonium: Towards a Retro-Organization Theory. London: SAGE

17.

Business Week, 1984. ‘Oops! Who’s Excellent Now?’ Business Week, 5 November, pp. 46–54.

18.

Carr

2008. ‘Narrative Explanation and its Malcontents.’ History and Theory 47(2): 19–30.

19.

Carroll

D. T.

1983. ‘A Disappointing Search for Excellence.’ Harvard Business Review 61(6): 78–88.

20.

Clark

Rowlinson

2004. ‘Treatment of History in Organisation Studies: Towards an “Historic Turn”?’ Business History 46(3): 331–52.

21.

Clark

Greatbatch

2004. ‘Management Fashion as Image-Spectacle: The Production of Best-Selling Management Books.’ Management Communication Quarterly 17(3): 396–424.

22.

Clark

Salaman

1998. ‘Telling Tales: Management Gurus’ Narratives and the Construction of Managerial Identity.’ Journal of Management Studies 35(2): 137–61.

23.

Collins

2004. Organisational Change: Sociological Perspectives. London: Routledge.

24.

Collins

2007. Narrating the Guru: In Search of Tom Peters. London: Routledge.

25.

Collins

2001. Good to Great. Why some Companies Make the Leap… and Others Don’t. New York: HarperCollins.

26.

Collins

2005. Level 5 Leadership: The Triumph of Humility and Fierce Resolve. Harvard Business Review 83(7/8): 136–46.

27.

Costea

Crump

Holm

2006. ‘Conceptual History and the Interpretation of Managerial Ideologies.’ Management & Organizational History 1(2): 159–75.

28.

Courtney

Thompson

1996. City Lives: The Changing Voices of British Finance. London: Methuen.

29.

Cox

J. W.

Hassard

2007. ‘Ties to the Past in Organization Research: A Comparative Analysis of Retrospective Methods.’ Organization 14(4): 475–97.

30.

Cummings

Bridgman

2011. ‘The Relevant Past: Why the History of Management Should Be Critical of our Future.’ Academy of Management Learning & Education 10(1): 77–93.

31.

Czarniawska

1997. Narrating the Organization: Dramas of Institutional Identity. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

32.

Czarniawska

1998. A Narrative Approach to Organization Studies. London: SAGE.

33.

Czarniawska

Rhodes

2006. ‘Strong Plots: Popular Culture in Management Practice and Theory.’ In Management Education and Humanities, edited by Gagliardi

Czarniawska

(pp. 195–221). Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

34.

Dauenhauer

2008. ‘Paul Ricoeur.’ Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Available at: http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2008/entries/ricoeur (accessed February 2012).

35.

de Haan

2004. Politieke reconstructie: Een nieuw begin in de politieke geschiedenis. Utrecht: University of Utrecht.

36.

Delahaye

Booth

Clark

Procter

Rowlinson

2009. ‘The Genre of Corporate History.’ Journal of Organizational Change Management 22(1): 27–48.

37.

Down

2001. ‘Knowledge Sharing Review: The Use of History in Business and Management, and some Implications for Management Learning.’ Management Learning 32(3): 393–410.

38.

Drukker

J. W.

2006. The Revolution that Bit its own Tail: How Economic History Changed our Ideas on Economic Growth. Amsterdam: Aksant.

39.

Dufy

B. K.

1992. ‘Foreword.’ In Ronald Reagan: The Great Communicator, edited by Ritter

Henry

(pp. xiii–xvii). New York: Green Wood Press.

40.

Economist, The. 1994. ‘Management Theorists: Tom Peters, Performance Artist.’ The Economist, 24 September, p. 73.

41.

Elton

G. R.

2002. The Practice of History. Oxford: Blackwell.

42.

Førland

T. E.

2008. ‘Mentality as a Social Emergent. Can the Zeitgeist have Explanatory Power?’ History and Theory 47(2): 44–56.

43.

Fridenson

2008. ‘Business History and History.’ In The Oxford Handbook of Business History, edited by Jones

Zeitlin

(pp. 9–37). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

44.

Gabriel

2000. Storytelling in Organizations: Facts, Fictions and Fantasies. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

45.

Galambos

2003. ‘Identity and the Boundaries of Business History: An Essay on Consensus and Creativity.’ In Business History around the World, edited by Amatori

Jones

(pp. 11–30). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

46.

Greatbatch

Clark

2005. Management Speak: Why We Listen to What Management Gurus Tell Us. London: Routledge.

47.

Grint

1994. ‘Reengineering History: Social Resonances and Business Process Reengineering.’ Organization 1(1): 179–201.

48.

Guthey

Clark

Jackson

2009. Demystifying Business Celebrity. London: Routledge.

49.

Hage

2008. ‘Zetsche hat es begriffen.’ Manager Magazine, 25 February. Available at: http://www.manager-magazin.de/unternehmen/artikel/0,2828,536888,00.html (accessed February 2012).

50.

Hansen

P. H.

2007. ‘Organizational Culture and Organizational Change: The Transformation of Savings Banks in Denmark, 1965–1990.’ Enterprise & Society 8(4): 920–53.

51.

Hawranek

2004. ‘Tag der Abrechnung.’ Der Spiegel, 5 April, pp. 82–6.

52.

Hesse

J.-O.

leinschmidt

Lauschke

2002. ‘Einleitung: Herausforderungen und Perspektiven der Unternehmensgeschichte.’ In Kulturalismus, Neue Institutionenökonomik oder Theorienvielfalt: Eine Zwischenblianz der Unternehemensgeschichte, edited by Hesse

J.-O.

Kleinschmidt

Lauschke

(pp. 9–19). Essen: Klartext.

53.

Hobsbawm

1997. On History. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson.

54.

Hood

2005. ‘The Word, the Movement, the Science.’ In Oxford Handbook Public Management, edited by Ferlie

Lynn

L. E.

Pollitt

(pp. 7–26). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

55.

Huczynski

1993. Management Gurus. What Makes Them and How to Become One. London: Routledge.

56.

Huizinga

1950. ‘Over een definitie van het begrip geschiedenis.’ In Geschiedwetenschap/Hedendaagsche cultuur: Verzameld werk vii, by Huizinga

Johan

(pp. 95–103). Haarlem: Tjeenk Willink & Zonen.

57.

Iacocca

1985. Iacocca: An Autobiography. Toronto: Bantam.

58.

Iggers

G. G.

1997. Historiography in the Twentieth Century: From Scientific Objectivity to the Postmodern Challenge. Middletown, CT: Weslyan University Press.

59.

Jackson

2001. Management Gurus and Management Fashion: A Dramatistic Inquiry. London: Routledge.

60.

Jacques

R. S.

2006. ‘History, Historiography and Organization Studies: The Challenge and the Potential.’ Management & Organizational History 1(1): 31–49.

61.

Jardine

2010. The Aftermath of Homo Ludens: From Huizinga to Zemon Davis and Beyond. 39th Huizinga Lecture, 10 December, Leiden, the Netherlands.

62.

Karsten

Keulen

Kroeze

Peters

2009. ‘Leadership Style and Entrepreneurial Change: The Centurion Operation at Philips Electronics.’ Journal of Organizational Change Management 22(1): 73–91.

63.

Keulen

Kroeze

2011. De leiderschapscarrousel: Waarom iedere tijd zijn eigen leider vraagt. Amsterdam: Boom.

64.

Kieser

1994. ‘Why Organization Theory Needs Historical Analyses – and How This Should be Performed.’ Organization Science 5(4): 608–20.

65.

Kieser

1997. ‘Rhetoric and Myth in Management Fashion.’ Organization 4(1): 49–74.

66.

Kocka

1995. ‘Bodenverluste und Chancen der Wirtschaftsgeschichte.’ Vierteljahrschrift für Sozial- und Wirtschafstgeschichte 82(4): 501–4.

67.

Koselleck

2004. Futures Past: On the Semantics of Historical Time. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

68.

Lipartito

2008. ‘The Future of Alfred Chandler.’ Enterprise and Society 9(3): 430–2.

69.

Lorenz

1998. ‘Can Histories Be True? Narrativism, Positivism, and the “Metaphorical Turn”.’ History and Theory 37(3): 309–29.

70.

Lorenz

2008. De constructie van het verleden. Een inleiding in de theorie van de geschiedenis. Amsterdam: Boom.

71.

Lorenz

2011. ‘History and Theory.’ In The Oxford History of Historical Writing, edited by Schneider

Woolf

(pp. 13–35). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

72.

McClain

1997. ‘Top 100 Monographic Records in OCLC Libraries.’ Available at: http://www.oclc.org/research/top1000/monographs97.htm (accessed February 2012).

73.

Maynes

M. J.

Pierce

J. L.

Laslett

2008. Telling Stories: The Uses of Personal Narratives in the Social Sciences and History. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

74.

Miller

Hartwick

2002. ‘Spotting Management Fads: What Makes Them so Popular is What Undermines Them in the End.’ Harvard Business Review 80(10): 26–7.

75.

Miller

Hartwick

Le Breton-Miller

2004. ‘How to Detect a Management Fad – and Distinguish It from a Classic.’ Business Horizons 47(4): 7–16.

76.

Munslow

2002. ‘Where Does History Come From?’ History Today 52(3): 18–21.

77.

Munslow

2003. The New History. Harlow: Pearson Education.

78.

Nora

1986. Lieux de Mémoire. Volume II: La Nation. Paris: Gallimard.

79.

Palonen

2003. Quentin Skinner. History, Politics, Rhetoric. Cambridge: Polity Press.

80.

Papaikonomou

2009. ‘Good to Great… or Just Lucky?.’ Available at: http://www.happen.com/index.php/home/articles/39-good-to-great-or-just-lucky (accessed February 2012).

81.

Partner

2009. ‘Narrative Persistence: The Postmodern Life of Narrative Theory.’ In Re-figuring Hayden White, edited by Ankersmit

Domańska

Kellner

(pp. 81–105). Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.

82.

Passmore

2011. ‘History and Social Science in the West.’ In The Oxford History of Historical Writing, edited by Schneider

Woolf

(pp. 199–219). Oxford: Oxford University Press.

83.

Pedersen

2004. ‘What is Political History Now?’ In What is History Now?, edited by Cannadine

(pp. 36–57). Houndsmill: Palgrave MacMillan.

84.

Perks

2010a. ‘Corporations Are People Too! Business and Corporate Oral History in Britain.’ Journal of the Oral History Society 38(1): 36–54.

85.

Perks

2010b. ‘The Roots of Oral History: Exploring Contrasting Attitudes to Elite, Corporate, and Business Oral History in Britain and the US.’ The Oral History Review 37(2): 215–24.

86.

Peters

1994. The Pursuit of Wow! Every Person’s Guide to Topsy-Turvy Times. New York: Vintage Books.

87.

Peters

2001. ‘Tom Peters’ True Confessions.’ Fast Company 53(11): 80–9. Available at: http://www.fastcompany.com/magazine/53/peters.html (accessed February 2012).

88.

Peters

Austin

1985. A Passion for Excellence: The Leadership Difference. New York: Random House.

89.

Peters

Waterman

R. H.

1982. In Search of Excellence: Lessons from America’s Best-Run Companies. New York: Harper & Row.

90.

Peters

Waterman

R. H.

2004. In Search of Excellence: Lessons from America’s Best-Run Companies. London: Profile Books.

91.

Pierenkemper

2000. Unternehmensgeschichte: Eine Einführung in ihre Methoden und Ergebnisse. Stuttgart: Steiner.

92.

Reagan

1980. ‘Presidential Nomination Acceptance Speech.’ 17 July. Available at: http://www.presidency.ucsb.edu/ws/index.php?pid=25970 (accessed February 2012).

93.

Reagan

1985. ‘Remarks at the AT&T Technologies Plant in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma.’ 5 June. Available at: http://www.reagan.utexas.edu/archives/speeches/1985/60585a.htm (accessed February 2012).

94.

Ricoeur

1984. Time and Narrative. Volume I. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

95.

Ricoeur

1994. Oneself as Another. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

96.

Rowlinson

Hassard

2011. Historical Methods in Management and Organization Studies. Gothenburg: European Group for Organizational Studies.

97.

Rowlinson

Procter

, 1999. ‘Organizational Culture and Business History.’ Organization Studies 20(3): 369–96.

98.

Scranton

2008. ‘Beyond Chandler.’ Enterprise and Society 9(3): 426–9.

99.

Sewell

W. H.

2005. Logics of History: Social Theory and Social Transformation. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

100.

Siegenthaler

1999. ‘Geschichte und Ökonomie nach der kulturalistischen Wende.’ Geschichte und Gesellschaft 25(2): 276–301.

101.

Skinner

2002. Visions on Politics. Volume I: Regarding Method. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

102.

Taylor

Bell

Cooke

2009. ‘Business History and the Historiographical Operation.’ Management & Organizational History 4(2): 151–66.

103.

te Velde

2005. ‘Moeizaam fietsen met de wind mee: Wim Kok in het politiek bestuur.’ In Met Kok, edited by de Rooy

te Velde

(pp. 97–149). Amsterdam: Wereldbibliotheek.

104.

Thomas

A. B.

1989. ‘One-Minute Management Education: A Sign of the Times?’ Management Learning 20(1): 23–38.

105.

Toms

Wilson

2010. ‘In Defence of Business History: A Reply to Taylor, Bell and Cooke.’ Management & Organizational History 5(1): 109–20.

106.

Tosh

2010. The Pursuit of History: Aim, Methods and New Directions in the Study of Modern History. Harlow: Longman.

107.

Troy

2005. Morning in America: How Reagan Invented the 1980s. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

108.

van Duin

2007. Tegen de Geschiedenis: Pleidooi voor een toekomstgerichte samenleving. Delft: Eburon.

109.

Watson

T. J.

2004. ‘Managers, Managism, and the Tower of Babble: Making Sense of Managerial Pseudojargon.’ International Journal for Sociology of Language 166: 67–82.

110.

Watson

T. J.

2009. ‘Narrative Life Story and the Management of Identity: A Case Study in Autobiographical Identity Work.’ Human Relations 62(3): 1–28.

111.

Watson

T. J.

Bargiela-Chiappini

1998. ‘Managerial Sensemaking and Occupational Identities in Britain and Italy.’ Journal of Management Studies 35(3): 285–301.

112.

Weick

K. E.

1995. Sensemaking in Organizations. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.

113.

White

1973. Metahistory. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.