Restricted accessReview articleFirst published online 2022-6
Defining breast cancer awareness and identifying barriers to breast cancer awareness for women with an intellectual disability: A review of the literature
Incidence rates for developing breast cancer are similar for women regardless of intellectual ability. However, women with an intellectual disability present with advanced breast cancers, which often have a poor prognosis.
Method:
A structured narrative review of the literature was performed to explore the concepts of breast awareness and breast cancer awareness and subsequently, identify barriers to breast cancer awareness encountered by women with an intellectual disability.
Results:
A total of 22 studies involving people with varying levels of intellectual disability informed this review. The barriers to breast cancer awareness encountered by women with an intellectual disability include: lack of their understanding, the role of the carer and literacy issues.
Conclusion:
Identifying the barriers to breast cancer awareness for women with an intellectual disability will help to facilitate breast cancer awareness which has the potential to result in better long-term outcomes through an early diagnosis of breast cancer.
AbbottSMcConkeyR (2006) The barriers to social inclusion as perceived by people with intellectual disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities10(3): 275–287.
2.
AlbuquerqueCPCarvalhoAC (2020) Identification of needs of older adults with intellectual disabilities. Journal of Policy and Practice in Intellectual Disabilities17(2): 123–131.
3.
AllenTLVan GroningenBJBarksdaleDJ, et al. (2010) The breast self-examination controversy: what providers and patients should know. The Journal for Nurse Practitioners6(6): 444–451.
AnothaisintaweeTWiratkapunCLerdsitthichaiP, et al. (2013) Risk factors of breast cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Asia-Pacific Journal of Public Health25(5): 368–387.
7.
BalajiS (2014) Breast cancer screening: options beyond the mammogram. Harvard Women’s Health Watch8: 3–4.
8.
BatesCTriantafyllopoulouP (2019) Exploring the impact of mental capacity on breast screening for women with intellectual disabilities. Health and Social Care in the Community27: 880–888.
9.
BergstromHElinderLSWihlmanU (2014) Barriers and facilitators in health education for adults with intellectual disabilities – a qualitative study. Health Education Research29(2): 259–271.
ByrnesKHamiltonSMcGeechanGJ, et al. (2020) Attitudes and perceptions of people with a learning disability, family carers, and paid carer workers towards cancer screening programmes in the United Kingdom: a qualitative systematic review and meta-aggregation. Journal of the Psychological, Social and Behavioral Dimensions of Cancer29(3): 475–484.
12.
ChaoCAHuangLVisvanathanK, et al. (2020) Understanding women’s perspectives on breast cancer is essential for cancer control: knowledge, risk awareness, and care-seeking in Mwanza, Tanzania. BMC Public Health20(930): 1–11.
13.
CibulkaN (2011) Update on breast cancer screening. The Journal for Nurse Practitioners7(1): 67–68.
14.
CobigoVOuellette-KuntzHBaloghR, et al. (2013) Are cervical and breast cancer screening programmes equitable? The case of women with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research57(5): 478–488.
15.
ColdmanAPhilipsN (2011) Population studies of the effectiveness of mammographic screening. Preventative Medicine53(3): 115–117.
16.
CollinsKMcClimensAMeKonnenS, et al. (2014) Breast cancer information and support needs for women with intellectual disabilities: a scoping study. Psycho-Oncology23(8): 892–897.
DaviesNDuffM (2001) Breast cancer screening for older women with intellectual disability living in community group homes. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research45(3): 253–257.
19.
De WinterCFBastiaanseLPHilgenkamoTIM, et al. (2012) Overweight and obesity in older people with intellectual disability. Research in Developmental Disabilities33: 398–405.
20.
DordevicMGlumbicNBrojcinB (2016) Paralinguistic abilities of adults with intellectual disability. Research in Developmental Disabilities48: 211–219.
21.
ForbatLMcCannL (2010) Adults with intellectual disabilities affected by cancer: critical challenges for the involvement agenda. European Journal of Cancer Care19(1): 91–97.
22.
ForbesLMcNaughton NichollsCLinsellL, et al. (2010) Involving users in the design of a Randomised controlled trial of an intervention to promote early presentation in breast cancer: qualitative study. BMC Medical Research Methodology10(110): 1–8.
23.
GattiMEJacobsonKLGazmararianJA, et al. (2009) Relationships between beliefs about medications and adherence. American Journal of Health-System Pharmacy66: 657–664.
24.
GotzschePJorgensenK (2013) Screening for breast cancer mammography. Cochrane Database of Systematic Review6: 1–59.
25.
HaakinsonDJStuckyCHDueckAC, et al. (2010) A significant number of women present with palpable breast cancer even with a normal mammogram within 1 year. The American Journal of Surgery200: 712–718.
26.
HannaLMTaggartLCousinsW (2011) Cancer prevention and health promotion for people with intellectual disabilities: an exploratory study of staff knowledge. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research55(3): 281–291.
27.
HarmerV (2008) Breast cancer. Part 1: awareness and common benign diseases. British Journal of Nursing17(15): 950–955.
28.
HarrisRYeattsJKinsingerL (2011) Breast cancer screening for women aged 50-69 years: a systematic review of observational evidence. Preventative Medicine53: 108–114.
29.
HayesJRichardsonAFramptonC (2013) Population attributable risks for modifiable lifestyle factors and breast cancer in New Zealand women. Internal Medicine Journal1198–1204.
30.
HockMF (2012) Effective literacy instruction for adults with specific learning disabilities: implications for educators. Journal of Learning Disabilities45(1): 64–78.
31.
HsiehKRimmerJHHellerT (2014) Obesity and associated factors in adults with intellectual disability. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research58(9): 851–863.
32.
Institute of Medicine (2004) Health Literacy: A Prescription to End Confusion. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Irish Cancer Society (2014) Understanding Cancer of the Breast. Dublin: Nursing Services of the Irish Cancer Society.
35.
JatoiI (2011) The impact of advances on the efficacy of mammography screening. Preventative Medicine53: 103–104.
36.
KaushalAMcCormickKWarburtonF, et al. (2019) Promoting breast cancer awareness in older women during the seasonal flu vaccination campaign. British Journal of Nursing28(1): 43–49.
37.
KennerleyJ (2015) What’s best for the breast?KaiTiaki Nursing New Zealand21(4): 26.
38.
KharboushIFIsmailHMKandilAA, et al. (2011) Raising the breast health awareness amongst women in an urban slum area in Alexandria, Egypt. Breast Care6: 375–379.
39.
KratzkeCVilchisHAmatyaA (2013) Breast cancer prevention knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors among college women and mother-daughter communication. Journal of Community Health38(3): 560–568.
40.
LalorARedmondR (2009) Breast screening for post-menopausal women. Learning Disability Practice12(9): 28–33.
41.
Lauby-SecretanLScocciantiCLoomisD, et al. (2015) Breast cancer screening-viewpoint of the IARC Working Group. The New England Journal of Medicine372(24): 2353–2358.
42.
LinsellLForbesLBurgessC, et al. (2010) Validation of a measurement tool to assess awareness of breast cancer. European Journal of Cancer46: 1374–1381.
43.
MacArthurCAKonoldTRGluttingJJ, et al. (2010) Reading component skills of learners in adult basic education. Journal of Learning Disabilities43(2): 108–121.
44.
MacBrideMPruthiSBeversT (2012) The evolution of breast self-examination to breast awareness. Breast Journal18(6): 641–643.
45.
ManningMDuricNLittrupP, et al. (2013) Knowledge of breast density and awareness of related breast cancer risk. Journal of Cancer Education28: 270–274.
46.
MarmotMGAltmanDGCameronDA, et al. (2013) The benefits and harms of breast cancer screening: an independent review. British Journal of Cancer108: 2205–2240.
47.
McIlfatrickSTaggartLTruesdale-KennedyM (2011) Supporting women with intellectual disabilities to access breast cancer screening: a healthcare professional perspective. European Journal of Cancer Care20: 412–420.
48.
MellardDFPattersonMB (2008) Contrasting adult literacy learners with and without specific learning disabilities. Remedial and Special Education29(3): 133–144.
NelsonHZakherBCantorA, et al. (2012) Risk factors for breast cancer for women aged 40 to 49 years. Annals of Internal Medicine156: 635–648.
52.
OldrieveWWaightM (2013) Enabling access to information by people with learning disabilities. Tizard Learning Disability Review18(1): 5–15.
53.
O’LearyLCooperSAHughes-McCormackL (2018) Early death and causes of death of people with intellectual disabilities: a systematic review. Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities31: 325–342.
54.
O’MahonyMComberHFitzgeraldT, et al. (2017) Interventions for raising breast cancer awareness in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews2: 1–34.
55.
ParishSLRoseRALukemK, et al. (2012) Cancer screening knowledge changes: results from a randomised control trial of women with development disabilities. Research on Social Work Practice22(1): 43–53.
56.
PeaceyVSteptoeADavidsdottitS, et al. (2006) Low levels of breast cancer risk awareness in young women: an international survey. European Journal of Cancer42: 2585–2589.
57.
PechlivaniEVivilakiV (2012) Breastfeeding and breast cancer. Health Science Journal6(4): 610–617.
58.
PerryNBroedersMDe WolfC, et al. (2006) European guidelines for quality assurance in breast cancer screening and diagnosis, 4th edn. Luxembourg: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities.
59.
PlourdeNBrownHKVigodS, et al. (2018) The association between continuity of primary care and preventative cancer screening in women with intellectual disability. American Journal on Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities123(6): 499–513.
60.
RaineyLVan der WaalDJervaeusA, et al. (2020) European women’s perceptions of the implementation and organisation of risk based breast cancer screening and prevention: a qualitative study. BMC Cancer20(247): 1–12.
61.
ReesG (2011) Increasing access to cancer screening programmes. Learning Disability Practice14(7): 14–19.
62.
ReidyMDenieffeSForanS (2014) Cancer screening in women with intellectual disabilities: an Irish perspective. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities18(1): 50–60.
63.
ReidyMDenieffeSForanS (2018) Exploring breast cancer and screening awareness among Irish women with intellectual disabilities. British Journal of Learning Disabilities46: 193–201.
64.
RuddyKGelberSTamimiR, et al. (2014) Breast cancer presentation and diagnostic delays in young women. Cancer120(1): 20–25.
65.
RyanAMCushenSSchellekensH, et al. (2015) Poor awareness of risk factors for cancer in Irish adults: results of a large survey and review of the literature. The Oncologist20: 372–378.
66.
SatgeDAxmonATretarreB, et al. (2020) Cancer diagnoses among older people with intellectual disability compared with the general population: a national register study. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research64(8): 579–588.
67.
SatgeDSauleauEAJacotW, et al. (2014) Age and stage at diagnosis: a hospital series of 11 women with intellectual disability and breast carcinoma. BioMed Central Cancer14(150): 1–6.
68.
SeatonMBMuracaLDevaneyJ, et al. (2018) “I want to help, but what do you do in a situation like that?” Health care providers’ qualitative perspectives on working with disabled women in breast cancer screening. Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Services49: 383–389.
69.
SemiglazovVPMoiseyenkoVMManikhasAG, et al. (1999) Interim results of a prospective randomised study of self-examination for early detection of breast cancer. VoprOnkol45: 265–271.
70.
ShermanSMLaneEL (2015) Awareness of risk factors for breast, lung and cervical cancer in a UK Student Population. Journal of Cancer Education30: 660–663.
71.
SwaineJGParishSLLukenK (2013) Breast and cervical cancer screening for women with intellectual disabilities. Health & Social Work38(3): 183–186.
72.
SwaineJGParishSLLukenK, et al. (2014) Test of an intervention to improve knowledge of women with intellectual disabilities about cervical and breast cancer screening. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research58(7): 651–663.
73.
TaggartLTruesdale-KennedyMMcIlfatrickS (2011) The role of community nurses and residential staff in supporting women with intellectual disability to access breast screening services. Journal of Intellectual Disability Research55(1): 41–52.
74.
TazhibiMFeiziA (2014) Awareness levels about breast cancer risk factors, early warning signs, screening and therapeutic approaches among Iranian adult women: a large population based study using latent class analysis. BioMed Research InternationalAvailable at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/306352(accessed 5 November 2015).
75.
ThomasDBGaoDLRayRM, et al. (2002) Randomized trial of breast self-examination in Shanghai: final results. Journal of the National Cancer Institute94(19): 1445–1457.
76.
ThorntonHPillarisettiRR (2008) Breast awareness and breast self-examination are not the same. What do these terms mean? Why are they confused? What can we do?European Journal of Cancer44: 2118–2121.
77.
Truesdale-KennedyMTaggartLMcIlfatrickS (2011) Breast cancer knowledge among women with intellectual disabilities and their experiences of receiving breast mammography. Journal of Advanced Nursing67(6): 1294–1304.
78.
WalshSO’MahonyMLehaneE, et al. (2021) Cancer and breast cancer awareness interventions in an intellectual disability context: a review of the literature. Journal of Intellectual Disabilities25(1): 131–145.
79.
WilkinsonJGreenwoodNTierney-WangC, et al. (2014) Measuring staff empowerment regarding health care for clients with intellectual disabilities. International Journal of Family Medicine2014: 1–6.
80.
WilkinsonJECerretoMC (2008) Primary care for women with intellectual disabilities. Journal of the American Board of Family Medicine21(3): 215–222.
81.
WilkinsonJEDeisCEBowenDJ, et al. (2011) ‘It’s’ easier said than done’: perspectives on mammography from women with intellectual disabilities. Annals of Family Medicine9(2): 142–147.
82.
WillisD (2013) Breast screening: participation of women with intellectual disabilities. Learning Disability Practice16(4): 24–26.
83.
WillisD (2016) What influences women with intellectual disabilities to attend breast screening? Experiences of women who have and have not participated. British Journal of Learning Disabilities44: 269–276.
84.
WilsonJF, (2003) The crucial link between literacy and health. Annals of Internal Medicine139: 875–878.
85.
WilsonLFPageANDunnNA, et al. (2013) Population attributable risk of modifiable risk factors associated with invasive breast cancer in women aged 45-69 years in Queensland. Maturitas76: 370–376.
86.
WyattDTalbotP (2013) What knowledge and attitudes do paid carers of people with a learning disability have about cancer?European Journal of Cancer Care22: 300–307.
87.
YensenJ (2013) Pico search strategies. Online Journal of Nursing Informatics17(3). Available at: http://ojni.org/issues/?p=2860(accessed 2 October 2015).
88.
ZeinomarNRMoslehiR (2013) The effectiveness of a community-based breast cancer education intervention in the New York state capital region. Journal of Cancer Education28: 466–473.
