The aim of this study was to gain service user and social care staff perspectives on
the barriers facing people with intellectual disabilities when accessing primary
healthcare. A qualitative mixed methods semi-structured approach involved the use of
focus groups and individual interviews within the service users' homes. A purposive
sampling strategy identified people using primary healthcare in the last 6 months
(N = 6) with support from social care staff (N = 19). Three
emergent themes were common to service users and carer staff: `accessing the
surgery', `communication issues' and `waiting around'. Other themes were unique to
each group. Social care staff identified the `attitudes and behaviour of primary
healthcare staff' as sometimes problematic, and the importance of `knowing the
service user'. Service users identified `feelings about going to the doctor',
`health education' and `making changes'. Gaining these views is an important first
step in improving access to primary healthcare.
Band, R.
(1998) The NHS: Health for All?London :
MENCAP.
2.
Beange, H.
,
Lennox, N.
&
Parmenter, T.
(1999)
`Health Targets for People with an Intellectual Disability'
, Journal of Intellectual and Developmental Disability24: 283-98.
3.
Bond, L.
,
Kerr, M.
,
Dunstan, F.
&
Thapar, A.
(1997)
`Attitudes of General Practitioners towards Health Care for People with
Intellectual Disability and the Factors Underlying These Attitudes'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41: 391-400.
4.
Burns, N.
&
Grove, S.
(2003) Understanding Nursing Research, 3rd
edn. Philadelphia, PA:
Saunders .
5.
Carey, M.
(1994) `The Group Effect in Focus Groups: Planning,
Implementing and Interpreting Focus Group Research', in
B. Morse
(ed.) Critical Issues in Qualitative Research Methods .
London:
Sage.
6.
Cooper, S.
(1997)
`Deficient Health and Social Services for Elderly People with Learning
Disabilities'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41: 331-8.
7.
Crabtree, B.
,
Yanoshik, M.
,
Miller, W.
& O'
Connor, P.
(1993) `Selecting Individual or Focus Group Interviews'
, in
D. Morgan
(ed.) Successful Focus Groups. Newbury Park,
CA: Sage.
8.
Department Of Health
(2001) Valuing People: A New Strategy for Learning Disability
for the 21st Century . London:
HMSO.
9.
Disability Rights Commission
(2004) EqualTreatment: Closing the Gap. Background Evidence
for the DRC's Formal Investigation into Health Inequalities Experienced by
People with Learning Disabilities or Mental Health Problems.
London: Disabilities Rights
Commission.
10.
Espie, C.
&
Brown, M.
(1998)
`Health Needs and Learning Disabilities: An Overview'
, Health Bulletin56: 603-11.
11.
Fife Council & Nhs Fife
(2001) Fife Partnership in Practice.
Glenrothes: Fife Council
& NHS Fife.
12.
Fraser, M.
&
Fraser, A.
(2001)
`Are People with Learning Disabilities Able to Contribute to Focus Groups
on Health Promotion
?' Journal of Advanced Nursing33 (2):
225-33.
13.
Hassiotis, A.
(2002)
`Community Mental Heath Services for Individuals with Intellectual
Disabilities'
, Disability Management and Health Outcomes10: 409-17.
14.
Jansen, D.
,
Kroll, B.
,
Groothoff, J.
&
Post, D.
(2004)
`People with Intellectual Disability and their Health Problems: A Review of
Comparative Studies'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research48: 93-102.
15.
Kiernan, C.
&
Qureshi, H.
(1993) `Challenging Behaviour', in
C. Kiernan
(ed.) Research to Practice? Implications of Research on the Challenging
Behaviour of People with Learning Disability .
Clevedon: British Institute of
Learning Disabilities .
16.
Krueger, R.
(1994) Focus Groups: A Practical Guide for Applied
Research , 2nd edn.Thousand Oaks, CA
: Sage.
17.
Lennox, N.
&
Kerr, M.
(1997)
`Primary Healthcare and People with an Intellectual Disability: The
Evidence Base'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41: 365-72.
18.
Lennox, N.
,
Diggens, J.
&
Ugoni, A.
(1997)
`The General Practice Care of People with Intellectual Disability: Barriers
and Solutions'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41: 380-90.
19.
Lennox, T.
,
Nadkarni, J.
,
Moffat, P.
&
Robertson, C.
(2003)
`Access to Services and Meeting the Needs of People with Learning
Disabilities'
, Journal of Learning Disabilities7: 34-50.
20.
Lennox, N.
,
Taylor, M.
,
Rey-Conde, T.
,
Bain, C.
,
Purdie, D.
&
Boyle, F.
(2005)
`Beating the Barriers: Recruitment of People with Intellectual Disability
to Participate in Research'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research49: 296-305.
21.
Lindsey, M.
(2002)
`Comprehensive Health Care Services for People with Learning
Disabilities'
, Advances in Psychiatric Treatment8: 138-48.
22.
Mcgrowther, C.
,
Bhaumik, S.
,
Thorp, C.
,
Hauck, A.
,
Branford, D.
&
Watson, J.
(2006)
`Epilepsy in Adults with Intellectual Disabilities: Prevalence,
Associations and Service Implications'
, Seizure15: 376-86.
23.
Manthorpe, J.
,
Alaswzewski, A.
,
Gates, B.
,
Ayer, S.
&
Motherby, E.
(2003)
`Learning Disability Nursing: User and Carer Perceptions'
, Journal of Learning Disabilities7: 119-35.
Martin, D.
,
Roy, A.
&
Wells, M.
(1997)
`Health Gain through Health Checks: Improving Access to Primary Health Care
for People with Intellectual Disabilities'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research41: 401-8.
26.
Melville, C.
,
Finlayson, J.
,
Cooper, S.
,
Robinson, N.
,
Burns, E.
,
Martin, G.
ET AL. (2005) `
Enhancing Primary Health Care Services for Adults with Intellectual
Disabilities
', Journal of Intellectual Disability Research49 (3):
190-8.
27.
Mencap
(2004) Treat Me Right! Better Healthcare for People with a
Learning Disability. London:
MENCAP.
28.
Merriman, S.
,
Haw, C.
,
Kirk, J.
&
Stubbs, J.
(2005)
`Risk Factors for Coronary Heart Disease among Inpatients who have Mild
Intellectual Disabilities and Mental Illness'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research49: 309-16.
29.
NHS Executive
(1998) Signposts for Success in Commissioning and Providing
Health Services for People with Learning Disabilities.
London:
HMSO.
30.
NHS Executive
(1999) Once a Day .
London:
HMSO.
31.
NHS SDO
(2004) Access to Health Care for People with Learning
Disabilities. London : NHS
Service Delivery Organization.
32.
Ouelette-Kuntz, H.
,
Garcin, N.
&
Lewis, S.
(2004) Addressing Health Disparities through Promoting Equity
for Individuals with Intellectual Disabilities. Queen's
University: Healthcare Equity for Intellectually Disabled Individuals
Programme, Kingston,
Canada.
33.
Powrie, E.
(2003)
`Primary Health Care Provision for Adults with a Learning Disability'
, Journal of Advanced Nursing42: 413-23.
34.
Prasher, V.
&
Janicki, M.
(2002) Physical Health of Adults with Intellectual
Disabilities . Oxford:
Blackwell.
35.
Royal College Of Nursing
(2005) Meeting the Needs of People with Learning
Disabilities: Guidance for Nursing Staff.
London: Royal College of
Nursing.
36.
Scottish Executive
(1999) Towards a Healthier Scotland:AWhite Paper on
Health. Edinburgh : Stationery
Office.
37.
Scottish Executive
(2000) Same asYou:A Policy Review.
Edinburgh: Stationery
Office.
38.
Scottish Executive
(2002) Promoting Health, Supporting Inclusion:The National
Review of the Contribution of all Nurses to the Care and Support of People with
Learning Disabilities. Edinburgh:
Stationery Office.
39.
Scottish Health Advisory Service
(2002) A Review of Learning Disability Services in
Fife. Edinburgh : Scottish Health
Advisory Service.
40.
Stanley, B.
&
Standen, P.
(2001)
`Effect of Unexpected Outcomes and Causal Attributions on Key Workers'
Expectancies of Goal Attainment'
, Journal of Intellectual Disability Research45: 351-60.
41.
Stein, K.
&
Ball, D.
(1999)
`Contact between People with Learning Disability and General Practitioners:
A Cross Sectional Case Note Survey'
, Journal of Public Health Medicine21: 438-50.
42.
Tak, S.
,
Nield, M.
&
Becker, H.
(1999)
`Nursing Informatics: Use of a Computer Software Program for Qualitative
Analyses. Part 1: Introduction to NUD*IST'
, Western Journal of Nursing Research21 (1):
111-17.
43.
Tesch, R.
(1990) Qualitative Research, Analysis, Types and Software
Tools. New York:
Falmer.
44.
Van Schrojenstein Lantman-De Valk, H.
,
Metsemakers, J.
,
Soomers-Turlings , M.
,
Haveman, M.
&
Crebolder, H.
(1997) `
People with Learning Disabilities in General Practice: Case Definition and
Case Finding
', Journal of Intellectual Disabilities Research41: 373-9.
45.
Walmsley, J.
(2004) `
Involving Users with Learning Difficulties in Health Improvement: Lessons
from Inclusive Disability Research
', Nursing Inquiry11; 54-64.
