Thermal evaluation of a highly insulated steel stud wall with vacuum insulation panels using a guarded hot box apparatus

Abstract

This paper presents the results of a Guarded Hot Box (GHB) experiment on a wall assembly made up of both steel stud framing and an external insulating assembly which incorporates vacuum insulation panels (VIPs) for which knowledge of the composition of the VIP barrier foil is not readily available. The purpose of the tests is to provide an experiment result for thermal resistance of a wall assembly containing several sources of thermal bridging, including those due to the barrier foil at the edge of and joint material between the VIPs and the condensation potential on the interior surface due to the steel studs. The steady-state GHB experiments were completed in accordance with ASTM C1363 for an interior air temperature of 20.9°C and an exterior air temperature of −34.9°C; this resulted in a thermal resistance for the wall assembly of 6.8 ± 0.8 m² K/W. Surface temperature measurements on a VIP in the wall assembly indicated that increased levels of heat transfer were occurring at the edges of the VIPs as compared to the center of the panel confirming thermal bridges were present at the panel edge. Measurement of the temperature on the interior surface of the sheathing board around the steel stud indicated that the external insulation effectively minimized the risk of condensation due to the steel studs. Determining the thermal resistance and condensation risk for a wall assembly which contains VIPs for which knowledge of the barrier film is not readily available demonstrates the potential for use of such a wall assembly according to energy and building code requirements. The wall assembly and test details can also be used to compare industry standard calculation methods and detailed 2D and 3D simulations to the GHB test result. The comparison can be used to inform on the validity of using calculations and simulation methods in lieu of testing for energy and building code compliance. The comparison of calculations and simulations is not the scope of the work presented in this paper and will be explored in future publications.

Keywords

Guarded hot box vacuum insulation panels (VIP)thermal bridges steel stud

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ASHRAE (2011) RP-1365 Thermal Performance of Building Envelope Details for Mid- and High-Rise Buildings. Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE.

ASHRAE (2016a) ANSI/ASHRAE/IES Standard 90.1-2019—Energy Standard for Buildings Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings. Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE.

ASHRAE (2016b) ASHRAE Handbook of Fundamentals. Atlanta, GA: ASHRAE.

ASTM (2013) ASTM C 1363-Thermal Performance for Building Materials and Envelope Assemblies by Means of a Hot Box Apparatus. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International.

ASTM E2178-13 (2013) ASTM E2178-13—Standard Test Method for Air Permeance of Building Materials. West Conshohocken, PA: ASTM International.

Atsonios

Mandilaras

Kontogeorges

, et al. (2018) Two new methods for the in situ measurement of the overall thermal transmittance of cold frame lgihtweight steel-framed walls. Energy and Buildings 170: 183–194.

Atsonios

Mandilaras

Manolitsis

, et al. (2007) Experimental and numerical investigation of the energy efficiency of a lightweight steel framed building incorporating vacuum insulation panels. In: 6th international energy in buildings conference, Athens, EL, 21 October 2017. Athens, EL: ASHRAE Hellenic Chapter.

Biswas

Desjairlais

Smith

, et al. (2018) Development and tehrmal performance verification of composite insulation boards containing foam encapsulated vacuum insulation panels. Applied Energy 228: 1159–1172.

Doran

Gorgolewski

(2002) U-Values for Light Steel Frame Construction (Digest 465). Watford, UK: BRE.

10.

Ghazi Wakili

Nussbaumer

Bundi

(2005) Thermal performance of VIP assemblies in building constructions. In: 7th international vacuum insulation symposium, Duebendorf / Zurich, Switzerland, 28–29 September, pp.131–138.

11.

Government of Canada (2018) Pan-Canadian Framework on Clean Growth and Climate Change. Ottawa, Canada: Government of Canada.

12.

ISO 10211-07 (2007) Thermal bridges in building constructions—Heat flows and surface temepratures—Detailed Calculations. Geneva, CH: ISO.

13.

ISO 14683-07 (2007) Thermal bridges in building construction—Linear thermal transmittance—Simplified methods and default values. Geneva, CH: ISO.

14.

ISO 6946-07 (2007) Building components and building elements—Thermal resistance and thermal transmittance—Calculation method. Geneva, CH: Internation Organization for Standardization.

15.

Kontogeorgos

Atsonios

Mandilaras

(2016) Numerical investigation of the effect of vacuum insulation panels on the thermal bridges of a lightweight drywall envelope. Journal of Facade Design and Engineering 4(1–2): 3–18.

16.

Kosny

(1995) Comparison of thermal performance of wood stud and metal frame wall systems. Journal of Thermal Insulation and Budiling Envelopes 19(1): 59–71.

17.

Lorenzati

Fantucci

Capozzoli

, et al. (2014) The effect of different materials joint in vacuum insulation panels. Energy Procedia 62: 374–381.

18.

Mandilaras

Atsonios

Zannis

, et al. (2014) Thermal performance of a building envelope incorporating ETICS with vacuum insulation panels and EPS. Energy and Buildings 85: 654–665.

19.

Moffat

(1988) Describing the uncertainties in experimental results. Experimental and Thermal Science 1: 3–17.

20.

Morrison Hershfield (2014) Building Envelope Thermal Bridging Guide. Vancouver B.C.: BC Hydro Power Smart. https://morrisonhershfield.com/bpa_library/building-envelope-thermal-bridging-guide/

21.

Morrison Hershfield Ltd. (2011) Thermal Performance of Envelope Details for Mid- and High-Rise Buildings(1365-RP). Vancouver, BC, Canada: Morris and Hershfield Ltd.

22.

National Research Council (2015) National Building Code of Canada. Ottawa, ON: National Research Council Canada.

23.

National Research Council Canada (2016) National Energy Code for Buildings Canada. Ottawa, ON: National Research Council Canada.

24.

Nussbaumer

Bundi

Muehlebach

(2005) Thermal analysis of a wooden door system with integrated vacuum insulation panel. Energy and Buildings 37: 1107–1113.

25.

Nussbaumer

Ghazi Wakili

Tanner

(2006) Experimental and numerical investigation of thermal perfromance of a protected vacuum-insulation system applied to a concrete wall. Applied Energy 83: 841–845.

26.

Schwab

Stark

Wachtel

, et al. (2005) Thermal bridges in vacuum-insulated building facades. Journal of Thermal Envelope and Building Science 28(4): 345–355.

27.

Simmler

Brunner

Heinemann

, et al. (2005) Vacuum Insulation Panels—Study on VIP Components and Panels for Service Life Prediction in Building Applications (Subtask A). International energy agency. Switzerland: EMPA.

28.

Sprengard

Holm

(2014) Numerical examination of thermal bridging effects at the edges of vacuum insulation panels (VIP) in various constructions. Energy and Buildings 85: 638–643.

29.

Tenperik

Cauberg

(2007) Analytical models for calculating thermal bridge effects caused by thin high barrier envelopes around vacuum insulation panels. Journal of Building Physics 30(3): 185–215.

30.

United Nations (2015) Paris Agreement. Geneva, CH: United Nations.

31.

Van Den Bossche

Moens

Janssens

, et al. (2010) Thermal Performance of VIP Panels: Assessment of the Edge Effect by Experimental and Numerical Analysis. Ghent: Ghent University, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning.