Accuracy of Energy Analysis of Buildings: A Comparison of a Monthly Energy Balance Method and Simulation Methods in Calculating the Energy Consumption and the Effect of Thermal Mass

Abstract

The purpose of this article is to analyze the effects of thermal mass on heating and cooling energy in Nordic climate and for modern, well-insulated Nordic buildings. The effect of thermal mass is analyzed by calculations made by seven researchers and by seven different calculation programs. Six of these programs are simulation programs (Consolis Energy, IDA-ICE, SciaQPro, TASE, VIP, VTT House model) and one monthly energy balance method (maxit energy) based on the standard EN 832, which is the predecessor of ISO DIS 13790. It is purpose to evaluate the reliability of the monthly energy calculation method and especially its gain utilization factor compared with the simulation programs. In addition some sensitivity analysis concerning e.g., the effects of the size and the orientation of windows and the weather data on the energy consumption are made.The results show that the simplified standard methods of EN 832 and of ISO DIS 13790 generally give accurate results in calculating the annual heating energy, e.g., in the context of energy design and energy certification. However, the gain utilization factor of these standards is too low for very light buildings having no massive surfaces resulting in a too high energy consumption. The study shows, that the differences in input data cause often greater differences in calculation results than the differences between various calculation and simulation methods.

Keywords

buildings energy consumption thermal mass heat capacity simulation monthly calculation utilization factor.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aittomäki, A. and Kalema, T. (1976). TASE - A Computer Program for Energy Analysis of Buildings. Technical Research Centre of Finland (VTT), Laboratory of Heating and Ventilating, Report. (in Finnish).

Balaras, C.A. (1996). The role of thermal mass on the cooling load of buildings. An overview of computational methods, Energy and Buildings, 24: 1-10.

Corrado, V. and Fabrizio, E. (2006). A Simplified Calculation Method of the Annual Energy Use for Space Heating and Cooling: Assessment of the Dynamic Parameters for the Italian Building Stock and Climate. Research in Building Physics and Building Engineering - Fazio, Ge , Rao & Desmarais (eds) Taylor & Francis, London, pp. 645-651.

Corrado, V. and Fabrizio, E. (2007). Assessment of Building Cooling Energy Need Through a Quasi-steady State Model: Simplified Correlation for Gain-loss Mismatch , Energy and Buildings 39: 569-579.

Directive 2002/91/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2002 on the Energy Performance of Buildings (EPBD). Brussels 2002.

European standard EN 832 (1998). Thermal Performance of Buildings - Calculation of Energy Use for Heating - Residential Buildings, European Committee for Standardisation , Brussels, Belgium.

Finnish Building Regulations, Part C3, Thermal insulation of Buildings. Regulations (2003). Ministry of Environment, http://www.finlex.fi/data/normit/1919-C3s.pdf. Read 22.12. 2006.

Hietamäki, T. , Kuoppala, J.-M. , Kalema, T. and Taivalantti, K. (2003). Thermal Mass of Buildings. Central Studies and Their Results (in Finnish). Tampere University of Technology. Institute of Energy and Process Engineering. Report 174. p. 43.

IDA Indoor Climate and Energy 3.0 (2006). http://www.equa.se/eng.ice.html. Read 22.12.2006.

10.

ISO/DIS 13790 (2005). Thermal Performance of Buildings - Calculation of Energy Use for Space Heating and Cooling, ISO TC 163/SC 2, International Organization for Standardisation, Geneva.

11.

Johannesson, G. (1981). Active Heat Capacity. Models and Parameters for the Thermal Performance of Buildings. PhD Thesis. Report TVBH - 1003, Lund Institute of Technology, Sweden.

12.

Johannesson, G. (2005). Building Energy - A Practical Design Tool Meeting the Requirements of the EPBD, http://www.byv.kth.se/avd/byte/reykjavik/pdf/art_125.pdf. Read 22.12.2006.

13.

Jokisalo, J. and Kurnitski, J. (2005). Effect of the Thermal Inertia and Other Building and HVAC Factors on Energy Performance and Thermal Comfort in Finnish Apartment Buildings. Report B79, Helsinki University of Technology. Laboratory of Heating, Ventilating and Air-Conditioning. p. 58.

14.

Jokisalo, J. and Kurnitski, J. (2007). Performance of EN ISO 13790 Utilisation Factor Heat Demand Calculation Method in a Cold Climate, Energy and Buildings 39: 236-247.

15.

Kalema, T. (1992). Thermal Analysis of Buildings - Verification and Further Development of the TASE Program, Tampere University of Technology . Publication 87, p. 185.

16.

Kalema, T. and Martikainen, H. (1987). The effect of buildings' structures and the heat distribution system on the heating energy of a single-family house (in Finnish) . Report D:121, Ministry of trade and industry, Energy department. p. 92.

17.

Kalema, T. , Pylsy, P. , Hagengran, P. , Johannesson, G. , Airaksinen, M. , Dokka, T.H. , Oberg, M. , Pöysti, M. , Rapp, K. and Keski-Opas, J. (2006). Nordic Thermal Mass - Effect on Energy and Indoor Climate Tampere University of Technology, Report 184, p. 105.

18.

Lindberg, R. , Binamu, A. and Teikari, M. (2004). Five-Year Data of Measured Weather, Energy Consumption and Time-dependent Temperature Variations within Different Exterior Structures , Energy and Buildings 36: 495-501.

19.

Lomas, K.J. , Eppel, H. , Martin, C. and Bloomfield, D. (1994). Empirical Validation of Thermal Building Simulation Programs Using Test Room Data, Volume 1, Final Report. International Energy Agency, Annex 21 and Task 12. p. 34.

20.

Lomas, K.J. , Eppel, H. , Martin, C.J. and Bloomfield, D. (1997). Empirical validation of building energy simulation programs, Energy and Buildings 26: 253-275.

21.

Maxit energy 2.0 (2006). Calculation of the Net Space Heating Energy. maxit Oy Ab. Helsinki.

22.

Meteonorm (2005). Global Meteorological Database for Engineers, Planners and Education. Version 5.0. Meteotest, Switzerland. www.meteotest.ch

23.

The PASSYS Project Phase 1 (1989). Subgroup Simplified Design Tools. Final Report. 1986 - 1989. EUR 12998 EN. 081 - 89 - PASSYS - SDT - FP- 020. Commissioning of the European Communities. Directorate-General XII for Science, Research and Development. p. 208.

24.

Tuomaala, P. (2002). Implementation and Evaluation of Air Flow and Heat Transfer Routines for Building Simulation Tools, VTT Publications 471.

25.

van Dijk, H.A.L. and Arkesteijn, C.A.M. (1987). Windows and Space Heating Requirements; Parameter studies leading to a simplified calculation method. The Netherlands National Report on Activities within Step 5, TNO Institute of Applied Physics. International Energy Agency, Energy conservation in buildings and community systems programme, Annex XII, Windows and fenestration. p. 151.

26.

VIP+ (2002). Computer Program for Energy Balance Calculations, STRUSOFT, Malmö , Sweden.

27.

Yohanis, Y.G. and Norton, B. (1999). Utilization Factor for Building Solar-heat Gain for Use in a Simplified Energy Model, Applied Energy, 63: 227-239.