In Praise of Rebellion: Constituent Power and Dissent in the American Revolution

Abstract

In the context of the American Revolution, alongside the influential notion of constituent power advocated, for instance, by the Federalists, emerged an alternative and potent perspective about this concept. This perspective, which was particularly strong in revolutionary Pennsylvania, had at least two distinctive features. First, rather than limiting constituent power to a sort of ante-room of constitutional authority, this view conferred primacy to the constituent process over the institutional machinery. Second, instead of exclusively assigning the exercise of constituent power to a few specialists, this perspective invented ways for the multitude to exercise its power directly. This article examines this particular vision of constituent power. This investigation, as I argue, can both assist in demystifying some common assumptions entrenched in the concept of constituent power and provide insights for contemporary reflection on the limits of representative democracy.