The rise of Baidu,Alibaba and Tencent (BAT) and their role in China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI)

Abstract

The Chinese digital technology giants, Baidu, Alibaba and Tencent (BAT), dominate over their competitors in China across platforms that include e-commerce, digital entertainment, e-finance and artificial intelligence (AI). To understand BAT’s corporate power and their strategic role working with the government – in this case, their involvement in the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) – this paper unveils the capabilities of these three oligopolies and discusses their international expansion in relation to the BRI. The BRI is being constructed on two layers, the physical and digital infrastructure, and the BAT are contributing to the latter. This paper examines the interrelations between BAT and the state through case studies, observing the tensions and potential contradictions arising from the reliance of the Chinese state on the BAT to build digital infrastructure, while the BAT seek to minimize direct state regulation for their data-driven business models.

Keywords

BAT belt and road initiative digital capital platform capitalism soft power state power

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alibaba Research Center Institute (2016) The Rise of the New Economy: Alibaba 3 Trillion Business Logic (

新经济崛起:阿里巴巴3万亿的商业逻辑

). Beijing: Machinery Industry Press.

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2019) Digital Platforms Inquiry – Final Report. Canberra: ACCC.

Barr

Feklyunina

Theys

(2015) Introduction: The soft power of hard states. Politics 35(3–4): 213–215.

Berry

Farquhar

(2006) China on Screen: Cinema and Nation. New York: Columbia University Press.

Brown

(2017) The digitization of belt and road initiative (“一带一路”倡议的数字化), Observation. Available at: http://www.guancha.cn/RachelBrown/2017_06_16_413544.shtml (accessed April 2018).

Callahan

(2015) Identity and security in China: The negative soft power of the China dream. Politics 35(3–4): 216–229.

Chan

(2009) Remade in Hollywood: The Global Chinese Presence in Transnational Cinemas. Hong Kong: Hong Kong University Press.

Cheng

(2013) Robin Li and His Baidu World (

李彦宏和他的百度世界

). Shanghai: China Citic Press.

Cheng

(2016) Three questions on China’s “Belt and Road Initiative”. China Economic Review 40(1043–951X): 309–313.

10.

Chitty

(2015) Analysing soft power and public diplomacy. Jilin University Press – Social Science Edition 5(3): 20–27.

11.

Chiu

Lee

(2018) Empirical study of the usability and interactivity of an augmented-reality dressing mirror. Microsystem Technologies 24(10): 4399–4413.

12.

de Sola Pool

(1983) Technologies of Freedom. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

13.

Ding

(2015) Engaging diaspora via charm offensive and indigenised communication: An analysis of China’s diaspora engagement policies in the Xi Era. Politics 35(3–4): 230–244.

14.

Ding

(2017) Development of China digital creative industry, BIRTV2017 Keynote Speech (中国数字创意产业的发展——在BIRTV2017主题报告会上的演讲). Modern Television Technology 9(1671–8658): 26–28.

15.

Djankov

Miner

(2016) China’s Belt and Road Initiative: Motives, Scope and Challenges. Washington, DC: Peterson Institute for International Economics.

16.

Donald

Hong

Keane

(2002) Media in China: Consumption, Content and Crisis. London: Routledge.

17.

(2017) Chinese traditional culture and cultural confidence (中华优秀传统文化与文化自信), Discovery 2(1007–5194): 163–168.

18.

Edney

(2015) Building national cohesion and domestic legitimacy: A regime security approach to soft power in China. Politics 35(3–4): 259–272.

19.

Elkins

(2016) The USA: Geoblocking in a Privileged Market. Amserdam: Institute of Network Cultures.

20.

Fei

(2017) 2017 Internet Trends Report: BAT, Today’s Headlines Cover 77% of China Mobile Internet Usage’ (2017互联网趋势报告：BAT、今日头条占据了中国移动互联网77%的使用时长). China Economic Network, Available at: http://www.ce.cn/culture/gd/201706/01/t20170601_23372369.shtml (accessed May 2018).

21.

Feng

(2015) One Belt One Road: The Chinese Logic of Globolization (“一带一路”: 全球发展的中国逻辑). Beijing: China Democracy and Law Publishing House.

22.

Ferdinand

(2016) Westward Ho—the China dream and “one belt, one road”: Chinese foreign policy under Xi Jinping. International Affairs 92(4): 941–957.

23.

Flew

(2016) Entertainment media, cultural power, and post-globalization: The case of China’s international media expansion and the discourse of soft power. Global Media and China 1(4): 278–291.

24.

Flew

(2018a) Platforms on trial. Intermedia 46(2): 18–23.

25.

Flew

(2018b) Post-globalisation. Javnost – The Public 25(1–2): 102–109.

26.

Flew

(2019) Guarding the gatekeepers: Trust, truth and digital platforms. Griffith Review 64: 94–103.

27.

Foster

Azmeh

(2016) Digital latecomer economies and national internet policy: The case of China. The Internet, Policy and Politics, Oxford, Available at: http://ipp/.oii.ox.ac.uk/2016/programme-2016/track-a-politics/government-iiidigital-government-and/christopher-foster-shamel-azmeh-digital (accessed June 2018).

28.

Fuchs

(2016) Baidu, Weibo and Renren: the global political economy of social media in China. Asian Journal of Communication 26(1): 14–41.

29.

Gilbert

(2017) Think big. Chinese Business Law Journal, Available at: https://www.vantageasia.com/think-big/ (accessed June 2018).

30.

Green

Jenkins

(2009) The moral economy of Web 2.0: Audience research and convergence culture. In Holt

Perren

(eds) Media industries: History, Theory, and Method. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons, pp.213–225.

31.

Han

(2015) Yanhong Li: the Imagination of Baidu and AI (

李彦宏:百度与智能时代的畅想

). Beijing: China Real Press.

32.

Han

Zou

(2014) “One belt, one road”—The trade cooperation and prospects of China and West Asia countries’ (“一带一路” 背景下的中国与西亚国家贸易合作现状和前景展望). International Trade 3(1002–4999): 21–28.

33.

Hong

(2017) Networking China: The Digital Transformation of the Chinese Economy. Champaign: University of Illinois Press.

34.

iNEWS (2017) Baidu map fully upgraded, released ‘belt and road’ smart travel map (百度地图全面升级，发布“一带一路”智慧旅游地图). Sohu, Available at: http://www.sohu.com/a/211740912_613239 (accessed May 2018).

35.

Jenkins

Deuze

(2008) Convergence culture. Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies 14(1): 5–12.

36.

Jin

(2017) China lanuches large-scale acquisition of overseas logistics companies (中国大举收购海外物流公司). Chinese Financial Times, Available at: http://www.ftchinese.com/story/001075472 (accessed May 2018).

37.

Keane

(2016a) Going global or going nowhere? Chinese media in a time of flux. Media International Australia 159(1): 13–21.

38.

Keane

(2016b) Online entertainment, disconnecting, connecting, and reconnecting: How Chinese television found its way out of the box. International Journal of Communication 10(18): 5426–5443.

39.

Keane

Zhao

(2015) TV or not TV? Re-imagining screen content in China. In: Hjorth

Khoo

(eds) Routledge Handbook of New Media in Asia. New York: Routledge, pp. 299–307.

40.

(2016) Alibaba faces growing pressure over counterfeit goods. The New York Times, Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/22/business/alibaba-ustr-taobao-counterfeit.html?_ga=2.145013940.1236725906.1518663250-1573659397.1518663250 (accessed May 2018).

41.

(2017a) Pioneers of OBOR E-commerce, Alibaba releases “Big data report of online OBOR” (“一带一路”电商先行阿里巴巴发布《网上丝绸之路大数据报告》). China Economics Network, Available at: http://www.ce.cn/xwzx/gnsz/gdxw/201704/21/t20170421_22219354.shtml (accessed May 2018).

42.

(2017b) Beijing pushes for a direct hand in China’s big tech firms. The Wall Street Journal, Available at: https://www.wsj.com/articles/beijing-pushes-for-a-direct-hand-in-chinas-big-tech-firms-1507758314 (accessed June 2018).

43.

(2017c) Xi Jinpin talks about one belt one road (习近平谈“一带一路”). People’s Daily International Edition, Available at: http://www.china.com.cn/news/2017-04/12/content_40604682.htm (accessed May 2018).

44.

Liu

(2018a) Tencent and Dunhuang are joining hands, initiating the digital silk road (腾讯携手敦煌，开启数字丝绸之路). Tenyun, Available at: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/dKp-gRh2ReH4PxovQj7ahg (accessed May 2018).

45.

Liu

(2016) Language services support “belt and road” go far (语言服务支持"一带一路"且行且远). China Today, Available at: http://www.chinatoday.com.cn/chinese/economy/news/201606/t20160603_800058589.html (accessed May 2018).

46.

Liu

(2018b) Baidu “cultural heritage protection program” will land in more than 10 museums this year (百度“文化遗产守护者计划”年内落地10家以上博物馆). China News Network, Available at: http://www.chinanews.com/cul/2018/01-26/8434183.shtml (accessed June 2018).

47.

(2018) ‘Alibaba first announced counterfeit rate: Only 0.0149% (阿里巴巴首次公布平台商品疑似假货率: ’’仅’’万分之一点四九). The Paper, Available at: http://www.sohu.com/a/215798799_260616 (accessed May 2018).

48.

Menon

(2017) The unprecedented promises—and threats—of the belt and road initiative. The Wire, Available at: https://thewire.in/127579/the-unprecedented-promises-and-threats-of-the-belt-and-road-initiative/ (accessed June 2018).

49.

Miller

Kraidy

(2018) Global Media Studies. Cambridge: Polity.

50.

Montag

Zhao

Sindermann

, et al. (2018) Internet communication disorder and the structure of the human brain: Initial insights on WeChat addiction. Scientific Reports 8(1): 2155.

51.

(2017) Tencent translation service debut “belt and road” forum, as a strategic partner of “national translation team” (腾讯翻译君亮相“一带一路”论坛成“翻译国家队”战略合作伙伴), Leiphone, Available at: https://www.leiphone.com/news/201712/gGH8MXqFIXbfRJFG.html?viewType=weixin (accessed May 2018).

52.

Nye

(2004) Soft power. In: Nye

(ed.) Power in the Global Information Age. New York: Routledge, pp.76–88.

53.

Office of Belt and Road Initiative (2017) The accomplishment of OBOR during the years (“一带一路”这几年，我们都做了什么). Xinhua News Agency, Available at: https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/QiVDz9dHEK7WVqDZXlCxVQ (accessed May 2018).

54.

Parker

van Alstyne

Choudary

(2016) Platform Revolution. New York: W. W. Norton & Co.

55.

(2016) One belt, one road: Visions and challenges of China’s geoeconomic strategy. Mainland China Studies 59(1013–2716): 111–132.

56.

(2017) Tencent layout digital economy, building internet “belt and road” (腾讯企点布局数字经济，共赢互联网“一带一路”). Xinhua News Agency, Available at: http://www.xinhuanet.com/itown/2017-05/15/c_136285405.htm (accessed May 2018).

57.

Qin

(2017) Influential enterprises rank of OBOR releases, Alibaba ranked NO.1 in private enterprises (“一带一路”企业影响力排名公布，阿里巴巴排名民企第一). China Economic Network, Available at: http://www.ce.cn/xwzx/gnsz/gdxw/201710/16/t20171016_26547326.shtml (accessed August 2018).

58.

Rolland

(2017) China’s “belt and road initiative”: Underwhelming or game-changer? The Washington Quarterly 40(1530–9177): 127–142.

59.

Shambaugh

(2015) China’s soft-power push: The search for respect. Foreign Affairs 94(4): 99–107.

60.

Srnicek

(2016) Platform Capitalism. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons.

61.

(2019) Changing Dynamics of Digital Entertainment Media in China. Doctoral Dissertation, Queensland University of Technology.

62.

(2016) China’s Encounter with Global Hollywood: Cultural Policy and the Film Industry, 1994-2013. Lexington, Kentucky: University Press of Kentucky.

63.

Sun

(2017) Network pioneer of belt and road, Alibaba initiates a new era of foreign trade (一带一路”的网络先锋阿里巴巴开启外贸新时代), China Economic Weekly, Available at: http://finance.sina.com.cn/chanjing/gsnews/2017-04-17/doc-ifyeimqc4376243.shtml (accessed May 2018).

64.

Sun

(2015) Slow boat from China: Public discourses behind the ‘going global’ media policy. International Journal of Cultural Policy 21(4): 400–418.

65.

Swaine

(2015) Chinese views and commentary on the “one belt, one road” initiative. China Leadership Monitor 47(2): 3.

66.

Tencent (2017) Announcement of Tencent financial report on 2017 quarter one. Tencent, Available at: https://www.tencent.com/zhcn/articles/15000611495014502.pdf (accessed May 2018).

67.

van Dijck

Poell

de Waal

(2018) The Platform Society: Public Values in a Connected World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

68.

Wang

(2014) “Chinese dream” and national identity, cultural identity and value recognition (论“中国梦”与国家认同、文化认同、价值观认同). Academic Exploration 10(1006–723X): 15–18.

69.

Wang

(2017) One belt and one road: Remaking China and the world (“一带一路”:再造中国与世界). Journal of the Central Socialist College 3(1002–0519): 11–18.

70.

Wei

S-J

Xie

Zhang

(2017) From “made in China” to “innovated in China”: Necessity, prospect, and challenges. Journal of Economic Perspectives 31(1944–7965): 49–70.

71.

(2017) Tencent Biography From 1998 to 2016: The Evolution of China’s Internet Company (

腾讯传1998–2016:中国互联网公司进化论

). Hangzhou: Zhejiang University Press.

72.

Yan

(2017) “King of glory” or “King of poison”: Healthy games are more than anti-addiction (“王者荣耀”还是“王者农药”：健康游戏不止于防沉迷), Xinhua News Agency, Available at: http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/201707/07/c_1121284021.htm (accessed May, 2018).

73.

Yang

(2016) Baidu and Wei Zexi incident, the sins of the information platform (魏则西事件背后的百度信息平台的一场罪与罚). Sohu, Available at: http://www.sohu.com/a/72757474_115933 (accessed August 2018).

74.

Yuanzhijun

(2017) Pony Ma: WeChat popularization also has disadvantages, my eyesight has deepened 50 degrees (马化腾：微信普及也有弊端我的近视又加深了50度). Fenghuang Wang Finance, Available at: http://finance.ifeng.com/a/20171206/15847638_0.shtml (accessed August 2018).

75.

(2015a) The future path: “Entry level information platform + vertical information service”—critical thinking based on the development of media convergence (未来之路:“入口级信息平台+ 垂直型信息服务”——关于未来媒介融合发展主流模式的思考). News and Writing 8(1002–2295): 39–41.

76.

(2015b) Internet as a “higher dimension media”—“platform media” is the mainstream of future media (互联网是一种 “高维” 媒介”——兼论 “平台型媒体” 是未来媒介发展的主流模式). News and Writing 2(1002–2295): 41–44.

77.

Zhang

Dang

(2018) Alibaba silk road headquarters settled in xi’an “internet +” boost “belt and road” construction (阿里巴巴丝路总部落户西安 “互联网+”助力“一带一路”建设). China News Network, Available at: http://usstock.jrj.com.cn/2018/01/16192023956114.shtml (accessed May 2018).

78.

Zhao

Keane

(2013) Between formal and informal: The shakeout in China’s online video industry. Media, Culture & Society 35(6): 724–741.

79.

Zuboff

(2019) The Age of Surveillance Capitalism. New York: Public Affairs.