In this paper, we argue that a focus on favouritism magnifies a central ethical ambiguity in leadership, both conceptually and in practice. The social process of favouritism can even go unnoticed, or misrecognised if it does not manifest in a form in which it can be either included or excluded from what is (collectively interpreted as) leadership. The leadership literature presents a tension between what is an embodied and relational account of the ethical, on the one hand, and a more dispassionate organisational ‘justice’ emphasis, on the other hand. We conducted 23 semi-structured interviews in eight consultancy companies, four multinationals and four internationals. There were ethical issues at play in the way interviewees thought about favouritism in leadership episodes. This emerged in the fact that they were concerned with visibility and conduct before engaging in favouritism. Our findings illustrate a bricolage of ethical justifications for favouritism, namely utilitarian, justice, and relational. Such findings suggest the ethical ambiguity that lies at the heart of leadership as a concept and a practice.
AlvessonMRobertsonM (2006)
The best and the brightest: The construction, significance and effects of elite identities in consulting firms. Organization13(2): 195–224.
2.
AtincGDarratMFullerBet al. (2010)
Perceptions of organizational politics: A meta-analysis of theoretical antecedents. Journal of Managerial Issues22(4): 494–513.
3.
AvolioBBassB (1995)
Individual consideration viewed at multiple levels of analysis: A multi-level framework for examining the diffusion of transformational leadership. The Leadership Quarterly6(2): 199–218.
4.
BargeJKFairhurstGT (2008)
Living leadership: A systemic constructionist approach. The Leadership4(3): 227–251.
5.
BassB (1985) Leadership and Performance Beyond Expectations.
New York:
Free Press.
6.
BassBRiggioR (2006) Transformational Leadership.
Mahwah, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
7.
BassBStogdillR (1990) Handbook of Leadership (Vol. 11).
New York:
Free Press.
8.
Baudrillard J (1992) The Hyper-realism of Simulation' in Art in Theory 1900–1990: An Anthology of Changing Ideas, (eds.) Charles Harrison & Paul Wood. Stanford: SUP.
9.
BlakeRMoutonJ (1985)
How to achieve integration on the human side or the merger. Organizational Dynamics13(3): 41–56.
10.
BraunVClarkeV (2006)
Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology3: 77–102.
11.
BrymanA (2008)
Of methods and methodology. Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management: An International Journal3(2): 159–168.
12.
BrymanABellE (2011) Business Research Methods.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
13.
Burns JM (2003) Transforming leadership: A new pursuit of happiness (Vol. 213). Grove Press.
14.
CaseCManerJ (2014)
Divide and conquer: When and why leaders undermine the cohesive fabric of their group. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology107(6): 1033–1050.
15.
CharlesKHurstE (2003)
The correlation of wealth across generations. Journal of Political Economy111: 1155–1182.
16.
CollinsonD (2014)
Dichotomies, dialectics and dilemmas: New directions for critical leadership studies?Leadership10(1): 36–55.
17.
CoyneIT (1997)
Sampling in qualitative research. Purposeful and theoretical sampling; merging or clear boundaries?Journal of Advanced Nursing26(3): 623–630.
18.
CraftJL (2013)
A review of the empirical ethical decision-making literature: 2004–2011. Journal of Business Ethics117(2): 221–259.
19.
CuddyAmy JC, FiskeSusan T, KwanVirginia SYet al. (2009)
Stereotype content model across cultures: Towards universal similarities and some differences, British Journal of Social Psychology48(1): 1–33.
20.
CunliffeALEriksenM (2011)
Relational leadership. Human Relations64(11): 1425–1449.
21.
DeanJWBrandesPDharwadkarR (1998)
Organizational cynicism. Academy of Management Review23(2): 341–352.
22.
Druckman D (2005) Doing research: Methods of inquiry for conflict analysis. Fairfax, VA: Sage.
23.
DubrinA (2009) Political Behavior in Organizations.
New York:
SAGE Publications.
24.
EinarsenSAaslandMSkogstadA (2007)
Destructive leadership behaviour: A definition and conceptual model. The Leadership Quarterly18(3): 207–216.
25.
EisenbeissSA (2012)
Re-thinking ethical leadership: An interdisciplinary integrative approach. The Leadership Quarterly23(5): 791–808.
26.
FairhurstGTUhl-BienM (2012)
Organizational discourse analysis (ODA): Examining leadership as a relational process. The Leadership Quarterly23(6): 1043–1062.
27.
FerrisGJudgeT (1990) Personnel/Human Resources Management: A Political Influence Perspective. CAHRS Working Paper Series.
28.
FerrisGKacmarM (1992)
Perceptions of organizational politics. Journal of Management18(1): 93–116.
29.
FerrisGTreadwayD (2012) Politics in Organizations: Theory and Research Considerations. The Organizational Frontiers Series.
30.
FerrisGRAdamsGKolodinskyRWet al. (2002) Perceptions of Organizational Politics: Theory and Research Directions. In: Yammarino FJ and Dansereau F (eds) The Many Faces of Multi-level Issues (Research in multi-level issues, Vol. 1). Oxford: JAI Press/Elsevier Science, pp.179–254.
31.
FerrisGerald R, JudgeTimothy A (2016)
Personnel/Human Resources Management: A Political Influence Perspective, Journal of Management17(2): 447–488.
32.
Ferris GR and Treadway DC (Eds.) (2012). Politics in organizations: Theory and research considerations. Routledge.
33.
FletcherJK (2004)
The paradox of postheroic leadership: An essay on gender, power and transformational change. The Leadership Quarterly15(5): 647–661.
34.
FordJHardingN (2007)
Move over management we are all leaders now. Management Learning38(5): 475–493.
35.
FordRMcLaughlinF (1986)
Nepotism: Boon or bane. Personnel Administrator31: 78–89.
36.
GabrielY (1999)
Beyond happy families: A critical reevaluation of the control-resistance-identity triangle. Human Relations52(2): 179–203.
37.
GabrielY (2014)
The caring leader – What followers expect of their leaders and why?Leadership11(3): 316–334.
38.
GilliganC (1982) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development.
Cambridge, MA:
Harvard University Press.
39.
GilliganC (2011) Joining the Resistance.
Cambridge, MA:
Polity Press.
40.
GlücklerJArmbrüsterT (2003)
Bridging uncertainty in management consulting: The mechanisms of trust and networked reputation. Organization Studies24(2): 269–297.
41.
GotsisGKorteziZ (2010)
Ethical considerations in organizational politics: Expanding the perspective. Journal of Business Ethics93(4): 497–517.
42.
GreenbergRABaronRA (2003) Behavior in Organizations. 8th ed.
Upper Saddle River, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
43.
HalaiN (2007)
Making use of bilingual interview data: Some experiences from the field. The Qualitative Report12(3): 334–355.
44.
HamiltonDLShermanSJLickelB (1998) Perceiving social groups: The importance of the entitativity continuum. In: Sedikides C and Schopler J (eds) Intergroup Cognition and Intergroup Behavior. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, pp.47–74.
45.
HeilmanMBattleWKellerCet al. (1998)
Type of affirmative action policy: A determinant of reactions to sex-based preferential selection?Journal of Applied Psychology83(2): 190.
46.
HeilmanMLucasJKaplowS (1990)
Self-derogating consequences of preferential selection: The moderating role of initial self-confidence. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes46: 202–216.
47.
Held V (2006) The ethics of care: Personal, political, and global. Oxford University Press on Demand.
48.
HernandezGMJ (2010)
Translated interviews in printed media – A case study of the Spanish daily El Mundo. Across Languages and Cultures11(2): 217–232.
49.
HoytCLBlascovichJ (2010)
The role of leadership self-efficacy and stereotype activation on cardiovascular, behavioral and self-report responses in the leadership domain. The Leadership Quarterly21(1): 89–103.
50.
KalshovenKDen HartogDDe HooghA (2011)
Ethical leadership at work questionnaire (ELW): Development and validation of a multidimensional measure. Leadership Quarterly22(1): 51–69.
51.
Karakitapoğlu-AygünZGumusluogluL (2013)
The bright and dark sides of leadership: Transformational vs. non-transformational leadership in a non-Western context. Leadership9(1): 107–133.
52.
Kellerman B (2004) Bad leadership: What it is, how it happens, why it matters. Boston: Harvard Business Press.
53.
KelleyKMBiselRS (2014)
Leaders’ narrative sensemaking during LMX role negotiations: Explaining how leaders make sense of who to trust and when. Leadership Quarterly25(3): 433–448.
54.
KhatriNTsangE (2003)
Antecedents and consequences of cronyism in organizations. Journal of Business Ethics43(4): 289–303.
55.
KnightP (1989)
Empathy: Concept, confusion and consequences in a national curriculum. Oxford Review of Education15(1): 41–53.
56.
KnightsDO’LearyM (2006)
Leadership, ethics and responsibility to the other. Journal of Business Ethics67: 125–137.
57.
LadkinD (2013)
From perception to flesh: A phenomenological account of the felt experience of leadership. Leadership9(3): 320–334.
58.
LeCompteMDGoetzJP (1982)
Problems of validity and reliability in ethnographic research. Review of Educational Research52(1): 31–60.
59.
LickelBHamiltonDLWieczorkowskaGet al. (2000)
Varieties of groups and the perception of group entitativity. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology78(2): 223.
60.
McClaneW (1991)
The interaction of leader and member characteristics in the leader-member exchange (LMX) model of leadership. Small Group Research22(3): 283–300.
61.
McGrathJE (1984) Groups: Interaction and Performance.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ:
Prentice-Hall.
62.
McNamee SJ and Miller RK (2009) The meritocracy myth. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.
63.
MarshallMN (1996)
Sampling for qualitative research. Family Practice13(6): 522–526.
MillerBRutherfordMKolodinskyR (2008)
Perceptions of organizational politics: A meta-analysis of outcomes. Journal of Business and Psychology22(3): 209–222.
66.
MountMIliesRJohnsonE (2006)
Relationship of personality traits and counterproductive work behaviors: The mediating effects of job satisfaction. Personnel Psychology59: 591–622.
67.
NystromP (1978)
Managers and the hi-hi leader myth. Academy of Management Journal21(2): 325–331.
68.
O’ReillyDReedM (2011)
The grit in the oyster: Professionalism, managerialism and leaderism as discourses of UK public services modernization. Organization Studies32(8): 1079–1101.
69.
Oxford English Dictionary (2017). Favouritism.
70.
Padgett MY and Morris KA (2000) The impact of sex-based preferential selection on subordinate perceptions of a new supervisor. In Administrative Sciences Association of Canada-Annual Conference-ASAC, Montreal, 27–29 May 1999. 21(11), pp. 21–31.
71.
PadgettMMorrisK (2005)
Keeping it “all in the family”: Does nepotism in the hiring process really benefit the beneficiary?Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies11(2): 34–45.
72.
PadillaAHoganRKaiserR (2007)
The toxic triangle: Destructive leaders, susceptible followers, and conducive environments. The Leadership Quarterly18(3): 176–194.
73.
RaelinJ (2016)
Imagine there are no leaders: Reframing leadership as collective agency. Leadership12(2): 131–158.
74.
RhodesC (2012)
Ethics, alterity and the rationality of leadership justice. Human Relations65(10): 1311–1331.
75.
RobinsonSBennettR (1995)
A typology of deviant workplace behaviors: A multidimensional scaling study. Academy of Management Journal38(2): 555–572.
76.
RosenblattV (2012)
Hierarchies, power inequalities, and organizational corruption. Journal of Business Ethics111(2): 237–251.
77.
SchillingJ (2009)
From ineffectiveness to destruction: A qualitative study on the meaning of negative leadership. Leadership5(1): 102–128.
78.
SchriesheimCCastroSCogliserC (1999)
Leader-member exchange (LMX) research: A comprehensive review of theory, measurement, and data-analytic practices. The Leadership Quarterly10(1): 63–113.
79.
ScottBColquittJPaddockE (2009)
An actor-focused model of justice rule adherence and violation: The role of managerial motives and discretion. The Journal of Applied Psychology94(3): 756–769.
80.
Sherif M (1966) In common predicament: Social psychology of intergroup conflict and cooperation. Houghton Mifflin comp.
81.
Sidanius J and Pratto F (1999) Social dominance: An intergroup theory of social hierarchy and oppression. 10.1017. CBO9781139175043.
82.
SidaniusJPrattoF (2001) Social Dominance. Cambridge University Press.
83.
SpectorLee, KleinJon, PerryChriset al. (2005)
Emergence of Collective Behavior in Evolving Populations of Flying Agents, Genetic Programming and Evolvable Machines6(1): 111–125.
84.
SpectorPEFoxSPenneyLMet al. (2006)
The dimensionality of counterproductivity: Are all counterproductive behaviors created equal?Journal of Vocational Behavior68(3): 446–460.
85.
SpencerTD (2011)
Christopher Kliewer: Seeing all kids as readers: A new vision for literacy in the inclusive early childhood classroom. Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders41(4): 530–531.
86.
SpillaneJHalversonRDiamondJ (2004)
Towards a theory of leadership practice: A distributed perspective. Journal of Curriculum Studies36(1): 3–34.
87.
TepperBJ (2000)
Consequences of Abusive Supervision., Academy of Management Journal43(2): 178–190.
88.
TepperB (2007)
Abusive supervision in work organizations: Review, synthesis, and research agenda. Journal of Management33(3): 261–289.
89.
TourishD (2014)
Leadership, more or less? A processual, communication perspective on the role of agency in leadership theory. Leadership10(1): 79–98.
90.
TreviñoLWeaverGReynoldsS (2006)
Behavioral ethics in organizations: A review. Journal of Management32: 951–990.
91.
TurnerJC, BrownRJ, TajfelH (1979)
Social comparison and group interest in ingroup favouritism, European Journal of Social Psychology9(2): 187–204.
92.
Uhl-BienMary (2006)
Relational Leadership Theory: Exploring the social processes of leadership and organizing, The Leadership Quarterly17(6): 654–676.
93.
van HooftS (2011)
Caring, objectivity and justice: an integrative view. Nursing Ethics18(2): 149–160.
94.
VardiYWeitzE (2004) Misbehavior in Organizations: Theory, Research, and Management.
Mahwah, NJ:
Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
95.
VigodaECohenA (2002)
Influence tactics and perceptions of organizational politics: A longitudinal study. Journal of Business Research55(4): 311–324.
96.
WeaverGReynoldsBrownM (2014)
Moral intuition: Connecting current knowledge to future organizational research and practice. Journal of Management40(1): 100–129.
97.
WilliamsMDuttonJ (1999) Corrosive political climates: The heavy toll of negative political behavior in organizations. In: QuinnRClairL (eds) The Pressing Problems of Modern Organizations: Transforming the Agenda for Research and Practice.
New York,
American Management Association, pp.3–30.
98.
WoodillaJForrayJM (2008)
Justice and the political in organizational life: A narrativeinquiry. Journal of Management Inquiry17(1): 4–19.
99.
YinR (2001) Applications of Case Study Research. Applied social research methods series. Vol. 34, Sage.
100.
YinRK (2008) Case Study Research: Design and Methods. Sage Publications, Inc.
101.
YuklGGordonATaberT (2002)
A hierarchical taxonomy of leadership behavior: Integrating a half century of behavior research. Journal of Leadership & Organizational Studies9(1): 15–32.
102.
Zanola A, Palermo O and Bisignano A (2012) MGM Marmi: challenging tradition with entrepreneurial leadership and business communication. In: Casebase 2: Case Studies in Global Business, Andrew Ashwin (Eds.) pp. 93–96. Detroit: Gale/Cengage Learning.
103.
ZellarsKLKacmarKM (1999)
The influence of individual differences on reactions to co-workers ingratiatory behaviors. Journal of Managerial Issues11(2): 234–248.
104.
Zhang Y, Bednall Timothy C (2016) Antecedents of Abusive Supervision: a Meta-analytic Review, Journal of Business Ethics 139(3): 455–471.
