Organizational democracy,ethics and leadership: The mediating role of organizational politics

Abstract

There has been a growing concern amongst commentators about the disconnection between the apparent pluralisation of society and the relatively limited adoption of democratic practices in the corporate workplace. This paper examines the experience of employees in an international broking company in order to explore the extent to which a political leadership perspective can provide insight into furthering organizational democratisation. Attention is given to the integral relationship between democracy, ethics and a political mindset, and the influence this has upon others. In the account reported here, the ethical and developmental agenda of one influential senior manager is central to both the enactment of politics and the form of democratisation which it enables.

Keywords

ethics organizational democracy organizational politics power

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ambrosini

Bowman

(2002) Mapping successful organisational routines. In: Huff

Jenkins

(eds) Mapping Strategic Knowledge. London: Sage, 19–39.

Armbruster

Gebert

(2002) Uncharted territiories of organisational research: The case of Karl Poppers's open society and its enemies. Organisation Studies 23: 169–188.

Bacharach

(1967) The Theory of Democratic Elitism: A Critique. Boston: Little Brown.

Brown

Trevino

(2006) Ethical leadership: A review and future directions. The Leadership Quarterly 17: 595–616.

Buchanan

(1999) The logic of political action: An experiment with the epistemology of the particular. British Journal of Management 10: S73–S88.

Burns

(1978) Leadership. New York: Harper and Row.

Butcher

Clarke

(2001, 2008) Smart Management: Using Politics in Organisations. Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave.

Butcher

Clarke

(2006) Political leadership in democracies – Some lessons for business? Management Decision 44(8): 985–1001.

Caldart

Ricart

(2004) Corporate strategy revisited: A view from complexity theory. European Management Review 1: 96–104.

10.

Chia

(2002) The production of management knowledge: Philosophical underpinnings of research design. In: Partington

(eds) Essential Skills for Management Research. London: Sage, 1–19.

11.

Child

McGrath

(2001) Organisations unfettered: Organisational form in an information-intensive economy. Academy of Management Journal 44: 1135–1148.

12.

Clarke

(2006) A study of the role of ‘representative’ leadership in stimulating organizational democracy. Leadership 2(4): 417–450.

13.

Clarke

Butcher

(2009) Political leadership, bureaucracies and business schools: a comfortable union? Management Learning 40(5): 587–607.

14.

Clegg

(1990) Modern Organisations. London: Sage.

15.

Clegg

(2003) Strange fruit hanging from the knowledge tree, or carry on carping. Management Learning 34: 375–378.

16.

Clegg

Kornberger

Rhodes

(2007) Business ethics as practice. British Journal of Management 18: 107–122.

17.

Cloke

Goldsmith

(2002) The End of Management and the Rise of Organisational Democracy. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.

18.

Coopey

Burgoyne

(2000) Politics and organisational learning. Journal of Management Studies 37: 869–885.

19.

Courpasson

Dany

(2003) Indifference or obedience? Business firms as democratic hybrids. Organisation Studies 24: 1231–1260.

20.

Dehler

(2009) Prospects and possibilities of critical management education: Critical beings and a pedagogy of critical action. Management Learning 40: 31–49.

21.

De Jong

van Witteloostuijn

(2004) Successful corporate democracy: Sustainable cooperation of capital in the Dutch Breman Group. Academy of Management Executive 18: 54–66.

22.

Denis

Lamothe

Langley

(2001) The dynamics of collective leadership and strategic change in pluralistic organisations. Academy of Management Journal 44: 809–837.

23.

Du Gay

(2000) In Praise of Bureaucracy. London: Sage.

24.

Easterby-Smith

Malina

(1999) Cross-cultural collaborative research: Towards reflexivity. Academy of Management Journal 42: 76–85.

25.

Etzioni

(1998) A communitarian note of Stakeholder Theory. Business Ethics Quarterly 8: 679–691.

26.

Gaumitz

Lere

(2004) A classification scheme for codes of business ethics. Journal of Business Ethics 49: 329–335.

27.

Gordon

(2007) Power, Knowledge and Domination. Liber: Sweden.

28.

Gordon

Clegg

Kornberger

(2009) Embedded ethics: Discourse and power in the New South Wales Police Service. Organisation Studies 30: 73–99.

29.

Grint

(2002) What is leadership? From hydra to hybrid. Paper presented at the 1st EAISM Conference on Leadership Research, December. Oxford, UK.

30.

Grit

(2004) Corporate citizenship: How to strengthen the social responsibility of managers? Journal of Business Ethics 53: 97–106.

31.

Hales

(2002) ‘Bureaucracy-lite’ and continuities in managerial work. British Journal of Management 13: 51–66.

32.

Harrison

Freeman

(2004) Is organisational democracy worth the effort? Academy of Management Executive 18: 49–53.

33.

Held

(1987) Models of Democracy. Cambridge: Polity Press.

34.

Hendry

(2006) Educating managers for post bureaucracy: The role of the Humanities. Management Learning 37: 267–281.

35.

Johnson

(2006) Whence democracy? A review and critique of the conceptual dimensions and implications of the business case for organisation democracy. Organisation 13: 245–274.

36.

Kerr

(2004) The limits of organisational democracy. Academy of Management Executive 18: 81–95.

37.

Lijphart

(1999) Patterns of Democracy. Government Forms and Performance in Thirty Six Countries. New Haven. CT: Yale University Press.

38.

Lovell

Fisher

(2003) Business Ethics and Values. Harlow: Pearson Education.

39.

Luhman

(2006) Theoretical postulations on organisation democracy. Journal of Management Inquiry 15: 168–185.

40.

March

Olsen

(1995) Democratic Governance. NY: Free Press.

41.

Morrell

Hartley

(2006) Ethics in leadership: The case of local politicians. Local Government Studies 32: 55–70.

42.

Painter-Morland

(2008) Business Ethics as Practice: Ethics as the Everyday Business of Business. Cambridge University Press.

43.

Peele

(2005) Leadership and politics: A case for a closer relationship? Leadership 1: 187–204.

44.

Pettigrew

(1990) Longitudinal field research on change: Theory and practice. Organisation Science 1: 267–292.

45.

Peters

Williams

(2002) Does organisational leadership theory apply to legislative leaders. Organisational Dynamics 30: 257–268.

46.

Poff

(2007) Duties owed in serving students: The importance of teaching moral reasoning and theories of ethical leadership in educating business students. Journal of Academic Ethics 5: 25–31.

47.

Robertson

Swan

(2003) Control – what control? Culture and ambiguity within a knowledge intensive firm. Journal of Management Studies 40: 831–858.

48.

Rousseau

Rivero

(2003) Democracy, a way of organising in a knowledge economy. Journal of Management Inquiry 12: 115–134.

49.

Stewart

(1998) The Ethnographer's Method. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

50.

Thompson

Davidson

(1995) The continuity of discontinuity: Managerial rhetoric in turbulent times. Personnel Review 24: 17–34.

51.

Vigoda-Gadot

Drory

(2006) Handbook of Organisational Politics. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing.

52.

Watson

(2003) Ethical choices in managerial work: The scope for moral choices in an ethically irrational world. Human Relations 56: 167–185.