This article takes a critical look at the management education offered by
business schools, seeking to establish whether it encourages the emergence and
development of leadership qualities. The author introduces a teaching experiment
he carried out as part of an MBA programme aimed at assessing whether it is
possible to teach a leadership course in which the students do not assume the
role of followers, but rather find themselves leading others, taking
responsibility and operating without the conventional safety net provided by the
lecturer. The author concludes that the structure, ideology and ethos of MBA
programmes are fundamentally opposed to an education of leaders, arguing MBA
experience is one for educating followers rather than leaders - committed
followers, obstinate, hardened lieutenants perhaps, but not generals. It is in
this sense then that MBAs may be seen as a contemporary parallel to the playing
fields of Eton. They are uniquely suited to people who can survive and even
prosper in the merciless fields of today’s business.
Bartlett, J.
(1980) Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations.
Boston: Little, Brown
.
2.
Bass, B. M.
, &
Seltzer, J.
(1990)
‘Transformational Leadership: Beyond Initiation and Consideration’
, Journal of Management16(4):
693-703
.
3.
Bennis, W. G.
(1989) Why Leaders Can’t Lead. The Unconscious
Conspiracy Continues.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
.
4.
Bennis, W. G.
(1998) On Becoming a Leader.
London: Arrow
.
5.
Bernstein, B.
(1975) Class, Code and Control, Vol III: Towards a Theory of
Educational Transmissions.
London: Routledge
.
6.
Bowles, S.
, &
Gintis, H.
(1976) Schooling in Capitalist America: Educational Reform
and the Contradictions of Economic Life.
New York: Basic Books
.
7.
Bowles, S.
, &
Gintis, H.
(1986) Democracy and Capitalism: Property, Community, and the
Contradictions of Modern Social Thought.
New York: Basic Books
.
8.
Brown, A. D.
(1997)
‘Narcissism, Identity, and Legitimacy’
, Academy of Management Review22(3):
643-686
.
9.
Bryman, A.
(1992) Charisma and Leadership in Organizations.
London: SAGE
.
10.
Burns, J. M.
(1978) Leadership.
New York: Harper and Row
.
11.
Chia, R.
, &
Morgan, S.
(1996)
‘Educating the Philosopher-Manager: De-signing the Times’
, Management Learning27(1):
40-55
.
12.
Contu, A.
,
Grey, C.
, &
Örtenblad, A.
(2003)
‘Against Learning’
, Human Relations56(8):
931-952
.
13.
Currie, G.
, &
Knights, D.
(2003)
‘Reflecting on a Critical Pedagogy in MBA Education’
, Management Learning34(1):
27-49
.
14.
Dixon, N.
(1976) On the Psychology of Military Incompetence.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
15.
Doh, J. P.
(2003)
‘Can Leadership Be Taught? Perspectives from Management Educators’
, Academy of Management Learning and Education2(1):
54-67
.
16.
Gabriel, Y.
(1997)
‘Meeting God: When Organizational Members Come Face to Face with
the Supreme Leader’
, Human Relations50(4):
315-342
.
17.
Gabriel, Y.
(1999) Organizations in Depth: The Psychoanalysis of
Organizations.
London: SAGE
.
18.
Gabriel, Y.
(2002)
‘Essai: on Paragrammatic Uses of Organizational Theory: A Provocation’
, Organization Studies23(1):
133-151
.
19.
Gabriel, Y.
, &
Lang, T.
(1995) The Unmanageable Consumer: Contemporary Consumption
and Its Fragmentation.
London: SAGE
.
20.
Goleman, D.
(2001) ‘What Makes a
Leader?’, in
J. Henry
(ed.) Creative Management, pp. 125-139.
London: SAGE
.
21.
Goleman, D.
,
Boyatzis, R.
, &
McKee, A.
(2002) Primal Leadership: Realizing the Power of Emotional
Intelligence.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard Business School Press
.
22.
Gosling, J.
, &
Mintzberg, H.
(2004)
‘Agenda - the Education of Practicing Managers’
, Mit Sloan Management Review45(4):
19-22
.
23.
Grey, C.
(2004)
‘Reinventing Business Schools: The Contribution of Critical
Management Education’
, Academy of Management Learning and Education3(2):
178-186
.
24.
Grint, K.
(2000) The Arts of Leadership.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
25.
Grint, K.
(2004) ‘Overcoming the Hydra: Leadersless Groups
and Terrorism’, in
Y. Gabriel
(ed.) Myths, Stories and Organizations: Premodern Narratives for Our
Times, pp. 85-100.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
26.
Grint, K.
(2005) Leadership: Limits and Possibilities.
Basingstoke: Palgrave/Macmillan
.
27.
Heifetz, R. A.
(1994) Leadership Without Easy Answers.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
.
28.
Heifetz, R. A.
, &
Linsky, M.
(2002)
‘A Survival Guide for Leaders’
, Harvard Business Review (June):
65-73
.
29.
Hirschhorn, L.
(1988) The Workplace Within.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
30.
Hoskin, K. W.
, &
Macve, R. H.
(1988)
‘The Genesis of Accountability - the West Point Connections’
, Accounting Organizations and Society13(1):
37-73
.
31.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R.
(1988)
‘Prisoners of Leadership’
, Human Relations41:
261-280
.
32.
Kets de Vries, M. F. R.
(2001) The Leadership Mystique: An Owner’s
Manual.
London: Pearson Education
.
33.
Knopp, G.
(2002) Hitler’s Children.
London: Sutton
.
34.
Krantz, J.
(1990)
‘Lessons from the Field: An Essay on the Crisis of Leadership in
Contemporary Organizations’
, Journal of Applied Behavioural Science26(1):
49-64
.
35.
Kretovics, M.
(1999)
‘Assessing the MBA: What Do Our Students Learn’
, Journal of Management Development18(2):
125-136
.
36.
Kuhn, T.
(1962/1996) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions.
Chicago: Chicago University Press
.
37.
Lataif, L. E.
,
et al.
(1992)
‘MBA - Is the Traditional Model Doomed’
, Harvard Business Review70(6):
128-140
.
38.
Levine, D. P.
(2002)
‘Thinking About Doing: On Learning from Experience and the Flight
from Thinking’
, Human Relations55(10):
1251-1268
.
39.
Maccoby, M.
(1976) The Gamesman: New Corporate Leaders.
New York: Simon and Schuster
.
40.
Maccoby, M.
(1981) The Leader.
New York: Simon and Schuster
.
41.
Maccoby, M.
(2000)
‘Narcissistic Leaders: The Incredible Pros, the Inevitable Cons’
, Harvard Business Review78(1):
69-77
.
42.
McCulloch, G.
(1991) Philosophers and Kings: Education for Leadership in
Modern England.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
43.
Mann, T.
(1924/1960) The Magic Mountain.
Harmondsworth: Penguin
.
44.
Mant, A.
(1977) The Rise and Fall of the British Manager.
London: Macmillan
.
45.
Meindl, J. R.
, &
Ehrlich, S. B.
(1987)
‘The Romance of Leadership and the Evaluation of Organizational Performance’
, Academy of Management Journal30(1):
91-109
.
46.
Meindl, J. R.
,
Ehrlich, S. B.
, &
Dukerich, J. M.
(1985)
‘The Romance of Leadership’
, Administrative Science Quarterly30(1):
78-108
.
47.
Mintzberg, H.
(2004) Managers Not MBAs: a Hard Look at the Soft Practice of
Managing and Management Development.
London: FT Prentice Hall
.
48.
Mintzberg, H.
, &
Lampel, J.
(2001) ‘MBAs as CEOs’, available
at: http://www.henrymintzberg.com.
49.
Mintzberg, H.
,
Ahlstrand, B. W.
, &
Lampel, J.
(2001) Strategy Safari: The Complete Guide through the Wilds
of Strategic Management.
Harlow: FT Prentice Hall
.
50.
Oglensky, B. D.
(1995)
‘Socio-psychoanalytic Perspectives on the Subordinate’
, Human Relations48(9):
1029-1054
.
51.
Parker, M.
, &
Jary, D.
(1995)
‘The McUniversity - Organization, Management and Academic Subjectivity’
, Organization2(2):
319-338
.
52.
Prichard, C.
, &
Willmott, H.
(1997)
‘Just How Managed is the McUniversity?’
, Organization Studies18(2):
287-316
.
53.
Ritzer, G.
(1999) Enchanting a Disenchanted World: Revolutionizing the
Means of Consumption.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press
.
54.
Russo, R.
(1998) A Straight Man.
New York: Vintage
.
55.
Selznick, P.
(1957) Leadership and Administration.
New York: Harper and Row
.
56.
Sennett, R.
(1998) The Corrosion of Character: The Personal Consequences
of Work in the New Capitalism.
New York: Norton
.
57.
Shils, E.
(1965)
‘Charisma, Order and Status’
, American Sociological Review30:
199-213
.
58.
Simpson, P.
,
French, R.
, &
Harvey, C.
(2002)
‘Leadership and Negative Capability’
, Human Relations55(10):
1209-1226
.
59.
Sims, H. P.
, &
Lorenzi, P.
(1992) The New Leadership Paradigm: Social Learning and
Cognition in Organizations.
Newbury Park, CA: SAGE
.
60.
Sinclair, A.
(1995)
‘Sex and the MBA’
, Organization2(2):
295-317
.
61.
Sturdy, A.
, &
Gabriel, Y.
(2000)
‘Missionaries, Mercenaries or Used Car Salesmen? Teaching MBA in Malaysia’
, Journal of Management Studies37(4):
979-1002
.
62.
Tzu, S.
(1963) The Art of War.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
63.
Weick, K. E.
(2001) ‘Improvisation as a Mindset for
Organizational Analysis’, in
K. E. Weick
(ed.) Making Sense of the Organizations, pp.
284-304.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
64.
Weick, K. E.
(2003)
‘Commentary on Czarniawska’
, Management Learning34(3):
379-382
.
65.
Wilkinson, R.
(1964) The Prefects.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
66.
Willis, P.
(1979) Learning to Labour.
London: Saxon House
.
67.
Yukl, G.
(2002) Leadership in Organizations.
London: Prentice Hall
.
68.
Zaleznik, A.
(1977)
‘Managers and Leaders: Are They Different?’
, Harvard Business Review55(May-June):
47-60
.
69.
Zaleznik, A.
(1989)
‘The Mythological Structure of Organizations and Its Impact’
, Human Resource Management28(2):
267-277
.
