There is inconsistency and lack of conceptual clarity regarding the concept of “recurrence” in diabetes-related foot ulcers. Therefore, the purpose of this concept analysis is to analyze the concept of recurrence-related to diabetes-related foot ulcer after the healing of a previous foot ulcer.
Method
The Rodger's evolutionary concept analysis method was employed to analyze the concept of recurrence in diabetes-related foot ulcers. Eight databases, including PubMed, EMBASE, CINAHL Plus with Full Text, MEDLINE with Full Text (EBSCO), Web of Science, Cochrane Library, PsychoINFO, and Scopus, were searched. Additionally, Google Scholar, bibliographies, and hand searching were conducted. The search spanned from inception through August 13, 2023, yielding 3290 studies. Among these, 3242 did not meet the inclusion criteria, leaving 46 articles that fulfilled the criteria.
Findings
In a majority of the studies (n = 20, 43%), diabetes-related foot ulcer recurrence occurred at the same site after the healing of previous foot ulcers. In contrast, in fourteen (20%) studies, the diabetes-related foot ulcer recurrence was described as not at the same site as the previous foot ulcer. In the other twelve (26%) studies, the attribute of recurrence was not identified.
Conclusions
The concept of recurrence-related to diabetes-related foot ulcer should be reserved for diabetes-related foot ulcers at the same site after the healing of previous foot ulcers.
GuoQYingGJingO, et al.Influencing factors for the recurrence of diabetic foot ulcers: a meta-analysis. Int Wound J2023; 20: 1762–1775.
2.
HuangZHLiSQKouY, et al.Risk factors for the recurrence of diabetic foot ulcers among diabetic patients: a meta-analysis. Int Wound J2019; 16: 1373–1382.
3.
JiménezSRubioJAÁlvarezJ,et al.Analysis of recurrent ulcerations at a multidisciplinary diabetic foot unit after implementation of a comprehensive foot care program. Endocrinol Diabetes Nutr2018; 65: 438.e1–438.e10.
4.
ArmstrongDGBoultonAJMBusSA. Diabetic foot ulcers and their recurrence. N Engl J Med2017; 376: 2367–2375.
5.
DubskyMJirkovskaABemR, et al.Risk factors for recurrence of diabetic foot ulcers: prospective follow-up analysis in the Eurodiale subgroup. Int Wound J2013; 10: 555–561.
6.
BusSANettenJJ. A shift in priority in diabetic foot care and research: 75% of foot ulcers are preventable. Diabetes Metab Res Rev2016; 32: 195–200.
7.
EngbergSKirketerp-MøllerKUllitsAH,et al.Incidence and predictors of recurrent and other new diabetic foot ulcers: a retrospective cohort study. Diabetic Med2019; 36: 1417–1423.
8.
MaderJKHaasWAbererF, et al.Patients with healed diabetic foot ulcer represent a cohort at highest risk for future fatal events. Sci Rep2019; 9: 10325.
9.
GonzalezJSVileikyteLUlbrechtJS, et al.Depression predicts first but not recurrent diabetic foot ulcers. Diabetologia2010; 53: 2241–2248.
10.
ApelqvistJLarssonJAgardhCD. Long-term prognosis for diabetic patients with foot ulcers. J Intern Med1993; 233: 485–491.
11.
HicksCWCannerJKKaragozluH, et al.Quantifying the costs and profitability of care for diabetic foot ulcers treated in a multidisciplinary setting. J Vasc Surg2019; 70: 233–240.
12.
ArmstrongDGSwerdlowMAArmstrongAA, et al.Five year mortality and direct costs of care for people with diabetic foot complications are comparable to cancer. J Foot Ankle Res2020; 13: 16.
13.
HicksCWCannerJKKaragozluH, et al.The society for vascular surgery wound, ischemia, and foot infection (WIfI) classification system correlates with cost of care for diabetic foot ulcers treated in a multidisciplinary setting. J Vasc Surg2018; 67: 1455–1462.
14.
RaghavAKhanZALabalaRK, et al.Financial burden of diabetic foot ulcers to world: a progressive topic to discuss always. Ther Adv Endocrinol Metab2018; 9: 29–31.
15.
Jodheea-JuttonAHindochaSBhaw-LuximonA. Health economics of diabetic foot ulcer and recent trends to accelerate treatment. The Foot2022; 52: 101909.
16.
DriverVRFabbiMLaveryLA,et al.The costs of diabetic foot: the economic case for the limb salvage team. J Vasc Surg2010; 52: 17S–22S.
17.
WaaijmanRDe HaartMArtsMLJ, et al.Risk factors for plantar foot ulcer recurrence in neuropathic diabetic patients. Diabetes Care2014; 37: 1697–1705.
18.
Sanz-CorbalánILázaro-MartínezJLAragón-SánchezJ, et al.Analysis of ulcer recurrences after metatarsal head resection in patients who underwent surgery to treat diabetic foot osteomyelitis. Int J Low Extrem Wounds2015; 14: 154–159.
19.
MillerJDSalloumMButtonA, et al.How can I maintain my patient with diabetes and history of foot ulcer in remission?Int J Low Extrem Wounds2014; 13: 371–377.
20.
MonamiMLongoRDesideriCM, et al.The diabetic person beyond a foot ulcer: healing, recurrence, and depressive symptoms. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc2008; 98: 130–136.
21.
FriggAPagenstertGSchäferD, et al.Recurrence and prevention of diabetic foot ulcers after total contact casting. Foot Ankle Int2007; 28: 64–69.
22.
PetersEJGArmstrongDGLaveryLA. Risk factors for recurrent diabetic foot ulcers: site matters. Diabetes Care2007; 30: 2077–2079.
23.
DargisVPantelejevaOJonushaiteA, et al.Benefits of a multidisciplinary approach in the management of recurrent diabetic foot ulceration in Lithuania: a prospective study. Diabetes Care1999; 22: 1428–1431.
24.
MohammedSIMikhaelEMAhmedFT, et al.Risk factors for occurrence and recurrence of diabetic foot ulcers among Iraqi diabetic patients. Diabet Foot Ankle2016; 7: 29605.
25.
JudeEBTentolourisNAppletonI, et al.Role of neuropathy and plasma nitric oxide in recurrent neuropathic and neuroischemic diabetic foot ulcers. Wound Repair Regen2001; 9: 353–359.
26.
GaleaAMSpringettKBungayH, et al.Incidence and location of diabetic foot ulcer recurrence. Diabetic Foot J2009; 12: 181–186.
27.
TabanjehSFHyassatDJaddouH, et al.The frequency and risk factors of diabetic foot ulcer recurrence among Jordanian patients with diabetes. Curr Diabetes Rev2020; 16: 910–915.
28.
FernandezMLGLozanoRMDiazMIG-Q, et al.How effective is orthotic treatment in patients with recurrent diabetic foot ulcers?J Am Podiatr Med Assoc2013; 103: 281–290.
29.
YazdanpanahLShahbazianHNazariI, et al.Incidence and risk factors of diabetic foot ulcer: a population-based diabetic foot cohort (ADFC Study)-Two-year follow-up study. Int J Endocrinol2018; 2018: 1–9.
30.
Lázaro-MartínezJLAragón-SánchezJÁlvaro-AfonsoFJ, et al.The best way to reduce reulcerations: if you understand biomechanics of the diabetic foot, you can do it. Int J Low Extrem Wounds2014; 13: 294–319.
31.
RodgersBLJacelonCSKnaflKA. Concept analysis and the advance of nursing knowledge: state of the science. J Nurs Scholarsh2018; 50: 451–459.
32.
ÖrneholmHApelqvistJLarssonJ,et al.Recurrent and other new foot ulcers after healed plantar forefoot diabetic ulcer. Wound Repair Regen2017; 25: 309–315.
33.
ManteyIFosterAVSpencerS,et al.Why do foot ulcers recur in diabetic patients?Diabetic Med1999; 16: 245–249.
34.
RodgersBLKnaflKA. Concept development in nursing: foundations, techniques, and applications. Philadelphia: Saunders, 2000.
35.
PageMJMcKenzieJEBossuytPM, et al.The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. Br Med J2021; 372: n71.
36.
GarrardJ. Health science literature reviews made essay. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Barlett, 2011.
37.
SteedDLEdingtonHDWebsterMW. Recurrence rate of diabetic neurotrophic foot ulcers healed using topical application of growth factors released from platelets. Wound Repair Regen1996; 4: 230–233.
38.
IwaseMFujiiHNakamuraU, et al.Incidence of diabetic foot ulcer in Japanese patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus: the Fukuoka diabetes registry. Diabetes Res Clin Pract2018; 137: 183–189.
39.
AbbottCACarringtonALAsheH, et al.The north-west diabetes foot care study: incidence of, and risk factors for, new diabetic foot ulceration in a community-based patient cohort. Diabetic Med2002; 19: 377–384.
40.
GhanassiaEVillonLThuan Dit DieudonnéJ-F, et al.Long-term outcome and disability of diabetic patients hospitalized for diabetic foot ulcers: a 6.5-year follow-up study. Diabetes Care2008; 31: 1288–1292.
41.
GazzarusoCGallottiPPujiaA, et al.Predictors of healing, ulcer recurrence and persistence, amputation and mortality in type 2 diabetic patients with diabetic foot: a 10-year retrospective cohort study. Endocrine2021; 71: 59–68.
42.
ZhangLFuGDengY, et al.Risk factors for foot ulcer recurrence in patients with comorbid diabetic foot osteomyelitis and diabetic nephropathy: a 3-year follow-up study. Int Wound J2023; 20: 173–182.
43.
LemasterJWReiberGESmithDG, et al.Daily weight-bearing activity does not increase the risk of diabetic foot ulcers. Med Sci Sports Exercise2003; 35: 1093–1099.
44.
NilsenFAMolundMHvaalKH. High incidence of recurrent ulceration and major amputations associated with charcot foot. J Foot Ankle Surg2018; 57: 301–304.
45.
OgurtsovaKMorbachSHaastertB, et al.Cumulative long-term recurrence of diabetic foot ulcers in two cohorts from centres in Germany and the Czech Republic. Diabetes Res Clin Pract2021; 172: 108621.
46.
ChengYZuPZhaoJ, et al.Differences in initial versus recurrent diabetic foot ulcers at a specialized tertiary diabetic foot care center in China. J Int Med Res2021; 49: 300060520987398.
47.
KhalifaWA. Risk factors for diabetic foot ulcer recurrence: a prospective 2-year follow-up study in Egypt. Foot2018; 35: 11–15.
48.
KeukenkampRBusch-WestbroekTEBarnR, et al.Foot ulcer recurrence, plantar pressure and footwear adherence in people with diabetes and charcot midfoot deformity: a cohort analysis. Diabetic Med2021; 38: e14438.
49.
FournierCSingboNMorissetteN,et al.Outcomes of diabetic foot ulcers in a tertiary referral interdisciplinary clinic: a retrospective Canadian study. Can J Diabetes2021; 45: 255–260.
50.
HicksCWCannerJKMathioudakisN, et al.Incidence and risk factors associated with ulcer recurrence among patients with diabetic Foot ulcers treated in a multidisciplinary setting. J Surg Res2020; 246: 243–250.
51.
FreitasFWinterMCieslinskiJ, et al.Risk factors for plantar foot ulcer recurrence in patients with diabetes – a prospective pilot study. J Tissue Viability2020; 29: 135–137.
52.
HofflerHLHoneycuttBJBrackneyCK, et al.Reulceration and reoperation incidence after isolated partial fifth ray amputations: a multicenter study. J Foot Ankle Surg2022; 61: 298–304.
53.
LedouxWRShoferJBSmithDG, et al.Relationship between foot type, foot deformity, and ulcer occurrence in the high-risk diabetic foot. J Rehabil Res Dev2005; 42: 665–672.
ReiberGESmithDGWallaceC, et al.Effect of therapeutic footwear on foot reulceration in patients with diabetes: a randomized controlled trial. Jama2002; 287: 2552–2558.
56.
ConnorHMahdiOZ. Repetitive ulceration in neuropathic patients. Diabetes Metab Res Rev2004; 20: S23–S28.
57.
NickersonDSRaderAJ. Nerve decompression after diabetic foot ulceration may protect against recurrence: a 3-year controlled, prospective analysis. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc2014; 104: 66–70.
58.
MatricaliGADerooKDereymaekerG. Outcome and recurrence rate of diabetic foot ulcers treated by a total contact cast: short-term follow-up. Foot Ankle Int2003; 24: 680–684.
59.
BrinkT. Induration of the diabetic foot pad: another risk factor for recurrent neuropathic plantar ulcers. Biomed Tech (Berl)1995; 40: 205–209.
60.
BatistaFMagalhãesAANeryC, et al.Minimally invasive surgery for diabetic plantar foot ulcerations. Diabet Foot Ankle2011; 2: 10358.
61.
BusSAWaaijmanRArtsM, et al.Effect of custom-made footwear on foot ulcer recurrence in diabetes: a multicenter randomized controlled trial. Diabetes Care2013; 36: 4109–4116.
62.
HelmPAWalkerSCPulliumGF. Recurrence of neuropathic ulceration following healing in a total contact cast. Arch Phys Med Rehabil1991; 72: 967–970.
PetrovOPfeiferMFloodM, et al.Recurrent plantar ulceration following pan metatarsal resection. J Foot Ankle Surg1996; 35: 573–577.
65.
UlbrechtJSHurleyTMaugerDT,et al.Prevention of recurrent foot ulcers with plantar pressure–based in-shoe orthoses: the careful prevention multicenter randomized controlled trial. Diabetes Care2014; 37: 1982–1989.
66.
MalufKSMuellerMJ. Comparison of physical activity and cumulative plantar tissue stress among subjects with and without diabetes mellitus and a history of recurrent plantar ulcers. Clin Biomech2003; 18: 567–575.
Bin RakhisSASrAlDuwayhisNMAleidN,et al.Glycemic control for type 2 diabetes mellitus patients: a systematic review. Cureus2022; 14: e26180.
69.
AzzamMMIbrahimAAAbd El-GhanyMI. Factors affecting glycemic control among Egyptian people with diabetes attending primary health care facilities in Mansoura District. Egypt J Intern Med2021; 33: 33.
70.
CraneMBranchP. The healed diabetic foot. What next?Clin Podiatr Med Surg1998; 15: 155–174.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
