Coaching and Mentoring in Small to Medium Sized Enterprises in the UK – Factors that Affect Success and a Possible Solution

Abstract

This paper, adopts a case study approach in order to examine the issues relating to the deployment of a coaching and mentoring intervention within the context of a specific UK based small and medium-sized enterprise (SME). The SME coaching and mentoring research agenda is highlighted as an area urgently needing attention given its economic impact. This paper seeks to initiate this debate. The pre-eminence of culture within an organisational context is analysed in order to establish its uniqueness and impact on coaching and mentoring deployment. A number of barriers to effective coaching and mentoring within this context are also identified as issues that need to be incorporated within an intervention if it is to be successful. A coaching and mentoring programme was developed to incorporate these findings and provide a starting point to address the SME research chasm.

Keywords

SME coaching mentoring barriers culture

References

Alder

(1992) ‘A model for personal success’, Management Decision, 23, 23–25.

Atkinson

D.L.

, Casas

and Neville

(1994) ‘Ethnic minority psychologists: Whom they mentor and benefits they derive from the process’, Journal of Multicultural Counseling and Development, 22, 37–48.

Barham

and Conway

(1998) Developing Business and People Internationally: A Mentoring Approach, Berkhampstead: Ashridge Research.

Birley

and Westhead

(1989) ‘Growth and performance contrasts between types of new firms’, EIASM 3^rd Workshop on Entrepreneurship Research.

Blackburn

and Kitching

(1997) ‘Management training for SMEs: a comparative study of three European regions’, ISBA 20^th National Small Firms Policy and Research Conference.

Bramley

(1999) ‘Evaluating effective management learning’, Journal of European Industrial Training, 23, 3, 145–53.

Burnes

(1996) Managing Change. A Strategic Approach to Organizational Dynamics, London: Pitman Publishing.

Cannon

(1997) ‘Management development and business performance: what do we know and what do we need to know?’, Managing the Solution, London, Management Charter Initiative.

Carson

D.J.

, Cromie

, McGowan

and Hill

(1995) Marketing and Entrepreneurship in SMEs: An Innovative Approach, London: Prentice-Hall.

10.

Carson

D.J.

and Cromie

(1989) ‘Marketing planning in small enterprises: a model and some empirical evidence’, Journal of Marketing Management, 5, 1, 33–51.

11.

Centre for Enterprise (2001) Evaluation of Management Development and Leadership Provision in the East Midlands: Is Supply Meeting Demand?, Leicester: Centre for Enterprise.

12.

Choueke

R.W. E.

and Armstrong

R. K.

(2000) ‘Culture: a missing perspective on small- and medium-sized enterprise development?’, International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour & Research, 6, 4, 227–238.

13.

Cleary

(1995) ‘You're the coach’, Credit Union Management, 40–42.

14.

Clutterbuck

(2001) Everyone Needs A Mentor, 3rd Edn., London: Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development.

15.

Crouch

(1997) ‘Winning ways’, People Management, 40–43.

16.

Curran

(1999) ‘A response to the DTI consultancy paper on the new small business service’, ISBA Policy Forum, unpublished paper.

17.

Curran

, Blackburn

, Kitching

and North

(1997) ‘Small firms and workforce training: Some results, analysis and policy implications from a national survey’, in Ram

et al., Small Firms: Enterprising Futures, London: Paul Chapman Publishing, 90–101.

18.

Curran

and Blackburn

(1994) Small Firms and Local Economic Networks: The Death of the Local Economy, London: Paul Chapman.

19.

Curran

and Blackburn

(1999) ‘A critical examination of the proposed new small business service and response to the DTI consultancy paper’, ISBA Policy Forum, unpublished paper.

20.

Department of Trade and Industry (2003) News Release, No. 03/92, London, HMSO.

21.

Devins

and Gold

(2000) "Cracking the tough nuts": Mentoring and coaching the managers of small firms’, Career Development International, 5, 4/5, 250–255.

22.

Down

(1999) ‘Owner-manager learning in small firms’, Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 6, 3, 267–78.

23.

Eisenhardt

K.M.

(1989) ‘Building theories from case study research’, Academy of Management Review, 14, 4, 532–550.

24.

Gaunt

(1998) ‘Investors in people and the small business’, ISBA National Conference, 497–511.

25.

Geroy

G.D.

, Wright

P.C.

and Anderson

(1998) ‘Strategic performance empowerment model’, Empowerment in Organisations, 6, 2, 57–65.

26.

Gersick

K.E.

, Davis

J.A.

, McCollom

M.H.

and Lansberg

(1997) Generation to Generation, Cambridge: HBS Press.

27.

Gibb

A.A.

(1997) ‘Small firms training and competitiveness: building upon the small business as a learning organisation’, International Small Business Journal, 15, 3, 13–29.

28.

Goldsmith

and Clutterbuck

(1984) The Winning Streak, London: Weidenfeld and Nicholson.

29.

Gray

(1998) Enterprise and Culture, London: Routledge.

30.

Hankinson

(1994) ‘Small firms training: The reluctance prevails’, Industrial and Commercial Training, 26, 9, 30–32.

31.

Hay

(1999) Transformational Mentoring: Creating Developmental Alliances for Changing Organizational Cultures, Watford: Sherwood Publishing.

32.

Hill

(2001) ‘A multidimensional study of the key determinants of effective SME marketing activity: Part 1’, International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research, 7, 5, 171–204.

33.

Hodgetts

R.M.

and Kuratko

D.F.

(1995) Effective Small Business Management, 5th ed, Fort Worth: Dryden.

34.

Holmund

and Kock

(1998) ‘Relationships and the internationalisation of Finnish small and medium-sized companies’, International Small Business Journal, 16, 64, 46–63.

35.

Horsfall

G.A.

(1996) ‘Accountability: the force behind empowerment’, Hospital Material Management Quarterly, 26–31.

36.

Joyce

, McNully

and Woods

(1995) ‘Workforce training: Are small firms different?’, Journal of European Industrial Training, 19, 5, 19–25.

37.

Klasen

and Clutterbuck

(2002) Implementing Mentoring Schemes; A practical guide to successful programs, London: Butterworth Heinemann.

38.

Kuratko

D.F.

and Hodgetts

T.M.

(1995) Entrepreneurship: A Contemporary Approach, 3rd ed, Fort Worth, TX: The Dryden Press.

39.

Leppard

and MacDonald

M.H.

(1991) ‘Marketing planning and corporate culture: a conceptual framework’, Journal of Marketing Management, 7, 3, 213–35.

40.

Martin

and Staines

(1994) ‘Managerial competencies in small firms’, Journal of Management Development, 13, 7, 23–34.

41.

Mead

, Campbell

and Milan

(1999) ‘Mentor and Athene: Supervising professional coaches and mentors’, Career Development International, 4, 5, 283–290.

42.

Megginson

and Clutterbuck

(1995) Mentoring in Action: A Practical Guide for Managers, London: Kogan Page.

43.

Merriam

(1983) ‘Mentoring: Person, process, practice and problems, Adult Education Quarterly, 33, 3, 161–173.

44.

Mullins

L.J.

(1989) Management and Organisational Behaviour, 2nd Edn., London: Pitman Publishing.

45.

Nancarrow

, Attlee

and Wright

L.T.

(1999) ‘Weaknesses in the marketing and the adoption of independent inventors with implications for international competitiveness’, Journal of Enterprising Culture, 7, 3, 233–56.

46.

Nash

(1994) ‘People power?’, The Director, 34–6.

47.

Parsloe

(1992) Coaching, Mentoring and Assessing: A Practical Guide to Developing Confidence, London: Kogan Page.

48.

Parsloe

and Wray

(2000) Coaching and Mentoring: Practical Methods to Improve Learning, London: Kogan Page.

49.

Pescuric

and Byham

W.C.

(1996) ‘The new look of behavior modeling’, Training and Development, 24–30.

50.

Phillips

(1995) ‘Coaching for high performance’, Executive Development, 5–7.

51.

Porter

(1980) Competitive Strategy: Techniques for Analysing Industries and Competitors, New York, NY: The Free Press.

52.

Ram

(2000) ‘Investors in people in small firms: case study evidence from the business service sector’, Personnel Review, 29, 1, 69–91.

53.

Robinson

and Henry

(2001) Government-Supported Management and Workforce Development Initiatives for SMEs: There is Another Way, Leicester: Small Firm Enterprise Development Initiative/Centre for Enterprise.

54.

Ross

(1993) ‘Training and evaluation in SMEs: Manufacturing enterprises in the West Midlands’, Local Economy, 8, 2, 143–154.

55.

Sarantakos

(1994) Social Research, London: MacMillan Press Ltd.

56.

Schein

(1985) Organization Culture and Leadership, San Francisco, CA.: Jossey Bass.

57.

Schein

(1996) ‘Three cultures of management: The key to organizational learning’, Sloan Management Review, 9–20.

58.

Smith

A.J.

, Bocock

, Loan-Clark

and Whittaker

(2002) ‘IIP and SMEs: Awareness, benefits and barriers’, Personnel Review, 31, 1, 62–85.

59.

Smith

A.J.

and Whittaker

(1998) ‘Management development in SMEs: What needs to be done?’, Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development, 5, 2, 176–185.

60.

Stanworth

and Gray

(1991) ‘Bolton 20 years on: The Small Firm in the 1990's’, Small Business Research Trust.

61.

Storey

D.J.

(1994) Understanding the Small Business Sector, London: Routledge.

62.

Storey

D.J.

and Westhead

(1996) ‘Management training in small firms a case of market failure’, Human Resource Management Journal, 7, 2, 61–71.

63.

Tamkin

(1996) ‘Practical applications for personal development plans’, Management Development Review, 9, 7, 32–36.

64.

Thompson

and McHugh

(1995) Work Organisations. A Critical Introduction, London: Macmillan.

65.

Westhead

and Storey

D.J.

(1996) ‘Management training and small firm performance: Why is the link so weak?’, International Small Business Journal, 14, 4, 13–24.

66.

Westhead

and Storey

D.J.

(1997) ‘Training provision and the development of small and medium-sized enterprises’, DfEE Research Report No. 26, London, DfEE/HMSO.

67.

Whitmore

(2002) Coaching for Performance: Growing People, Performance and Purpose, 3rd edn., London: Nicholas Brealey Publishing.

68.

Wilhelm

(1992) ‘Changing corporate culture – Or corporate behavior? How to change your company’, Academy of Management Executive, 72–77.

69.

Wynarczyk

, Watson

, Storey

D.J.

, Short

and Keasey

(1993) The Managerial Labour Market in Small and Medium-Sized Enterprises, London: Routledge.

70.

Yin

R.K.

(1984) Case Study Research: Design and Methods, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

71.

Zenger

J.H.

(1991) ‘The power of applied principles’, Executive Excellence, 18–19.

72.

Zimmer

T.W.

and Scarborough

N.M.

(1994) Essentials of Small Business Management, New York, NY: MacMillan.