Popular documentary representations of crime and punishment have traditionally tended to fall into two camps: programs that are critical of law enforcement agencies and those that are sympathetic to them. In this article, we show how programs that present themselves as critical of legal authorities can nonetheless reinforce the “law and order punitivism” that underlay the ratcheting up of harsh punishment in the late 20th century. In a case study of the popular documentary miniseries Making a Murderer, we show how this can happen when texts fetishize the question of a criminal defendant’s innocence, adopt a “good versus evil” approach to players in the criminal justice system, and perpetuate a procedural rather than substantive vision of justice. Arguments are supported by a close reading of Making a Murderer and illustrated by a line of discussion it inspired in an internet forum.
CarrabineE (2014) Seeing things: Violence, voyeurism and the camera. Theoretical Criminology 18(2): 134–158.
6.
CavenderGFishmanM (1998) Introduction. In: FishmanMCavenderG (eds) Entertaining Crime: Television Reality Programs. New York: Aldine De Gruyter, pp. 1–15
7.
ColeSAAronsonJD (2009) Blinded by science on the road to abolition? In: OgletreeCJSaratA (eds) The Road to Abolition. New York: New York University Press, pp. 46–71
8.
DoyleA (2003) Arresting Images: Crime and Policing in Front of the Television Camera. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
GottschalkM (2011) The long shadow of the death penalty: Mass incarceration, capital punishment, and penal policy in the United States. In: SaratAMartschukatJ (eds) Is the Death Penalty Dying? European and American Perspectives. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 292–321.
11.
HaleGE (2010) A Nation of Outsiders: How the White Middle Class fell in Love with Rebellion in Postwar America. New York: Oxford University Press.
IsenbergN (2016) White Trash: The 400-Year Untold History of Class in America. New York: Penguin.
14.
KennedyL (2018) ‘Man I’m all torn up inside:’ Analyzing audience responses to Making a Murderer. Crime Media Culture. 14(3): 391–408.
15.
KohmSA (2006) The People’s Law versus Judge Judy justice: Two models of law in American reality-based courtroom TV. Law & Society Review40(3): 693–727.
16.
LaChanceDKaplanP (2019) The seductions of crimesploitation: The apprehension of sex offenders on primetime television. Law, Culture and the Humanities15(1): 127–150.
17.
LevineLW (1992) The folklore of industrial society: Popular culture and its audiences. The American Historical Review97(3): 1369–1399.
18.
Making a Murderer (2015) [TV] Directed by Laura Ricciardi and Moira Demos. Los Angeles, CA: Netflix and Synthesis Films.
19.
MarshallL (2004) The innocence revolution and the death penalty. Walter C. Reckless Memorial Lecture. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law1: 573–584.
RubinJS (1992) The Making of Middlebrow Culture. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.
29.
SassoubreTM (forthcoming) Knowing it when we see it: Realism, melodrama, and the epistemology of American film. In: SaratAUmphreyMMSilbeyJessica (eds) Trial Films on Trial. Tuscaloosa, AL: University of Alabama Press.
30.
SchulzK (2016) Dead certainty: How ‘Making a Murderer’ goes wrong. The New Yorker, 25January, pp. 60–64.
31.
SimonJ (2007) Governing Through Crime: How the War on Crime Transformed American Democracy and Created a Culture of Fear. New York: Oxford University Press.
32.
SingerB (2001) Melodrama and Modernity: Early Sensational Cinema and Its Contexts. New York: Columbia University Press.
33.
SmithA (2010) In praise of the guilty project: A criminal defense lawyer’s growing anxiety about innocence projects. University of Pennsylvania Journal of Law and Social Change. 13: 315–329.
SteikerCSSteikerJM (2005) The seduction of innocence: The attractions and limitations of focusing on innocence in capital punishment law and advocacy. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology95(2): 587–624.
36.
StoryB (2017a) Against a ‘humanizing’ prison cinema. In: BrownMCarrabineE (eds) Routledge International Handbook of Visual Criminology. New York: Routledge, pp. 455–465.
WeisselbergCD (2016) Against innocence. In: HunterJRobertsPYoungSDixonD (eds) The Integrity of Criminal Process–From Theory to Practice. Hart, pp. 349–370.
39.
WassermanE (2013) Ethics of poverty coverage. Journal of Mass Media Ethics28(2): 138–140.
