Gallous stories or dirty deeds? Representing parricide in J.M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World

Abstract

The most famous play in the history of Irish theater, J.M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World has been oddly neglected in sociology and criminology. This article examines the provenance of the violence around which Playboy’s dizzying text swirls, namely, a tragicomic parricide seemingly twice committed. In particular, we ask: is the text plausible? Though Synge’s authorial intentions are not open to complete reclamation, we explore first, his self-stated reliance on the actual cases of William Maley and James Lynchehaun and, second, whether the representation(s) of parricide in Playboy more or less accurately reflected the presence and character of parricide at the time the controversial play was being imagined and first performed in 1907. The culture wars and associated media frenzy over the play provide an ever-looming backcloth against which to interpret the meanings of intergenerational violence in a colonial society lurching towards national self-determination.

Keywords

Irish literary culture J.M. Synge parricide The Playboy of the Western World

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

‘A.F.’ (1907) ‘"I Don’t Care a Rap" - Mr. Synge’s Defence,’ The Mail, 29 January, p. 7.

Allen, G. ( 1997) ‘An Irishman’s Diary’, The Irish Times, 31 January, p. 13.

Ashley, S. ( 2001) ‘The Poetics of Race in 1890s Ireland: An Ethnography of the Aran Islands’, Patterns of Prejudice , 35(2): 5-18.

Bessai, D.E. ( 1968) ‘Little Hound in Mayo: Synge’s Playboy and The Comic Tradition In Irish Literature’, Dalhousie Review, 48(3): 372-83.

Bourgeois, M. ( 1913) John Millington Synge and the Irish Theatre. London: Constable and Company.

Bretherton, G. ( 1991) ‘A Carnival Christy and a Playboy for All Ages’ , Twentieth-Century Literature, 37(3): 322-34.

Carney, J. ( 1986) The Playboy & the Yellow Lady. Dublin: Poolbeg.

Conley, C.A. ( 1999) Melancholy Accidents: The Meaning of Violence in Post-Famine Ireland. Lanham, Maryland: Lexington Books.

Dallett, A. ( 1996) ‘Protest in the Playhouse: Two Twentieth-Century Audience Riots’, New Theatre Quarterly, 12(48): 323-32.

10.

Doggett, R. ( 1997) ’The Three Fathers of the Past: A Sociological reading of The Playboy of the Western World and the Playboy Riots’, Colby Quarterly, xxxiii(4): 281-94.

11.

Foucault, M. (1975) (ed.) I, Pierre Rivière, Having Slaughtered My Mother, My Sister, and My Brother… Lincoln, Nebraska: University of Nebraska Press.

12.

Frazier, A. (2004) (ed.) Playboys of the Western World. Dublin: Carysfort Press.

13.

Jones, G. ( 1998) ‘Contested Territories: Alfred Cort Haddon, Progressive Evolutionism and Ireland’, History of European Ideas , 24(3): 195-211.

14.

Kiberd, D. ( 1979) ‘J.M. Synge and the Songs of the Folk’ , Hermathena (126): 7-37: in press.

15.

Kiberd, D. ( 1995) Inventing Ireland: The Literature of the Modern Nation . London: Jonathan Cape .

16.

Kiberd, D. ( 2000) Irish Classics. London: Granta Books.

17.

O’Donnell, I. ( 2005) ‘Lethal Violence in Ireland, 1841 to 2003: Famine, Celibacy and Parental Pacification’, British Journal of Criminology, 45(1): 671-95.

18.

O’Donnell, I. ( 2010) ‘Killing in Ireland at the Turn of the Centuries: Contexts, Consequences and Civilizing Processes’, Irish Economic and Social History, 37:

19.

‘Pat’ (1907) ‘That Dreadful Play’, The Irish Times, 30 January 1907, p. 9.

20.

Synge, J.M. ( 1907a/1995) ‘The Playboy of the Western World’ , in A. Saddlemyer (ed.) The Playboy of the Western World and Other Plays, pp. 95-146. Oxford : Oxford University Press.

21.

Synge, J.M. ( 1907b) ‘Letter to the Editor’, The Irish Times, 31 January, p. 5.

22.

Synge, J.M. ( 1907c/1983) ‘To Stephen MacKenna, April 17’ , in A. Saddlemyer (ed.) Collected Letters, vol. 1, 1871-1907, pp. 332-3. Oxford : Clarendon.

23.

Synge, J.M. ( 1907d/1979) The Aran Islands. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

24.

Trotter, M. ( 1998) ‘Which Fiddler Calls the Tune? The Playboy Riots and The Politics Of Nationalist Theatre Spectatorship’, Theatre Survey, 39(2): 39-52.

25.

Yeats, W.B. ( 1907/2005) ‘To John Quinn, February 18’ , in J. Kelly and R. Schuchard (eds) Collected Letters, vol. 4, 1905-1907, p. 630. Oxford: Oxford University Press.