The purpose of this systematic review is to further our understanding of women and educational leadership knowledge production from three Chinese societies and to contribute to the development of a more diverse global knowledge base in gender and educational leadership and management. A total of 341 articles were identified from 4 electronic databases. We conducted a systematic review of 24 eligible articles that focused on women and educational leadership in Mainland China, Hong Kong and Taiwan, utilised empirical research designs and were published in peer-reviewed English-language journals between 2000 and 2021. This review synthesised six overarching themes, including the underrepresentation of women leaders in schools and universities; barriers for women's career advancement; impact of social-cultural contexts on gender-related leadership; gender stereotypes and gender dynamics; gender-based variation in leadership behaviours; and gender equity legislation and policies. The review reveals that underrepresentation of female leaders is a pervasive problem in both schools and universities across three Chinese societies. Substantial gaps still exist between policies and practices. The study highlights systemic barriers and lack of organisational enablers for women's career advancement. The implications and directions for future studies are discussed.
AistonSJ (2014) Leading the academy or being led? Hong Kong women academics. Higher Education Research & Development33(1): 59–72.
2.
AistonSJFoCK (2021) The silence/ing of academic women. Gender and Education33(2): 138–155.
3.
AistonSJFoCKLawWW (2020) Interrogating strategies and policies to advance women in academic leadership: The case of Hong Kong. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management42(3): 347–364.
4.
AistonSJYangZ (2017) “Absent data, absent women”: Gender and higher education leadership. Policy Futures in Education15(3): 262–274.
5.
AlvessonMAshcraftLKThomasR (2008) Identity matters: Reflections on the construction of identity scholarship in organization studies. Organization15(1): 5–28.
6.
BenschopYBrounsM (2003) Crumbling ivory towers: Academic organizing and its gender effects. Gender Work and Organization10(2): 194–212.
7.
BillingYD (2011) Are women in management victims of the phantom of the male norm?Gender, Work & Organization18(3): 298–317.
8.
BlackmoreJ (2010) ‘The other within’: Race/gender disruptions to the professional learning of white educational leaders. International Journal of Leadership in Education13(1): 45–61.
9.
BlackmoreJ (2013) A feminist critical perspective on educational leadership. International Journal of Leadership in Education16(2): 139–154.
10.
BlackmoreJSawersN (2015) Executive power and scaled-up gender subtexts in Australian entrepreneurial universities. Gender and Education27(3): 320–337.
11.
BreretonPKitchenhamBABudgenD, Turner M and Kahlik M (2007) Lessons from applying the systematic literature review process within the software engineering domain. Journal of Systems and Software80(4): 571–583.
12.
CastilloFAHallingerP (2018) Systematic review of research on educational leadership and management in Latin America, 1991–2017. Educational Management Administration & Leadership46(2): 207–225.
13.
ChanAKW (2011) Feminising and masculinising primary teaching: A critical examination of the interpretive frameworks of Male primary school principals in Hong Kong. Gender and Education23(6): 745–759.
14.
ChanAKWNgaiGSKChoiPK (2016) Contextualising the career pathways of women principals in Hong Kong: A critical examination. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education46(2): 194–213.
15.
ChenPHsiehHC (2019) Women’s academic leadership under competing higher education policies in Taiwan. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education49(5): 759–776.
16.
ChengLHaoMXiaoLWangF (2020) Join us: Dynamic norms encourage women to pursue STEM. Current Psychology41(9): 5967–5977.
17.
ChoiPL (2013) Gender identities and career aspirations of middle leaders: Cases in Hong Kong secondary schools. International Journal of Educational Management27(1): 38–53.
18.
ColemanM (2007) Gender and educational leadership in England: A comparison of secondary headteachers’ views over time. School Leadership & Management27(4): 383–399.
19.
CrenshawK (1989) Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. In: University of Chicago Legal Forum.
20.
CromptonHBurkeD (2018) The use of mobile learning in higher education: A systematic review. Computers & Education123: 53–64.
21.
DanellRHjermM (2013) Career prospects for female university researchers have not improved. Scientometrics94(3): 999–1006.
22.
DaviesJYarrowESyedJ (2020) The curious under-representation of women impact case leaders: Can we disengender inequality regimes?Gender, Work & Organization27(2): 129–148.
23.
DeemR (2003) Gender, organizational cultures and the practices of manager-academics in UK Universities. Gender, Work & Organization10(2): 239–259.
24.
EaglyAH (2015) Foreword. Charlotte: Information Age Publishing.
25.
EaglyAHKarauSJ (2002) Role congruity theory of prejudice toward female leaders. Psychological Review109(3): 573–598.
26.
EaglyAHKarauSJJohnsonBT (1992) Gender and leadership style among school principals: A meta-analysis. Educational Administration Quarterly28(1): 76–102.
27.
EnglandKVLBoyerK (2009) Women s work: The feminization and shifting meanings of clerical work. Journal of Social History43(2): 307–340.
28.
FaroukUK (2006) Gender in management: The case of Malaysian women. Proceedings of International Conference on Social Sciences: Endangered and Engendered. Fatima Jinnah Women University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan, 441–459.
29.
FengFI (2011) A study on school Leaders’ ethical orientations in Taiwan. Ethics & Behavior21(4): 317–331.
30.
FengFIChenWL (2019) The effect of Principals’ social justice leadership on Teachers’ academic optimism in Taiwan. Education and Urban Society51(9): 1245–1264.
31.
FordJ (2006) Discourses of leadership: Gender, identity and contradiction in a UK public sector organization. Leadership2(1): 77–99.
32.
FullerKMoorosiPShowunmiVShahS (2021) Editorial: Ways of seeing women’s leadership in education—stories, images, metaphors, methods and theories. Frontiers in Education6: 781049.
33.
GallantA (2014) Symbolic interactions and the development of women leaders in higher education. Gender, Work & Organization21(3): 203–216.
34.
GaskellJEichlerMPanJXuJZhangX (2004) The participation of women faculty in Chinese universities: Paradoxes of globalization. Gender and Education16(4): 511–529.
35.
GatesS (2002) Review of methodology of quantitative reviews using meta-analysis in ecology. Journal of Animal Ecology71(4): 547–557.
36.
GordonRD (2002) Conceptualizing leadership with respect to its historical–contextual antecedents to power. The Leadership Quarterly13(2): 151–167.
37.
GuarinoCMBordenVMH (2017) Faculty service loads and gender: Are women taking care of the academic family?Research in Higher Education58(6): 672–694.
38.
HallingerPLiDWangW-C (2016) Gender differences in instructional leadership: A meta-analytic review of studies using the principal instructional management rating scale. Educational Administration Quarterly52(4): 567–601.
39.
HammadWSamierEAMohammedA (2022) Mapping the field of educational leadership and management in the Arabian gulf region: A systematic review of arabic research literature. Educational Management Administration & Leadership50(1): 6–25.
40.
HannumKMMuhlySMShockley-ZalabakPS and White JS (2015) Women leaders within higher education in the United States: Supports, barriers, and experiences of being a senior leader. Advancing Women in Leadership35: 65–75.
41.
HigginsJThomasJChandlerJ, Cumpston M, Li T, Page MJ and Welch VA (2021) Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
42.
HofstedeG (2007) Asian management in the 21st century. Asia Pacific Journal of Management24(4): 411–420.
43.
Howe-WalshLTurnbullS (2016) Barriers to women leaders in academia: Tales from science and technology. Studies in Higher Education41(3): 415–428.
44.
HuangY-CYangC-CWuH-H (2012) The comparison of gender distribution among school principals and teachers in Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea. International Education Studies5(4): 1–10.
45.
KnightsD (2021) Leadership, Gender and Ethics: Embodied Reason in Challenging Masculinities. New York: Routledge.
46.
KwanPWalkerA (2012) Linking vice-principals’ perceptions of responsibilities, job satisfaction and career aspirations. International Studies in Educational Administration40(1): 3–17.
47.
LawW-W (2013) Culture, gender and school leadership: School leaders’ self-perceptions in China. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education43(3): 295–322.
48.
LeithwoodKSunJ (2012) The nature and effects of transformational school leadership: A meta-analytic review of unpublished research. Educational Administration Quarterly48(3): 387–423.
49.
LuH (2022) Funv quanyi baozhangfa xiuding- zhongguo funv renquan shiye de xinqidian [Amendment to the law on the protection of women's rights and interests-A new starting point for the cause of women's human rights in China]. Reming Ribao [People’s Daily]. Available at: https://news.ruc.edu.cn/archives/380094 (accessed on 28 June 2022).
50.
MarshallCWynnS (2012) Expanding the conversation: Collaboration, complexities and the missing pieces. Educational Administration Quarterly48(5): 883–892.
51.
McRobbieA (2009) The aftermath of feminism: Gender, culture and social change. London: Sage.
52.
Ministry of Science and Technology of China (2021) Guanyu zhichi nvxing keji rencai zai keji chuangxin zhong fahui gengda zuoyong de ruogan cuoshi [A series of measures to support female researchers in playing a greater role in sci-tech innovation]. Available at: http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2021-07/19/content_5625925.htm (accessed 14 Aug, 2022).
53.
MonroeKOzyurtSWrigleyTAlexanderA (2008) Gender equality in academia: Bad news from the trenches, and some possible solutions. Perspectives on Politics6(2): 215–233.
54.
MoreauMPOsgoodJHalsallA (2007) Making sense of the glass ceiling in schools: An exploration of women teachers’ discourses. Gender and Education19(2): 237–253.
55.
MorleyL (2013) The rules of the game: Women and the leaderist turn in higher education. Gender and Education25(1): 116–131.
56.
MorleyL (2014) Lost leaders: Women in the global academy. Higher Education Research & Development33(1): 114–128.
57.
MorleyLCrossouardB (2016) Women's leadership in the Asian century: Does expansion mean inclusion?Studies in Higher Education41(5): 801–814.
58.
OakleyA (2012) Foreword. In: GoughDOliverSThomasJ (eds) An introduction to Systematic Reviews. London: Sage Publications, vii–vix.
59.
OECD (2010) Atlas of gender and development: How social norms affect gender equality in non-OECD Countries. Paris: OECD.
60.
OplatkaI (2006) Women in educational administration within developing countries: Towards a new international research agenda. Journal of Educational Administration44(6): 604–624.
61.
PisapiaJLinY (2011) Values and actions: An exploratory study of school principals in the mainland of China. Frontiers of Education in China6: 361–387.
62.
QinLTorresMSMadsenJ (2019) Building pathways: Nurturing a female generation of school leaders in China. Journal of Women in Educational Leadership: 1–24. Available at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/jwel/217/ (accessed on 25 June 2022).
63.
RobinsonKShakeshaftCGroganMNewcombWS (2017) Necessary but not sufficient: The continuing inequality between men and women in educational leadership, findings from the American Association of School Administrators Mid-Decade survey. Frontiers in Education2(12). Available at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/feduc.2017.00012/full (accessed on 25 June 2022).
64.
RuanN (2021a) Accumulating academic freedom for intellectual leadership: Women professors’ experiences in Hong Kong. Educational Philosophy and Theory53(11): 1097–1107.
65.
RuanN (2021b) Female professors developing intellectual leadership in Hong Kong: Considering disciplinary. Institutional and Gender Factors. Journal of Comparative & International Higher Education12(6S1): 82–90.
66.
ScottGBellSCoatesHGrebennikovL (2010) Australian Higher education leaders in times of change: The role of Pro Vice-Chancellor and Deputy Vice-Chancellor. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management32(4): 401–418.
67.
ShahS (2010) Re-thinking educational leadership: Exploring the impact of cultural and belief systems. International Journal of Leadership in Education13(1): 27–44.
68.
ShahS (2018) ‘We are equals’; datum or delusion: Perceptions of Muslim women academics in three Malaysian universities. British Journal of Sociology of Education39(3): 299–315.
69.
ShahS (2020) Gender equality and situated constructions: Perspectives of women educational leaders in a muslim society. Educational Studies56(1): 37–53.
70.
ShakedHGlanzJGrossZ (2018) Gender differences in instructional leadership: How male and female principals perform their instructional leadership role. School Leadership & Management38(4): 417–434.
71.
ShowunmiV (2021) A journey of difference: The voices of women leaders. Frontiers in Education6(13): 548807.
72.
ShowunmiVAtewologunDBebbingtonD (2016) Ethnic, gender and class intersections in British women’s leadership experiences. Educational Management Administration & Leadership44(6): 917–935.
73.
ShowunmiVMoorosiPWoodhouseJShahSFullerK (2017) Gender in educational leadership: Where are we in research?Management in Education31(2): 51–53.
74.
SperandioJ (2010) Modeling cultural context for aspiring women educational leaders. Journal of Educational Administration48(6): 716–726.
75.
SposatoMRumensN (2021) Advancing international human resource management scholarship on paternalistic leadership and gender: The contribution of postcolonial feminism. The International Journal of Human Resource Management32(6): 1201–1221.
76.
TangLHortaH (2021) Women academics in Chinese universities: A historical perspective. Higher Education82(5): 865–895.
77.
ThomasRDaviesA (2002) Gender and new public management: Reconstituting academic subjectivities. Gender, Work & Organization9(4): 372–397.
78.
TsangAYChanPSZhangL (2011) Reconciling conflicts: The “accidental” women leaders in contemporary China. Affilia26(3): 314–326.
Van den BrinkMBenschopYJansenW (2010) Transparency in academic recruitment: A problematic tool for gender equality?Organization Studies31(11): 1459–1483.
81.
WangSJonesGA (2021) Competing institutional logics of academic personnel system reforms in leading Chinese universities. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management43(1): 49–66.
82.
WangYQiYKaiY (2013) Women leaders of higher education: Female executives in leading universities in China. Cross-cultural Communication9(6): 40–45.
83.
WhiteKCarvalhoTRiordanS (2011) Gender, power and managerialism in universities. Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management33(2): 179–188.
84.
WilkinsonJPurveeAMacDonaldK (2021) Gender and educational leadership. In: CourtneySJGunterHMNiescheR, et al. (eds) Understanding Educational Leadership, 1st ed. London UK: Bloomsbury Academic, 255–268.
85.
WongKCNgHM (2003) On Hong Kong: The making of secondary school principals. International Studies in Educational Administration31(2): 35–53.
86.
XiaoYWatsonM (2019) Guidance on conducting a systematic literature review. Journal of Planning Education and Research39(1): 93–112.
87.
Xinhua News Agency (2019) Dangzheng lingdao ganbu xuanba renyong gongzuo tiaoli [Regulations on the Work of Selecting and Appointing Leading Party and Government Cadres]. Available at:http://www.gov.cn/zhengce/2019-03/17/content_5374532.htm(accessed on 14 August 2022).
88.
YangJ (2020) Women in China moving forward: Progress, challenges and reflections. Social Inclusion8(2): 23–35.
89.
YangR (2011) Self and the other in the confucian cultural context: Implications of China’s higher education development for comparative studies. International Review of Education57(3): 337–355.
90.
ZhaoJJonesK (2017) Women and leadership in higher education in China: Discourse and the discursive construction of identity. Administrative Sciences7(3): 21.
91.
ZhongWEhrichLC (2010) An exploration of two female principals’ leadership in mainland China. Journal of Educational Administration48(2): 241–260.
