Portraits of UK Black and South Asian headteachers five years on: Leadership retention in the age of academization

Abstract

This article analyzes the career trajectories of eight Black and South Asian headteachers who were part of a larger study of three generations of Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic (BAME) headteachers (28) interviewed in 2015 (Johnson, 2017). Using a longitudinal life history approach and portraiture, it seeks to answer the question, “How do Black and South Asian headteachers narrate their career progression and leadership values over time?” In particular, I explore the growth of academization and the formation of Multi-Academy Trusts (MATs) on the work lives of Black and South Asian headteachers and the role of autonomy, value alignment, and professional support on their leadership retention.

Keywords

Black headteachers South Asian headteachers leadership retention academization

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arar

(2019) The challenges involved when Arab women forge a path to educational leadership: context, personal cost, and coping. Educational Management, Administration, and Leadership 47(5): 749–765.

Bush

(2019) Talent, determination, and resilience: leadership accession and enactment for black, Asian, and minority ethnic leaders. In: Miller

Callendar

(eds) Race, Education and Educational Leadership in England. London: Bloomsbury, pp. 81–97.

Crow

(2015) ISSPP Identity Protocol. Unpublished.

Department for Education (DfE) (2018) School Leadership in England 2010 to 2016: Characteristics and Trends. Revised July 2018. London: Author.

Dickens

(2020) Fraud costs balloon, and 7 more academy sector accounts findings. Schools Week Available at: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/fraud-costs-balloon-and-7-more-academy-sector-accounts-findings/ (accessed 4 September 2020).

Early

(2020) Surviving, thriving and reviving in leadership: the personal and professional development needs of educational leaders. Management in Education 34(3): 117–121.

Early

Weindling

(2007) Do school leaders have a shelf life? Career stages and headteacher performance. Educational Management, Administration, & Leadership 35(1): 73–88.

Gilligan

Spencer

Weinberg

Bertsch

(2004) On the listening guide: a voice-centered relational method. In: Camic

Rhodes

Yardley

(eds) Qualitative Research in Psychology: Expanding Perspectives in Methodology and Design. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association, pp. 157–171.

Goodson

(1992) Studying Teachers Lives: Problems and Possibilities. London: Routledge.

10.

Goodson

Sikes

(2001) Life History Research in Educational Settings: Learning from Lives. Buckingham: Open University Press.

11.

Greany

Higham

(2018) Hierarchy, Markets and Networks: Analysing the ‘Self-Improving School-Led System’ Agenda in England and the Implications for Schools. London: UCL IOE Press.

12.

Hallinger

Heck

(2010) Leadership for learning: does collaborative leadership make a difference in school improvement? Educational Management, Administration, & Leadership 38(6): 654–678.

13.

Iqbal

(2019) Race, religion and school leadership: the experience of Muslim-Pakistani headteachers. In: Miller

Callender

(eds) Race, Education, and Educational Leadership in England: An Integrated Analysis. London: Bloomsbury Press, pp. 211–236.

14.

Johnson

(2013) Segregation or “thinking Black”? Community activism and the development of Black-focused schools in Toronto and London, 1968–2008. Teachers College Record 115(11): 25.

15.

Johnson

(2016) Boundary spanners and advocacy leaders: black educators and race equality work in Toronto and London, 1968–1995. Leadership and Policy in Schools 15(1): 91–115.

16.

Johnson

(2017) The lives and identities of UK Black and South Asian head teachers: metaphors of leadership. Educational Management, Administration, & Leadership 45(5): 842–862.

17.

Johnson

Campbell-Stephens

(2010) Investing in diversity in London schools: leadership preparation for Black and Global Majority educators. Urban Education 45(6): 840–870.

18.

Johnson

Campbell-Stephens

(2013) Developing the next generation of Black and Global Majority leaders for London schools. Journal of Educational Administration 51(1): 24–39.

19.

Keddie

(2019) Context matters: primary schools and academies reform in England. Journal of Educational Policy 34(1): 6–21.

20.

Lawrence-Lightfoot

(1984) The Good High School: Portraits in Character and Culture. New York, NY: Basic Books.

21.

Lawrence-Lightfoot

(2019) Learning to Listen Featuring Sara Lawrence-Lightfoot. Learning to Listen: Conversations for Change. Brazelton Touchpoints Center. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_s-rIEP4EGk (accessed 14 April 2021).

22.

Lawrence-Lightfoot

Davis

(1997) The Art and Science of Portraiture. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

23.

Lofthouse

Whitehead

(2020) Sustaining a Vital Profession: A Research Report into the Impact of Leadership Coaching in Schools. Leeds: Leeds Beckett University.

24.

Lynch

Mills

Theobald

Worth

(2017) Keeping Your Head: NFER Analysis of Headteacher Retention. Slough: NFER.

25.

MacBeath

Gronn

Opfer

Lowden

Forde

Cowie

O’Brien

(2009) The Recruitment and Retention of Headteachers in Scotland. Edinburgh: Scottish Government Social Research.

26.

Male

(2019) Governance in Multi-Academy Trusts: Evidence from the Field. Paper presented at the European Educational Research Association (ECER) conference, Hamburg, 3 September 2019, pp. 1–22. European Educational Research Association.

27.

Miller

(2020) Tackling race inequality in school leadership: positive actions in BAME teacher progression- evidence from three English schools. Educational Management, Administration, & Leadership 48(6): 986–1006.

28.

Moorsi

Fuller

Reilly

(2018) Leadership and intersectionality: constructions of successful leadership among Black women school principals in three different contexts. Management in Education 32(4): 152–159.

29.

National Association of Head Teachers (2017) Recruitment and Retention. The Leaky Pipeline. Haywards Heath: NAHT. Available at: https://www.naht.org.uk/news-and-opinion/news/pay-and-conditions-news/the-leaky-pipeline/ (accessed 13 April 2021).

30.

National Audit Office (2018) Converting Maintained Schools to Academies. Available at: https://www.nao.org.uk/press-release/converting-maintained-schools-to-academies/#:∼:text=Academies%20are%20publicly%20funded%20independent,set%20up%20as%20free%20schools (accessed 13 April 2021).

31.

National Union of Teachers and Runnymede Trust (2017) Visible Minorities, Invisible Teachers: BME Teachers in the Education System. Available at: https://www.runnymedetrust.org/uploads/Runnymede%20ReportNEW.pdf (accessed 13 April 2021).

32.

Nicholas

West-Burnham

(2016) Understanding Leadership: Challenges and Reflections. Williston, VT: Crown House Publishing.

33.

Riessman

(1993) Narrative Analysis. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE Publications.

34.

Robertson

(2018) Mind the gap: the best and worst gender-based pay at multi-academy trusts. Schools Week. Available at: https://schoolsweek.co.uk/mind-the-gap-the-best-and-worst-gender-based-pay-at-multi-academy-trusts/ (accessed 14 April 2021).

35.

Shapira

Arar

(2018) The listening guide: a socio-cultural analysis of Arab women leaders’ stories. Narrative Works: Issues, Investigations, and Interventions 7(1): 21–43.

36.

Simon

(2017) Beyond Every Child Matters: Neoliberal Education and Social Policy in the New Era. Abingdon: Routledge.

37.

Simon

James

Simon

(2019) The growth of multi-academy trusts in England: Emergent structures and the sponsorship of underperforming schools. Educational Management, Administration, & Leadership 49: 112–127. Published online first 20 December 2019.

38.

Small

Trethewey

Menzies

Bowen-Viner

Shaw

(forthcoming). Teach London: Improving Teacher Recruitment and Retention in London. London: LKMco.

39.

Sugrue

(2015) Unmasking School Leadership: A Longitudinal Life History of School Leaders. Dordrecht, the Netherlands: Springer.

40.

Tereshchenko

Mills

Bradbury

(2020) Making Progress? Employment and Retention of BAME Teachers in England. London: UCL Institute of Education.

41.

Thompson

Lingard

Ball

(2020) “Indentured autonomy”: headteachers and academisation policy in Northern England. Journal of Educational Administration and History. DOI: 10.1080/00220620.2020.1850433. Online first 24 November 2020.

42.

Tower

(2020) Why do headteachers stay in disadvantaged primary schools in London? Leadership and Policy in Schools Published online first 1 May 2020. DOI: 10.1080/15700763.2020.1759651.

43.

Wilkin

(2019) Rescaling the local: multi-academy trusts, private monopoly and statecraft in England. Journal of Educational Administration and History 49(2): 171–185.